6 ms·
The Vatican's Latinist (2017)
- cbm-vic-20 2y agoIt's fun to set your browser preferences to Latin (ISO 639-1: "la") and see what sites respect that.
- Aransentin 2y agoDo you have any examples of sites that do that?
- cbm-vic-20 2y agoWikipedia does this. The Vatican site did in the past. Google seems to have partial support, showing Italian in some places and Latin in others.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gnabgib 2y agoDiscussions at the time (148 points, 61 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14769758 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14769758 (105 points, 23 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13789097 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13789097
- coolsunglasses 2y agoFoster was basically the rallying point for people opposed to the grammarian methods of teaching languages that started in Classics but ended up taking over how foreign language is taught in most schools and contexts. Virtually everyone actually fluent in Latin today (reading, listening, or speaking) either learned directly from his a tutor using Ossa Latinitatis Sola or was downstream of that. Striking contrast with the most well known classicist in the UK being unable, by their own admission, to comfortably read Latin text basically at all. Abandoning the old ways has cost us a lot in almost every area of human endeavour. Especially in pedagogy.
- globnomulous 2y ago> Striking contrast with the most well known classicist in the UK being unable, by their own admission, to comfortably read Latin text basically at all. Sorry, what? Who is this? Even the PhD students I knew in classics, the ones who were specializing in history or literature, were comfortable reading texts written during their time periods of interest.
- svat 2y agohttps://blogicarian.blogspot.com/2019/03/argumentum-ad-ignorantiam.html https://blogicarian.blogspot.com/2019/03/argumentum-ad-ignor... — per this blog post (which takes https://www.the-tls.co.uk/regular-features/mary-beard-a-dons-life/what-does-the-latin-actually-say https://www.the-tls.co.uk/regular-features/mary-beard-a-dons... as the starting point), most classicists “can't sight-read a complex Latin text all that well” [unlike medievalists and Renaissance scholars].
- dhosek 2y agoGranted I’m 35 years out of undergrad, but my classics professors could most definitely sight-read complex Latin just fine.
- camcil 2y agoIt is fascinating that a language that still has study devoted around it has died right in front of our eyes.
- gattilorenz 2y agoBut among the dead languages it’s one if the liveliest
- mmooss 2y ago> Striking contrast with the most well known classicist in the UK being unable, by their own admission, to comfortably read Latin text basically at all. That's hard to believe. A friend was a Latin teacher; high school students read actual Roman Latin in their second year. I've heard that few can speak Latin 'correctly', because the skill is almost useless - you can't talk to Romans or almost anyone else; it's all written. (I don't know about the Catholic or other churches, but I do recall that 'church Latin' differs from classical Latin.)
- spudlyo 2y agoIf you find this article fascinating, and are intrigued by the possibility of learning to speak a dead language like Latin, I'm here to tell you that it's probably a lot easier than you think. To start off, there is a textbook that I think really resonates with hackers. It's called "Lingua Latina Per Se Illustrata" (The Latin Language Illustrated through itself) and it teaches Latin in a fun and mind-altering way. The entire book is in Latin, but it starts of with very simple sentences that anyone who speaks English or a Romance language can intuit with a bit of effort. There are very clever marginal illustrations that help drive the meaning home. It builds an understanding in Latin brick by brick, and eventually you find yourself understanding complex sentences and ideas. Furthermore the book is just fun and often funny, it tells a story of a Roman family and strikes an excellent balance between teaching and entertaining. Contrast this approach with dense Latin texts that have a heavy focus on grammar and translation. So that's one way to learn the language, but what about speaking it? Well, that's where the Legentibus app comes in. It's a Latin language podcast application which has wealth of well recorded stories in classical Latin at a bunch of different difficulty levels. It also has has the Latin language text of the stories that are highlighted as the audio is read, with optional interlinear English translations. I find these really help at first to help me understand the content. I turn them off later once I get the gist of what is being said, or just listen without reading. You can also do dictionary lookups of individual words without turning on the translation. Here are the reasons why I think this is one of the most enjoyable and useful things I do as a newbie Latin language learner: 1) The stories themselves are engaging. Some of my favorites are from "Gesta Romanorum" (Deeds of the Romans) which is a 13th or 14th century collection of stories often with a moral allegorical themes. These were rewritten in a beginner friendly style, but use classical Latin idioms, some of which are explicitly pointed out in the text as clickable footnotes. 2) Daniel (the co-founder of the app and Latin scholar) does an excellent job as a reader. I listen to a lot of audio books, and I especially like it when the reader consistently does memorable character voices. Be it an extortionist dog slyly claiming "Omnēs canēs amant" (everyone loves dogs) or Pluto, King of the Underworld, commanding "Eurydicē accēde hūc!" in a booming voice, Daniel nails it. 3) You can listen to these while folding laundry, cooking dinner, or doing whatever. I manage to squeeze in 40 minutes a day or so of these stories, and I'm always happy to do it. 4) Often times when I learn a new bit of grammar or learn the precise meaning of a word, my mind often will replay in my head a phrase (in Daniel's voice) from one of the stories that uses that word or grammatical concept. This happens more than you might expect. Finally, there is a pretty vibrant online community of Latin language learners out there, from the /r/Latin subreddit, to the LLPSI (Lingua Latina per se Illustrata) Discord (https://discord.gg/uXSwq9r4 https://discord.gg/uXSwq9r4) to the Latin & Ancient Greek) Discord (https://discord.gg/latin https://discord.gg/latin) and others. It's never been easier to pick up Latin.
- schoen 2y agoI've mentioned here that I got to study with him in his summer course the very last year it was held in Rome (when he got sick and ultimately came back to the U.S.). He was a really cool guy and teacher of some really cool students, many of whom are still teaching Latin with their own spins on it. This article was published in 2017, so it doesn't mention that Foster subsequently died in 2020.
- spudlyo 2y agoHe's quite a character! I found a great video[0] of him speaking for over an hour to a classroom filled with former students. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZLcWl_NCMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZLcWl_NCMY
- schoen 2y agoWow, it looks like there are also interviews recorded with him in his nursing home after his retirement! https://www.youtube.com/@latintalk9556/videos https://www.youtube.com/@latintalk9556/videos He had a lot more energy earlier in his life (of course), but you can still see a lot of his ideas and passion. In the classroom in earlier decades he was sometimes a lot louder than this. :-)
- unit149 2y ago"You don't study Liszt, you don't study Wagner, and come out hating music." [17:21] Foster's work is based in the classical and English schooling tradition. When a boy was sent to school he would typically be introduced to the paradigms of Latin. Only having mastered it would Greek forms be introduced.
- ks2048 2y agoSome of the suggested videos from that link him speaking just in Latin, which is pretty interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wBIZEkTKuq4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wBIZEkTKuq4 [LatinTalk: 045 Duo suadeo, duo propono]
- akshayshah 2y agoI had the chance to attend some of Father Reginaldus’s summer school in 1999, and it sparked a lifelong love of Latin. The article did a wonderful job capturing the verve that Reginaldus brought to the material. I’ve always imagined the Recurse Center being similar-ish for programming.
- dang 2y agoRelated: Father Reginald Foster has died - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25539292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25539292 - Dec 2020 (51 comments) The Vatican's Latinist - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14769758 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14769758 - July 2017 (61 comments) The Vatican’s Latinist - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13789097 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13789097 - March 2017 (23 comments)
- DemocracyFTW2 2y agoWould not have expected to read all of this article, but I did, started my day. Can recommend, would read it again.
- slyall 2y agoWhen Pope Benedict resigned he announced it in Latin unexpectedly. Many present did not understand what he was saying. https://insidethevatican.com/magazine/pope-benedicts-resignation-speech/ https://insidethevatican.com/magazine/pope-benedicts-resigna...
- felipeerias 2y agoTime will tell, but after more than two millennia this might have been the last significant announcement made in Latin.
- error_logic 2y agoRevealing much?
- error_logic 2y agoMemetic hazard.
- Jun8 2y agoWho would be a person with similar competency in Ancient Greek living now?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gorgonical 2y agoI don't know but if you want to find out a good place to look is Luke Ranieri's Polymathy/ScorpioMartianus channels. He engages very actively with the Ancient Greek and Latin languages and his content is also useful for discovering other links. The tl;dr with Ancient Greek as I understand it (warning) is that dramatically less content was written and over a much larger time period. Homer's works are even described as their own (Homeric) and as such it makes "Ancient Greek" a more nebulous term than "Latin," even when you account for Old/Classical/Late branches. In turn, making it in my estimation harder to have a Fr. Foster equivalent. Look into it and let me know.
- dhosek 2y agoI’ve been rebuilding the meagre Latin I picked up in college in the 80s and I’ve found late Latin to be a bit helpful for building confidence—Beeson’s Primer of Medieval Latin and the Vulgate Bible have been my primary texts of late. With the Vulgate, I’ve been painstakingly translating by hand every verse (I’m not as diligent as I should be so I’m only up to Genesis 17 despite a few years of doing this in fits and starts). With Beeson, I reached the point where by the time I got to the poetry section, I was relying much less on wiktionary (which is handy because you can find most words by their inflected forms rather than having to know the correct dictionary form). I doubt I’ll ever be fully fluent, but I’ve got a pretty solid reading knowledge these days.
- Koshkin 2y agoFor anyone curious, this is one of the best places to learn about some early Indo-European languages: https://lrc.la.utexas.edu/eieol https://lrc.la.utexas.edu/eieol
- dhosek 2y agoA bit late to add to the discussion, but a couple things of note: 1. Foster died in 2020 (he tested positive for Covid at the time of his death, but it’s unclear whether that was the cause). 2. The promised second volume to the bones is available now. 3. There is a third volume coming out in August.