3 ms·

That's fair. I look at my fellow office workers and see a lot of obesity and back problems caused by too much sitting, but those are optional in a way that my d

That's fair. I look at my fellow office workers and see a lot of obesity and back problems caused by too much sitting, but those are optional in a way that my dad's physical wear and tear from farming weren't. I definitely wouldn't tell a tech guy with no farming experience to just jump into it. Get a few chickens or something, and see what it's like to depend on you for food and water every day, whether it's 100 degrees or a blizzard that day. Or plant a 10x10 garden in your backyard and see what it's like to pull weeds in July heat. And don't expect to make money (or even break even) at it. Farming today only makes money if you go large-scale, which isn't what anyone dreams about, or if you find a niche and are really good at marketing something like artisan cheese. Even people who know what they're doing struggle to make that work.

nradov 2y ago
I've met plenty of farmers who are obese and have a variety of musculoskeletal ailments.
- bigstrat2003 2y ago
  Nobody is saying that being a farmer is a magical key to physical fitness. We're saying that farming, no matter how hard you try to take care of your body, will be hard on your body in ways that office work simply isn't. If you're working in an office you can choose to exercise and eat right, you can choose to practice good posture and take breaks. But as a farmer you can't choose to not do hard physical labor all day long.
  - defrost 2y ago
    > But as a farmer you can't choose to not do hard physical labor all day long. The seasons dictate when a farmer will spend 16 hours a day in a tractor seat ploughing, or seeding, or spraying, or harvesting (and roping a friend in to drive chaser trucks behind the combine). Eyestrain from watching the GPS screen, backache from chair springs getting old, cursing when the air conditioning malfunctions .. it's tough, demanding hard work fit only for RealMen™. At other times of the year there's a lot of choice as to time spent welding, engine mechanics, radio mantainance, going over blueprints for new silos, contracts for grain, yarning with ag advisors, dropping trees on firebreaks, cutting rounds, feeding rounds into hydraulic splitters. And more. So it goes. All the farmers I know are active from dawn to dusk, sometimes quite active, often just idling along fettling something or another. But hard physical labour every day all day long? That's 1930's pre mechanised talk for farmhand work. Picking stones off fields, drywall building by the foot, harnessing bullocks to haul water from the spring. Hand saw and axe. Grapevine pruning and Grapes of Wrath harvesting is what farmers hire backpackers for .. and they get pnuematic cutters and fancy tools these days.
  - s1artibartfast 2y ago
    I grew up on a farm and it isnt hard physical labor that takes a toll on the human body. That is actually the healthy and beneficial part. It is poor ergonomics and acute injury that does the damage to farmers and trade workers too. Work is physical but there is almost always a smart and safe way to do it.

nradov 2y ago

I've met plenty of farmers who are obese and have a variety of musculoskeletal ailments.

bigstrat2003 2y ago
Nobody is saying that being a farmer is a magical key to physical fitness. We're saying that farming, no matter how hard you try to take care of your body, will be hard on your body in ways that office work simply isn't. If you're working in an office you can choose to exercise and eat right, you can choose to practice good posture and take breaks. But as a farmer you can't choose to not do hard physical labor all day long.
- defrost 2y ago
  > But as a farmer you can't choose to not do hard physical labor all day long. The seasons dictate when a farmer will spend 16 hours a day in a tractor seat ploughing, or seeding, or spraying, or harvesting (and roping a friend in to drive chaser trucks behind the combine). Eyestrain from watching the GPS screen, backache from chair springs getting old, cursing when the air conditioning malfunctions .. it's tough, demanding hard work fit only for RealMen™. At other times of the year there's a lot of choice as to time spent welding, engine mechanics, radio mantainance, going over blueprints for new silos, contracts for grain, yarning with ag advisors, dropping trees on firebreaks, cutting rounds, feeding rounds into hydraulic splitters. And more. So it goes. All the farmers I know are active from dawn to dusk, sometimes quite active, often just idling along fettling something or another. But hard physical labour every day all day long? That's 1930's pre mechanised talk for farmhand work. Picking stones off fields, drywall building by the foot, harnessing bullocks to haul water from the spring. Hand saw and axe. Grapevine pruning and Grapes of Wrath harvesting is what farmers hire backpackers for .. and they get pnuematic cutters and fancy tools these days.
- s1artibartfast 2y ago
  I grew up on a farm and it isnt hard physical labor that takes a toll on the human body. That is actually the healthy and beneficial part. It is poor ergonomics and acute injury that does the damage to farmers and trade workers too. Work is physical but there is almost always a smart and safe way to do it.