7 ms·
Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies
- toomuchtodo 2y agoAbstract: https://psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037/ebs0000374 https://psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037/ebs0000374
- TheRealPomax 2y agoThat's not the paper, that's just the abstract, which doesn't actually talk about sample size. It does point out an important limitation of the research: it looks at number of children specifically at 23 and 24 years old, rather than the full range of ages at which people have children in Canada. Which is the other limitation: it only looked at Canada, and the abstract doesn't say which parts of Canada, so there's so much information missing that it's impossible to tell what this study actually found.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoEdited.
- delichon 2y agoPresumably individual aggression versus fertility is an inverted U shaped curve in which fertility rises with aggression to an inflection point and then declines. That point is probably higher than we would like for the achievement of other social goals. It may be that at the level of civilizations the aggression versus fertility curve is different than for individuals: Memes may propagate more efficiently with more or less aggression than genes do. But social media is showing that brutality is more positively correlated with virality than we'd hope for. If cultural values about aggression reduce fertility to below replacement they become culturally suicidal. For both aggression and pacifism the dose is the poison. Calibrating the dose is an eternal political and biological battle.
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoWhat exactly is fertility here? I don’t think all the non-bullies are shooting blanks. What if the bullies are just worse on average at family planning? How are you differentiating civilizations, especially in the modern age when national borders don’t constrain enormous trade of goods and culture?
- decimalenough 2y agoIt's not about shooting blanks, but getting the chance to reproduce in the first place. There's a lot of research showing that women are attracted to confidence and dominant traits (read: "bad guys"), and that this preference is basically universal.
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoCould you share some of this research. I haven’t seen it, but I’d be happy to learn.
- hwbehrens 2y agoAs one example, here is a relatively well-cited study from 1994: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0146167294202008 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/014616729420200... Note that interpretations of "dominance" tend to vary, it seems, between papers and over time.
- 1659447091 2y agoWomen can be and are bullies too. The article took into account both sexes: >>The research shows that higher levels of bullying in both men and women were associated with having children in young adulthood (by ages 23 or 24) in addition to having more children overall. Their reason appears to be that they are able to date more and engage in more sexual activity as they assert their (I assume, higher) social position: >> The recent findings build on previous BRAVE research that has indicated adolescent bullies date more and engage in more sexual activity than their peers—attracting potential mates by publicly asserting their dominance and establishing their position socially. My guess is that more aggression leads to less foresight about consequences of action, or as OP mentioned, are just worse on average at family planning
- dboreham 2y agoBecause they have more money?
- firefax 2y agoMakes sense. I've seen folks justify being needlessly adversarial because their crotchspawn obviously deserve the best, so anyone who stands in the way of a promotion or publication is a threat and therefor they can reframe bullying as being a breadwinner.
- dennis_jeeves2 2y ago>crotchspawn New word for me. Good one.
- firefax 2y agoHaha thanks, I'm guessing English is not your first language? Glad I could be of help ;-)
- dennis_jeeves2 2y agoWell, nearly the first language... Haven't see the use of that word in the circles I frequent (in US/Canada).
- sitkack 2y agoStanding up for someone else, you can be 10x over the top karen, and you are an alley and a hero. Do it for yourself and you are an asshole. Other people's causes give you cover to act poorly. *pre-edit, I realize this gives us a way to demonize those protecting the weak via an Ad hominem against the moral.
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoBecause pressure works on girls? The rapes?
- actionfromafar 2y agoEspecially the marital rapes.
- alabastervlog 2y agoI can't see the article without buying it (nope) but my first "hm, I wonder..." would be to see if they adjusted for education, income level, and parents' income level. This might just be saying something like "bullies don't excel in school", given what we already know about socioeconomic demographic trends WRT fertility. With the wrong study design they could even get this result if bullies have lower fertility than some SES sub-group they also tend to be a part of. One would suppose they adjusted for that, but sometimes papers make it out with some really weird oversights.
- anon012012 2y agoColor me naive, but isn't it simply more pleasant to have sex with a manly bully than with a "nice guy" pushover? Do we need to explain further? I guess, we can study the extent to which pushovers are being pushovers, but it should not be surprising that they are being pushed over to some extent.
- johnny22 2y ago> "nice guy" pushover These two things aren't as related as people think they are. One can be a "nice guy" and still not be a pushover. Being assertive is not the same as being aggressive.
- itishappy 2y agoLoad bearing "simply" because that doesn't sound simple at all. For one, is the scale really this simple? less manly <--------> more manly pushovers most men bullies That sounds extremely reductive to me. I suspect there's at least one more axis.
- djaouen 2y agoNon-bullies don't want their unborn children to experience the same shit that they did. I wasn't bullied, and I think the exact same way and have no kids, btw.
- scottLobster 2y agoCounterpoint: I was bullied, have two kids and want more. I was fed a diet of "just ignore them and they'll go away" (ha), the school promising to do something about it but never more than a slap on the wrist for the bullies, "violence never solves anything", I learned to stay within view of the teachers at recess. As I got older, I realized the issue was the authority figures in my life never allowed or taught me how to fight, physically or otherwise. The practical solutions to the problem made them so uncomfortable that they avoided even discussing them. So they just let me suffer for years knowing that eventually I'd graduate and the problem would "go away". Let's just say that my kids won't have that same upbringing, and any bully who tries what I experienced will be in for a shock.
- nostrademons 2y agoI was bullied and have 3 kids. Living well is the best revenge.
- silisili 2y agoI personally wasn't bullied, but if I had to live in the school district I grew up in and felt I had no way out, I would have never had kids. It was that bad. Luckily that wasn't the case, so I do, and a change of scenery helps a ton. The way they describe school now is nothing like when I was in public school.
- quantadev 2y agoNo one needs to "prove" an obvious correlation. Why do people have such a hard time spotting root causes? The root cause here is obviously testosterone levels. There will be a precise correlation if anyone were to bother to check.
- freedomben 2y agoI'm guessing you are trolling, but this is a terrible take. Insert meme of Homer Simpson: "Everyone is stupid except for me"[1] If you're interested on the subject, Robert Sapolsky has studied and written about Testosterone extensively. He has some videos up on Youtube as well as several books. [1]: https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/ZzMAAOSwscVlpdzW/s-l1200.jpg https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/ZzMAAOSwscVlpdzW/s-l1200.jpg
- linksnapzz 2y agoAh, you went and did the ackchyually meme. Way to go.
- quantadev 2y agoHe had to [intentionally?] misread the word "people" as if I'd said "all people" in order to be able to justify his rude response. Anyway, even at slightly above average IQ that makes me smarter than 4 billion humans. So yeah...."all of them". And I did use "all" that time. lol. It's so easy to make fun of people who can't even read.
- quantadev 2y ago[flagged]
- mp05 2y ago> The root cause here is obviously testosterone levels. This is a patently absurd observation and you didn't even bother to offer an anecdote, as if that would make a difference anyways.
- 2y ago
- croissants 2y agoI don't think there's a good discussion to be had about this article. The referenced paper is based on two data sources. One is a longitudinal study (great!) of "hundreds" of children in one region (not bad!) and only checks parenthood at the rather young age of 23-24 (uhhh). The other study is based on Mechanical Turk questions. In both the article and the fullest version of the paper I can find online [1], no further details are provided -- not the size of the effects, not the statistical power, nothing. [1] https://psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2Febs0000374 https://psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2Febs0000374
- boh 2y agoYeah it feels like too much "research" is just click bait at this point (or just a lazy dissertation).
- r00fus 2y agoPerhaps it would be more useful to say (specifically for that first more valid study) that bullies have kids earlier.
- fxtentacle 2y agoYeah, checking at such a young age is a serious distortion of the data. The average age at first pregnancy is somewhere around 30. That means they are counting exclusively pregnancies that are untypically early. A more accurate summary of the results would be: Bullies have more accidental children before reaching the age where the average couple will start to deliberately get pregnant.
- TheRealPomax 2y agoNo, a more accurate summary of the results would be: "we generated a tiny bit of data from which no conclusions can be drawn, but it's some extra data that other studies may be able to use in the future maybe".
- elzbardico 2y agoMy experience with bullying as the occasional victim is that bullying is mostly a social phenomenon. The bully itself was rarely the problem, he was just the enforcer of conformity for the group. And as such he was really popular.
- bloomingkales 2y agoSo if we have to go with your observation, the bully is the leader of a group. Such a person is rarely alone in life, and it would follow with the article. To live with yourself as a bully, you need a complicit group. If the group becomes aware of you, you kind of need a new group to believe you. A group can be just two people. The bully exists because there is another that allows the group to exist (allows the abusive dynamic to exist). If the group stops existing, the bully stops existing, unless they find another group that allows it. The bully by themselves (to be truly alone) would feel uncomfortable because their life is centered around extreme group dynamics.
- elzbardico 2y agoThe problem in my particular case is that the bully's group was basically every other kid but me and a couple of other nerds. The other kids kind of didn't like our quirkness, or our poverty, or whatever other thing. Maybe they were fed up with the fact that we were the know it alls and the teacher's pet. It doesn't matter, but the fact is that we were the object of social rejection and the bully as the leader of the pack of kids, was also the executor.
- bloomingkales 2y agoI'm sorry you went through that. In fact, I knew you went through that soon as you described it so accurately.
- elzbardico 2y agoYeah. It sucked, but understanding the dynamic and changing school eliminated the problem. I was lucky to have the opportunity to changing school though. few parents have this option nowadays.
- CaptWillard 2y agoI reject the premise that people can be sorted into bullies and non-bullies. It's amusing/frustrating that such a premise is taken seriously.
- bandinobaddies 2y agoI agree, somewhat. In my high school, there was hierarchy of bullies. Some bullied other bullies. The victim bullies bullied other weaker kids. And some bullies only bullied other bullies, they were considered heros.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- taeric 2y agoI'm curious. If you had some that you would categorize as only bullying people that bullied others, would this fit with a justice perception? How does this account for someone "repenting," as it were, of bullying? Put differently, I think the objection is that "bully" is not an immutable facet of someone. For many, it often isn't even a choice moreso a by product of the general environment they find themselves in. Obviously malicious actors are defined by their intent to bully. But sometimes people will feel bullied from someone's intent to maintain a preexisting order? How does that get categorized?
- bandinobaddies 2y ago> If you had some that you would categorize as only bullying people that bullied others, would this fit with a justice perception? How does this account for someone "repenting," as it were, of bullying? I think some of it was complex rivalries. Bullies on the top were the cool kids who cared about their image a lot. They mostly bullied bullies who were challenging their status. They were also more sophisticated in their bullying and have other bullies do the dirty work of physical fights. Then there were hero bullies who targeted other bullies. These hero bullies were usually stronger kids and really looking for fights. They didn't care about their images as much. A lot of time they were already in trouble with school. They would become protectors of the weakest kids. But they were probably the most violent and beat up the bullies of those weakest kids pretty bad. Maybe they had a savior complex. We really considered them heros at the time but now I realize that they went too far and probably pushed their victim bullies to get more violent. > For many, it often isn't even a choice moreso a by product of the general environment they find themselves in Yes, it was indeed the environment, at least, for some kids. Almost every kid was victim and a bully at the same time. We were like dogs, there was power hierarchy that was constantly challenged and enforced. Things would be fine most of the time if you didn't challenge anyone, every once in a while someone try to establish their dominance over you by verbally or physically assaulting you.
- hcarvalhoalves 2y agoThe plot from the "Idiocracy" movie gets more real everyday.
- jmugan 2y agoI was thinking of that scene/meme from Back to the Future, "Hey, wait, I've seen this one!"
- skyyler 2y agoEugenics watered down just enough to be palatable to the average American?
- dandanua 2y agoWe live in an inexplicable mixture of idiocracy + matrix + terminator. Only aliens are missing. Yet.
- aurumque 2y agoInterestingly, the research doesn't indicate whether these additional children are wanted or expected. Similar to substance abuse, I would not be surprised if having more children is in fact an unwanted behavior that helps the genome but not the individual within society.
- Retr0id 2y agoDoes this imply that parents are more likely to be bullies than non-parents?
- ajb 2y agoShark neonates attack each other in the womb. Hyena cubs kill each other. I don't know if the evidence of this paper is good, but it's plausible to me that human children attempt to damage each other for evolutionary benefit. It's not a very optimistic viewpoint, because it means the parents of bullies have a strong motivation to prevent the rooting out of this behavior.
- nkmnz 2y agoThe biggest bullies have 14+ kids.
- knowitnone 2y agoGood guys ALWAYS finish last
- terminatornet 2y agonow just to look up how many kids one Elon Musk has
- GistNoesis 2y agoUnfortunately bullying doesn't stop with adulthood. Bullies only get more power. Victims are ignored and blamed. How could they have children when everyone in power rather look the other way than help. Why would they bring a significant other down with them? Why would they have children if that's what await them?
- thedonkeycometh 2y ago[dead]