3 ms·

I don't believe there would be a legal basis for taking down a site cataloging metadata about files. The information would be just as useful to copyright holder

I don't believe there would be a legal basis for taking down a site cataloging metadata about files. The information would be just as useful to copyright holders as it would be to copyright violators (e.g. tracking ownership, issuing takedowns on the basis of hash collisions, etc...). To be very careful, we might decide that no URLs to a hash be cataloged in the 'wiki'. As far as quality control - take a look at wikipedia - it's a beautiful mess. People make edits to entries all the time, some malicious, some not - there is a change tracker, and a community of editors. The consensus and the truth win out over individual acts of malice. If shut downs were truly a concern, the database entries could be stored locally by the user making the entry and retrieval of entries would be like doing a query on a decentralized p2p network (gnutella). But then, that's messier and less scalable. I think we should just make the wiki, and see how it goes as a first step. Establish its usefulness, build a community, and then support it.

Dylan16807 14y ago
I don't believe there would be a legal basis for taking down a site cataloging metadata about files. Remind me what Demonoid did.
rmc 14y ago
I don't believe there would be a legal basis for taking down a site cataloging metadata about files Laws can be changed. The copyright cartels have the money and political connections to change the law in their favour. We have seen them do it before and they're going to do it again. Torrent sites (like The Pirate Bay) are essentially just that (sites cataloguing metadata about files). They have not be immune to legal troubles, and they are certainly not "beneficial to copyright holders". You're essentially describing current torrent sites. We have them, they are very valuable and useful. They work well enough. However they can (and are) shutdown. We need better.

Dylan16807 14y ago

I don't believe there would be a legal basis for taking down a site cataloging metadata about files. Remind me what Demonoid did.

rmc 14y ago

I don't believe there would be a legal basis for taking down a site cataloging metadata about files Laws can be changed. The copyright cartels have the money and political connections to change the law in their favour. We have seen them do it before and they're going to do it again. Torrent sites (like The Pirate Bay) are essentially just that (sites cataloguing metadata about files). They have not be immune to legal troubles, and they are certainly not "beneficial to copyright holders". You're essentially describing current torrent sites. We have them, they are very valuable and useful. They work well enough. However they can (and are) shutdown. We need better.