5 ms·
Study finds 46 percent of U.S. counties have pharmacy deserts
- tomrod 2y agoWhen I was a kid, it seemed every town had two or three pharmacies (~1980s). Now, unless you have a CVS, Walgreens, or are lucky enough to have a pharmacy in a grocery store, its not as common. Did something change in the regulation or cost model to make pharmacy deliver unprofitable? Medicare/Medicaid too expensive? Less demand for Pharma services? Not sure of the driver -- there are a lot of points one could evaluate.
- pfdietz 2y agoThere's a lot of competition with mail order pharmacies, I think.
- llamaimperative 2y agoVertical integration among healthcare providers, insurers, and pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) due to PBMs being extremely costly middlemen. So the big insurers and providers started buying the PBMs and using them to abuse pharmacies out of the market to continue their vertical integration and complete rent-capture of American health.
- donnachangstein 2y ago{ Amazon, Target, Walmart } happened. In the 80s the local pharmacy was your primary source of sundries, towns and cities alike. Everything from hardware to toys to medicine. If the local pharmacy didn't have it, you didn't buy it. Now with hoards of Chinese shit available at your fingertips to order with same-day delivery, pharmacies couldn't survive on selling medicine alone, of which there are very small margins. San Francisco and other cities making widespread theft and shoplifting de facto legal didn't help either. Local mom & pop pharmacies can't afford to put the entire store behind glass.
- shermantanktop 2y agoRural resentment of cities is as old as the hills. I don’t know what the solution is. Price supports to keep small pharmacies alive? Heavy regulation of e-commerce? I’m no free-market zealot, but it’s hard to see how you blunt this impact in a non-heavy-handed way.
- throwawaysleep 2y agoWait for them to actually care about it. Where I live, rural areas are supposedly desperately short of doctors but the rural people can’t stop whining about them always wanting more money and to not be berated for being brown or gay. Why is a solution needed if the people it supposedly impacts hardly care?
- matheweis 2y agoYes, pricing regulations forced brick and mortar pharmacies to sell drugs below cost. Several closed in my area in the last few years and this was one of their cited reasons why.
- clipsy 2y agoWhat regulations specifically?
- fzeroracer 2y agoNo, what happened is the same thing that's been happening to smaller retail shops, grocery stores and so forth. Smaller pharmacies are either obliterated by larger stores using economy of scale to undercut and kill competition, or they're bought out by larger corporations, hollowed out and then consolidated. You can look at the history of Bartell Drugs in WA. They were sold to Rite Aid, Rite Aid went under because of them being a shitty business and so most Bartells have closed down or are practically dead. And without replacement, that means there's now fewer pharmacies and the ones remaining are understaffed and overworked.
- breakyerself 2y agoI have two pharmacies in my town, but they're both owned by RiteAid which can't keep inventory on the shelves. If you need a prescription filled they can do that, but if you need something over the counter they won't have it. I walked into a Walgreens the other day in the next town over and was amazed at fully stocked shelves. Hadn't seen that in a drug store for quite some time.
- bluedino 2y agoWe had Rite Aid and Walgreens, then Rite Aid went bankrupt or whatever all they aren't here anymore (they would always be across the street from each other). Now you have a 45 minute wait when you go, they never have stuff in stock, their phone support people are terrible... Walgreens was great (and 24 hours) but now it's a shit show. At least we still have the pharmacy at grocery stores, Walmart, and a couple mom-n-pop pharmacies but their hours stink. There are a couple other places without a storefront that are delivery-only but I haven't tried any of them yet.
- metaphor 2y ago> I have two pharmacies in my town, but they're both owned by RiteAid which can't keep inventory on the shelves. Rite Aid filed chapter 11 bankruptcy almost 2 years ago.
- cowsandmilk 2y agoSure, but the point of Chapter 11 is to restructure so you can hopefully get back to operating profitably.
- metaphor 2y agoYes, keyword hopefully...over some indeterminate time horizon...but surely not a mere 6 months after emergence from a legal proceeding that took a year to resolve. Commodified OTCs are hardly raking in compelling margins relative to filling scripts, so it's unsurprising that some Rite Aids are operating as the parent reports.
- 2y ago
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoAren’t compounding pharmacies meant to solve this? I’m not familiar with how they work but I remember small family compounding pharmacies used to be everywhere. Now you never see them and I’ve heard some states like California are trying to get rid of them.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoAre you thinking of the correct term? Compounding pharmacies provide simple drug manufacturing tasks, like pressing pills from raw ingredients or splitting and mixing liquid drugs. Some regulators dont like them because the medicine and dosages they produce do not need FDA review for safety or efficacy.
- aomix 2y agoI was working in a college job for a pharmaceutical distributor when the New England Compounding Center outbreak happened. I think that dropped a nuke on the whole industry. We stopped dealing with compounding pharmacies after that because that whole thing was more like a matter of when not if.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI'm most familiar with them for off label ocular injections. Avastin is a common medication for colorectal cancer, but has an extremely similar biologic to Lucentis, used of ocular injections. Compounding pharmacies will breakdown Avastin because it is cheaper than Lucentis, and pre-fill disposable syringes.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI think I am. But maybe I’m wrong. What I remember is these pharmacies could basically make prescription drugs locally and do custom drugs and things like that because they worked differently from big pharmacies. That was what kept them surviving as small businesses. But over time they’ve just disappeared. At least in places I’ve lived and traveled to.
- delichon 2y agoI live in a county bigger than Connecticut with zero pharmacies. The clinic has a big medicine pantry, but if they don't have it your next best bet is to drive to the next state over, about two hours from the clinic. The clinic was staffed by a nurse practitioner only on my last visit. Rural America is not a convenient place to be sick.
- grapesodaaaaa 2y agoSimilar story here. Our insurance likes to mail things, but gets the prescription wrong or it doesn’t show up 60% of the time. We spend a lot of time arguing on the phone.
- FireBeyond 2y agoNot just likes to mail things, they basically try to force you to use the mail pharmacy service that they own. My Aetna policy will deny all prescriptions for anything greater than 30 days supply or multiple refills unless you go through their mail pharmacy - it's the only way to get a 90 day supply. And yup. Their online service often is "unable to determine status" of a prescription that they are filling, which means I can't even order a refill through them.
- notyourwork 2y agoSo let’s vote for the party who isn’t for healthcare for everyone. Obviously business will sort this out and put pharmacies in these places. I cannot help but remain cynical of the world that we’ve inherited.
- rayiner 2y agoPutting pharmacies in all those places when door to door delivery exists would be insanely wasteful. Just make it easier for pharmacists to mail you your medicines.
- notyourwork 2y agoLet’s see how that works out with privatized USPS. Last mile isn’t free.
- dyauspitr 2y agoIt’s only going to get worse with brick and mortar pharmacies not being able to compete with online pharmacies.
- matheweis 2y agoIt’s not even legal for them to try to compete. Even if someone preferred to pay more for the convenience the brick and mortar shops aren’t allowed to charge a premium over the online pharmacies.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoThere is no law against a pharmacy owner from charging whatever they want. However, most pharmacies enter into contracts with various groups, such as the government, insurance companies, etc so that they effectively give away their right to charge what they want.
- matheweis 2y ago> There is no law against a pharmacy owner from charging whatever they want. On closing, one of my local pharmacies claimed otherwise and referenced the following: > states have enacted legislation prohibiting certain PBM clients from imposing additional co-payments, deductibles, limitation on benefits, or other conditions (“Conditions”) on covered individuals utilizing a retail pharmacy when the same Conditions are not otherwise imposed on covered individuals utilizing home delivery pharmacies. However, the legislation requires the retail pharmacy to agree to the same reimbursement amounts and terms and conditions as are imposed on the home delivery pharmacies. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1532063/000153206318000004/esrx-12312017x10k.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1532063/000153206318...
- lotsofpulp 2y agoInteresting. I guess that sort of qualifies, even though a pharmacy owner can technically choose to not enter into any agreements. The government is at the root cause of wanting to squeeze all players in the healthcare business, since public rancor reached a tipping point in the late 2000s and ACA was passed. Pharmacists just got shafted first because they were the easiest to squeeze due to supply and demand. Doctors were next with the insertion of physician assistances and nurse practitioners.
- laughing_man 2y agoDoes it really matter that much when you can get same day delivery?
- SlightlyLeftPad 2y agoI think same day delivery only applies to urban and some suburban areas, definitely not the majority of rural America.
- Wumpnot 2y agoThat is not a thing in rural areas, Prime 1 day is more like Prime 3 day
- s1artibartfast 2y agoprobably not as much as it would without mail delivery, but in person pharmacies have an important role. Examples would be if you are discharged and need your medication that night, or for serving the disabled and handicapped.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y agoI'm grateful for the focus on counties here. Health discussions commonly assume that medical services are within reach. But for much (often most) of the US that isn't the case. Most counties do not have sufficient mental health services, few have medical specialists and an ER can be several counties away. People who live in underserved areas matter. Overwhelmingly, they are people who are trapped there by poverty. And while poor urban Americans get occasional lip service (if little else), poor rural Americans (inc brown, white, indigenous) don't even get that. No one is more invisible than the rural poor.
- throwawaysleep 2y agoThe rural parts consistently prefer a tax cut over anything else. Rural people elected the current federal government.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> The rural parts consistently prefer a tax cut over anything else. No. They do not prefer tax cuts over eating, for example. > Rural people elected the current federal government. When the entire country acts as if you and your problems don't exist (for several generations), burning it all down doesn't feel like much of a catastrophe. I've heard from Indigenous Americans who aren't overly bothered by our massive ongoing crises. Their position is something like 'you might experience a tiny sliver of what we've had for centuries'. And they have a point.
- throwawaysleep 2y ago> No. They do not prefer tax cuts over eating, for example. They turned out in droves to cut food stamps to fund large tax cuts. So yes, they do.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> They turned out in droves to cut food stamps to fund large tax cuts. They can't get SNAP so, again, burning down SNAP doesn't feel like a catastrophe. When calls to aid the poor and vulnerable consistently omit most counties, we ought to be not stupid; we ought to expect those counties to become estranged. Estranged, vulnerable people are more likely to be susceptible to manipulation because that's how people work. If this -> We Need To Help The Rural Poor In A Consistent And Meaningful Way <- will never be on the table, that's a decision. Own it.
- CaffeineLD50 2y agoWhy do we need a pharmacy when it can be delivered by postal mail. I for one welcome our postal overlords. Is it not self serving for the JAMA to fund a study on a lack of pharmacies but not on, say,medical incompetence, fraud, or corruption? Luigi wasn't applauded because he seemed to decry a lack of pharmacies afaict.
- rtkwe 2y agoOne big thing pharmacies do is answer questions about drugs to educate the users in ways the doctors prescribing them often don't and also check for drug interactions to protect patients. Sometimes you wind up getting prescriptions for two things from different doctors and one doesn't notice or ask to find out that your prescription from doctor A has a bad interaction with drug B they're prescribing. Also the US mail is also being actively degraded so the ability to reliably get mail delivered to the entire US guaranteed may just disappear soon.
- gruez 2y ago>One big thing pharmacies do is answer questions about drugs to educate the users in ways the doctors prescribing them often don't and also check for drug interactions to protect patients. That can easily be done over the phone.
- rtkwe 2y agoIt /could/ be but we also all know how great remote call centers do actually caring about the people they're supposed to serve. The real outcome will be fewer people servicing more customers for less money.
- CaffeineLD50 2y agoI've had uncaring in person pharmacists
- rtkwe 2y ago
- abetusk 2y agoTo me, the headline is a little misleading. From the first paragraph of the article: > ... 46 percent of all counties studied had at least one pharmacy desert, and that 15.8 million people in the U.S. live in pharmacy deserts. So while 46% of all counties have at least one pharmacy desert, less than 5% of people actually live in a pharmacy desert (USA population of ~340.1M).
- maxerickson 2y agoThere's also problems with the concept of these deserts. I live in a small town in a pretty rural county, the town is big enough to have a couple of superstores, so we have those pharmacies, a Walgreen's, and a regional one. People that don't live in the small town are definitely going to be driving 10 and 20 minutes to get to a pharmacy, but the majority of that population is living outside of town by choice, because they want the lifestyle. Much of the cheaper housing in the county is in the town, and it's not like it's crime ridden or anything.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoWalgreens is being taken private in a $10B deal, and is planning on closing 1200 locations in the near future.
- renewiltord 2y agoPharmacists could be replaced by vending machines and a phone consult. They're the proof that even if GPT-n can replace humans, humans will still have jobs. The only thing they're good for in my experience is to fail to read the script properly, necessitating you to perform some social engineering so that they can read it again and get it right. Bottom tier intelligence. "Oh but they can tell you drug interacti-" give me a break. They've never done that and besides, so can a computer.
- readthenotes1 2y agoThe computer could do it better, with little errors from fatigue or focus degradation--provided you tell them the drugs/supplements to worry about ...
- ryandrake 2y agoThe thing that always shocks me is the number of Americans on prescription drugs. We eat this stuff like candy. 66 percent of all adults in the United States use prescription drugs[1]. 50 percent of people used at least one prescription drug in the past 30 days[2]. I get asked as part of a routine doctor's visit what prescription drugs I'm on, and I sometimes get weird looks when I say "none." I'm not a doctor, but these numbers seem totally out of whack and out of control. It's not just the elderly, either, although the percentages from 80+ aged folks do skew the overall numbers. 1: https://hpi.georgetown.edu/rxdrugs/ https://hpi.georgetown.edu/rxdrugs/ 2: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/drug-use-therapeutic.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/drug-use-therapeutic.htm
- brucehoult 2y agoI was given my first prescription drug (to suppress stomach acid) around my 61st birthday. It's a PITA. Though the drug itself is "free" (or was ... my last pickup in December they charged me $5) they will only give you three months of it at a time and the freaking GPs office charges $20 each time to receive a "please can I have some more" request on their web site / app and forward the order to the pharmacy.
- donnachangstein 2y ago> they will only give you three months of it at a time and the freaking GPs office charges $20 each time to receive a "please can I have some more" request on their web site / app and forward the order to the pharmacy. I take it you are outside of the US? For all the criticism of the American health system, this has never been a problem. For most maintenance medications, which this sounds like it is, the doctor will authorize one year's supply, for which you pick them up every 30 or 90 days at a time. When you run out of refills the pharmacy will usually contact your doctor for re-authorization, typically at no charge. Often the doctor wants to see you anyway to check your progress before you run out. During your yearly visit there is usually a short conversation about getting medication refilled. The exception to this are when the doctor wants to order tests to see how you are reacting to the medication, or periodic tests for long term medications (in case they need to adjust the dosage). Things like pain medications or for urgent issues are dispensed as a one-time thing.
- brucehoult 2y agoI'm trying to understand what their actual definition of a Pharmacy Desert is, as they don't seem to define it. A search suggests it might be having no pharmacy within 1 mile in a city or 10 miles in a rural area. I'm guessing I've lived most of my life in a pharmacy desert without realising it. Looks like I'm 18 km (23 km by road) from a pharmacy to the north and 22 km (28 km by road) to the south, but the one I actually go to because it has longer hours (7 days until 9 PM) is 32 km drive. On the other hand, when I lived in Russia every street had a pharmacy seemingly about every 300m, and people ran to them for the slightest sniffle. That's probably why they have such a good life expectancy.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoThe paper describes it as communities >=10 miles from the nearest pharmacy. This is a pretty garbage definition in my opinion, if you are somewhere like the Midwest or the basin and range.
- xnx 2y ago"X desert" is a catchy phrase that often covers up weak analysis. Commonly the availability of delivery grocery, medicines, etc. is ignored.
- raincom 2y agowhat is the population of these 46% of U.S. counties? 15% of the total US population?
- knbknb 2y ago4.7% of population, as the says so in summary of the study[1] , 3rd sentence. (1st sentence of second paragraph) [1] https://www.drugtopics.com/view/pharmacy-deserts-prominent-in-areas-of-high-social-vulnerability https://www.drugtopics.com/view/pharmacy-deserts-prominent-i...
- BenFranklin100 2y agoThere’s an ignorant, trolling comment on this thread I’m not going to dignify with a response that suggests rural Americans somehow deserve a lack of proper medical care because they “chose” to live in a rural area. Many of these people have no choice to live where they do because of high home prices in Bluer cities. The reason why home prices are high is because zoning restricts the supply of new homes. This often prevents poorer Americans from moving to cities with better jobs. Instead of inflaming Red vs Blue state politics (which is really Red rural America vs Blue urban America), we should think about how our housing policies act like Medieval walls of centuries past, keeping the poor and disfavored outside the city gates.