5 ms·
Some of the stuff in the details section is pretty astounding. They've copied things as closely as the wall-height to floor size ratio. I doubt even EA thought
by Macha 14y ago
Some of the stuff in the details section is pretty astounding. They've copied things as closely as the wall-height to floor size ratio. I doubt even EA thought much about that, other than selecting a size that they thought looked reasonable, yet Zynga neeeded to put effort into copying it so exactly? Why? If you're going to rip off a game, why put effort into making it so blatant?
I understand Zynga even less now.
My gut feeling on reading the headline was originally "Well, EA can't complain, Simcity Social was far more a Cityville clone than a continuation of Simcity", but wow, actually looking at the complaint is pretty damning for Zynga.
- jlgreco 14y agoI'm willing to bet those exact dimensions came about by someone sending an email that went something to the general effect of: "Here are some screenshots. Redraw them."
- aswanson 14y agoI wonder if their internal emails can be subpoenaed.
- jlgreco 14y agoIf they do get subpoenaed and it turns out I am right, I'm going to buy myself a beer. ;)
- aswanson 14y agoI'll spring for one brew of your choice as well.
- darkarmani 14y agoAbsolutely.
- derefr 14y agoProbably, they prototyped the game using rips of Sims assets, and as they replaced EA's art with their own they tried to keep the new elements consistent with the old ones (rather than, say, having some walls suddenly 1.3x as tall as others for no obvious reason.)
- wmf 14y agoIf you're not skilled enough to create something good, you're better off finding something good and copying it exactly — you're probably not qualified to understand which parts are essential and which are arbitrary. It takes guts to copy something exactly, though; most people can't resist the urge to make their mark.
- georgemcbay 14y ago> It takes guts to copy something exactly, though; Guts and a total disregard for copyright law.
- saraid216 14y ago> I understand Zynga even less now. Honestly, it works. We can hate it as much as we like; at the end of the day, Zynga is in fact pulling in cash.
- anon808 14y ago"it works". what a destructive attitude. many things 'work'. insider trading and extortion work too, does that mean we can't 'hate' on them? just because something happens doesn't mean it 'should' happen. you filter options through your values to really decide if 'it works'. good insight into your character.
- praxulus 14y agoYou completely missed the point. He's not saying that Zynga's actions are moral or should be socially acceptable, just that it's easy to see their motivation. It's not hard to understand why they do what they do, no matter how reprehensible.
- anon808 14y agoi got that. but i don't call that something that 'works'. my point is that making cash isn't the only condition that needs to be met for something to 'work'. i take issue with his use of 'it works'.
- saraid216 14y ago> my point is that making cash isn't the only condition that needs to be met for something to 'work'. To make cash, you must make cash. This is a simple tautology. Insider trading and extortion work. Again, fact. Denying reality does not make it go away. We 'hate' on them because we have larger goals that are sabotaged by these things: a free market, a trusting society. If we are to succeed at our better goals, then we cannot do so by pretending things are other than what they are. I probably hate Zynga more than you do, since they basically killed my dreams of entering the industry on my terms. But I don't let my hatred make me blind and stupid to the point where I no longer understand what it means for something to work.
- alanfalcon 14y agoAs a graphic designer, I can tell you that a detail like the wall height to tile size ratio is actually a very specifically chosen value based on a number of trade-offs and priorities, and not something easily arrived at because it just looks pretty good. Which isn't to say that a given ratio is inevitable (or that the match in this legal case is pure coincidence, it certainly is NOT), just that you may wish to be aware that you're short-changing the designers based on your lack of domain expertise.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]