5 ms·
PG&E asks to raise rates for California customers so it can pay investors more
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://www.pge.com/en/newsroom/currents/energy-savings/pg-e-s-cost-of-capital-application-and-what-it-means-for-custome.html https://www.pge.com/en/newsroom/currents/energy-savings/pg-e...
- tamaharbor 2y agoIsn’t this the way regulated utilities work?
- danans 2y agoIt's the way investor-owned regulated utilities work. Municipal utilities are also regulated but don't have investors to pay.
- rayiner 2y ago> Municipal utilities are also regulated but don't have investors to pay Somebody has to pay.
- goosedragons 2y agoNo? Privately owned utilities with guaranteed return rates will charge more to guarantee those return rates. A publicly owned utility would be fine operating at 0% returns.
- refurb 2y agoNot always. A public utility has little incentive to be efficient as like you said, they are fine with 0% returns. If a private utility gets a rate of $1.00 on $0.94 of expenses, it has an incentive to further reduce costs to increase the return, which reduces future rate growth (as higher rates won’t be approved).
- reverendsteveii 2y ago>as higher rates won’t be approved Won't they, though? It seems like a rubberstamping process at this point.
- rayiner 2y agoStudies show the opposite is true. Nobody gets voted out of the municipal rate board for denying rate approvals and allowing maintenance and capital investment to fall by the wayside. It's one reason U.S. infrastructure is in such terrible shape.
- refurb 2y agoCPUC members in California aren’t voted in, they are nominated by the Governor. So CA is a unique situation where the regulator effectively controls the public utility so calling it “private” is a bit of a stretch. More like a state controlled entity that trades on the stock market.
- refurb 2y agoIf you’re talking about California utilities the rate decisions are all on the CPUC website. Rate increases absolutely aren’t rubber stamped, the CPUC routinely denies expenditures and the comedians rate increases. But speaking more of the hypothetical, if set up correctly a regulated private utility could be incentivized to reduce costs to capture a higher profit at the same rate.
- supertrope 2y agoInvestor owned utilities have more access to capital. The credit union / non-profit / co-op / municipal alternative is not an automatic win for customers.
- goosedragons 2y agoMight have more access to more capital. And they're not very incentivized to use it. There's no competition.
- rayiner 2y ago> A publicly owned utility would be fine operating at 0% returns. A publicly owned utility running at 0% returns wouldn't be able to pay interest on the debt it would have to issue to make capital investments.
- loeg 2y agoWhy not? The only reasonable 0% target for public agencies would be net of expenses, including cost of capital.
- esbranson 2y agoThey "pay" their customers. Which makes your comment silly.
- fenced_load 2y ago[dead]
- barryrandall 2y agoSomeone has to pay, but there's no requirement that someone gets to take a percentage as profit.
- rayiner 2y agoWhere do you think a rinky-dink municipality gets the money to pay for infrastructure? They turn to capital markets, who will make a profit on the bonds or whatever.
- antasvara 2y agoWhere does an investor owned utility get the money to pay for infrastructure? Because they're generally not cutting into profits to fund infrastructure improvements. PG&E is paying 2.4 billion dollars a year in interest expense (at least in 2023), so it's fair to wonder if that's really any better.
- loeg 2y agoThey also don't build transformers in-house; they pay vendors for providing goods and services. Why do you think capital is any different from other services? If a private utility issues a bond, investors in the bond will also make a profit on the bond in addition to investors in the private utility making a profit on the utility.
- robertlagrant 2y ago> Municipal utilities are also regulated but don't have investors to pay. They also don't keep your 401k healthy.
- Supermancho 2y agoJPMorgan is responsible for that, not the private run utility.
- y33t 2y agoMuni utilities get treated with kid's gloves by courts though. I have direct personal experience of a muni burning nearly a quarter million acres, destroying over 500 homes and ~100K acres of timber. When it came to trial, the court capped their liability at $50m on day one. Their employees even joked about what an outrageous fire hazard all their lines were over text just a few days before it happened. The funniest part is the utility increased rates...but only for people living in the fire-affected areas.
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/power-moves-how-electric-utility https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/power-moves-how-electric-... https://kevin.burke.dev/kevin/norcal-cities-new-utility/ https://kevin.burke.dev/kevin/norcal-cities-new-utility/
- k310 2y agoThe Public Utilities Commission doesn't know how to say no to PG&E.
- sc68cal 2y agoRegulatory capture
- powerbroker 2y ago1. I've paid electric bills in four different cities. Rates haven't been increased at more than 1x annually in any of them. 2. California is getting what seems to be two overhauls: a) replacing/upgrading lines and vegetation practices to harden them against sparking fires; b) massive electrification of cars, data centers, appliances. The capex has to be paid somehow... and interest rates are a drag to that.
- riku_iki 2y ago> Rates haven't been increased at more than 1x annually in any of them. Do you mean 2x? > California is getting what seems to be two overhauls I believe large share of rate increase is because PG&E need to pay multibillion penalty for previous years of negligence which caused multiple fires with casualties.
- xeromal 2y agoThey're part of the wildfire fund so hopefully it's not all that. https://www.cawildfirefund.com/participating-utility-companies https://www.cawildfirefund.com/participating-utility-compani...
- riku_iki 2y agothat's safety improvement 5B fund, but there are also damage payments for 25.5B: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/judge-oks-nearly-25-billion-for-pge-fire-victims-insurers https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/judge-oks-nearly-25-bill...
- DistractionRect 2y agoWhen talking about increases, usually you're talking about the increase by itself. So if the total bill doubles from last pay period period, it is said that it has _increased_ 1x.
- riku_iki 2y ago> it is said that it has _increased_ 1x. my experience is that people say it increased 2x times. You can say it increased by 100%.
- phendrenad2 2y agoThe biggest investors in PG&E are Blackrock, Vanguard, Fidelity, JP Morgan. So in other words, people's 401ks. Not sure how it makes sense that your retirement depends on a company with no competition and the ability to charge you any amount of money they want.
- martin8412 2y agoWell, that sounds more like a discussion about if it should be a private company, government run or some kind of coop owned by the customers. The last one generally benefits the customers.
- phendrenad2 2y agoThat too. But since we're in this situation where it's a public company, it's just funny to me that people's finances are both being helped and harmed by PG&E, probably canceling itself out.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoOld people’s (specifically asset owners, so above average wealth) finances being helped out and young people’s finances being harmed. Although, I don’t really see any other way for a society with a non pyramid shaped population histogram.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> coop owned by the customers I find it a bit hilarious that I, living in the reddest state in the union, have member-owned cooperative power [1] that is 100% wind while my parents in California pay 6x my rate for mostly natural gas [2] and wildfires. [1] https://www.lvenergy.com/my-account/ https://www.lvenergy.com/my-account/ [2] https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/california-electricity-data/2023-total-system-electric-generation https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/califo...
- throwawaytn4U9 2y agoOn the aggregate this cancels out, but on the micro level this is just a kind of wealth transfer from the poor to the investor/retiree class, not too different from a tax on the young and less fortunate. The rich boomers are getting their retirement subsidized by screwing over the working class and the younger generation, pretty on brand I'd say.
- reverendsteveii 2y ago>The new request comes after the California Public Utilities Commission, which Gov. Gavin Newsom's administration oversees, approved six rate increases for PG&E in 2024. >PG&E also reported a record $2.47 billion in profits in 2024, which was an increase from an earlier record that was set in 2023. Well that's all I needed to see. If an increase every two months and setting a new profit record every year isn't enough then maybe someone else should be in charge of this. Maybe the people who need this should be in charge of this, not someone whose sole purpose is to squeeze those people for as much as possible.
- gruez 2y ago>Well that's all I needed to see. If an increase every two months and setting a new profit record every year isn't enough then maybe someone else should be in charge of this. Given inflation is a thing, wouldn't you expect "record profits" year after year, even if nothing else changed?
- sc68cal 2y agoNo. You _could_ argue that record _revenue_ could happen due to inflation, but that's not profit.
- gruez 2y ago>but that's not profit. Did you mean profit margins? OP mentioned profits in absolute dollar amounts, not in % terms. Otherwise it's absurd to claim that dollar profits should stay the same, even with inflation.
- smegma2 2y agoprofit = revenue - cost Revenue and cost both increase by 10% due to inflation profit = 1.1 * revenue - 1.1 * cost profit = 1.1 * (revenue - cost) So profit also increased by 10 percent.
- reverendsteveii 2y ago
- hnburnsy 2y ago>Well that's all I needed to see. If an increase every two months and setting a new profit record every year isn't enough then maybe someone else should be in charge of this. Gross profit is not relevant, $2.4B on sales of $24B is only a 10% profit margin. With 5.6 million customers, that is $440 per customer in profits.
- altairprime 2y agoThey said they invest 97% of profits back into infrastructure, prior to this rate increase proposal. A 3% investors profit share is quite enough and I hope they’re denied by the state. PG&E capped at returning 3% of profit to investors a year for a century would be an appropriate sentence and sentencing term for the Redwood City explosion. Investors will invest in it no matter how small the guaranteed profit, because they’re a monopoly, and literally every dollar the state allows them to pay out in shareholder dividends is paid for out of the state’s GDP after the year’s wildfires and outages. It would be interesting to do the math and estimate about how many dollars they expect this to generate in payouts, and then express that payout in terms of infrastructure ruggedization. Are they asking for an investor payout the size of “10% of the estimated cost of deploying underground wiring in wildfire-probe forested regions”? 25%? 150%?
- tracker1 2y agoIt could also mean doing what health insurance corporations are doing... just spending more, so they get their $limit% return from a larger pie.
- altairprime 2y agoThey are of course perfectly welcome to spend more, given their catastrophic underinvestment in every aspect of their business other than shareholder dividends. Pay line workers more! Buy more electrical service gear! If they do that they’re absolutely welcome to the higher dividends.
- 2y ago
- tzs 2y ago> The new request comes after the California Public Utilities Commission, which Gov. Gavin Newsom's administration oversees, approved six rate increases for PG&E in 2024 How are rate increases counted? I don't know how rates work in California, but looking at rates in my state the power company for my region has a bunch of different rate schedules. There's the normal residential rate schedule, 3 different time-of-use based residential rate schedules that are being tested, and rate schedules for businesses (I think there may be several depending on the kind of business). They may be different residential schedules for rural customers and non-rural customers. I think there are also some different schedules for farms. Depending on how you count you could end up with a dozen rate increases in a year but with each customer seeing 0 or 1 increases. > [...] state Sen. Aisha Wahab filed a proposal, the Investor-Owned Utilities Accountability Act, that would [...] > It would also cap any rate increase to no more than the Consumer Price Index, which is a measure of the average change over time in the prices consumers generally pay for goods and services. Is the CPI appropriate for this? I would expect that the most important factors that affect the cost of running an electric utility would not not correlate well with the CPI. Shouldn't any cap be tied to something that more closely matches the costs of running the utility?