9 ms·
This is a really important thing to bring up. There's so much focus on letting women have balance in their lives, but almost never men. Women complain that th
by crazygringo 14y ago
This is a really important thing to bring up.
There's so much focus on letting women have balance in their lives, but almost never men.
Women complain that they can't keep up with men because they can't reconcile 80-hour workweeks with raising children.
The solution is not healthier, more balanced workweeks for women. The solution is healther, more balanced workweeks for everyone.
The solution is creating a cultural expectation where CEO's work 50 hours a week, not 90, regardless of gender or children.
After all, male CEO's would love this just as much as female CEO's with children. But they can't ask for it, because it's seen as weak and uncommitted, and another male CEO will take their place.
There's a truth behind the clichéed businessman dying in his bed, saying he wishes he had spent less time working and more with his wife and children. But as a society, we refuse to let our male CEO's work less. Why?
- gms 14y agoSociety doesn't refuse anything. If a male CEO wants to work less, he can do so. If another male potential CEO can perform better by working more, he will probably replace him. The only solution to this is to mandate working hours for CEOs, an idea that rather impractical to say the least.
- lmm 14y ago>Society doesn't refuse anything. If a male CEO wants to work less, he can do so. If another male potential CEO can perform better by working more, he will probably replace him. If another male potential CEO can perform worse by working more, he will probably replace him. And that's a societal/cultural problem; we need to get over the idea that someone who puts in longer hours must be contributing more.
- gms 14y agoHow will he replace him if he is worse-performing? I'm not sure this imaginary company is competent.
- refurb 14y agoYou've already stated why we don't do it. Many people (men and women) choose not to have children. So if you're a CEO and you say "I don't want to work 80 hour a week", they could easily replace you with someone who says "I'll do it!". And do you know what? That's life. It's no different than any other choice. Plenty of people who don't have children don't want to put in 80 hrs per week at their job. Should we accomodate them as well?
- nitrogen 14y agoPlenty of people who don't have children don't want to put in 80 hrs per week at their job. Should we accomodate them as well? Yes, why not? "Think of the parents" arguments may just be a pretext for letting everyone work less. As productivity increases, the amount of available work decreases. We can either concentrate that work among a few, leaving many unemployed (e.g. the would-be 50hr/wk CEO), or have everyone work less.
- refurb 14y agoThe amount of available work doesn't decrease as productivity increases. Global productivity has increased by at least an order of magnitude since 1900. If available worked decreased, we'd have 90% unemployment now. The biggest obstacle to "spreading out the work" is payroll taxes. It's much cheaper for an employer to hire 1 person who works 100 hr/week than is it to hire 3 people at 33 hr/week. But my point remains, there are people out there who do nothing but work, by choice. They want a job that requires 60,70,80 hrs per week. Are you suggesting we tell these people to find something else to do with their time?
- makomk 14y agoWhy? Because as a society we're not interested in confronting the problems with male gender roles when they affect men, only when they affect women. So you'll occasionally see someone poking at the edge of the problem when they realise (for instance) that men being pressured into 80-hour workweeks means women are forced to look after kids, or that women can't rise as high in the ranks as men, but that's it. Often they'll just end up trying to patch the symptoms whilst ignoring the underlying problem, for instance by trying to lower demands on female executives and employees compared to their male counterparts.
- NotMyMorals 14y agoWhy are gender roles a "problem?"
- makomk 14y agoGender roles are a problem because they mean that anyone who doesn't fit into them nicely gets screwed over. This affects, oooh, probably pretty much everyone because the odds of someone matching up with them exactly in every possible regard are pretty damn low.
- NotMyMorals 14y ago>Gender roles are a problem because they mean that anyone who doesn't fit into them nicely gets screwed over. This affects, oooh, probably pretty much everyone because the odds of someone matching up with them exactly in every possible regard are pretty damn low. Do you have any evidence of gender roles so specific and enforced so strictly that "pretty much everyone" gets "screwed over" for not matching up with them exactly in "every possible regard?" How do you account for all the people, perhaps a majority, who don't seem to have any problem with traditional gender roles, but in fact, embrace them? They don't seem to feel they are being "screwed over."
- Cushman 14y agoYou ever worn a skirt? They are freaking comfortable. Especially if you're just sitting at a desk all day. Lightweight, breezy, totally stylish. I don't expect you to agree with me, of course, but just try one on for work one day. You'll be amazed.
- roguecoder 14y agoIf I might turn this around, some men don't. What makes them different than those who do? I think the answer is "they are willing to be seen as less than manly." We can not both live balanced lives and keep the prestige and power we are used to. We, as individuals, must give up our illusions that we are better than others because we manage more people or make more money or get more funding. Instead, we much know we are good enough and choose for ourselves how to distribute our short time on earth. Men can't have it all: we must give up "man" as our primary identity in order to find our more-satisfying "self".
- colmvp 14y ago"We can not both live balanced lives and keep the prestige and power we are used to." Isn't that a double edged sword? That prestige and power is an attraction and sometimes necessity for men to court women. While I know it does happen, it's rare to find women who marry 'down' in the status ladder (be it race, income, or position). And as a marginalized male minority in the U.S., I know for certain that even good well-adjusted women wouldn't have given me the time of day if I wasn't earning a certain amount or at a high level or at a great company.
- roguecoder 14y agoI think your generalizations are ridiculously broad here. Some women are golddiggers, but those relationships are, IMHO, not worth having anyway. Why do you think such a relationship is going to contribute more to your life than spending time on things that actually make you happy? Even if all women wanted was power, we are playing a zero-sum, I-got-mine, race-to-the-bottom, everyone-loses game if we demand total devotion to status, and I don't think most women want that either. Already 25% of stay-at-home parents are men. The majority of women are now in the work force. Egalitarian marriages last longer. Things are changing, and we can help them change faster by opting out of that self-destructive game. That doesn't mean giving up on being able to find a romantic relationship, however. There is a difference between being a bum and not seeking to dominate the people around us to get ahead at all cost. I'd recommend reading http://postmasculine.com/ http://postmasculine.com/ for the dating advice that worked best for me. Much like weight loss, there are no short cuts to becoming capable of having satisfying relationships. It is hard work to move from desperation to a place where relationships are one possible way your life could be a bit nicer, but certainly not the only one. On the other hand, I found it worth the energy.
- rmc 14y agoBut as a society, we refuse to let our male CEO's work less. Why? There are people fighting traditional gender roles. But then you get called a feminazi by people who don't want change. Come over to feminism. We're fighting for everyone to have the same opertunities.
- Arelius 14y ago> Come over to feminism. We're fighting for everyone to have the same opertunities. The problem is feminism doesn't actually do a particularly good job at making it clear that is what they are fighting for, and perhaps because there is a particularly vocal minority that doesn't believe that to be the true and proper goal of feminism.
- egillie 14y agoYeah, this is the problem with any big movement without a figurehead, like the 99% movement.
- NotMyMorals 14y ago>There are people fighting traditional gender roles. But then you get called a feminazi by people who don't want change. People who embrace our traditions get called "troglodytes" "fascists" "nazis" "sexists" and the like by cultural Marxists, moralistic activists, and other fanatics. >Come over to feminism. We're fighting for everyone to have the same opertunities. No thanks. Feminism, like religion, should be kept to one's self. Stop trying to proselytize. You may be surprised to learn how little many people care about your 20th century social ideologies.
- ShawnBird 14y agoExcept that feminism is a social movement that only works when it is widely understood and religion is a personal belief structure. The two are nothing alike.
- NotMyMorals 14y ago
- crusso 14y agoThe solution is healther, more balanced workweeks for everyone. Why do some even feel the need to have such a strong opinion on what "balance" means to different people and where they draw that line? If you want more money and financial success, focus on your work. If you want more attention to your parenting and to devote more time to parental interaction, then focus more time on your family life. The idea that we're going to decide as a society what a "balanced workweek" is and what that balance means between parents is alien to me. It's a topic that's so subjective and so based upon individual goals, situations, and preferences that to discuss it in the aggregate is meaningless. Worse, once people start talking about having a "balanced workweek" or a "living wage", the next step always seems to be, "Well now we need to legislate a lowest-common-denominator norm."
- josephlord 14y agoOn the other hand unhealthy unproductive competition to work the longest doesn't do anybody any good at all. Sometimes individual incentives don't lead to the best societal outcome and it can be beneficial to try to change the situation by setting examples, incentives or even sometimes with rules.
- crusso 14y agoOn the other hand unhealthy unproductive competition to work the longest doesn't do anybody any good at all. It's normally preferable to let the market sort out what is unproductive and what isn't. If you're running a company and overworking your employees, then you leave yourself open to a competitor who better optimizes worker productivity by being smarter about hours worked. You'll also risk having your employees leave if they don't like the working conditions. Rather than have a bunch of politicians and bureaucrats make a bunch of rules based upon their normal levels of incompetence and lack of knowledge, I'd rather let smaller groups of people and companies determine what works for them.
- akldfgj 14y agoOverworked miserable people caught in rat race can be highly productive and contribute to successful businesss. That doesn't mean they are happy.
- prodigal_erik 14y agoI would prefer that balance only apply to average people. Not maximizing unique and valuable contributions, in return for more of the grunt work that 3.5 billion couples are already covering, is not a win.
- run4yourlives 14y ago> But as a society, we refuse to let our male CEO's work less. Society is not choosing how you live your life - you are. Your point is valid, but the real solution is to simply not play the game.
- freshhawk 14y agoIf you have a way to become a CEO or any position that's highly competitive without playing the game I'm sure everyone would like to hear it.
- run4yourlives 14y agoCreate your own company. This site is littered with examples of people doing exactly this. The other way is to discard the idea that being a "CEO" is a desirable goal at all.
- freshhawk 14y agoI did, with some cofounders, went through an accelerator, rounded up investors. Sitting in our office right now. So yes, I am familiar with this path. Now the answer is to create your own company? I thought the answer was not to play the game? If you think you don't have to play the game to start a company then you haven't done it before.