4 ms·
SAML (more broadly XML-DSIG) is literally the worst security protocol in common use. I think you should generally be taking whatever hits you need to take to tr
by tptacek 2y ago
SAML (more broadly XML-DSIG) is literally the worst security protocol in common use. I think you should generally be taking whatever hits you need to take to transition from it to OAuth. Certainly, I would refuse to bring a new product to market that relied on it. It's incredibly dangerous. Unless there's some breakthrough in practical formal verification, I can't imagine that this will be the last or the worst DSIG vulnerability.
- shellcromancer 2y agoSecurity Cryptography Whatever’s take on this week SAML non-sense will be fun.
- tptacek 2y agoHonestly, hadn't thought of it, but of course we should do that. Thanks!
- janderson215 2y agoI’d sub to infosec rant podcasts. $5/mo Patreon sub for a non-vtuber version.
- nimish 2y agoOne day I will write an essay on all of the incredibly stupid things XML DSig does, and that's not even touching the cryptography. It's peak enterprise software brain. Someone should go deep on the mailing list and standards body horrors of WS-* and OASIS/XACML and all that crap
- pushkar2911 2y agoPlease write about this. I would love to read it.
- akdor1154 2y agoMy (possibly misunderstood to the point of misphrasing) understanding, is that SAML still has the point-of-difference that your sso provider can cancel a session. Is that right?
- Nextgrid 2y agoOIDC has out-of-band backchannel logout.
- akerl_ 2y agoCan it? In many SAML setups, there's not direct network interaction between the IDP and Service, other than at most sharing metadata via URL.
- recursive 2y agoThere's an optional feature in the spec I think. But in my very limited experience, it is never implemented or working correctly.
- p_ing 2y agoMicrosoft implements this in Azure/M365.
- securesaml 2y ago[dead]