4 ms·
It's so strange that this should have been a solved problem decades ago, but somehow a robust and secure non-commercial solution never gets off the ground. Spe
by amelius 2y ago
It's so strange that this should have been a solved problem decades ago, but somehow a robust and secure non-commercial solution never gets off the ground.
Speaking of which, how is the IPFS project doing these days?
- piyuv 2y agoIt was solved a decade ago, BitTorrent protocol
- brulard 2y agoBitTorrent started in 2001, so more than 2 decades.
- pzmarzly 2y agoArguably, only in BitTorrent V2, which released in 2017, wasn't supported by major clients until 2020, and is still not widely adopted.
- piyuv 2y agoThe same reason universal healthcare and free education is not widely adopted in the US. BitTorrent is quite “widely adopted” in other parts of the world.
- pessimizer 2y ago> Bittorrent V2
- SirMaster 2y agoI think people mean something seamless like AirDrop is on Apple devides, but some public standard that gets implemented on all platforms like iOS, Android, Windows, macOS and Linux, so all these platforms can just easily send files to each other simply and securely over WiFi.
- piyuv 2y agoThere’s no incentive for big players to play nicely with other platforms so they just won’t. Hardware standards like Qi2 are different since it affects costs directly. Software is usually built for lock-in since quite some time. “Buy your mom an iPhone” and how Apple buried beeper mini into nonexistence was a nice example.
- pjc50 2y ago"Securely" is doing a lot of work here; you need some out of band mechanism to transfer the link in the first place, to determine who you're getting the file from, and then you might as well use that to transfer the file instead. Also people want to be able to do it asynchronously, so they use things like WeTransfer. During the brief period that open Airdrop / bluetooth file transfer was a thing, there was a short fad of spamming porn to nearby people on public transport. So that was the end of that.
- JadeNB 2y ago> During the brief period that open Airdrop / bluetooth file transfer was a thing, there was a short fad of spamming porn to nearby people on public transport. So that was the end of that. My recollection is that the end of that was Apple's worry about the protests in China, not any concern about spam on public transit. (The first Google hit: https://restofworld.org/2022/apple-airdrop-china-memes/ https://restofworld.org/2022/apple-airdrop-china-memes/.)
- slt2021 2y agoI had a lot of fun airdropping rickroll videos to nearby phones while waiting for rides in disneyland
- SirMaster 2y agoSeems like such a simple fix though... Blur the shared photos unless you tap preview. Or unless it's coming from someone you have in your contacts. Or just not have it show the preview at all and obviously you would decline files from someone you aren't expecting to receive files from. Or the simple fix of just not having this P2P transfer option always enabled. It should be off until you toggle it on because you and someone you are with want to transfer a file.
- lxgr 2y agoVery different use case. It seems both too heavy weight and not capable enough for e.g. sharing a screenshot or PDF from an Android phone to a Linux laptop without Internet connectivity.
- megadata 2y agoYeah, your can do your dishes with the fire hose too.
- supertrope 2y agoPeople drive one ton pickup trucks to commute to their desk job. Or to get two bags of groceries.
- culi 2y agoThis is true but this sucks. Modern American SUVs are an abomination too. The American auto industry started pushing them because they're legally classified as "light trucks" which lets them take advantage of certain safety and environmental standard loopholes
- pessimizer 2y agoYes, but it's no harder to get your groceries with an SUV than with a compact car. The firehose metaphor doesn't make sense; you're not going to accidentally wash all of the data off of the recipient's computer if you're not especially skilled in handling bittorrent. The problem with bittorrent is ports, just like ipfs. I have to tell somebody to open a port to the outside who may never use bittorrent again. Opening ports can be obnoxiously hard for someone who doesn't know anything, even if it sometimes just means finding the UPnP checkbox; 90% of the time it involves trying to figure out how to access the UI for their router, and after that trying to figure out what their password could possibly be or how to reset it. Now, they've got a port sitting open for a piece of software they might never use again, and that's not something I want to be responsible for. People who often share files should be setting up standing private networks. Group chats/texts can last for years, they should be packaged with an entire range of services that the members can easily provide for themselves (like file sharing and voice/video messaging.) So many companies make their money from centralizing and siloing this.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 2y ago
- hot_gril 2y agoThis isn't always encrypted, right?
- sidewndr46 2y agoPeer to peer sharing doesn't really have much opportunity for commercialization. The closest thing I can think of is bluetooth file sharing, which can still be a painful experience in some circumstances
- megadata 2y agoNot only sharing, bluetooth in general can be a painful experience in some circumstances.
- supertrope 2y agoYes businesses tend to only work on interoperability when the interoperable product is just a complement to their main revenue generator. Like how Netflix releases clients for many platforms. No one is going to be motivated to make a (1) free (2) easy to use (3) cross platform file sharing solution. It'll also draw the ire of the copyright cartel. File locker websites have been harassed and "legitimate" cloud storage services are forced to police their user's files.
- Yizahi 2y agoXKCD from a decade ago, and we still can't figure it out ;( https://xkcd.com/949/ https://xkcd.com/949/ Recently I had to send file from Whatsapp to Telegram, because apparently it is forbidden to download file from the Whatsapp and it's a "feature". Facepalm.... PS: afaik IPFS doesn't guarantee file storage, a separate paid middleman is required for that.
- j_maffe 2y agoIPFS allows you to store your file and share the content ID to someone else so that they can get it through P2P
- j_maffe 2y agoIPFS is in this weird state where it's getting barely enough updates and enough usage to not be considered vaporware.
- makeworld 2y agoIt is partially being succeeded by Iroh. https://www.iroh.computer/ https://www.iroh.computer/
- IsTom 2y agoI think it's because of all the NAT, which makes any attempt cumbersome for a lot of people.
- pmarreck 2y agoIf only IPv6 had taken off...