8 ms·
Veteran NYTimes Photographer Arrested & Allegedly Beaten by NYPD
- mikemarotti 14y agoInteresting, but what does this have to do with HN?
- res0nat0r 14y agoHN has really turned into anti {government, Hollywood, big music, Facebook, Google, Craigslist, anything-else-that-is-large-and makes-a-bunch-of-money} lately so this isn't surprising.
- untog 14y agoAgreed. I think everyone here is aware of Reddit- if we want to talk about that kind of stuff, let's just go there.
- tikhonj 14y agoReddit also has /r/programming, so why don't we just move all the technical discussions there too, while we're at it? The reason HN is interesting is not that it has unique submissions--it mostly doesn't--but that it has consistently insightful commentary. It makes sense to bring up topics like this here rather than Reddit simply because of the resulting discussions. Also, my impression is that HN has always been disproportionately libertarianish. In fact, in my experience, this is true of the tech and startup communities in general. So I don't think this is a particularly new development.
- jmduke 14y agoI'd argue that it doesn't have consistently insightful commentary with regards to these issues. I love reading HN comments on tech news/debates/articles because I know there's going to be a huge depth and breadth of different commenters' experiences and anecdotes. This generally isn't true with regards to political/social stuff, where the vast majority of commenters have the same belief and experience. That being said, I don't really mind the submissions -- because they're easily identifiable -- I just hope they aren't signals of a larger trend towards generalism. (Reddit, too, used to be predominantly tech/programming articles.)
- Jach 14y agoI like to keep in mind http://www.paulgraham.com/identity.html http://www.paulgraham.com/identity.html for these topics. And it does seem like there have been more and more of them--hopefully at worst it's a trend to "tech, programming, startups, and politics" rather than full generality. From that essay, the large number of comments on these threads is explained by "Politics, like religion, is a topic where there's no threshold of expertise for expressing an opinion. All you need is strong convictions." Though I would add that this extends to many more subjects, including bashing companies. If submissions to nothing more than image macros ever get popular, then it's time to jump ship because HN has become way too much like Reddit.
- lotharbot 14y agoOne of the reason HN has consistently insightful commentary is that we consistently flag/downvote non-insightful articles and posts. You can't simply introduce more social-justice type articles and expect the rest of HN to stay the same. This is why I recommend sticking with the site guidelines: if it would be covered on TV news (this would!) it doesn't belong here, unless it's evidence of some new phenomena (this isn't!)
- Karunamon 14y agoWell, government, Hollywood, Big music, Facebook, (arguably) Google, Craigslist, and any other enterprise which is large and makes a bunch of money, are clear and present dangers to the mostly free internet we have today. Which, considering my job, and considering the average startup, is the biggest threat to their existence. If this bothers you, good. It should.
- tedunangst 14y agoCraigslist is a danger to the free internet? I've browsed my way into the twilight zone...
- res0nat0r 14y agoSince it doesn't allow other websites to wholesale copy it's listings and data for their own use (and monetization) it is a danger to the free(loading) internet apparently.
- Karunamon 14y agoConsidering you now have to give up your copyright to them if you post anything there, I'd have to say yes. Abusing our broken system of laws makes you a danger.
- AJ007 14y agoThat sounds like the same attitude of 2600 or /. It is hardly new in this sub-culture, and has been around for decades. Innovative technologies are disruptive, and those behind the disruption generally look down on monopolies with antiquated products. Given the pace of change, sometimes we as the disruptive become the disrupted.
- paulsutter 14y agoPrivacy and civil liberties are immensely important to the technology entrepreneur. We need to be aware of the legal pitfalls of technology, and be sensitive to the privacy risks we can create. I find this story very relevant to HN. For example, if you are creating an app that records sound or images, you would want to be aware of the risks to camera users. Especially if that camera is less obvious than the camera used by the photographer in this story. The law seems to be on the side of the photographer but the realities are complex. This is covered under the HN guidelines, as the intersection between technology, privacy, and civil liberties is definitely an interesting new and ongoing phenomenon.
- tptacek 14y agoEvery civil liberties story ever posted to HN has been accompanied by that justification, and, were it to be taken seriously, there would be nothing but social justice stories on HN, there being no dearth of important social justice stories to find on any given day.
- Steko 14y ago"were it to be taken seriously, there would be nothing but social justice stories" Total non-sequitur. I'm not saying I think this is a good HN article to upvote but the idea that this is somehow going to exclude everything else is bizarre.
- tptacek 14y agoI think you misread (or, equally likely, I wrote unclearly). I'm not saying "if you take the article seriously, we'll have nothing but social justice stories". I'm saying that if you take the premise that social justice is inherently interesting to hackers, then we'll end up with nothing but those stories. Many people here, myself very much included, get their social justice stories in a different section of their RSS readers. It's not that those stories aren't interesting; it's that they simply aren't Hacker News, any more than updates about Girl Talk albums are Hacker News because hackers are so likely to listen to them.
- 385668 14y agoI would say that it shows evidence of the increasingly common trend of police officers frequently greeting citizens going about lawful activities with violence.
- k-mcgrady 14y agoAnd what does that have to do with HN?
- xutopia 14y agohttp://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jusben1369 14y agoOff Topic indeed it would appear.
- Karunamon 14y agoIt's technology related, is it not?
- jamesmcn 14y agoMost of us carry smart phones that could, at any time, be recording audio, photos or video. It is useful to know if the police can abuse you simply because you are suspected of recording them. Some of us are building or contemplating building products that make use of those smart phone features. If such activity is likely to result in police brutality directed at our customers, that is worth knowing. Technology impacts the real world. How and where our technology touches society in general is worth understanding.
- untog 14y agoMost of us carry smart phones that could, at any time, be recording audio, photos or video. Most of everyone does, though. That doesn't make it HN material. I'd wager that most of us brush our teeth, but I don't think that an article about toothbrush sales should be posted here.
- jamesmcn 14y ago> I'd wager that most of us brush our teeth Woah, woah, woah! Let's try to be realistic here!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- adaml_623 14y agoYou have to know about the world in order to change it. I don't want to sound like an idiot spouting zen koans but you really have to be aware of major trends to be able to navigate around them or even perhaps change them. The clash between technology and authority is a very interesting one. The individual, the mob and the government are all empowered differently by each new advance.
- davidw 14y agoSo read a newspaper, no? Nothing says you have to get the totality of your news from HN.
- tptacek 14y agoIt has nothing at all to do with HN.
- thebigshane 14y agoYet here we all are, reading it and discussing it. :-)
- larrys 14y agoI think there is a story here actually that is a valuable lesson to those who read HN. He goes to a great lengths to tell this as "nothing to see here, move along.." Now why would he do that? My theory on this is that in the past he didn't have to contend with pain in the ass bystanders doing the same thing that he did. Those amateurs are now making it increasingly difficult for a professional like him to do his job. As a result he wants to send a message out there for fear that if he doesn't his rights will be restricted as a result of others behaviors. It's a little "last man over the bridge". The other possibility of course is that he has something to hide. He doesn't want to stir the hornets nest for fear that something will happen to him and he wants to keep a low profile by ending this as soon as possible.
- harshreality 14y agoReally? He didn't say there was nothing to see here. He said his rights were violated (and given his professional history, he seems capable of making that determination). He said he was appalled at his treatment, at the individual police who did this to him, and the people who are backing up the police who did this to him. His equivocation was intended to head off the "police are all nazis because one of them took my camera and arrested me when I was in the middle of a crime scene and interfering with the police" attitude that's all too common. He pointed out that there is a line between responsible documentation of events, and interference, and that line is crossed sometimes, and people criticize the police anyway, and that's not right.
- jcc80 14y agoI agree that he might be concerned about the proliferation of amateur journalism. But, my guess is that his balanced attitude is really because doesn't want to be known as a problem photographer to NYPD officers. It would just make his job (and life) more difficult.
- lifeguard 14y agoAmerican democracy has now begun to begin "The Internet Reformation". This will be annoying for the apathetic. Expect significant friction with police as they are the tools of those currently in power. To put it another way, how useful is the right to read the source if one does not have the right to free speech, assembly, religion (or lack there of), and petition for redress of grievances. To be even more blunt, the Magna Carta Libertatum is under attack.
- liquidcool 14y agoWhile civil liberty issues get upvoted here, I think the added element of photography amplifies the interest. The intersection between techies and photography enthusiasts seems pretty high (you'll note there are a number of photography/imaging technology stories here as well).
- MartinCron 14y agoPhotography, even before digital, has always been such a technical art form that it makes sense that a lot of hacker-types are drawn to it. I have more computers in my house than cameras, but only barely.
- mmaunder 14y agoIt's part of the Redditization. Please try to keep up.
- dromidas 14y agoI really hope he presses charges and brings yet another wrongful suit against the state. Police officers must be held accountable for things they do and if it is a public area then they should act accordingly. A judge already ruled this many times, when will they learn.
- fotbr 14y agoHe won't. Just read the article - he's already apologizing for the officers' behavior and just wants his equipment back.
- nateabele 14y agoIt's a pretty safe bet that no such thing would ever pass a state legislature, but in cases where it can be demonstrated that an officer's behavior is clearly illegal, there need to be provisions for the officer to be held personally liable: no more hiding behind the city or the department. Again, not that it'd likely ever happen, but hey, petitioning your elected representatives never (okay, rarely) hurt.
- travisp 14y agoIn this recent case, NYC officials are refusing to defend a police inspector in lawsuits against him: http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2012/08/03/city-wont-defend-nypd-officer-in-occupy-pepper-spray-lawsuit/ http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2012/08/03/city-wont-defend-nypd... However, his union is now paying for his defense.
- Symmetry 14y agoWell, legally speaking the union has to defend him no matter what he does.
- adrianwaj 14y ago"He was charged with obstructing government administration and with resisting arrest as he was taking photographs of a brewing street fight in New York that involved a teenage girl." Let's call it for what it is... the police were enjoying watching the fight and didn't want to be disturbed. What happened to the girl or rather the attacker? nothing, the justice was instead leveled at Stolarik, and what's he going to do back, nothing. What a shit hole NYC must be. (I might be wrong too)
- dedward 14y agoAs a tourist, NYC was pretty awesome, far better than I expected. Then again, it's awfully hard to generalize about a city that has the population of my country.
- look_lookatme 14y agoInterestingly enough, it looks like his assignment was probably related to this: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/07/nyregion/for-women-in-street-stops-deeper-humiliation.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/07/nyregion/for-women-in-stre... stop-and-frisk is a significant issue in NYC. Ostensibly the authority is granted as part of a larger effort to eliminate firearms on the street. It resulted in nearly 700K stops in 2011. That got 800 some-odd guns off the streets of the city at an unknown cost to goodwill (given most people stopped-and-frisked are Black or Latino). On the flip side there is no doubt that stop-and-frisk has contributed to one of the highest rates of marijuana arrests in the country for NYC. Odd, given New York state effectively decriminalized small amounts of weed in the 70's. It's only through a loophole that states publicly displaying the drug makes possession an arrestable offense and it's been reported that the NYPD consistently instructs people in stop-and-frisk situations to remove any drugs from their pocket and present it for inspection prior to frisking, making it publicly displayed. Gov. Cuomo called on NY state legislature this year to eliminate the public display issue, but nothing happened before the end of the January-June session. edit: added "small amounts"
- daenz 14y ago> it's been reported that the NYPD consistently instructs people in stop-and-frisk situations to remove any drugs from their pocket and present it for inspection prior to frisking, making it publicly displayed. That's really interesting. Are you saying that if an officer finds marijuana, instructs you to remove it, and you refuse, you can't be arrested because you didn't display it publicly?
- rhizome 14y agoNo, they say "empty your pockets," and if there is pot there, they charge you not only with possession, but display as well.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoThis is one of those things where I say "isn't that illegal?" And then realise it's the people enforcing the law who are breaking it. Even if it isn't illegal, no chance they'd enforce that.
- fleitz 14y agoI think the reporter may be suffering from stockholm syndrome.
- darien 14y agoHe wants to keep his job at the NYTimes. If he is known as an biased photographer who 'agitates' police, he won't be sent on certain assignments.
- fleitz 14y agoYes, one should always keep their impartiality towards human rights. It's important that journalists refrain from writing pieces which advocate human rights.
- darien 14y agoPhotojournalists follow a slightly different standard of operations than reporters. They are supposed to let images speak for themselves and work as an impartial observer. This is the attitude that allows them to be embedded in dangerous war zones where hopefully they wont be shot or kidnapped...
- thinkingisfun 14y agoHere are some quotes from James Nachtwey: "I want my work to become part of our visual history, to enter our collective memory and our collective conscience. I hope it will serve to remind us that history's deepest tragedies concern not the great protagonists who set events in motion but the countless ordinary people who are caught up in those events and torn apart by their remorseless fury. I have been a witness, and these pictures are my testimony. The events I have recorded should not be forgotten and must not be repeated." "I used to call myself a war photographer. Now I consider myself as an antiwar photographer." "There is a job to be done...to record the truth. I want to wake people up!" Doesn't sound impartial to me.. and Nachtwey is no noob, to put it mildly. Embedded or not, anyone calling themselves photojournalist ought to learn from him and others. People who can remain impartial in the face of suffering or abuse of power aren't being professional, they're being sociopaths. It takes a strong, big heart to not be impartial and still do the job, sure. It's not for everybody. So what. Lead, follow or get out of the way :P
- ggchappell 14y agoFTA: > I was taking pictures of something that was really wasn’t anything shocking for them. There was no police line. Ive been doing this a long time and its frustrating. Im credentialed. They asked for the credential, I’m shooting, the next thing I know I’m in jail and my equipment is confiscated. Serious question: Why does/should it matter that he is credentialed?
- dedward 14y agoIt shouldn't - but it being NYC, and being a veteran reporter for the NYT, with your classic credentials just drives the point home even harder as there's no room to debate whether it was journalism or not....
- mariuolo 14y agohttp://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2007/apr/24/usa.comment http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2007/apr/24/usa.comment
- olalonde 14y agoAs a side note, why do Americans frequently refer to the New York police department by its acronym (NYPD) instead of simply calling it "the police"? Is it because this particular police department is distinct from other "regular" police departments? I find it a bit strange since I don't recall observing this phenomenon for any other city's police departments (except maybe LAPD).
- galadriel 14y agoBecause most of the police force in US in maintained by local government, like cities or counties. Since laws vary from state to state and cities to cities, it is helpful to mention where the incident is taking place. Mentioning NYPD tells you a lot of things at once- that the incident is specific to New York city (since state and federal authorities were not involved), and that it was done by local police force of New York city, which has very distinct operating pattern and policies from some other police force, like one in LA (the LAPD), or some small rural police force. As to why LAPD and NYPD are famous, that must be probably because these two cities have incidents that are worth national/international discussion. If you start reading more local US news, they usually mention which police department is involved in the case, like the county head or State attorney, etc.