15 ms·
Responding to Wired's ad hominem hatchet job
- shiven 14y agoReverse-sexism undermines and hurts the anti-sexist and female-friendly atmosphere that most of the tech community would like to foster. Gender discrimination and sexism need to be called out and stopped everywhere, but "crying wolf", without reason, weakens the very moral ground we purport to defend.
- objclxt 14y agoIndeed - I find Ryan Singel's attitude to be completely and utterly baffling. From his Wired post: "Soghoian suggesting that if Quinn Norton ever wanted to write about about encryption tools in the future, she ought to “step back, take a deep breath, and pull the power cord from your computer” isn’t just rude and obnoxious, it’s border-line sexist" Out of context, I can't really see what he's getting at. In context, the idea it's 'border-line' sexist makes no sense at all. Singel has chosen to infer sexism under the mis-guided impression it's targeting one of his writers, but in fact the quote is pretty clearly intended to be read as a criticism of all technology journalists.
- jlgreco 14y ago"Borderline" anything does not make any sense to me. It seems to be nothing more than a way to call somebody something with plausible deniability, I guess to protect against libel/slander suits? The way I see it, being "borderline" to something means that it is "close" to something, but not actually something. I guess an octagon could be a "borderline" circle? The issue here though is that if you are pointing out that something is "borderline sexist", you are basically saying "it is not sexist, but it is close to it". What the hell does "close to sexist" mean? Is being "close to sexist" wrong? If yes, why isn't it just called "sexist"?
- king_jester 14y ago> Reverse-sexism undermines and hurts the anti-sexist and female-friendly atmosphere that most of the tech community would like to foster. It may be that the tech community would like to foster anti-sexism, but reality shows that it does anything but that. Also, reverse-sexism isn't a thing, there is just sexism (which men, as a gender, are largely not affected by). > Gender discrimination and sexism need to be called out and stopped everywhere, but "crying wolf", without reason, weakens the very moral ground we purport to defend. Soghoian's original paragraph about Norton's tweets are sexist as they don't add anything to his original blog post except to taint Norton as someone who is biased against men, which Norton's tweets don't even support. Soghoian knows his audience is primarily men and even if he didn't intend to show Norton in that light he sure did.
- andrewcooke 14y agoThere's an interesting post at Cryptome that mentions crypto.cat - http://cryptome.org/2012/07/chile-comments.htm http://cryptome.org/2012/07/chile-comments.htm (apparently the Chilean police have some transcripts of conversations, and it's not clear how).
- nopassrecover 14y agoWithout a lot of prior context, this seems like a clear-headed rebuttal to an otherwise pretty low ad hominem attack. On a specific note, to characterise someone as sexist because they disagree with someone who happens to be a woman is in my opinion itself one of the most egregious examples of both sexism (for reasons I'll detail) and libel (for the damaging political and social impact of being branded with such a label). First, throwing the term 'sexist' around carelessly undermines genuine claims of sexism. Second, it attempts to not only target an individual as sexist, but often the male gender as a whole as being part of a "misogynistic boys-club", in turn implying that masculine identity itself is inherently wrong. Third, it undermines genuine gender equality - if people are concerned about their criticisms being perceived as sexist they will refrain from open and honest critique which is the hallmark of colleagues and equals. Fourth, it assumes (paternalistically) a gender role for women as "poor persecuted girls" who need protecting from criticism and attack. Consequently, sexual inequality is perpetuated - after all, if this same criticism had been targeted at a male journalist would we expect to see responses such as "you're only picking on him because he's a man"? There are plenty of genuine cases of sexism (against male, female, and other gender identities) which emerge out of the obsolescence of traditional social roles. Leveraging the political sensitivity of this important issue to attack an opponent is pretty low.
- rimantas 14y ago> First, throwing the term 'sexist' around carelessly > undermines genuine claims of sexism. The same goes for rasism. We are at the stage, that merely acknowledging someone's sex or race will earn you these labels. Too bad.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sordina 14y ago> ... one might argue that a woman may or may not understand a female target audience better One might argue that women _on average_ may or may not understand a female audience better, but I can't even begin to think how someone wouldn't understand that variations between individual understandings would dwarf any potential divide here.
- hexagonal 14y agoAnother response: http://c1qfxugcgy0.tumblr.com/post/28976190142/oops http://c1qfxugcgy0.tumblr.com/post/28976190142/oops [Wired's rebuttal is] kinda annoying. Ryan Singel, old white guy, repeats Quinn Norton’s gender (female) five separate times (she is a girl) because Sogohian, dirt-poor terrorism suspect, is apparently the chairman of the Patriarchy.[1] Hey, you know who else has white male privilege, Ryan? Editors at old-media print magazines.
- gyardley 14y agoIf the author's going to complain about hype in news coverage, perhaps he shouldn't be a leading contributor to one-sided news coverage like the Wall Street Journal's 'What They Know'. Or is hype in news coverage only a problem when it's hype the author personally disagrees with?
- reply0005 14y ago> ... perhaps he shouldn't be a leading contributor to one-sided news coverage ... > ... Or is hype in news coverage only a problem when ... In fact it is only a problem when it's from the other side; and that's an understanding that separates the people who know what they're talking about here from the people who don't. One flaw suffices to break security. Any number of paranoid suspicions can be held without harm (...to the security). That's why you don't cheerlead for new systems. Maybe she should've asked, oh, I don't know, any security researcher at all, besides apparently Patterson? I don't know what Patterson said. If Patterson didn't warn her then Patterson deserves a drubbing, too.
- kragen 14y agoWhile I wasn't privy to Meredith and Quinn's conversation, Meredith is a world-class security researcher, as you can verify with DBLP; and she has a strong interest in protecting political dissidents. So I strongly suspect that she covered all the relevant issues. Quinn knows plenty of security researchers.
- jopt 14y agoIsn't that a Tu Queue fallacy?
- raphman 14y agoack. And additionally, this "tu quoque" accusation also insinuates that WSJ reporting focuses on hype - whereas the author explicitely mentions their reporting as a example of high-quality journalism (and other commenters here seem to agree).
- 14y ago
- jerrya 14y agoThere is nothing I can find in Soghoian's two posts that are any sort of criticism of Patterson, the security expert. It seems to be a huge and false claim of Wired's that there is any criticism of Patterson. Soghoian does criticize the reporter, who is a woman. Apparently for Wired, when you criticize one of their reporters, and their editor it's all out war to the death and here they played the gender card. It was either that or admit their mistake.
- johngalt 14y agoSeems simple to me. If you call us out for terrible reporting, we'll slander you as a sexist. Welcome to my hosts file Wired.
- heretohelp 14y ago>Welcome to my hosts file Would you mind sharing your hosts file, or some sanitized subset of it?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ebbv 14y agoWired really sucks a lot of the time. This is an unfortunate example of just how bad it can be.
- tomp 14y agoBeing sexist is bad. Accusing a man of sexism just because he doesn't agree with a woman is worse.
- tomrod 14y agoThis. US culture on the whole is overly sensitive to criticism in my view. If someone criticizes another, the typical response is to give a "No way, you're judging my unchangeable characteristics!" rather than "Hey, let me think if this has any merit." Mountains from molehills, methinks. I think the blog author did a great job handling the ad hominems though.
- ajscherer 14y agoThis statement makes no sense to me. "Being sexist" encompases an absolutely huge range of behaviors. It could mean something as small as making a dumb assumption about what type of aesthetic preferences someone has, to something as large as making hiring decisions that can permanently stunt someone's career growth. It could even mean promulgating laws that legitimize violence against people. Sexism is thus a category of bad behaviors, some of which are worse than anything I could imagine stemming from being accused of sexism. I am not saying that being falsely accused of sexism is nothing. It certainly would make me angry and frustrated to be so attacked. I just think false accusation of sexism is worse than the least severe forms of sexist behavior, and better than the most severe forms of sexists behavior. Asserting that false accusations of sexism are always worse than sexism seems obviously false.
- tomp 14y agoMostly, I agree. Except with the part about (laws that legitimize) violence against people. In this case, the problem, IMO, is not sexism/discrimination, but violence as such. I wrote the above mostly because I wanted to make a statement, and I wasn't in the mood for writing lengthy arguments. Also, from a purely philosophical point of view, where we analyze not the actions, but the motivations and principles behind them, the statement holds true, because accusing someone of being sexist is both sexism (belief that people of different sex differ in more than their most basic biology (which they maybe do, but that shouldn't be generalized)), and ad-hominem, which is (philosophically) worse than being just sexist.
- wmeredith 14y agoAs usual Wired's brand of journalism is skin deep, at best. Any time they report on something I have a bit of expertise in, it's wildly inaccurate. OP's tale sucks, but does not surprise me.
- incision 14y agoI can't say I'm surprised. I've read some great stories in the Wired print magazine over the years, but their online presence is typically Gawkeresque.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- 0x36 14y agoUnfortunately, a lot of "tech journalists" are amateurs with exaggerated notions of self-worth because they have some readership. Like the hacked guy at Wired who was so clueless as to keep important data in one place (his Apple acct), but blames everybody else for his loss. If you keep all your data on your MacBook and believes Apple will take care of the rest, you are not an expert, you are a fanboy that has no right to state your opinion publicly.
- rickmb 14y agoI still remember when Wired was relevant. You know, back in the 90s, before they declared the web dead for the first time.
- smackfu 14y agoYou mean the Wired who has been getting tons of press for their reporting on the Apple iCloud debacle last weekend? That irrelevant Wired?
- franzus 14y agoWell, maybe not irrelevant but way more less relevant than it was. Back then it was something I read regularly. But now it's the place where I go to on lazy days when there's no other action on the internet and I'm too procrastinate-y to code :)
- sn0rd 14y agoThat whole Apple thing was staged. It started as a thought experiment over beers and was carried to its natural conclusion in the name of page views and awareness. Wired has oscillated between relevant and annoying for many, many years now. The type of attack they 'documented' is well-known and has been discussed in many circles. This is part of the reason they've had so many quotes from 'the hacker'. It's all about pushing the right buttons. Apple stuff is news. Life is awesome. Enjoy.
- tesseractive 14y agoIs this your pet theory, or do you have some way of documenting that it was staged? And do you have examples of records on the internet where this attack was discussed before? I'm not saying that you are mistaken, nor am I saying that you are lying. But I can't accept an assertion like that at face value without seeing some supporting evidence.
- sn0rd 14y agoI can accept that. I don't have anything that I'm willing to share. To be sure, I'm not suggesting that any of the companies (Apple, Google, Etc.) were willing participants. Likewise, if you're looking for a discussion of this exact implementation of exploiting the trust relationships created by users of cloud services, you'll not find it. That said, exploiting trust relationships that users naturally create in the cloud, is common. This is just one specific attack, designed to get page views and raise awareness. It worked flawlessly. Life is but a dream.
- snowwrestler 14y agoTo me the Wired piece reads like the sort of defensive rebuttal that is usually best to put in a drawer for a day or two before sending (or in this case publishing). It's long, wandering, needlessly emotional (appeal to sexism), and in places reflects an inaccurate reading of Chris's piece.
- cyber 14y agoSadly, there is a growing contingent amongst the computer security/hacker scene who, instead of actually looking to improve things, are looking to be indignant about something. A major conference has recently had to deal with issues stemming from a complaint about harassment that wasn't actually a complaint. It was never reported to staff, nor venue, nor law enforcement. Instead, twitter and blog posts were used.
- void-star 14y agoThis sort of nonsense isn't surprising from tech media at all. However, I am genuinely surprised and dismayed to see it coming out of Threat Level.
- franzus 14y agoITT: snake oil people talk about snake oil things
- robertskmiles 14y agoI decided a while ago to stop reading Wired, after some ridiculous piece of hack journalism I can't even remember now. This makes me want to stop reading Wired again, but I can't do it twice. This is like Sony all over again. I've been boycotting them for the past few years, and they just keep doing things that make me want to boycott them. When will someone invent the double boycott?
- chris_wot 14y agoDunno, but I've all too often had a Clayton's boycott - the boycott you have when you aren't having a boycott. Perhaps we could email each other to exchange ideas?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- btipling 14y agoI hope users of crytpo software in critical situations look to more than Wired Magazine to evaluate the safety and reliability of their software.
- mattbeck 14y agoWow, wired really has hit a low point here. This feels like little more than linkbaiting trolling, but I suspect that it was in earnest which is almost worse.
- benatkin 14y agoThe header of the blog post is broken in Firefox. I had to remove an element with Firebug in order to read the first couple paragraphs.
- ten_fingers 14y agoSorry, Ms. Singel, your sexism card has expired.
- evan_ 14y agoI'm thinking Singel's -ism meter is just screwed up, here's a twitter post where he seems to equate the driver-bicyclist relationship to racism, and in a somewhat offensive way to boot: https://twitter.com/rsingel/status/232719063854510082 https://twitter.com/rsingel/status/232719063854510082
- bybjorn 14y agoJohn Lennon, apparently: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woman_Is_the_Nigger_of_the_World
- natrius 14y agoI don't think that was offensive. I think it was a pithy, vivid way to get his point across.
- evan_ 14y agohe deleted the tweet and posted an apology: https://twitter.com/rsingel/status/233624361104470016 https://twitter.com/rsingel/status/233624361104470016
- gavanwoolery 14y agoSexism debate in 3...2...1...
- Nrsolis 14y agoI know csoghoian personally. I found the rebuttal article from Wired to be absolutely abhorrent. I do not speak for him, but I think you can safely assume that the vitriol reserved for Chris is somehow co-incident with his preference towards working with the WSJ to bring cogent computer security reporting to a wide audience. My impression is that Wired sees this as a US vs. THEM kind of thing. Delivering secure solutions to an audience that is unaware of the risks is always a dodgy proposition. Better informed customers would improve the market for those solutions and keep vulnerable persons from over-trusting a flawed product. We all benefit when this happens. Chris is asking for better reporting, not male reporters. A very big difference indeed.
- ceol 14y ago> Today, Ryan Singel, the editor at Wired's Threat Level > blog responded to my blog post, but incorrectly frames > my criticism as if it were solely directed at Quinn > Norton and her coverage of Cryptocat. Considering about half of your original article was strictly discussing Norton's coverage, I can see where he got that idea. Then your original piece includes this bit: > It isn't clear why Norton felt it wasn't necessary to > publish any dissenting voices. From her public Tweets, > it is however, quite clear that Norton has no love for > the crypto community, which she believes is filled > with "privileged", "mostly rich 1st world white boys > w/ no real problems who don't realize they only build > tools [for] themselves." That's an attack on the author, don't you think? You just implied she neglected to include any criticism of the tool because she hates the crypto community. Not only does this illustrate your lack of understanding the concept of privilege, but it's rude and unnecessary, so I don't blame Ryan for taking offense. For starters, Quinn wasn't trying to bury facts— the paragraph about how Cryptocat is an experiment is directly above the screenshot of the app, so it's fairly noticeable. Second, your section titled "On the issue of privilege" doesn't actually talk about privilege. It talks about how two white men were stopped at the border to the US and one who had some of his devices seized. Her tweet was stating that maybe tools made by white men in first-world countries might not be able to adequately address the needs of less fortunate individuals under oppressive regimes. So sure, it's great to call out projects that seem Too Good To Be True™, but multiple times you drew attention to Quinn's specific article, and even once needlessly quoted a few of her tweets. I don't see that attention paid to any other reporter, so Ryan's rebuttal is mostly on point.
- CamperBob2 14y agoThat's an attack on the author, don't you think? (Shrug) Quinn effectively attacked and discredited herself by posting that Tweet. It's fair to bring it up when suggesting that she might not be the most qualified person to write articles on subjects related to cryptography and information security. If there are any subjects that don't benefit from uninformed opinions posted by dilettantes, cryptography and security would be near the top of the list.
- 14y ago
- rdl 14y agoHe's right that WSJ security coverage is by far the best of any "normal" publication. I also think WSJ AllThingsD is probably the best general startup coverage (and also headed by a woman).