4 ms·
Ariane 6 is Europe’s SLS, Arianespace its ULA. Every launch requires public subsidies to float and cements SpaceX’s global advantage by denying funding to Europ
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
Ariane 6 is Europe’s SLS, Arianespace its ULA. Every launch requires public subsidies to float and cements SpaceX’s global advantage by denying funding to European companies who might one day compete with SpaceX.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Teever 2y agoBut the cost to develop falcon 9neas peanuts. Europe can toss that money to a bunch of different groups and get the results of the talent is there while maintaining an ability to launch with Ariane 6 in the meantime.
- bojan 2y agoThe ESA and Arianespace provide hundreds of European companies with business, most of those subsidies go directly back to the knowledge economy that in turn generate tax income. It's a win-win really, and I'd rather have that than a private company that is dependent on a whim of one man. Not for something so crucial.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoArianespace is essentially assured launch leadership for SpaceX. It denies Europe economies of scale in launch. At the end of the day, if Europe is happy having a small fraction of its own launch market, whatever, Arianespace keeps people employed.
- Gravityloss 2y agoThere are European launcher startups. But they are years away from being dependable launch vehicles. Meanwhile Ariane is strategically important. So it has to exist. Ariane was actually born because Americans wouldn't launch European satellites if they competed with American ones.
- bbatsell 2y agoArianespace ≈ ULA, yes. Ariane 6 ≈ SLS, absolutely not. There is no official figure yet, but even the most pessimistic estimates place its per-launch cost at $150m (as opposed to $2b for SLS — with a hazy goal to eventually trim it to $500m). The rumors are that Ariane 6 is already well below $100m.
- nickff 2y agoBoth SLS and Ariane 6 are late and over-budget, with little hope of being cost-competitive sans-subsidy. Aside from that, they’re very different rockets.
- imtringued 2y agoSo you're saying it's like ULA's Vulkan. Got it.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Ariane 6 ≈ SLS, absolutely not. There is no official figure yet, but even the most pessimistic estimates place its per-launch cost at $150m Oh goody, just 2.5x the Falcon 9's cost. After a €140mm / launch subsidy [1]. > rumors are that Ariane 6 is already well below $100m Yes, they're asking for more subsidies. [1] https://arstechnica.com/space/2023/10/oops-it-looks-like-the-ariane-6-rocket-may-not-offer-europe-any-launch-savings/?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email https://arstechnica.com/space/2023/10/oops-it-looks-like-the...
- LizPa 2y agoYou're missing the point that SpaceX development is (heavily) publicly subsidized.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoI’m really not. Subsidies aren’t the problem. An uncompetitive rocket is. Ariane 6’s per launch costs are multiples SpaceX’s. Nothing Arianespace makes is competitive without operating—not development—subsidies. As long as Europe is dependant on Arianespace, it’s less serious about space as a place than as a job description. And its companies will continue being reliant on foreign launch providers.