5 ms·
Doge Privacy Act Requests
- tw04 2y agoI hope at this point people agree this has gone well beyond partisanship. Having a private citizen unilaterally gutting government agencies is an affront to the checks and balances of a functioning democracy.
- roenxi 2y agoWhich check or balance do you think is being ignored here? The point of the executive branch is to be the one where unelected and loosely vetted administrators work. Congress is mostly voted officials, the judiciary is the group that are carefully vetted for cultural fit and the executive is where the messy parts happen with oversight from the other two government branches. It is where people like Musk are supposed to be working - the president thinks he a good person to be wielding power.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> Which check or balance do you think is being ignored here? Which check + balance is being adhered to? Which actions aren't in violation of the constitution, are operating fully with stipulated oversight and clearly operate within established best practices? This should be trivial to provide from the Most Transparent Administration Ever.
- roenxi 2y agoI don't think "All of them and everything" is really a serious attempt at a response. But a non-serious question demands an unserious answer! Trump hasn't been impeached this time round, for example, so that is check and balance that is being adhered to. And he gave the State of the Union speech which is an action unambiguously in line with the constitution. So there you go, there are checks that are holding and actions taken that are constitutional.
- danorama 2y agoSo if it's government as usual they won't mind adhering to the Privacy Act of 1974 like every other agency, right?
- roenxi 2y agoI assume they're cool with it. Why wouldn't they be? Musk + Trump probably don't care, it isn't data on them. Hire a bunch of interns and get them on the job.
- danorama 2y agoMy sense is they're going to shred any requests like this or just send back a "No Responsive Records" response for every one and dare someone to try to call them on it. But I envy your trusting nature.
- artificialLimbs 2y agoIt was clearly told to the American people that this would happen before the election, repeatedly. This is what the American people voted for.
- bickfordb 2y agoNope
- ldoughty 2y agoYep? I mean it's threatened every time by Republicans. But it's usually just grandstanding... Take Obamacare for instance. It was threatened to be repealed constantly, over and over, But even when they had full control and could do whatever they wanted it still survived.. at the end of the day, the elected officials know that it hurts their own people more to appeal it, so they just give the issue lip service and tweaks and fly a giant mission accomplished banner from the deck of their ship. So on one side, I agree with you, who would think that they actually follow through with what they were saying over and over on the campaign trail.... And now they have.
- krapp 2y ago"I never thought the party that's been saying for 20 years that they want to reduce government to the size where they can drown it in the bathtub would ever do anything drastic..."
- someothherguyy 2y agoYeah, they voted for all this too https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_war_crimes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_war_crimes. It doesn't make it right. Last term it was, "He is your president you have to support him". Now it is, "The American people voted for this" All the same meaningless phrases that do nothing to discuss issues, just an appeal to the masses. Political sentiment has never been static. We'll see what people think when inflation sky rockets, they max out their credit, etc, and they have fewer social programs to reach out to for help. You can follow along here: https://www.realclearpolling.com/latest-polls https://www.realclearpolling.com/latest-polls
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mateus1 2y agoTopics mentioning DOGE and Musk are being quickly flagged here in HN, so I don’t think there is much hope for discourse here.
- rcpt 2y agoI don't think flagging automatically kills posts, no?
- pogue 2y agoIt's still here, and anyone who finds HN posts by rss or other means will see the headline, url & have access to this discussion (although it might be closed to replies by then)
- _fs 2y agoIts completely obvious that a bot army is gaming the system. Posts are flagged within minutes of posting
- throwawa14223 2y agoI am in the habit of flagging anything related to American politics. It never leads anywhere and seems orthogonal to HN.
- _fs 2y agoYea, I got tired of people attempting to make comments like this and wrote a script to quickly analyze past comment history to see if they were truly being honest. You have consistently and reliably posted your political views here. Please don't try to pretend that you hate the political discourse now that people are critical of your guy.
- throwawa14223 2y agoFirst not my guy. I'm not left enough to vote for Trump. Second I can both flag and comment as I did here.
- Spivak 2y agoI guess the argument for is that this is isomorphic to an outside contractor being granted access, providing a list of cuts, and the prez signing off on it. I don't like it but it seems like a difference in semantics and paperwork so I'm not sure if going after it is meaningful.
- stvltvs 2y agoThat's not a description of the status quo ante. Prior Presidents more or less respected the need for independent agencies within the Executive, and the courts upheld the right of Congress to direct how money is spent meaning the President couldn't arbitrarily shutter an agency created by law written by Congress.
- jfengel 2y agoThey don't. Very little has actually changed. For the people who voted for this, "unilaterally gutting government agencies" was what they voted for. For people who didn't vote, they don't seem to be saying, "Gosh, I didn't realize this would happen."
- Trasmatta 2y agoI'm losing my mind. This thread is already full of people sanewashing DOGE and Musk. I don't even know how to debate with them, because we seem to live on entirely different conceptual planets.
- roenxi 2y ago> I don't even know how to debate with them, because we seem to live on entirely different conceptual planets. Typically the process is to exercise empathy, look into their world, see what it is like and then check for any logical problems or general weaknesses. If you want to debate with someone persuasively you have to meet them where they are.
- watwut 2y agoThey don't care about logic and reason. We all know it. There are no stable moral or ethical values - transparency mayter then it don't depending on tactical needs. On emotional level, they like it when someone else is harmed. And that is it.
- roenxi 2y ago> On emotional level, they like it when someone else is harmed. And that is it. On the other hand I recommend you work on improving your empathy even if you don't use it for debating. That is ridiculous and you don't have the excuse of an upcoming election to get away with bad behaviour. The pro-DOGE people generally want to pay less tax. That is a much better motivating theory. Will they get that? Probably not. But the emotional response (if any) is going to be much more on the greed or fairness aspects.
- watwut 2y agoNo, what you say is just what you want to be true. A comforting lie that is being repeated in various forms. Listen to what those people say, watch what they do. They literally say they want to cause harm. When their politicians gets insulting or cause harm, they get more votes instead of less. Instead of listening and watching, you knee jerk sanitize it, use euphemisms and basically gaslight everyone else. I do actually read and listen to what conservatives actually say and write. It is in project 2025. It is online. It is in conservative journals and articles. Talk to them in person long enough personally and they will tell you. It is the same thing with trade war. It is in Trumps rhetoric. And it was the same thing with abortions - it was totally paranoid to say they plan to remove protection for women ... until they actually did it. Again and again, their opinions and plans are sanitized and euphemized away. And then they get benefit of doubt no democrat or leftist is ever getting. There were enough low tax republican politicians who lost against Trump. When centrist democrats adopt republican plans, the previously cheered on plans are suddenly bad and republicans who keep supporting them are suddenly ennemies too. And the reason is that it is not the economics or taxes. --------------------------------------------- Also, speaking about empathy, why is there consistent expectation that empathy flows exactly one way? You are demanding that I am emphatetic to people who see empathy as weakness on an ideological level. And who are never ever asked to return the favor.
- danorama 2y agoFlagged. We don't talk about privacy issues on Hacker News. Especially not when they involve the government.
- tocs3 2y agoSo, is anyone here sending off a request for the info DOGE has on them?