6 ms·
The fact pattern doesn't fit well with ICE, because Indiana University cooperated with the investigation (and struck him and his wife from their pages). The tr
by tptacek 2y ago
The fact pattern doesn't fit well with ICE, because Indiana University cooperated with the investigation (and struck him and his wife from their pages).
The track record of espionage investigations against people of Chinese origin is not great, so it's not a defense of this investigation to say that that the details rhyme with that rather than immigration.
- whatshisface 2y agoSpies don't get "vanished," at least not historically. They're caught, imprisoned and tried in huge public media-heavy trials. The USSR even did huge public trials for American spies, because there's no incentive to forgo the nationalist boost to public opinion when collaborators would be aware of the disappearance either way.
- bigfatkitten 2y agoMedia-heavy espionage cases are the exception, not the norm. "Diplomats" routinely get declared persona non grata and just put on the next plane home. Neither the U.S. nor the other country wants to make a fuss.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- aerostable_slug 2y agoThat's generally because those diplomats can't be tried for their activities in the host nation, and also because said diplomats are running spies, not stealing secrets themselves. In other words, they aren't the traitors, their agents are. And those agents are the ones who get tried in the media circuses we're all so familiar with.
- bigfatkitten 2y agoMedia circus doesn't appear until the trial, which hasn't happened in this matter yet either. The feds execute warrants every day without making the news.
- tptacek 2y agoBeing removed from your employer's web pages isn't "being vanished"; we don't even know if Wang is in custody. All I'm saying is, in the fact pattern where this is another unhinged ICE raid, IU doesn't strike a tenured faculty member in an endowed chair position from all their websites. I've got nothing past that. Later From the TPM follow-up link downthread: faculty at IU were notified more than a week before the raid that he'd been placed on leave, and it was at that point Wang's pages were zapped from the IU sites.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 2y agoIt's also pretty clear that this isn't matching the pattern of an espionage case, since they gave everyone more than a week of advance notice that something was to happen.
- tptacek 2y agoWho knows? The "advanced notice" (I'm assuming here you're referring to IU's decision to place him on leave, remove him from their web pages, and notify his colleagues, more than week before the raid) makes this look less like some extrajudicial ICE-type thing, not more. But nobody knows anything right now! We know he has legal representation, from the story, and competent legal representation is going to tell you to shut the absolute hell up in a situation like this, so there's not much to learn from the fact that Goodin can't raise him for a quote. My only take here (besides the certainty that the shadowy hand of the FISA FISC court is not behind all this) is that it doesn't look like another ICE raid.
- whatshisface 2y agoSure, I mean, the FBI's involvement makes it not look like another department's case. I am saying that on top of that, an arrest of any kind would (normally) go differently than whatever happened to this professor. The idea that the FBI would call the employer of a suspected spy, inform them that something was going to happen, that all of his colleagues would be informed, and then after a week they'd search his home, stands out as not a full explanation.
- TechDebtDevin 2y agoMaybe the Chinese disapprared him brcause his cover was blown :/ The Chinese are alleged to havr their own secret police in the United States keeping tabs on important citizens.. An expert in cryptography seems like someone theyd be keeping tabs on if they really do this. Just spit balling here and dont mean to accuse the guy of anything.
- nurettin 2y agoA lot of "spies" seem to be falling off the window/balcony /stairs lately.
- lolinder 2y ago> Spies don't get "vanished," at least not historically. They're caught, imprisoned and tried Or they vanish themselves before they're caught and are never heard from again because they got away. We don't know that anyone has Wang in custody. He was scrubbed from the University computer systems weeks before the FBI raided his house, which suggests that whatever happened started then and built up to this recent raid which finally drew media attention.
- that_guy_iain 2y agoThey all get “vanished” before the media-heavy trials. You normally find out at the end not when they’ve been arrested.
- gdilla 2y agowhat if your "employer" vanishes you?
- genocidicbunny 2y agoSome spies in the USSR did just get vanished, especially low-level domestic spies. Yeah the American dude running around and being caught for spying would probably get the media circus, but the mid-level manager he gave some cigarettes and money to in exchange for information about the production levels at the factory the manager worked to might instead find himself quietly arrested one evening, tried and sent off to the gulag by the early hours of the morning. You didn't really want or need to make a spectacle of those kinds of spies, since everyone already sort of had an idea of what happened.
- salynchnew 2y agoBeing American right now makes this whole episode feel like a 1950s McCarthyism/Qian Xuesen-type situation. Maybe another xenophobic red scare-type U.S. gov't overreaction will inadvertently export top talent to China a second time.
- briandear 2y agoThis has zero to do with ICE. FBI does counterespionage investigations (among other things,) but doesn’t have anything to do with immigration.
- derbOac 2y agoI have a problem with any of this being secret one way or another. If someone is detained the public has a right to know about the case. Otherwise it's all abductions as far as I'm concerned.
- tptacek 2y agoWe don't even know that he's been detained!
- radicalbyte 2y agoOr who has taken him. We rolled up cells of the Chinese security services who would disappear (or worse) Chinese nationals on foreign soil. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/apr/20/explainer-chinas-covert-overseas-police-stations https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/apr/20/explainer-chin...
- orochimaaru 2y agoThis isn’t immigration. He’s a tenured professor and already has permanent residency at the very least. He is most likely a US citizen. FBI is most likely dealing with an espionage angle. His research field of cryptography and using it to protect genomic data probably has something to do with it. The US govt track record on stuff like this is quite abysmal with several researchers having their career and livelihood destroyed. What he did was public domain, unless he consulted for alphabet agencies. The Chinese govt also has a pretty nasty track record of pressuring erstwhile Chinese citizens to engage in espionage by making life hard for family back in china
- tptacek 2y ago(For what it's worth, at the time I wrote the comment, the rest of the comments on this story were about ICE raids). Nobody knows anything about this story. He might be in custody, he might be in Indiana, he might be abroad, he might be about to get charged, he might not be, he might keep his positions at IU, he might have lost all his positions at IU. It's an interesting story worth paying attention to because he's a prominent figure in an area of research we all pay attention to. But given some kind of criminal investigation is in process, and that he has a lawyer, there's no signal to derive from the fact that we can't get quotes from him in the media; that could just be him being smart.
- kortilla 2y agoDoes he have a lawyer? It wasn’t clear who retained council, it sounded like it was just a woman living at the Carmel house, which could have been a rental tenant…
- freeopinion 2y agoAre you suggesting that it isn't helpful or useful to speculate that he was an undercover FBI agent working to infiltrate US-based dark web crypto gangs and that the University's actions tipped off the gangs? So when he went missing the FBI kicked into high gear? Just making stuff up like that doesn't provide clarity?
- 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- scythe 2y ago>The track record of espionage investigations against people of Chinese descent For context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hsue-Chu_Tsien https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hsue-Chu_Tsien
- tlogan 2y agoWe don’t know whether Xiaofeng is a U.S. citizen, a Chinese national, or holds some other status. He’s been in the U.S. for at least 20 years. He hasn’t been arrested, but it’s unclear whether he’s been located or is currently missing. Let’s not spread misinformation. This could turn out to be a simple criminal case. He might even be a victim. Or it could be something bigger—maybe a spy case, or even something on the scale of Watergate. At this point, no one really knows.
- Terr_ 2y ago> The fact pattern doesn't fit well with ICE, because Indiana University cooperated Disagree: There are reasons to think the Indiana University leadership would willingly assist with something dodgy from right-wing politicians. There was already a big controversy against the IU leadership enabling political censorship last year, which lead to an overwhelming no-confidence vote from faculty and students. https://www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2024/04/17/iu-bloomington-faculty-votes-no-confidence-leaders https://www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2024/04/17/i... https://www.idsnews.com/article/2024/04/behind-the-vote-faculty-lost-confidence-whitten-administration https://www.idsnews.com/article/2024/04/behind-the-vote-facu...
- lokar 2y agoGreen card holders are now subject to arbitrary revocation of that status, lengthy detention and deportation.