5 ms·
> My feeling is that the F-35 is "too big to fail" Allies cancelling orders may force Washington’s hand: the cost of additional jets, parts, et cerera skyrocke
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> My feeling is that the F-35 is "too big to fail"
Allies cancelling orders may force Washington’s hand: the cost of additional jets, parts, et cerera skyrocket if spread over fewer planes.
- pjmlp 2y agoThat is only happening thanks to the way US view on the world has changed, and the remote kill switch used against Ukrainian jets. US has killed the allies trust. Had these two events not happened, and most likely sales would not have been cancelled regardless of the F-35 issues.
- kelnos 2y ago> the remote kill switch used against Ukrainian jets. Could you provide some references to this? A quick search only turned up denials that such a kill switch exists.
- pjmlp 2y agohttps://www.zona-militar.com/en/2025/03/10/the-u-s-has-reportedly-suspended-support-for-the-electronic-warfare-systems-installed-on-the-ukrainian-air-forces-f-16-fighter-jets/ https://www.zona-militar.com/en/2025/03/10/the-u-s-has-repor...
- benterix 2y agoThe name is imprecise and causes endless semantic discussions, what happened is lack of updates that render the aircraft vulnerable. Some will argue it's the same, some will disagree.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> only happening thanks to the way US view on the world has changed Sure. My point is it does become small enough to fail if its effective price to taxpayers doubles due to allies cancelling orders. > remote kill switch used against Ukrainian jets Source?
- pjmlp 2y agohttps://www.zona-militar.com/en/2025/03/10/the-u-s-has-reportedly-suspended-support-for-the-electronic-warfare-systems-installed-on-the-ukrainian-air-forces-f-16-fighter-jets/ https://www.zona-militar.com/en/2025/03/10/the-u-s-has-repor... One of many.
- daemoens 2y agoNo such kill switch exists, the US stopped providing electronic warfare intelligence that made the jets more survivable. The stoppage of all military aid was significantly more damaging.
- XorNot 2y agoYeah this is both bad but also being heavily misreported: the US can't shutdown hardware remotely, but loss of access to proprietary software effectively disables critical functionality which can effectively render a platform useless. Up till now, there was no demonstrated risk of this happening - but that's a broken trust which won't be repaired for generations, if ever.
- guappa 2y ago> the US can't shutdown hardware remotely And you know this because you've personally audited those planes?
- XorNot 2y agoIf people are going to declare there's definitely a kill switch, then the burdens on them to provide proof. The story being reported as a "kill switch" does not include this capability existing or being used.
- guappa 2y agoI think they're saying there might be one, and we no longer trust the USA to believe there isn't one (and I can't really understand why we ever did, USA has been an unreliable ally even before trump). You made the extraordinary claim that the USA has no kill switch. Where's the proof to your claim?
- randomcarbloke 2y agoWhat an absurd argument to justify the baseless idea. American-made systems are present in most western developed military hardware, there might be backdoors or killswitches in any of it.
- maxglute 2y agoMy tinfoil hat theory is perversely US probably wants LESS foreign F35 orders. US accounts for 80% of long term F35 procurement (~2500/3100). Capitalization / replacement of airframes across US forces is at attrocious levels. If anything US better off absorbing 100% of next 20 years of LH production, and get full F35 buy years earlier, i.e. by late 2030 instead of projected 2045s sharing with partners. Especially now LH seems to have finally sorted out Tech Refresh 3. US probably wants LH to focus on upgrading/delivering US airframes and get as much US airframes to TR3 and then block4 standards. IIRC airforce general said he would not want take pre TR3 F35s to Pacific fight. If US is serious about countering PRC in decade of concern, they need all the airframes.
- pyrale 2y agoIf we follow your logic, they would still want the orders ; they would simply look for ways to avoid fulfilling them.
- maxglute 2y agoFor a 1-2 years, maybe, as seen with JP, but for 10+ years? That's ~200+ airframes. LH already have TR3 backlogs, and TBH if you follow the LH TR / F35 SaaS drama (LH contract essentially held DoD hostage), I'm would not be surprised if DoD doesn't want to slap LH with less global orders so they can solely focus on US program.
- atmosx 2y agoA common misconception - often echoed on this site - is that NATO allies and the U.S. operate on equal terms. They don’t. If the U.S. wants to sell 100 F-35s to European nations, it will happen. Even today, with all this talk around NATO, there’s a massive U.S. military presence at NATO bases across Europe. These forces are, in effect, under U.S. control, stationed in countries like Germany and Italy. And if Germany suddenly decided it wanted them gone - well, it’s not their call. TL;DR: Life on the empire’s periphery might be comfortable, but you don’t get to choose your enemies - and you still have to pay your dues, or else.
- rat87 2y agoThose massively military bases exist to protect Europe. The countries can of course choose to tell soldiers to fuck off but now is not a particularly good time for that. The real danger is that Trump abandons our allies because a dictator flattered him
- mcv 2y ago> They don’t. If the U.S. wants to sell 100 F-35s to European nations, it will happen. How do you imagine that will work? The US may have to lower the price more than they can afford to. Some countries have already cancelled their F-35 orders. You can't force someone to buy what they don't want.
- ggm 2y agoThe implications are that non financial or indirect financial leverage would be used to make you "want" to complete purchase.
- benterix 2y agoWell that period seems to be ending right in front of our eyes.
- chgs 2y ago> You can't force someone to buy what they don't want. The opium wars would disagree