8 ms·
Study finds solo music listening boosts social well-being
- SteelByte 2y ago[flagged]
- tananan 2y agoStudy finds you enjoy doing things you like. If there's something you particularly like, you seem to enjoy it even more. If you are missing on some form of pleasure in your life, substituting it for another pleasure can help alleviate the pain. Woah.
- wobfan 2y agoThe study also explains that one feels less lonely when listening to their favourite music, which is kinda new to me. I mean, feeling better makes sense and is quite obvious, as you sarcastically say, but I wouldn't think that listening to music makes one feel less alone.
- jack_pp 2y agoDepends, if you listen to Emo/sad/heartbreak songs you will probably feel much more lonely.
- odyssey7 2y agoThe cause or the effect? I would actually guess no for the effect, since music preferences are associated with community membership.
- clcaev 2y agoI wouldn't assume that sad songs make you more lonely. For someone dealing with grief, it may act as drug-free therapy. Perhaps deepened sorrow at first, but when one deals with grief, mental state and behavior can improve.
- zdragnar 2y agoUnstructured therapy is exactly as effective as it sounds. You're just as likely to process the emotion as you are to enable and reinforce it. Taken too far, wallowing in the pain becomes a perverse pleasure in itself, a bit like cutting or other self harm.
- basisword 2y agoI think it's the opposite. Those songs are good because you find someone can relate to you and therefore you would feel less lonely. Maybe not less sad, but more connected.
- InsideOutSanta 2y agoWhen I work from home, I usually listen to Sade, Brandy, Monica, Faith Evans, and similar music. Although the music is often about heartbreak, it doesn't make me sad. I find it calming.
- jjulius 2y agoI listen to sad songs with great regularity and jam the hell out to the sheer musicianship within, actually.
- metalman 2y ago:) pleasure is the gateway experience into enjoying yourself
- neuroticnews25 2y agoI wonder if it may be beneficial even if you're not naturally willing to do it, similar to how introverts feel better after acting extroverted [0] [1] [0] https://archive.is/Ipdxc https://archive.is/Ipdxc [1] https://online.ucpress.edu/collabra/article/7/1/29931/119109/Enacted-Extraversion-as-a-Well-Being-Enhancing https://online.ucpress.edu/collabra/article/7/1/29931/119109...
- RajT88 2y agoI used to live near a nice downtown with a riverwalk. I liked to take my guitar and go play under the bridge at night. The bridge was concrete and the reverb was crazy good. (Does that make me a troll? A troll posting on the internet??) I found it terribly soothing. Sometimes I'd bring a friend with and we'd play together.
- bluGill 2y agoI assume you listened for kids walking over the bridge and then jumped up "Who is trip tropping over my bridge". One of my favorite actives, and done right the kids laugh (don't get too close or do anything else that would make the kids scared!)
- RajT88 2y agoThis was Naperville, IL. So that kind of behavior is very risky. You could get sued for 10 million dollars. Or these days, deported to Aurora.
- seplox 2y agoYou just reminded me of one of my favorite Tony Joe White songs, so thanks! Tony Joe White - Even Trolls Love Rock and Roll https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fJMNJTEhuw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fJMNJTEhuw
- pearlsontheroad 2y agoI wonder if the positive effect is also associated with a sense of autonomy and control of the environment.
- singularity2001 2y agoThis is one of the cases I call reality mismatch: Through evolution we have been programmed to associate music with security of the group being nearby. Now we can listen to music even though the group is very distant in time and space. Maybe it's not a complete reality mismatch because in a sense we are still close to the group through the Internet. However the positive feelings are over exaggerated given the limited modern benefits.
- hackable_sand 2y agoDid you mean to say "performance" instead of "music"? Either way, this sounds like vague popsci reasoning.
- scop 2y agoThat’s a fascinating take. Music until very recently was indeed an incredibly social activity bound with layers of talent, leisure (purpose/meaning/security), belonging, etc. As people have been chatting about the Metaverse or AR I often quip that we’ve already had AR for awhile: headphones. The ubiquitous of AirPods, even amongst employees on the clock in recent years, has only reinforced my belief that we are already deep down the AR rabbit hole and seeing both the positive and negative effects. Augmented reality is great, but we still need to be grounded and able to act within reality. It’s the reality that must be our base, not the augmented part. The augmented should serve to improve reality, not replace.
- cryptopian 2y agoOne of the most enjoyable musical experiences I had recently was on a choir exchange in Europe. We were at a concert afterparty with choirs from two other countries, exchanging drunken folk songs. Were we pleasant to listen to? Probably not. It was raucous and out of tune, but it was a bunch of people sharing something we loved.
- moritzruth 2y agoThat sounds beautiful.
- Pixelious 2y agoAnother study that states obvious facts. Of course listening to music boosts your well-being, heck, doing anything you enjoy doing tends to do so.
- tonytamps 2y agoNot sure if your response was deliberately obtuse or not, but in case it was accidental I wanted to point out that you may have missed a key word - "social" well-being. It's one thing if listening to music makes you feel good, but another completely if listening makes you more capable of socialising. This may be more important for others than it is for you.
- tananan 2y agoYou are reading into something that isn't there. The study doesn't have to do with music making you more capable of socializing. The hypothesis being tested is that in the absence of social interaction, people will turn to surrogates in order to make up for the perceived lack. Specifically, they test if music can be such a surrogate. They do some surveys and a kind of silly experiment to provide evidence that yes- it can. The reason it is rightly called pointless is that it brings nothing actionable to the table. You cannot extract advice from showing evidence for a common-sense observation: If you feel a certain lack, activities you find pleasurable can diminish that lack. And look at the experimental setup: They make people play an online game with others where certain people are excluded from playing. It turns out that people who are hyped from listening to their favorite song found this less jarring, hence showing that music can be a "social buffer", i.e. make up for a perceived social exclusion. Let everyone individually conclude how insightful this experiment is. EDIT: Misunderstood the nature of the "Cyberball" experiment, fixed
- bluGill 2y agoUntil it doesn't. It is an obvious fact that a heavy rock will fall faster than a light rock. Only because you have been taught otherwise for all your life do you realize it isn't a fact even though it is obvious.
- retskrad 2y ago[dead]
- FollowingTheDao 2y ago"This study was funded in part by the International Coalition of Headphone Manufactures." But seriously, "Music as a social surrogate"? How is this good? What we need is to fix the social structure, not find out ways to compensate for the miserable state we are in. From https://www.utica.edu/college-community/utica-stories/filling-social-fuel-tank https://www.utica.edu/college-community/utica-stories/fillin... "In terms of social needs, we have a social fuel tank. This tank helps us understand if we are able to get to our destination—the destination being positive mental health outcomes, like feeling satisfied with our lives, having positive self-image, and feeling accepted by others. The problem is that past measures used in psychology research only tell us how much fuel is in the tank—not what types of fuel are in the tank, or how much of each type of fuel is in there. In this study, the measure that I created helps researchers understand what types of fuel are in the tank, and how much of each type of fuel is in the tank, that is leading to those outcomes. It gives us a better idea of what is going on to help people get those positive outcomes."
- JKCalhoun 2y agoMaybe others will relate? I'm not a headphone person but always have music playing in the background on speakers — often at a fairly low volume so it is easily ignored, talked over. I find without the presence of external music I will have a song playing in my head instead. And generally the same song for hours (!). So I suppose the external click-track freezes up my mind somehow. In case anyone cares, my "playlist" is local music I've purchased over the decades — maybe 4 or 5 days long? In my "lab" (man-cave, I suppose) I have a shorter, streamed playlist on the stereo that is looping over new music that I am currently "auditioning". The songs that make the cut are purchased and added eventually to the local playlist that plays elsewhere.
- Novosell 2y agoAs another music-purchaser, it's annoying how difficult it is to buy FLAC releases of bigger artists.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoYeah, since I prefer Bandcamp and, as you say, the bigger artists are not there, I end up buying shitty MP3s from Amazon for their songs. So I end up with real high quality Japanese Breakfast and MP3-quality Pixies.
- Novosell 2y agoAye, bandcamp is the go-to. It's funny that the further production gets from someones bedroom the less likely you are to be able to buy a lossless version. All that production for a 192kbps MP3...
- skydhash 2y agoYou can try qobuz and 7digital.
- piperswe 2y agoFor big artists, I tend to just go to my local record store, pick up a CD, and rip it when I get home.
- qoez 2y agoStudy shows people relying on studies for common sense found less adept at independent thinking
- johntitorjr 2y ago[dead]
- _fat_santa 2y agoJust from personal experience, listening to music in the morning while I make my coffee is an essential part of my morning routing, to the point that I will be upset if I can't do it.
- hk1337 2y agoI wonder if it's a similar case with having tv shows running in the background? Music is often too stimulating for me but I like having the TV running in the background cycling through tv shows.
- Ylpertnodi 2y agoMany years ago, I always used to have TV on whilst I did (composed) music. With YouTube (and others) nowadays, I still found myself doomscrolling, so I bought a digital TV tuner and have that in a window. Productivity up.
- jrmyphlmn 2y agoif one's childhood had many instances of tv playing in the background, then I suspect it's their nervous system marking that environment as their most safe/comfortable environment and that revisiting it can have a soothing effect on them?
- autobodie 2y agoWonderful! I am increasingly drowning in debt, my career is a dead end thanks to AI, and my landlord is making my daily life a stressful misery, but I can listen to music on my headphones. Thanks science!
- ssttoo 2y agoConfusing title, I thought there was something special in solo music, e.g. pieces for one piano or a single classical guitar
- euvitudo 2y agoMy birds are much happier when music is playing. And they seem to have preferences over time. Like there are no predators around when the environment around them is noisy.
- khalladay 2y agoThough I found they like having control over whether the music is playing more... to my chagrin. I tried to keep my parrot from being too noisy through the day by setting up a microphone in his room, and having it turn off the radio for 30 seconds every time he was louder than a threshold amount. Day one -> he triggered the shut down ~10 times. Day two -> easily 50. Day three -> you can see where this is going Dude freaking LOVED being able to turn on and off the radio. It almost beat out being able to flap his wings and make the curtains move as one of his favourite hobbies.
- em-bee 2y agoyou thought you were punishing him by taking away the music if he makes to much noise and you give him a tool that gives him control over his environment. seems that backfired because it looks like the parrot is less interested in the music itself but in this new ability to control the radio.
- chaosprint 2y agois there any good app to know local music event?
- 6stringmerc 2y agoYeah but having a CHOICE in the music typically plays an important role! I mean in jail the only free option Tarrant County offered was Christian music (rap and contemporary) and that stuff was actually irritating to me. I wasn’t actively accessing it - I couldn’t NOT hear it coming through the ventilation system. I wrote about how it’s a form of indoctrination to exploit people’s desire for something that they love yet only present a brainwashing oriented selection: https://samhenrycliff.medium.com/tarrant-county-sheriff-bill-waybourn-wants-to-brainwash-inmates-into-christianity-d71990f134d4 https://samhenrycliff.medium.com/tarrant-county-sheriff-bill...
- em-bee 2y agowell in that situation you are not listening in isolation.
- jasondigitized 2y agohttps://somafm.com/player/#/now-playing/groovesalad https://somafm.com/player/#/now-playing/groovesalad is my well-being
- e40 2y agoDoes nothing for me ("Play" does nothing) with uBO enabled in FF.
- tetris11 2y agoWorks fine for me in Firefox for Android with uBO. The music is quite sparsely melodic though and easy to miss
- e40 2y agoMaybe because I'm not signed in? I disabled uBO and it still doesn't play. Hmm.
- haileys 2y agoSomaFM is some of the best of the internet. There's no ads and you don't need to sign in. You can just stream it without faff. Try opening your browser's console, network inspector, etc. and see what happens when you try to play. There will almost certainly be enough hints in there to diagnose the issue.
- ews 2y agoSOMAFM's SF police radio with ambient music is surprisingly good for concentration, I have this on an alias in my box : mpv https://somafm.com/sf1033.pls https://somafm.com/sf1033.pls
- dimal 2y agoThis is a cynical take, but I’m increasingly becoming tired of studies like this. Is this is where our science funding is going? It’s clever, trite, and probably meaningless. I keep reading about the publish/perish problem in academia and how it encourages research that safe, slightly interesting, but not too interesting, and doesn’t move anything forward. This study seems to fit that criteria. And since it’s behind a paywall, I can’t really determine the how the study was designed, how well powered it is, how they defined statistical significance, and exactly how they justify their conclusion. But it got clicks and comments, so I guess it served its purpose, only to be quickly forgotten in endless churn of popular science news. I’m sad to say, I’m beginning to think that a lot of current science is bullshit. As a very pro-science person, this is very depressing.
- riyanapatel 2y agoI can't argue that I really enjoy music as my working background noise. Something else unique is I enjoy listening to TV shows, or more, "noise". I usually put on a simple TV show I've seen before that doesn't need a lot of attention (Friends, the Office, New Girl, Big Bang Theory), that creates that background noise. It's like white noise to me :)
- bitwize 2y agoI dunno, man, just from personal experience... I never went to raves back in the day, and only occasionally to clubs. With one exception I found the mobs of sweaty drunken (or otherwise intoxicated) people borderline intolerable. But sitting in my room with headphones on, blasting trance or other EDM... I feel swept up and part of something. It's also the best way for me to bro out lots of code, with that stuff pumping. It's like the rhythm provides guide-rails for my brain to keep it going a certain direction. The one exception? I once saw Armin Van Buuren do one of his legendary hours-long sets. That man is like the Pied Piper. Whatever energy the floor had before he came on was amplified a hundredfold and I just danced and danced, people be damned.
- stronglikedan 2y agoIf you want to know if this is for you, but you don't want to spend a lot of money, start with iems. It's quite the hobby, as well as education. It's very cheap and accessible to start off, while getting the full hi-fi music feeling. Of course, if you stick with it, it can get very expensive.
- replete 2y agoFor a while I switched to mee6 pro's with some squishy foam cushions, they were around £30 and had a surprisingly flat response. Of course, that will sound bad to a typical listener until you realize the v curve you are used to has been hiding details in the midrange
- ThinkBeat 2y agoThe study found that for people who are lonely or sad, listening to music helped them. Wow. How utterly expected. Next, they will do studies and find that people who are lonely or sad, are helped when they attend a concert with their favorite band. Or when they eat their favorite food. "After two years of studies, we conclude that people who are feeling lonely or sad, eating their favorite food gives them a boost and feel better". The metric that would be useful is "better" for how long?
- rramadass 2y agoEverybody here is missing the point of this article which is actually about the increasing need for "Social Surrogates" in our current times. Music is just one of them. See Social Surrogates, Social Motivations, and Everyday Activities: The Case for a Strong, Subtle, and Sneaky Social Self - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0065260115000258 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00652...
- Eddy_Viscosity2 2y agoI really wanted to read the article and then comment "in mice!", but alas, they used humans.