3 ms·
> Also consider the mouse that couldn’t charge while you use it I've come around a lot on that design. Well, it's still an awful mouse shape as far as I'm con
by Dylan16807 2y ago
> Also consider the mouse that couldn’t charge while you use it
I've come around a lot on that design. Well, it's still an awful mouse shape as far as I'm concerned. But putting the port on the bottom gets people to unplug the mouse. I like that as a goal. And it can do a temporary charge pretty fast, so the downside isn't very big.
- airstrike 2y agoSorry, what's the advantage here? People are going to unplug the mouse anyway when it doesn't need charging because it feels much more natural. _Forcing_ people to stop using the mouse to charge is a braindead decision
- FredPret 2y agoIt might be wrong but it's not braindead. The idea was to prevent non-techy users from using it plugged-in all the time, which would look stupid. They wanted to accentuate the wireless nature and easy connectivity of the mouse. Essentially a marketing decision. I disagree with this take but it's worth remembering that it's marketing that turned computing from a niche activity to what it is now (which, by the way, is what makes it a viable career to the people here)
- ryandrake 2y agoThis is ugly. User behavior modification as a product goal. The reverse of how you should build products. You need to start with "The user wants to do X." rather than "I want the user to do X." Who is Apple to dictate the "correct" way for me to use a mouse?
- Dylan16807 2y agoI don't know how much users "want" to have a cord dangling off the mouse and doing nothing. If your starting premise is "the user wants to use the mouse and have a good experience", you can see how a designer can get from there to a feature that causes/encourages an unplug. Even if you disagree, they're not going backwards.
- hbn 2y agoUsers aren't designers, they don't know what they want and will put up with bad experiences because they don't know it can be better. If Apple let the mouse be used when plugged in, everyone would do it immediately and never try using it unplugged cause of their battery anxiety from every other device. Then you try it unplugged and you realized you have to plug it in for like an hour every couple months and it's way better than tethering yourself with a cable. I've used a Magic Mouse daily for work for years and it's literally never been an issue once.
- ryandrake 2y ago> If Apple let the mouse be used when plugged in, everyone would do it immediately and never try using it unplugged So what? Why should that bother Apple so much? They sold the mouse. Who cares how the user uses it? A user who chooses to use their mouse while plugged in does not in any way affect the mouse's manufacturer. My Apple keyboard lets me use it while it's plugged in, and the world hasn't ended. Why didn't they put the charger on the bottom of the keyboard too? Why don't they make their phones so you can't use them while charging?
- Dylan16807 2y ago> So what? Why should that bother Apple so much? They sold the mouse. Who cares how the user uses it? A user who chooses to use their mouse while plugged in does not in any way affect the mouse's manufacturer. If the user has a worse experience, that's a lose/lose situation. Of course they should care about things that affect the experience. > My Apple keyboard lets me use it while it's plugged in, and the world hasn't ended. Why didn't they put the charger on the bottom of the keyboard too? A cable doesn't impact a keyboard because it's not moving. > Why don't they make their phones so you can't use them while charging? The chance of a phone being left plugged in forever is minimal to begin with, and the hassle of not being able to use it while it charges would be much larger.
- ryandrake 2y agoHow is using a peripheral while plugged in a worse experience? It's a better experience: I've had many more problems with wireless peripherals than wired ones. Bluetooth disconnecting randomly, batteries discharging while I'm working. Wireless is a worse experience in almost all ways. If you make a wireless peripheral and everyone keeps using it while plugged in, the solution is not to force them to use it wirelessly. The solution is to make the wireless experience actually better so the user voluntarily chooses to use it.
- elevatedastalt 2y agoNo, it's utility that turned computing from a niche activity to what it's now. Apple is a fashion statement and it's okay for them to market to that effect, but don't credit the growth of computing to Apple's aesthetic but oft-ill-designed stuff.
- FredPret 2y ago> don't credit the growth of computing to Apple's aesthetic but oft-ill-designed stuff. I'm not; I'm crediting the activity of marketing. It's an engineering blind spot to think utility = adoption. Emacs is more powerful than MS Word; which one has more users? Which one has an organization dedicated to going around and pointing out how and where it is useful? It's when you have utility + marketing that you get something like the computer revolution.
- dubrocks 2y agoThe problem is the software. macOS could remind you to charge the night before, but it always ends up needing charging in the morning as you're ready to start working. One engineer could fix the problem in under an hour if anyone at Apple cared about user xperience.
- acdha 2y agoI’ve used one of those for years and there’s never been any impact on the user experience. Every few months, the low battery warning pops up. At that point, it will still work for hours and it only takes a few minutes to charge so even if it popped up first thing in the morning I’d plug it in the next time I got coffee, went to a meeting, walked the dog, etc.
- RunSet 2y agoDesigning the mouse so it is useless while the charging cable is connected means that if the battery no longer takes a charge the mouse becomes e-waste.
- Dylan16807 2y agoDoes that happen often? Especially compared to the switches? If any other component fails the mouse becomes e-waste so that's not exactly novel. And 50% of the original long lasting battery capacity would be fine here.
- samatman 2y agoI've never heard from anyone who likes the Apple Mouse enough to use it, but doesn't like the charging from the bottom. It's frequently cited as a 'flaw' by those who don't use it, this has become a bit of conventional wisdom. In reality it's a non-issue. I have heard from a whole lot of people who don't like the Apple Mouse. I don't like that mouse. But it isn't because of the charge port. It's an uncomfortable shape for my hand, and I prefer a trackball. I think it's fine for Apple to have one peripheral which appeals to a minority taste. We're not short of mouse designs and they all work with the operating system. It's not even the main peripheral Apple sells for the purpose, that's the trackpad and everybody likes it. I still prefer a trackball, Tim Cook uses some kind of oddball vertical mouse with a bunch of buttons. It's a big design space. If they wanted to please the maximum amount of people, they'd need to clone Microsoft's mouse, and that would be boring.
- p_j_w 2y ago>It's frequently cited as a 'flaw' by those who don't use it Maybe without this flaw they would use it.
- Dylan16807 2y agoThat's possible. But for a small or medium flaw, you'd expect a bunch of people that complain but keep using it. Only a really big flaw would prevent users entirely and find no complaints among the people that keep using the product. I find it hard to believe it's that big of a flaw. It seems much more likely that the people that started off against the charging decided after trying it that they didn't care very much.
- ksec 2y agoI actually like the charging port design. It stops normal user from using the mouse plugging in. Which is not what it was designed for. They could have designed the USB-C port in the mouse does not come with Data Pin. But given it is a wireless mouse it would still work plugged in as wireless mouse powered by cable. In the end I really think it is a non-issue. The shape still sucks though.
- KoolKat23 2y agoI'm sorry no amount of mental gymnastics can convince me that location is user friendly. Reminds me of Zoolander haha. Either that or what you describe is Stockholm syndrome. A port on the side is harmless. In an alternate world, it would have become the design zeitgeist and a port under would've seemed just as preposterous as it actually is.