8 ms·
> It’s just nuts to me the degree to which FE development as a whole seems to embrace the breaking change, the deprecation, etc. I’m amazed at how much of this
by Aurornis 2y ago
> It’s just nuts to me the degree to which FE development as a whole seems to embrace the breaking change, the deprecation, etc.
I’m amazed at how much of this is driven by the FE influencers. The FE world has embraced social media, YouTube, and even Twitch to a degree that I haven’t seen in other domains.
Influencers in these areas need to have a constant stream of fresh material to stay relevant, so they’re always driving toward something new that they can produce content about.
This is in addition to the very active conference circuit. FE and JS conferences feel like one big competition to present on some hot new topic.
There’s also a huge market for selling FE courses. These course creators need you to convince your boss to approve a $700 (limited time price!!!) video course to learn the new hot thing, but they can only do that if they get the industry to move away from the old thing that everyone knows already. So they push hard to drive the new thing and deprecate the old thing.
- ewzimm 2y agoThat's fascinating, and I had no idea web dev influencers were so big. I checked, and there really are people with millions of followers doing development. Personally, the idea of learning anything related to coding through a video is extremely frustrating. It's a text medium. I want to look at things, take time, think it over, compare code, follow references, look up functions. That people like video formats isn't really surprising to me since it's everywhere, but I still don't fully understand the appeal. Even if you were raised on video content and started coding that way, at some point you have to reference text documentation, right? At that point, I would think you would just stick to the text and not go back to the video, but maybe it's just more entertaining the other way.
- wiseowise 2y ago> That people like video formats isn't really surprising to me since it's everywhere That’s because those “people” are either larping students or kids that want to become programmers. I have never in my 10 year career met a person who said “yeah, I learn my craft from Fireship videos”.
- nine_k 2y agoLikely these videos did not exist when your reference / age group was acquiring these skills. Videos are sort of easier to produce (via screen capture), and are much easier to show the effect of FE things: look, we write code like this, now we can click here, and the page reacts that way. No need to muck with JSFiddle or something. I'm not a fan of videos as a reference medium, but they can be elucidating to those who needs more hand-holding, literally "click here, see the result". Back in the day, a few short videos about Blender helped me quite bit to grasp certain things that were not obvious from descriptions.
- golergka 2y agoI've learned most of what I know about database internals from MCU lecture course on YouTube. It's great.
- willhslade 2y agoMarvel cinematic university?
- aaronblohowiak 2y agoI assume its CMU, Carnegie Mellon u
- thaumasiotes 2y agoYou wouldn't believe what else you can learn there.
- bloomingkales 2y agoHere's one: https://remix.run/ https://remix.run/ These grifters sell entire courses on the product, that's their game. So when you find an unmaintained Remix app at your company, well, the grifters got the ears of your junior devs :( And they just promote it and promote it: https://kentcdodds.com/blog/a-review-of-my-time-at-remix https://kentcdodds.com/blog/a-review-of-my-time-at-remix https://kentcdodds.com/blog/why-i-love-remix https://kentcdodds.com/blog/why-i-love-remix https://kentcdodds.com/courses https://kentcdodds.com/courses Pure grift. But since most people are decent people they don't know and fall for it, and something like this influencer emerges. They have entire Discords of customers, the same as crypto scams. Edit: I don't know why people would downvote calling out a notable grifter in a thread that extended out to a discussion about influencers. WHICH influencers? Are we scared of that topic? The climate of the JS ecosystem didn't happen accidently. People fall victim to this shit right here on HN, and then write blog posts about what the fuck is wrong with frontend: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39453767 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39453767 (This entire thread reads like deliberate testimonials.) Stop buying this stuff.
- numinoid 2y agoNot sure it's fair to characterize a repo with 6k + commits and the last being 10 hours ago as "pure grift".
- bloomingkales 2y agoI think that adds to my point. How does that have so many stars on github? The customers "star" it. Who uses this on a real app? It's alright to slowly accept the bitter truth that grifting scales.
- numinoid 2y agoNot really sure that's relevant. Grift implies an intentional value extraction without providing anything. Using your example: I'm confident that the time spent working on remix and courses related to it resulted in far less monetary gain than spinning out courses on React. If you think Remix is misguided or a bad framework etc... that is very different from grifting. A corollary: Is Deno a grift because it shares the same creator as Node and has a paid product attached to it? In my opinion no but you might disagree... I'm mostly opposed to the idea remix in particular exists purely as a grift - love it or hate it there are far easier ways for someone with the influence of Kent to make money.
- Vegenoid 2y agoThese videos are edutainment at best, which is generally not a good way to learn something well enough to be able to actually work with it. A lot of them are pretty much straight up entertainment, where the entertainment value comes from drama and strong opinions. They're totally fine if you know that, but some of their audience does not know that. I've been seeing more and more of a certain kind of person who are into these videos on some Discord servers, and it is clear that they are driven more by culture and style than by the goal of creating some thing, or having a strong understanding of how to make computers do certain things.
- jasode 2y ago>, the idea of learning anything related to coding through a video is extremely frustrating. It's a text medium. I want to look at things, take time, think it over, compare code, follow references, look up functions. That people like video formats isn't really surprising to me since it's everywhere, but I still don't fully understand the appeal. I like (some) programming videos and I'll give my perspective as someone who learned 100% from books and 3-ring binders for old languages like C/C++/C#/Javascript/Python/bash/etc. (The 1980s Microsoft C Compiler manuals were 3-ring binders.) The newer languages I learned with a hybrid of videos + traditional books would be HTML CSS, Apple Swift, and PyTorch with the latest AI toolkits and libraries. The extra dimension that videos offer besides plain text is the live usage of IDE, tools, troubleshooting, etc. For me, watching a dynamic screen with a moving mouse cursor and voiceover seems to activate extra neurons moreso than just reading static text in a book. There's also a lot of "activities in-between the coding" that's helpful such as seeing the programmer looking up something in various pages of documentation, scrolling around, navigating etc. Another useful aspect that's underappreciated is seeing the mistakes the programmer makes during the video recording. E.g. the code doesn't compile because of invalid syntax. Or a config setting is wrong and he troubleshoots what's preventing it from working. In contrast, virtually all text books or blogs of coding are "perfect happy path" outcomes. But real-world programming is messy with broken intermediate states. A lot of videos show the messy steps to get to a working state. The videos that are not that helpful would be the videos of C++ CppCon conference sessions where there are a bunch of static slides with bullet points and the speaker just reads them aloud word-for-word. Although I learned C++ from textbooks, I found videos of Matt Godbolt showing tips & tricks of how to use his Compiler Explorer (http://godbolt.org http://godbolt.org) very helpful. In summary, the artifacts of coding may be the text, but the activity of coding involves a lot more than just the text and that's why some videos can enhance learning.
- kunzhi 2y agoI'm not sure if this is what you intended, but I read this as a great argument in favor of pair programming.
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoDefinitely. As long as the videos are uncut, they can be a confidence booster that I'll be able to replicate the result, because I can follow them knowing they won't skip over those little steps that often go without mention. Well, unless they're being sneaky with hotkeys.
- 2muchcoffeeman 2y agoI get shorts in my feed and it’s all Front End developers. It’s all stupid JS behaviour and other inconsequential stuff.
- zeroq 2y agoThis correlates to my parent post - when my generation started with Flash around 2000 there was no literature on how to programm in Flash, it just happened. So we went to the nearest bookstore and got a bunch of other books on programming. For many Flash developers the bible was Thinking in Java by Bruce Eckel. Most of the source materials for game programming (and that was a lion share of Flash programming) was in C++. I'm not claiming that we were smarter, but by sheer coincidence, most people, even folks like me who skipped school, had very solid fundamentals. And partially due to the fact that it wasn't that lucrative back then. Today most people don't care, IT is just easy money, kids have short attention span and trends are tailored by tiktok videos. All in all, it's just a fashion driven developement.
- SkyBelow 2y ago>I'm not claiming that we were smarter, but by sheer coincidence, most people, even folks like me who skipped school, had very solid fundamentals. Higher barrier of entry should statistically lead to less people making it past and that those who do make it past aren't a random sampling of the initial group making the attempt. While the selection isn't only for intelligence, specifically the subsets of intelligence related to programming, I would doubt any claims it wasn't a factor at all.
- koreth1 2y ago> That people like video formats isn't really surprising to me since it's everywhere, but I still don't fully understand the appeal. Me either, but I have a hunch about why. Are you a fast reader? I am, at least compared to the population at large. And one of the reasons I can't stand video as a format for learning about coding topics is that it is so frustratingly slow compared to my reading speed. To get anywhere close, I have to crank the playback speed up so high that I start having trouble understanding what the presenter is saying. That's on top of other things like poor searchability and no way to copy-paste code snippets. The decline of reading skills, at least in the US, is pretty well-documented. And my hunch is that for the increasingly large number of people coming into the industry who don't read quickly or well, the efficiency of learning from videos is closer to parity with text. What's more, I suspect there's high correlation between lower reading skills and dislike of the act of reading, so videos are a way to avoid having to do something unpleasant. I have no solid evidence to back any of this up, but it seems at least as plausible to me as any other explanations I've run across.
- Swizec 2y agoAlternatively: you can listen to audio while commuting or driving or cleaning or working out. I love audio for higher level things and to get an overview of the topic. Then text to dive into the details.
- ricardobeat 2y agoIt can be quite difficult to follow programming topics over audio only, so it's not interchangeable with video in this case.
- throwaway2037 2y agoAnother big driver to move from text to video: It is easier to monetise video via YouTube compared to a blog. People with millions of subscriptions on YouTube aren't creating FE learning material out of the goodness of their hearts; it is a big business. Also, video is almost always lower information density compared to text, so it is easier for your net to capture more customers.
- WuxiFingerHold 2y agoIt's not about learning (anymore). It's about consuming content. People spending (wasting) their time on X and YT are not there to learn something but to get their social media (dopamine) fix. I hate YT, X, Insta. Don't even have an account. Some years ago there was really great content on YT, now it's mostly clickbait.
- skeeter2020 2y agoThere's still lots of great YT content, much of it by the same producers you allude to, and they need your support more than ever with all the slop around them.
- dartos 2y agoI can read pretty fast, but prefer videos for introductions to any new tech. Then if I decide I like it I read the manual.
- torginus 2y ago> web dev influencers The fact that there's influencers for everything nowadays made me realize I'm old. It's super useful that everyone is sharing their opinions and expertise to get that sweet 5 minutes of fame - I just learned how to tile my bathroom after watching a slew of TikToks on the subject, some with millions of views.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 2y agoI also don't think these front end influencers are even coding very much. Like if you hired them on a job on a serious team, they would probably come off like a junior engineer
- GitPushOrigin 2y agoI get that same vibe. It seems like their intent is to "wow" others into thinking how easy it is to become a developer and build an app with X framework. When in reality they just built a todo app that barely resembles how real software is built.
- josephg 2y agoYeah, it seems sort of obvious in its own way. People like “the primagen” on YouTube are really entertainers first and educators second. The pitch is something like “I’ll pretend to teach you something, and you’ll pretend to learn. But actually I’ll just entertain you by being a goofball for 20 minutes. You don’t have to do any work, and afterwards you can walk away pretending like you learned something”. I suspect in his case he might actively dumb down his skill level for the stream, so he doesn’t scare away the junior devs.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cratermoon 2y agoThe #1 tell is that all their projects are solo. Working on a team, working with peers, building software systems the live in production for years, through change and expansion, all seem beyond the typical influencer.
- ninininino 2y agoI'm only recently getting into some of the dev influencer stuff (and enjoying watching some!), I've discovered Primeagen and Theo but that's about it. Are you willing to name some names? I am trying to still form my mental model about these people and what I should pay attention to and what I should ignore.
- bloomingkales 2y agoYou should ignore all of it. They mostly sell the idea of a developer to you, the same with any marketing. That's what an influencer does, they make you feel good about buying a cheap identity.
- molteanu 2y agoI agree with the other comment. Ignore them all, go with the fundamentals. Heck, ask chatgpt what do they think are the fundamental ideas in computer science and go from there. Look for classic books written on those subjects. There have been plenty of smart people around the sw field who took years of their lives to write succint and valuable technical books! Use them! Ignore the poison-mixers who probably didn't write a single line of code in their whole life! Go for a decent text editor, learn how to type! It's incredible how we use ai tools to write code for us but some don't know how to actually write themselves! Again, look it up, there are plenty of resources out there. If in doubt, search for said resources here on hn. If still in doubt, ask chatgpt what does the hn community recommend for x or y.
- emseetech 2y agoThey're just entertainment. Like throwing on a movie or tv show. I found value in a handful of Primeagen's videos (he inspired me to relearn C programming in a roundabout way) but the vast majority are fluff and I skip them based on the title or within the first 5 minutes. A couple exceptions are Low Level Learning and Tsoding, who both generally stay technical, and any guest appearance by Casey Muratori will be worthwhile. But even those, you're better off with a book or your own project to work on.
- HankStallone 2y agoThe best programming videos I've seen are ones where someone just pointed a camera at a teacher in a classroom setting, like the Programming Paradigms series Jerry Cain did at Stanford some years ago. No attempt to add entertainment value, just a teacher, students, and chalkboards. I wish I could find more content like that, especially about newer stuff.
- pjmlp 2y agoYeah, back in my day being an "influencer" required being able to crack copy protection mechanisms and add an intro into the loading screen, or animations deemed impossible in the given hardware, while remaining anonymous behind a group handle. With fame being slowly propagated via tapes and floppies sent by mail, or some BBS archives. Now you comment on what others do, or commit single function packages.
- jongjong 2y agoTrue, the barrier to becoming a tech influencer are very low now and yet it's harder than ever. This suggests that dumb luck plays an increasing role. Current tech influencers are generally smart and qualified but they aren't experts in anything specific and they aren't innovative in any way. They are chosen by algorithms out of a large pool of possible candidates.
- josephg 2y ago> This suggests that dumb luck plays an increasing role. Nah. It’s not luck. It’s charisma. And skill at performance & in many cases clowning. Some people just have that certain something that makes people enjoy listening to them. It can be learned, but like programming it takes a lifetime to master. And like programming, some people are naturals at it. I know because I’ve been training in improv theatre and clowning for the last 6 years. That’s enough that I could tell you in detail what people like the Primagen or Joe Rogan are doing. But I can’t replicate it. I’m way better than I was, but I’m nowhere near their skill level as a performer.
- wyclif 2y agoThere's no doubt the Primeagen has a popular channel (459K subs at last count), but his videos are super annoying to me. Many of them are just him reading a blog post and adding some light clowning to it. To me it feels like a waste of time...I can just read the article myself a lot faster and the clowning doesn't add any value to me.
- 2y ago
- isleyaardvark 2y agoMaybe now that’s a factor, but this has been a problem with FE development for many years, well before these influencers showed up.
- torginus 2y agoI think it used to be much worse. While the youtube/Tiktok churn might be much more active than 5 years ago, back in the ancient era of 2018-2016, the churn was driven by the fact that tooling sucked, which was capitalized on by people who were very good at self promotion but a lot less good at engineering. I'm not a 'frontend guy', but I do write frontend code. I use Typescript React with hooks and context most of the time, rollup with esbuild to bundle and to run my dev workflows and raw CSS/SCSS for styling or Bootstrap for cookie-cutter UIs. I've also dabbled with Svelte. This stack has served me well, and nothing here is newer than 5 years old. There's a cadre of much newer technology that I would consider stable (Vite + SvelteKit), but since new projects come with a maturity curve from the framework side and a learning curve, learning to troubleshoot issues and solve problems. Anyone who constantly hops frameworks is doomed to be a perpetual amateur, working with buggy frameworks they know nothing about, and they will leave a trail of projects using deprecated frameworks in their wake.
- julik 2y agoIt is incredibly pertinent. Even with the 20+ years of web dev I sometimes get swayed with clickbait like "If you are not using <frontend tech x> you are behind the curve, you are missing out, nobody works this way anymore, you are toast." This is an incredibly harmful take from those influencers. I do remember when it started - and it came from a good place, from a desire to "modernize from jQuery soup". But what it turned to now is noise that is sometimes hard to ignore. It is only natural for a dev to ask themselves "am I still current? am I still relevant?". The induced FOMO triggers the worst bits of that anxiety, and sometimes I feel the influencers do not realise just how harmful this is.
- sirsinsalot 2y agoIt doesn't help that JS projects are often thin wrappers around thin wrappers where the project owner puts more work into their Vitepress logo than a stable API. It all seems like it is for CV glory. Then the projects don't see a commit for years.
- myth2018 2y ago> Influencers in these areas need to have a constant stream of fresh material to stay relevant, so they’re always driving toward something new that they can produce content about I feel sad to hear that. I thought that the decrease in the VC-money flow would also slow down the number of new FE-related frameworks entering the mainstream, but it seems I was wrong then
- gasull 2y agoRelevant YouTube video: Dear Developer, the Web Isn't About You https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WYXSck7TyVM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WYXSck7TyVM