3 ms·
Is there any way to turn suburbs into small towns? I never understood the mentality of people so against the convenience of walking to the corner to buy a gall
by jimbokun 18y ago
Is there any way to turn suburbs into small towns?
I never understood the mentality of people so against the convenience of walking to the corner to buy a gallon of milk that they zoned properties in such a way to make it impossible. I guess it's some masochistic thing, that would just make life too easy.
The debate seems to be suburb vs. big city, evil vs. good (or vice versa). But I grew up in a small town, and never realized what a privilege it was to walk to my elementary and high schools, ball fields, play grounds, library, grocery store, pharmacy, even friends' houses without crossing major highways.
Can we all just admit now that the people who invented suburbs were idiots and find ways to make a subdivision more like a very small town? I'm afraid the answer might be no, but maybe hope I'm overlooking some way this could work.
- natrius 18y ago"I never understood the mentality of people so against the convenience of walking to the corner to buy a gallon of milk that they zoned properties in such a way to make it impossible." If you build retail close enough to housing to walk to it, then people will walk to it. If my house is near that retail, people will walk near my house. People commit crimes. Walkable retail means I will get robbed. Or at least that's how I assume their thought process goes. "Can we all just admit now that the people who invented suburbs were idiots and find ways to make a subdivision more like a very small town?" People are trying: http://www.cnu.org/ http://www.cnu.org/ One such development that I've been paying attention to: http://muelleraustin.com/ http://muelleraustin.com/ It's closer to the center of the city than what most people would call a suburb, but it's in the midst of plenty of suburban density, segregated-use development. The part that has been built is really pleasant to walk around. Instead of giant garages being the primary architectural feature, the garages are in the back on alleys. There aren't driveways every couple of feet with cars blocking the sidewalk like there were in the neighborhood I grew up in. When the "town center" part gets built, the neighborhood should be a pretty amazing place to live. In the Bay Area, Palo Alto's not so bad. You can't really walk anywhere unless you live really close to downtown or the Middlefield shopping area, but at least you can bike places without cheating death.
- flashgordon 18y agobut do we really need a clear distinction between the two? apart from political agendas, how is a suburb, with the same facilities (eg mall, shopping centers, amenities etc) that different functionally from a town?? i mean at the end of the day it does come to supply and demand (for beneficial real estate).. suburbs are where people move out of the city to... or rather suburbs are what the expanded regions of a city are.. as demand for a particular location grows (along with the number of inhabitants), the demand for infrastructure grows (further fuelling demand for the said location?).. the article talks about what to do about the "communities we are left with"... last i checked population is RISING.. unless we have found ways to live magically in thin air, demand for housing will rise (not taking into account short term abnormalities like the current financial slump)...