5 ms·
WB offers replacements, but no refunds, for DVDs rotting prematurely
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoActual article: https://www.joblo.com/warner-bros-dvds-dont-work/ https://www.joblo.com/warner-bros-dvds-dont-work/
- TylerE 2y agoWhy would anyone expect refunds for a product bought 20 years ago?
- timewizard 2y agoWhy would any company expect their copyrights to last for life of the creator plus 70 years? If I can't pirate it, then I expect it to be replaced, this is the system they demanded.
- TylerE 2y agoThat doesn't logically follow. You bought a disc, not lifetime access rights.
- hnuser123456 2y agoCan't wait til I need to own at least 10 stocks of the publisher to watch a movie
- JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B 2y agoYou rent a disk which you cannot legally backup. I expect a refund if it’s not usable anymore.
- bigstrat2003 2y agoCannot legally back up depends heavily on the specifics. For a long time (IDK about currently) it was legal to rip your own discs for backup purposes, and even to break the encryption as long as you did it yourself. So it was potentially legal but not necessarily within reach to do it legally. And that is, of course, wrong. There should never be any uncertainty about whether you can back up the media you purchased. Saying you're "renting" the disc is just plain disingenuous, though. You own it free and clear. You can give it to anyone you like, for free or for a profit (i.e. how Netflix did things back in the day). The original owner is not asserting the right to come and take it back from you. It is in no way a rental, it is a sale.
- josephcsible 2y agoI wouldn't expect refunds for a product, but I would for a perpetual license to a copyrighted work that I couldn't access anymore. They can't have it both ways.
- cogman10 2y agoIf a book falls apart are you owed a replacement by the publisher?
- JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B 2y agoI would ask for a replacement if the seller and the law said "I am renting the book."
- toast0 2y agoBuying a book doesn't give you any more rights or privileges that buying a dvd. Although I guess it's a lot easier to take a book and give all your favorite people a portion of it. You're paying for the physical object and have a license to read it or view it, but not to copy it (other than what fair use provides). Many books have an explicit statement of this on the copyright page.
- cogman10 2y agoThe seller and law say you own the book but you don't own the content of the book. That is, you are free to read the book as many times as you like, you aren't free to start printing out and distributing copies of the book as "backup" for all your friends and family. The laws around DVDs are the same. You have a right to access and view the contents of the DVD. You don't have a right to make copies of the dvd. I'd also point out products like cheap paperbacks which obliterate themselves after 4 or 5 reads. Don't get me wrong, I'm all for some good reforms and regulations around copyrights and media access, especially in the digital age. I just think it's a little bit ridiculous to expect purchased media to never degrade.
- josephcsible 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- huang_chung 2y agoCostco abusers.
- morley 2y agoI don't know why you've been downvoted so much. I'd expect a company to issue replacements, not refunds, when they're not the end retailer.
- nosioptar 2y agoI wouldn't for a DVD. I would for my cello if a repair or replacement wasn't doable because it came with a lifetime warranty against defects.
- CamelCaseName 2y agoI mean, it's been almost two decades. At some point, things just don't work anymore, even if two decades is significantly less time than other DVDs.
- throwaway48476 2y agoIt's an order of magnitude less due to a manufacturing error in one factory.
- skyyler 2y agoI have CDs from the 80s that still work. Heck, I have DiscoVision discs from the 70s that still work. DVDs from 2006 should definitely still work.
- joezydeco 2y agoRTA. They're defective.
- Ukv 2y agoskyyler is refuting a comment that implies this is expected by mentioning that their own (non-defective) discs have lasted ~50 years and counting.
- 6SixTy 2y agoLaserdiscs/DiscoVision are analog, they can technically still work but their image quality could be heavily degraded. Also, storage conditions can deeply affect how well a medium lasts but that's no excuse for defective discs.
- m463 2y agoOne thing I've noticed with older era CDs is that they were heavy and frequently not balanced to play at 48x
- toast0 2y ago
- mcphage 2y agoAh, I bet this is what happened with my boxed set of extended edition Lord of the Rings trilogy. I bought it years ago, finally opened it a few months back to show my kids—only to find that several of the disks failed half-way through. That was a really frustrating experience.
- MobileVet 2y agoBeyond personal images and documents of important, this was the second reason for establishing a home NAS with 3,2,1 backup [1]. Physical media fails, so you better have a plan for dealing with that if you care to maintain access. [1](https://www.backblaze.com/blog/the-3-2-1-backup-strategy/ https://www.backblaze.com/blog/the-3-2-1-backup-strategy/)
- shmerl 2y agoHard drives and DRM-free videos are a thing.
- kulahan 2y agoSo is video streaming, which is just as unrelated to the topic at hand.
- shmerl 2y agoNope, not comparable. Streaming isn't a replacement for stored DVDs. Hard drives are.
- kulahan 2y agoNeither are hard drives. You cannot legally copy them. You’ve missed the point of the article. This comment you made was unrelated to the topic being discussed, which was about the issue of discs rotting and the fallout from that. This matters because discs are not a physical product so much as a representative of a license you own. If the license doesn’t expire, the format shouldn’t matter at all. So again, your comment was way off topic because this has nothing to do with the idea of superior storage techniques, but fallout from licensing-based approaches.
- shmerl 2y agoWho said you can't legally copy them? Let the stuck up DRM control freaks sell video DRM-free, then you would legally copy it. Otherwise everyone will copy it ignoring their DRM anyway. Disk is a physical copy. Those who think it's a "representation of the license" are just luddites who cause harm to preservation of art.
- kulahan 2y agoThe law says you can’t. You have a license for one copy of the movie, to be played via whatever medium you bought it on. You absolutely cannot legally copy it. If your solution is “just break the law”, there are an enormous number of problems you could get past.
- StillBored 2y agoThis was known about HDDVDs a few years back too. I pulled my Harry Potter collection out for my kids and their friends to watch and evntually concluded that every single WB disk was bad, even some that weren't even opened. It was unique to WB, other companies disks continued to mostly work. Some people online at the time mentioned WB replaced a few of their disks with bluray's but I never managed to get WB to respond to my inquiries. I ended up flying the jolly roger, I mean I own a legal copy, so its just format shifting...
- cyanydeez 2y agoYeah, it would seem if they're not responsible for providing a disk that as a documented and known longevity, there's really nothing you're buying but a license to view the material and that's unrevokable.