8 ms·
California bill aims to phase out harmful ultra-processed foods in schools
- cat_plus_plus 2y agoWhy would it take longer to phase out ultra processed food than to supposedly phase out gasoline cars? 2032 is a whole generation lost from now.
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoI hate to break the news to you, but 2032 is only 7 years away, and the article says it'll be another year still until the list of foods to phase out will be finalized. The phaseout of gasoline cars is set to take 15 years from 2020 to 2035, over twice as long, and IIUC some plug-in hybrids will still be allowed even after then.
- joe-collins 2y agoI'm grateful that this bill is taking a much more measured approach than the headline suggests. The bill is targeting specific additives, or "excessive" amounts of added sugar, salt, or fat (exact thresholds unnamed). "Ultra-processed" gets thrown about as a big food quality bogeyman, but some definitions of the label are as broad as "contains any amount of added sugar". I'm glad California isn't following a standard that extreme.
- rahimnathwani 2y agoThe bill is targeting specific additives... Where did you get information about what this bill is targeting? When I look at the official page about AB1264 and look at the 'full text', there is virtually nothing there: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=202520260AB1264 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm... Same if I follow the link to the bill PDF: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billPdf.xhtml?bill_id=202520260AB1264&version=20250AB126499INT https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billPdf.xhtml?bill_... This is the complete text I see: Date Published: 02/21/2025 09:00 PM Bill Start CALIFORNIA LEGISLATURE— 2025–2026 REGULAR SESSION Assembly BillNo. 1264 Introduced by Assembly Member Gabriel February 21, 2025 An act relating to pupil nutrition. LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL'S DIGEST AB 1264, as introduced, Gabriel. Pupil nutrition. Existing law requires the State Department of Education to develop and maintain nutrition guidelines for school lunches and breakfasts and for all food and beverages sold on public school campuses. This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact future legislation limiting the sale of ultraprocessed foods in California schools. Digest Key Vote: MAJORITY Appropriation: NO Fiscal Committee: NO Local Program: NO Bill Text The people of the State of California do enact as follows: SECTION 1. It is the intent of the Legislature to enact future legislation limiting the sale of ultraprocessed foods in California schools.
- Aloisius 2y ago> To identify which ultra-processed foods should be eliminated from school offerings, scientists will consider whether a product includes additives that are banned elsewhere, whether it has been linked to health harms, whether it has been show to contribute to food addiction, and whether it contains excessive fat, sugar or salt, California Assemblymember Jesse Gabriel, one of the lawmakers who introduced the bill, said on the call. >The scientists will be required to publish a first report outlining this subcategory of especially harmful ultra-processed foods by July 1, 2026, said Gabriel, and will be required to update the list every two years as research on these foods evolves. I guess the text just isn't available yet, but the article describes what is intended.
- bitwize 2y agoBanning foods that contain any amount of added sugar, except for sweets that are explicitly marketed as such, is very reasonable and would go a long long way in helping manage the obesity crisis.
- InitialLastName 2y agoSo ban all mass-produced bread, especially whole-grain?
- asoneth 2y agoI'm not sure I understand. Are you claiming that mass-produced bread, or whole-grain bread in particular, cannot be produced without adding sugar?
- InitialLastName 2y agoThere is almost no whole-grain bread on the market in the US that does not have added sugar. AIUI this is because the whole wheat flour tends to impart a bitter taste, so the sugar balances it. The sugar also enables the yeast to raise the bread faster, helping mass production.
- asoneth 2y agoInteresting, the only mass-produced whole-grain bread I have on hand is Ezekiel and it didn't list any added sugar, or indeed any sugar at all. It's also not listed as an ingredient on the (partially) whole-grain bread I got from our local bakery. Having said that, I see your point that setting too low a threshold might be unnecessarily onerous on cafeterias and manufacturers. Perhaps a threshold of ~1g sugar per slice would be more reasonable?
- InitialLastName 2y agoEzekiel bread is one exception, but they are also (at my local big box store) 3x the price (by kcal) of the white-label whole wheat bread AND less shelf-stable (thus will incur more process losses and expenses).
- SlightlyLeftPad 2y agoIt doesn’t go far enough. The states food for schools is so bad, most kids aren’t eating anything at all.
- SlightlyLeftPad 2y agoI’ll add my anecdote: my kids and their friends would have “rather starved than eat the food provided in hot-lunch.” We had a picnic day and the ham sandwich my kid bought was two stale pieces of bread with a single slice of ham. No lettuce, no tomato, no mayo, mustard. Just two pieces of stale bread and a slice of ham. I came home pretty livid that day.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 2y agoCouldn't agree more. I see this a lot here in Norway too. So much talk of "ultra-processed" food and its dangers, and recommendations to avoid it but the category is so wide as to include even things like baked beans, because they may have some salt, sugar and modified starch added; or peanut butter because it may have some sugar added to help it stay emulsified and some saturated fat added to make it less runny. Does that processing suddenly turn the beans from one of the healthiest foods we know of to an unhealthy one? Probably not. Does it make them easier to use in cooking vs dried beans, leading more people to eat beans? Probably yes. Same thing for the peanut butter. As part of my breakfast, I often have a slice or two of brown, whole grain bread with peanutbutter(the non-disgusting kind with additives mentioned above, about 89% peanuts) and banana. That's a meal rich in protein, various kinds of fiber, polyunsaturated fats, slow carbs, various vitamins and minerals. The fact that the PB has a little sugar and sat fat in it doesn't really matter very much. I've tried PB That's 99% peanuts and frankly it's disgusting. It separates, it's runny and it has an off taste too. If that was the only PB on the market I wouldn't even use it. The problem is 1. That government recommendations and public discourse place far, far too much emphasis on population studies based on overly vague categories like this and 2. That there's an almost singular focus on things people should avoid rather than things people need more of, especially fibre and protein. Fibre is crucially important, and maybe this is a hot take, but I think lack of fibre is maybe the most important factor when it comes to public health and food. Fibre increases satiety and bulk, leading you to eat less calories, lowers glycemic index avoiding insulin resistance and diabetes, improves intestinal function(via interaction with gut biome) and therefore micronutrient uptake, and it(specifically beta-glucans found in oats and other grains) even lowers LDL cholesterol. Not to mention it prevents hemorrhoids, which might not affect longevity, but it's certainly nice. And indeed, no surprise, a lot of "ultra-processed" food happens to be devoid of fibre. I think "fibre-depleted" and "protein-depleted" would be more useful categories to use than the much more vague "ultra-processed".
- Symbiote 2y agoModified starch seems like a prime candidate for an ultra-processed ingredient. I don't know which one is used in baked beans, but there's a whole list of enzymes, acids and alkalis used: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_starch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_starch I didn't realize we could buy 89% peanut butter in Europe. At my nearest supermarket in Copenhagen I have the choice of 99.5% (Machandel), 99.6% (Urtekram) or 99.3% (Salling). The other 11% of yours is probably palm oil, sugar and salt, so less questionable than the modified starch but it's still additives to increase shelf life and make the boring, natural peanut more appealing.
- encoderer 2y agoI hope this includes fake meat.
- throwway120385 2y agoIf you can figure out how to include real meat and still account for dietary preferences and allergies for the entire student populace for $2.15 a day then you should publish a book.
- Auracle 2y agoIf you can figure out how to account for the dietary preferences and allergies for the entire student populace for $10 a day I'd call you crazy. That's why we have multiple lunch lines, why they can say "no" to certain things, and why they can bring bagged lunches.
- encoderer 2y agoWe spend about $22,000 a year per student in California. A lot of it is wasted on well meaning but ineffective policy. I think we can afford real meat.
- windhaven 2y agoAs someone who went to public schools and has food allergies, schools I went to just… didn’t account for students with allergies beyond “don’t include nuts.”
- 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mistrial9 2y agoas an American, I saw a documentary xxxxeditxxxxx about food in schools. Some of the French cried actual tears when they saw what American (mostly poor) students ate at school. edit: oh maybe that was "Where to Invade Next?"
- delichon 2y agoI don't expect a school's judgement on proper brain food to be better than for actual food. If they don't much care about the body, why trust them with the mind.
- rightbyte 2y agoI think the cafeteria is run by a profit driven entity quite often.
- johnisgood 2y agoIn Hungary, hospitals and schools and kindergartens make their own food from scratch (they all have their own kitchen), from healthy ingredients. Crazy how different it is in the US. We don't give chips to students, we give them real, healthy food. Every single day. We have been doing this for many decades.
- YesBox 2y agoSame in France: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovO18E-hgew https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovO18E-hgew Your comment brought back my memory of watching this CBS mini-documentary comparing school lunches in France vs USA from years ago. Enjoy!
- impossiblefork 2y agoThis thing about eating slowly that they mention is something I've begun to think is worth it. I've noticed that the stomach is more relaxed and happier if one chews carefully and lets the eating take some time.
- Yeul 2y agoSchools wants to save money and outsource to the cheapest catering service. And pizza is cheaper than fresh vegetables.
- johnisgood 2y agoIn the US? We have never been given harmful, ultra-processed food here, let alone pizza. The differences are wild. Pizza costs a lot here, to be honest. It is cheaper here to just make food from scratch from fresh, healthy ingredients.
- crowbahr 2y agoPizza is flour, tomatoes, yeast, salt and cheese with a splash of oil. Cheese is heavily subsidized by the us govt so the only expensive piece is tomatoes. It's made on an assembly line and shipped out as frozen slabs or as constituent ingredients that are then baked on demand.
- damnitbuilds 2y agoBased on about as much hard evidence as the anti-vaxxers have.
- tossit444 2y ago> To identify which ultra-processed foods should be eliminated from school offerings, scientists will consider whether a product includes additives that are banned elsewhere, whether it has been linked to health harms, whether it has been show to contribute to food addiction, and whether it contains excessive fat, sugar or salt, California Assemblymember Jesse Gabriel, one of the lawmakers who introduced the bill, said on the call. Should make it a rule for people to read the post instead of merely the title.
- damnitbuilds 2y agoWhat hard evidence will they use to decide if foods "Contribute to food addiction"? How can food have "excessive fat, sugar or salt" if it is the only fatty/sugary/salty food someone eats? Why should being banned elsewhere be a reason to ban it in California? Surely being proven harmful should be the bar? Should make it a rule for people to comprehend the post and think about its implications instead of merely reading it.
- sp3000 2y agoAh yes, we should wait for irrefutable proof to determine whether nutrient-dense real foods are better for our children than the ubiquitous ultra-processed food made up of ingredients that are entirely foreign to the human body. Over 50% of American kids are dealing with chronic illness. The food supply is the #1 culprit.
- damnitbuilds 2y agoSo you only eat ingredients that are not foreign to the human body? Is this the first post here by a cannibal?
- sdo72 2y agoI grew up in Vietnam, where freshly cooked meals were a daily staple. Getting them was effortless—just a few steps from home. Coming to the U.S., however, turned this into a major challenge, especially while raising my own kids. Ultra-processed food is everywhere, and preparing fresh meals takes significant time, even though I’ve become quite efficient (a typical meal takes 30–60 minutes). While this doesn’t fully solve our food challenges for kids, it’s a step in the right direction for the future.
- woah 2y ago> I grew up in Vietnam, where freshly cooked meals were a daily staple. Getting them was effortless—just a few steps from home. Huh... I wonder what the difference is between the two societies that allows for this
- wingworks 2y agoThe US is a rich country (compared to Vietnam), so I'd have thought they'd have the resources to automate much of the process of making healthy meals, and thus cheaply. Yet here we are.
- gopher_space 2y agoThe US sees their children as both a cost center and exploitable resource, while Vietnam sees their children as citizens.
- zdragnar 2y agoZoning and sanitary regulations, presumably. For zoning, there's plenty of places that don't allow commercial operations near residential zones- hence the push for more mixed-use zoning. Unfortunately, urban environments still have very high rents, so to stay cheap enough you'd have to get permission to operate a good truck or sidewalk stand. For regulations, there's no way to run (or rent) a commercial kitchen and sell low cost freshly made food and make enough money, especially if you aren't operating out of a food truck. There's several other licenses involved depending on the nature of the business.
- 2y ago
- dwighttk 2y ago>If signed into law, Assembly Bill 1264 would establish the first statutory definition of what qualifies as an ultra-processed food… >Ultra-processed foods, which have typically undergone many industrial changes such as the addition of preservatives, sweeteners, and artificial flavors… Would like to see the definition… that second quotation was the best I could see
- duskwuff 2y agoDoesn't look like the definition has been introduced yet; the current bill is a placeholder: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=202520260AB1264 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...
- gosub100 2y agoI wonder if there will be specific carve-outs for Gavin Newsomes special friends, like how Panera got an exemption from the minimum wage hike?
- mortos 2y agoI guess we'll be fighting this one until the end of time. Panera never had a carve out and was never exempt. Newsom never met with Flynn Group (Panera's owner).[1] [1] https://www.politico.com/news/2024/02/29/gavin-newsom-fast-food-panera-00144282 https://www.politico.com/news/2024/02/29/gavin-newsom-fast-f...
- gosub100 2y ago"The Governor never met with Flynn" All that would be needed for that statement to be true is if Flynn's lawyer talked to one of Newsom's. Follow the money. Baking bread has nothing whatsoever to do with how much it costs to live in CA. It's a carve-out. 325_290_8544
- Animats 2y agoThis is the bill text: "SECTION 1. It is the intent of the Legislature to enact future legislation limiting the sale of ultraprocessed foods in California schools." That's it. It's fairly well understood what makes junk foods tasty without much nutritional value. Salt and sugar play a big role. Those aren't "ultraprocessed". Bread is "ultraprocessed". The number of steps from wheat to bread is large, and the output looks nothing like the input. Here's how "artisanal bread" is really made.[1] It's the ingredients, not the processing. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y-RnRvSGFgY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y-RnRvSGFgY
- ensignavenger 2y agoThe CA legislature actually passed a law stating it was their intent to pass a law?
- Animats 2y agoNot passed, just introduced. It's a placeholder that can move forward to committee. Then, if it goes anywhere, details will be filled in by amendment. This is the legislative equivalent of a function stubbed out in code.
- ensignavenger 2y agoOh I see, my bad, I thought this was passed legislation. I guess I should have paid more attention to the details.
- hnpolicestate 2y agoThis used to be widely accepted and non-controversial. We want kids to have access to whole foods. Organic even better. It's my opinion that climate change activists are responsible for demonizing the whole foods because ultra -processed foods are more sustainable, more efficiently produced etc. I remember a NYT interview of Bill Gates a few years ago where he said organic farming was bad for the environment.
- siliconc0w 2y agoFWIW my local school (CA, US) is serving today: * Beef and cheese taquitos * Orange Chicken, Broccoli Rice Bowl * Granola * Assorted Fresh Fruit/Vegetables So yeah not 100% ultra-processed but generally the mains are and a lot is fried. Pizza is at least one a week. They also have a penchant for questionable vegan food like impossible burgers or the fake chicken fingers.
- bcrosby95 2y agoOurs is all school made and still offers pizza. Pizza is both fast and easy to make. It's "funny" because oftentimes our kids won't eat the school's version of things because they're too used to the processed crap version.
- Molitor5901 2y agoWith respect to "not 100% ultra-processed" - how do you know?
- ndsipa_pomu 2y agoQuite a lot of vegan convenience food is also UPF and generally not very healthy as they'll have a lot of fat added.
- mixmastamyk 2y agoI noticed that carbs were the main ingredient in our school district lunch. A really bad idea if you want kids to be able to focus, rather than alternating cycles of hyper/sleepy.
- Beestie 2y agoI applaud the intent but the devil dwells in the details. I keep up with the latest nutritional gurus in the US and UK and even staunch advocates of abstaining from Ultra Processed Food (UPF) self-admit to having a very hard time defining exactly what that means. In addition, there are not a wealth of studies to support the harm of UPF - its mostly, avoid till more is known and educated supposition. This frustrates attempt to be precise about what's in and what's out. Secondly, why push the deadline out to 2032. Start banning the clear junk next week. Ok, maybe it takes a while to hammer out a definition that works but start with simple rules - ratio of dietary fiber to total carbs <= 5; at least one fresh veggie and one fresh fruit per meal (fresh = not the canned in syrup stuff). CA produces a significant portion of US produce so should be somewhat easy for them. Not so much for Minnesota but baby steps.
- Spooky23 2y agoStandard USDA school breakfast fare includes French toast sticks cooked in an oven in their individually wrapped plastic pouch.
- dawnerd 2y agoWhen I was in high school ages ago we had burritos that were cooked in an oven in their plastic which would sometimes melt into the food. It’s disgusting.
- wingworks 2y agoomg, really, what is happening over there. Sounds like the wild west.
- Molitor5901 2y agoSchool cafeteria food is what is known as Institutional Foods, and it's the same mass produced, empty calorie food served to prisoners, soldiers, school childre, and other people who can't complain.
- 4gotunameagain 2y ago
- gosub100 2y agoI'm not the first person to say this, but the school food should be easily accessible to parents. Maybe have a quarterly parent lunch where the adults try the same meals served to their children. If they are grossed out, that would be a good place to start the discussion on how to improve.
- Gormo 2y agoI wish these sort of articles would stop using vague, catch-all categories like "ultra-processed" and instead explain the specific ingredients in these foods that are thought to be harmful. Valid but insufficiently detailed arguments are indistinguishable from bullshit, and public discourse today is swimming in bullshit. And unless someone is are adding tar and nicotine to chicken nuggets and ginger ale, saying these "ultra-processed" foods have more in common with a cigarette than to fruits and vegetables is disingenuous bullshit.
- Symbiote 2y agoHere's a commonly accepted definition: > Industrially manufactured food products made up of several ingredients (formulations) including sugar, oils, fats and salt (generally in combination and in higher amounts than in processed foods) and food substances of no or rare culinary use (such as high-fructose corn syrup, hydrogenated oils, modified starches and protein isolates). Group 1 foods are absent or represent a small proportion of the ingredients in the formulation. Processes enabling the manufacture of ultra-processed foods include industrial techniques such as extrusion, moulding and pre-frying; application of additives including those whose function is to make the final product palatable or hyperpalatable such as flavours, colourants, non-sugar sweeteners and emulsifiers; and sophisticated packaging, usually with synthetic materials. Processes and ingredients here are designed to create highly profitable (low-cost ingredients, long shelf-life, emphatic branding), convenient (ready-to-(h)eat or to drink), tasteful alternatives to all other Nova food groups and to freshly prepared dishes and meals. Ultra-processed foods are operationally distinguishable from processed foods by the presence of food substances of no culinary use (varieties of sugars such as fructose, high-fructose corn syrup, 'fruit juice concentrates', invert sugar, maltodextrin, dextrose and lactose; modified starches; modified oils such as hydrogenated or interesterified oils; and protein sources such as hydrolysed proteins, soya protein isolate, gluten, casein, whey protein and 'mechanically separated meat') or of additives with cosmetic functions (flavours, flavour enhancers, colours, emulsifiers, emulsifying salts, sweeteners, thickeners and anti-foaming, bulking, carbonating, foaming, gelling and glazing agents) in their list of ingredients. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nova_classification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nova_classification It may well take some similar techniques, processes and chemicals to produce a modern cigarette as it does a chicken nugget. > Chicken McNuggets® > Ingredients: White Boneless Chicken, Water, Vegetable Oil (canola Oil, Corn Oil, Soybean Oil, Hydrogenated Soybean Oil), Enriched Flour (bleached Wheat Flour, Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamine Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic Acid), Bleached Wheat Flour, Yellow Corn Flour, Vegetable Starch (modified Corn, Wheat, Rice, Pea, Corn), Salt, Leavening (baking Soda, Sodium Aluminum Phosphate, Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate, Calcium Lactate, Monocalcium Phosphate), Spices, Yeast Extract, Lemon Juice Solids, Dextrose, Natural Flavors.
- aiauthoritydev 2y agoI am not sure why this needs a bill. Giving parents a greater power over choosing the food in the schools would have worked. Palo Alto parents can afford to ensure the schools have fair trade, organic, locally produced food with vegan options but in stockton having decent colorie intake with some vegetables might be a win.
- NickC25 2y agoOnce met a guy who set up a whole rooftop garden in LA for a couple of schools so they could teach their students about growing food and as well about the importance of fresh ingredients. Part of the program was that kids would take turns (in groups) preparing (under the supervision of a chef) the lunch the school would eat that day, teachers included. The results were awesome, and then the program got cut because it was too expensive. The dude is now a management consultant, ironically enough.
- chneu 2y agoI feel for that dude. I worked in public service for a while and eventually burnt out because I felt like I wasn't making much progress. Even as a vegan today I often ask myself if it's worth it when Cletus is proudly eating 5x the beef anyone should just to "stick it to the soy boys". Progress is slow. Destruction is quick.
- ashoeafoot 2y agoshould just adapt japanese school food. no experiments,embrace tradition
- Molitor5901 2y agoI think this is a great step in the right direction. The first six years of my career were in food safety, specifically public policy, technology, and what to do when an outbreak occurs. The FDA is woefully, exceedingly, ridiculously myopic about these kinds of definitions. [T]he first statutory definition of what qualifies as an ultra-processed food will be the mother of all political fights, just like GMOs, just like artificial dyes, just like high fructose corn syrup. It's almost a losing fight because these are MASSIVE conglomerates that do not want to make anything but super cheap, super profitable, mass produced, ultra processed foods. IF we can define it, and my experience tells me it's a pipe dream at best, it will be a tremendous step forward for better quality in food. Then we can tackle other labels slapped on EVERYTHING such as "all natural" (when it's not) "healthy" when it's not, and my favorite, "sugar free" when it is absolutely not. IMHO, and experience, food companies will do anything to stop these kinds of measures.
- AngryData 2y agoI have zero hope this will improve things when they throw around worthless terms like "ultra processed foods" on top of leaving it essentially a blank page of rules to be filled in at a later date by whoever pays off the right people.