3 ms·
Let me get this straight: the article author paid $10 for his page to "be liked" in Egypt (population estimate: 90 mil) and India (population estimate 1.2 billi
by acqq 14y ago
Let me get this straight: the article author paid $10 for his page to "be liked" in Egypt (population estimate: 90 mil) and India (population estimate 1.2 billion) as he himself claims "a potential audience of 112 million customers" and then was surprised that he got total of 1600 "likes" from the given area in 24 hours?
Then he acts surprised!? What exactly did he expect?
As others also point: his page is a joke, somebody will always "like" the joke, maybe even recommend it to other friends!
From his target population, one of 70000 potential "eyes" "liked" the joke in 24 hours. So what?
- schulz 14y agoThe article kind of glossed over this, but the Click through rate of .55% is off the charts. It's _clearly_ fraud, based on having seen thousands of ad campaigns data. Anything over .1 is great, and over .2 you start looking for what you broke. .55 is an Adops executive daydream. (The .059% from UK visitors is about what you'd expect)
- Dylan16807 14y agoI honestly can't tell what your point is. Why are you bringing up populations? You seem to be implying some kind of expectation but I can't tell what. I'll try to explain the author's point. He was confused by and suspicious of the vastly higher liking rates in certain countries than in US/UK.
- acqq 14y agoHe paid $10 for area that included India and Egypt, for only one day, receiving 1600 likes in one day. He paid additional $50 for smaller area that didn't have these countries for 3 days, receiving 1400 likes, average 350 per day. So: 1600 likes from India and Egypt in one day: $10 == 0.6 cent per like. 350 likes without that area: $16 per day == 4.6 cent per like. Where's the surprise? If he pays for cheaper likes, he gets the cheaper likes. Did he expect to pay for cheap likes and get the expensive ones? Does such an expectation have any economic sense?
- Dylan16807 14y agoI still don't see how the size of the area matters. He's not showing it to everyone in the area, just ten bucks worth of them, But his complaint isn't about the price per like. It's about the fact that likes per impression are ten times higher in certain countries. Can you explain that disparity?
- acqq 14y agoThe disparity you observe is already reflected in the prices he paid, as he presented it and as I calculate in the post you just replied. He paid different order of magnitude for different kinds of likes. That's how the market functions when it functions. We can theorize all day "why" but we don't have any information about that. What he presents is only how much he paid and how much he received, and there everything seems consistent.
- Dylan16807 14y agoI really can't understand you here. Apparently you find it so amazingly obvious that India will click a like button ten times as much as the UK that you said "he acts surprised!?". Why is it so obvious to you that these likes are 'cheaper'? You certainly haven't given any reasons. People are looking at the market doing something strange and your contribution is "the market functions, who cares". Sure, I'm not very surprised that if the likes seem highly fraudulent the price per like is lower, but that's not the issue. The issue is these fraud-seeming levels in the first place!
- acqq 14y agoThe fact his experiment obtained is simply that there are cheaper and more expensive likes. You don't dispute that I hope? So it's obvious to me because of experiment of his. It would be strange if the prices didn't match the fact, which would mean that he was tricked. But they actually did. I support you if you are curious what produces the effects, I just claim that the article doesn't give any information about that and that from information he gives, everything fits -- the prices matched what he obtained.