11 ms·
How the Curiosity Rover's Nuclear Battery Works
- andre 14y agoRelevant: INL helps power mission to Mars http://www.idahostatesman.com/2012/08/06/2219647/inl-helps-power-mission-to-mars.html http://www.idahostatesman.com/2012/08/06/2219647/inl-helps-p... "In simple terms, Curiosity runs, in part, on a $100 million nuclear battery developed at the lab, said Stephen Johnson, division director of Space Nuclear Systems and Technology. The 2-foot-tall, 2-foot in diameter cylinder aboard Curiosity is packed with radioactive isotopes generating heat. That thermal energy is converted into the electricity fueling Curiosity's wheels, arms and other gadgets, as well as recharging its bank of lithium-ion batteries." "Fuel cells in the energy source are 1 inch tall and 1-inch diameter cylinders. Each puts out a mind-boggling 9,000 to 10,000 degrees of heat, shift supervisor Dave Hendricks said."
- dkkarthik 14y agoWow, that's super cool. I wonder if this technology is being used on any earth-based applications? If not, I'm assuming there are harmful side effects that don't necessarily affect the space missions. I'd like to learn more about the negatives of this technology basically.
- aakil 14y agoThere's probably a radiation issue that wouldn't make it suitable for close to human contact. I wonder how much energy the rover needs to move around since the gravity there is considerably weaker.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoRover mass is same on Earth or Mars. So acceleration costs the same. Low gravity also means less friction with the ground, making it somewhat harder to move on Mars. Climbing hills would be easier on Mars.
- aakil 14y agoIsn't there also an issue of impulse though? There must be an acceleration dip compared to earth since I'm basically pushing a mini cooper on earth but only a bicycle on mars. Note: I'm a scientist so I'm embarrassingly bad at physics.
- mpyne 14y agoIt would be easier to lift the rover perhaps, but F=ma, so since the mass of the rover hasn't changed, neither has the acceleration you can develop for a given force applied.
- Shadow6363 14y agoIsn't the friction dependent upon the normal force which on Mars would be less. Therefore, shouldn't the force required to overcome that also be less?
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoWheels need friction to develop acceleration. So its a negative not a positive.
- maxerickson 14y agoIt's only a negative if the vehicle needs to accelerate quickly. So sufficient friction is sufficient, not a negative or a positive. Given that the batteries store roughly 2.4 kW-h, it's probably safe to assume that the max drive power is less than 500 watts (2.4 kW-h / 10 hours -> 240 watts). Earth side electric vehicles commonly have drive power over 100 kilowatts.
- rlpb 14y agoAbsolutely, if you were pushing a block along the ground. Fortunately modern "wheel" technology reduces the bearing friction so much that it is no longer a factor. The only friction left is the friction holding the wheel to the ground. This is reduced in reduced gravity, such that wheels are more likely to slip.
- nikic 14y agoSometimes used in earth-based applications too. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_generator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_gen....
- kalleboo 14y agoIf this is the same tech I remember, Soviet Russia used them a lot for far-flung lighthouses that couldn't be easily refueled. Many of them are still out there, or have been stolen, vandalized, stripped of metal by unwitting thieves, spreading hazard all around. One was even found underwater. edit: links: http://bellona.no/bellona.org/english_import_area/international/russia/navy/northern_fleet/incidents/37598 http://bellona.no/bellona.org/english_import_area/internatio... http://englishrussia.com/2009/01/06/abandoned-russian-polar-nuclear-lighthouses/ http://englishrussia.com/2009/01/06/abandoned-russian-polar-...
- rdtsc 14y agoThere is a movie on Netflix streaming that has some small plot feature tied to one of these these nuclear batteries in a far North Russian weather station: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1588875/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1588875/
- shabble 14y agoFor a short while they were used in implantable pacemakers as 'lifetime' power sources[1] The main issue is that they're really rather inefficient. The efficiency of the thermocouple at converting thermal->electrical is only about 5-10%, and combined with the cost of shielding, expense of the radioisotope to begin with, and security/safety considerations, they're really only suitable for niche aerospace/defense applications. Edit: I was curious if anyone had considered a stirling or other heat-engine driven by decay heat, and found https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stirling_Radioisotope_Generator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stirling_Radioisotope_Generato... which looks like it can hit 20+% efficiencies. The downside is that unlike thermo-electric/Seebeck effect converters, they have moving parts that could be a threat to reliability, which is the major issue when you're a planet away from the nearest repair tech. [1] https://www.orau.org/ptp/collection/Miscellaneous/pacemaker.htm https://www.orau.org/ptp/collection/Miscellaneous/pacemaker....
- ceejayoz 14y agoThe bigger issue using it in pacemakers is it's actually beneficial to have a battery that needs replacing every 10 years or so - pacemaker tech gets better so fast that a 30 year old device would be crap compared to the current generation.
- banana_bread 14y agoHow much better really, if the current one wasn't working well you would find out real quick.
- ceejayoz 14y agoMore sophisticated programs (fewer false positives and false negatives), smaller devices, batteries that last longer between charges, etc.
- sp332 14y agoHow much power does the device generate? How much will it generate in 14 years when it is "expended"? Edit: Initially 2 kW of thermal power and 125W of electrical power, falling by only 20% after 14 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MMRTG#Design_and_specifications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MMRTG#Design_and_specification...
- sehugg 14y agoAccording to Wikipedia, 125 watts when it was launched, down to about 100 watts in 14 years. The JPL guys claim that the RTG is really just a trickle charger for the batteries that actually handle the load -- which likely has transients that the thermocouple in the RTG couldn't handle. I don't know the lifetime of the lithium-ion battery pack but I'm guessing it'll degrade way before the RTG power decreases below the point where it can effectively charge the battery.
- bigiain 14y agoThere's a LiPo technology called "thin film lithium" which is claimed good for 10,000 cycles - assuming one charge/discharge cycle per day (and incorrectly using earth-days for simplicity), that'd give you ~27 years lifetime from the battery. (I wonder if this'll end up with the same "over engineered" reliability that let the Spirit rover last over 6 years when intended for a 90 day mission?)
- i_cannot_hack 14y agoThe Opportunity rover is still up and running, which means it has exceeded its planned duration of activity more than thirty times over.
- grecy 14y agoMany people here in the far north have extensive solar setups and live completely off-grid. Unfortunately in winter, we only get ~4 hours of sunlight, and it's a pain to sweep snow off the panels every day at ~ -30C to -40C We don't get much wind, and rivers are only liquid for ~4-5 months, so wind and hydro are not popular. I've been investigating commercial thermoelectric couplings as a source in the winter. Everyone has a BIG wood stove burning 24x7 for ~6 months. My best research shows it shouldn't be hard to see +400C on the top surface of the stove. My plan is to have a radiator outside, run anti-freeze in the system and get an approx 400 deg C temperature drop. Now, my interest is peaked in this approach from NASA. I wonder how long it will be until I can buy or build such a thing?
- Erifcit 14y agoThis might interest you. http://www.biolitestove.com/campstove/camp-overview/features/ http://www.biolitestove.com/campstove/camp-overview/features...
- peterwwillis 14y agoWho knew steampunk inventions were environmentally friendly?
- grecy 14y agoThanks. I looked into that a while ago (and a similar one), and it looks like any power produced from the TEC is considered a bonus, and is in the range of 1-5W, probably only enough to charge a phone, etc. I'm looking to produce a sustained 150W + to charge deep cycle batteries.
- peterwwillis 14y agoTech specs show the biolite to have about a 2.5in radius and (approx) 6.5in high fuel compartment, which is about 2.1L (http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=volume+of+a+vertical+cylinder+with+a+radius+of+2.5+inches+and+height+of+6.5+inches http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=volume+of+a+vertical+cy...). Using its design you can get about 2W continuous power at 5V. Scaling this up, roughly, you would need about 157.5 liters of fuel space, though probably much less if your fuel was more compact (obv you don't fill up exactly 2L of space in the canister while burning twigs). The realistic output of heat/power based on space is probably much more efficient than something this large, considering they say 46 grams of fuel can boil 1 liter of water, and 46 grams is approx 0.046 liters (based on water density). Somebody please correct my horrible assumptions, but basically, fill an oil drum up most of the way with wood and build a thermoelectric generator and you should be good to go. (Also, if you're charging deep-cycle batteries, i'm assuming you're not going camping? Maybe solar would be simpler? http://www.mdpub.com/SolarPanel/index.html http://www.mdpub.com/SolarPanel/index.html) (Edit again: I forgot your original post, no solar) More edit: Check this page for an adaptable thermoelectric generator: http://www.tegpower.com/ http://www.tegpower.com/ And more edit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bUH1HA3EnZE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bUH1HA3EnZE (i'll stop posting links now!)
- DennisP 14y agoNASA has almost run out of U238: http://www.popsci.com/military-aviation-amp-space/article/2009-09/nasas-plutonium-shortage-threatens-deep-space-exploration http://www.popsci.com/military-aviation-amp-space/article/20... People promoting liquid thorium reactors have been pointing out that they could supply it: http://flibe-energy.com/products/ http://flibe-energy.com/products/
- juiceandjuice 14y agoPlutonium 238 is NOT Uranium 238. There's shitloads of U238 in the world.
- DennisP 14y agoCrap, that's what I meant. Thanks.
- adrr 14y agoThere's Pu238 in our nuclear fuel rods, we aren't allowed to reprocess spent fuel to extract it.
- uvdiv 14y agoThat's worthless because it's contaminated with other isotopes of plutonium. Pure Pu-238 is made by irradiating Np-237, which comes from spent fuel but is already separated in very large amounts in the US. I think the main setback is funding.
- excuse-me 14y agoIt's useless in a fissile device, perfectly usable as a nuclear battery. Waste Pu238 it's a bit dirty if it explodes because of all the other stuff that's mixed in with it - but it's only Florida.
- joaorj 14y agothis article is wrong on many things. one being that the rover can drive during night. the small power output of the "nuclear battery" is not used to drive the rover. it used to recharge batteries during day and night so that the rover can operate on the batteries during the day.
- mbreese 14y agoThat's a good point... while in theory is probably could drive at night, it probably isn't a good idea to have a rover on a different planet driving around in the dark.
- nnnnnnnn 14y agoIs radio communication with the rover even possible at night? We only have line of sight to mars during the martian daytime.
- digitalsushi 14y agoOur line of sight to Mars is independent from Mars seeing the sun.
- danweber 14y agoNot really. If the rover is on the side of Mars facing away from the Sun, it's almost always facing away from the Earth, too, since the Earth is deeper inside the solar system. Facing the Earth and facing the sun are highly correlated. Seeing one xor the other is possible, but unusual.
- saraid216 14y agoHe's still right in a very technical, strict sense. I'm too lazy to look up numbers and do the math, but I expect there's a window near the Martian sunrise/sunset when the sun isn't visible over the horizon and we have line of sight. I expect that window is small to the point where no one actually cares. It would be an interesting applied-math problem for a grade-schooler, though.
- stcredzero 14y ago[In the voice of old "Gauntlet" game] "About-robots.com needs editing badly!" > The first time I heard about the Curiosity Rover nuclear battery, I was thinking this must be top notch technology. What a surprised I had when I saw it has been used for more that 40 years already. Évariste Galois came up with mathematics in the early 1800's which only in just the past several decades had widespread applications in cryptography. Carbon electric arcs were developed right at the start of the 1800's, and not only have we been finding new applications for them ever since, we'll probably keep doing so! Also note that the mid-90's trappings of the digital office were running at Xerox PARC in the early 1970's. As is often said: "The future is here, it just hasn't been evenly distributed yet." There is a lot of "top-notch technology" that the general public doesn't know about yet, and may not for a decade.
- swalsh 14y agoe-ink is another good example. The technology was originally developed in the 70's.
- ScotterC 14y agoThis concept was also used in russian lighthouses because it would be cold enough in siberia to create the delta difference needed. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_generator#cite_ref-Ref__4-0 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_gen...
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoDirect link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_generator#cite_ref-Ref__4-0 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_gen...
- ScotterC 14y agoThanks. Edited
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoSome interesting info about safety on this one: http://bellona.no/bellona.org/english_import_area/international/russia/navy/northern_fleet/incidents/37598 http://bellona.no/bellona.org/english_import_area/internatio... (from Wikipedia citation)
- ScotterC 14y agoI'd disagree with the article and say the biggest threat of the RTG's is not being used by terrorists because a dirty bomb isn't all that effective with that amount of material, however, a bystander digging into one and having fun with the material could be a serious problem. Like the Goinia Incident [0]. Then again. It's kind of a funny thing to worry about with all the unexploded ordinance that's around most countries, even the U.S. I was just out sailing in the long island sound last week and my girlfriend thought it extremely odd how many unexploded bombs pockmark the navigation charts. 0: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goi%C3%A2nia_accident http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goi%C3%A2nia_accident
- bigiain 14y agoUsed as a plot device in a movie called "How I ended last summer": http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1588875/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1588875/ I enjoyed it a lot - it's got that real bleak outlook that some of my favorite Russian cinema has, and some _spectacular_ cinematography.
- jamesmcn 14y agoIs a thermocouple more efficient than a Sterling engine, or just more reliable because of the lack of moving parts?
- sliverstorm 14y agoDon't forget more compact. A sterling engine would require a generator, which in turn means a regulator and a rectifier. Plus, R&R's aren't very reliable either. When the alternator in your car dies, it's usually the R&R that failed. The main disadvantages of thermocouples are cost and efficiency, but cost isn't a big deal for mega government projects and efficiency isn't a big deal when the goals are modest (i.e. not flying about like a helicopter) and the power source is amazing (i.e. nuclear decay)
- ilamont 14y agoWhat are the safety implications of launching 10 pounds of plutonium-238 on a rocket that could malfunction or explode before gaining escape velocity? The article says the plutonium would not explode, but what about plutonium particles or radiation entering the atmosphere and ocean?
- Negitivefrags 14y agoSomehow I stumbled on the exact PDF you want to see: http://www.nasa.gov/pdf/604332main_APP%20MSL%20Launch%20Nuclear%20Safety%20FS%203-2-11.pdf http://www.nasa.gov/pdf/604332main_APP%20MSL%20Launch%20Nucl...
- ilamont 14y agoThanks. The relevant bits: Like previous generations of this type of electrical- power generator, the MMRTG is built with several layers of protective material designed to contain its plutonium dioxide fuel in a wide range of po- tential accidents, verified through impact testing. Each MMRTG carries eight individually shielded general purpose heat source modules (compared to 18 modules in the previous generation). The thickness of the protective graphite material in the center of the modules and between the shells of each module in the MMRTG has been increased by 20 percent over previous modules. However, the same report says there is about a 3% chance of an accident with no release, and a .4% chance of an accident "with release".
- jerf 14y agoThe same safety implications as launching 10 pounds of anything twenty miles in the air, over an ocean, and subjecting it to an explosion. 10 pounds divided by any realistic footprint is negligible. Plutonium is dangerous stuff, sure, but it isn't 10 orders of magnitude more dangerous than anything else the way some people act like it is. It's just dangerous, not imbued with an evil malevolent spirit that wants to irradiate your soul. Bear in mind the Earth is covered in radioactives; it doesn't take all that much division before you've got less radioactivity per acre than already exists naturally, which contrary to apparently popular belief is not 0.
- rogerchucker 14y agoBurning question... can a miniature version of this ever be ported to consumer electronics devices? :-/
- banana_bread 14y agoYes, you would be burning with such a power source in a consumer electronic device.
- uvdiv 14y agoThere's a prototype betavoltaic battery which can sustain 50 microwatts on 20 Curies of tritium [1] -- an efficiency of about 2%. Scaling linearly by 10^4, current technology could get 500 milliwatts on 200 kCi, or 20 grams, enough to charge a 5 watt-hour phone battery in 10 hours. The tritium cost would be on the order of $600,000 today [2]. If you could do this, the battery charge time would be a few decades. [1] http://www.citylabs.net/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=10&Itemid=25 http://www.citylabs.net/index.php?option=com_content&vie... [2] http://fire.pppl.gov/fesac_dp_ts_willms.pdf http://fire.pppl.gov/fesac_dp_ts_willms.pdf
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- aik 14y ago>> The Curiosity Rover Nuclear Battery will supply the system with constant power, allowing it to work as much as needed, all year long for as long as 14 years. Very cool. Massive improvement over the solar panels that only worked during the day and non-winter times.
- ktizo 14y agoSo, when can I get a nuclear car? And what's the insurance gonna cost?
- joshAg 14y agowhen we start building "breeder" reactors again. Plutonium is a byproduct of the breeder reactors when they create the type of uranium that can be used for nuclear bombs (this is one of the reasons that breeder reactors aren't popular). I was talking with one of the scientists at Ames last night, and apparently this is pretty much the last of NASA supply, since the US has significantly cut down on their production of weaponizeable uranium.
- pjscott 14y agoThat's not really accurate, but rather than explaining why, I'll just give the abbreviated rundown on plutonium: Plutonium 238 is a powerful alpha emitter with a half-life of 87.7 years, making it a great element for powering mars rovers. It's produced by exposing Neptunium 237 to neutron flux. You can get Np-237 out of nuclear waste from ordinary reactors. The US has mostly been buying Pu-238 from Russia, but we're running out, and starting up our own production again is kind of expensive. We can do it, though. Plutonium 239 is the kind that gets used in bombs. It's fissile. It's produced by exposing Uranium 238 ("depleted uranium") to neutron flux in a nuclear reactor. It's tricky to make weapons-grade Pu-239, because it tends to be contaminated with Pu-240. Plutonium 240 is annoying and nobody likes it.
- joshAg 14y agowell, i guess i learned not to blindly trust NASA scientists today. thanks for the info; that was pretty interesting.
- caf 14y agoThe type of Uranium used in nuclear weapons (fissile U235) isn't created in reactors; it's purified from natural Uranium, which is almost entirely non-fissile U238 but contains a small proportion of U235. Most commerical enrichment of Uranium uses gas centrifuges to separate the heavier isotopes from the lighter.
- Wingman4l7 14y agoCalling it a "battery" is disingenuous. An RTG doesn't fit the typical definition of a battery -- it doesn't store electrical energy. A better name would be "power supply". </pedant>
- DeepDuh 14y agoWell it does - it stores nuclear binding energy that's unstable enough to be extracted and stable enough to last for x years. It's a nuclear battery just like convential ones are chemical batteries.
- Wingman4l7 14y agoYou're not clipping leads to the ends of it and getting current, though -- you're using thermocouples. It's more of a "heat battery", I suppose.
- DeepDuh 14y agoAnd now draw a black box around that whole system. What do you get? A voltage source, right? Engineers usually don't care much about the principles of how something is made. As long as it can be abstracted to a known concept you're all good and you can integrate it with your given tools, e.g. a combinational circuit plan.
- shirro 14y agoGiven the MSL has a constant power source does that mean it can operate 24hrs and 40 minutes a day? Do they have driving lights or can drive with IR or other sensors? If so they could get a lot more science done than the MER mission. Or do they have to channel the power into heaters each evening?
- nickolai 14y ago>Or do they have to channel the power into heaters each evening? AFAIK, No. The battery generates 2kw of heat in addition to the electricity, so I dont think the rover even has any heaters.
- wcoenen 14y ago> does that mean it can operate 24hrs and 40 minutes a day? Not if it consumes electrical energy from the batteries faster than the MMRTG replenishes it. Then it needs to "rest" to give the MMRTG a chance to recharge the batteries. > Or do they have to channel the power into heaters each evening? Besides 125 watts electric, the MMRTG also continuously outputs 2000 watts of heat. Heat can be pumped around the rover (either for cooling or heating) to keep the instruments at optimal temperature [1][2] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fBtXnug-rgM#t=89s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fBtXnug-rgM#t=89s [2] http://www1.nasa.gov/mission_pages/mars/images/20081209_msl.html http://www1.nasa.gov/mission_pages/mars/images/20081209_msl....