9 ms·
Fights like this only legitimize the EU's DSA to me. UK users would not be beholden to Apple for E2EE if their clients had legitimate alternatives to the first-
by bigyabai 2y ago
Fights like this only legitimize the EU's DSA to me. UK users would not be beholden to Apple for E2EE if their clients had legitimate alternatives to the first-party iCloud service. There would be no world where Apple could even threaten to disable it.
Break the walled garden down, and all of the sudden it doesn't matter what Apple's stance on E2EE is. But Apple wouldn't want that, since then you might realize they aren't the sole arbiters of online privacy.
- nkellenicki 2y agoI'm all for the DSA as well, but this argument doesn't hold water. Any sufficiently large cloud provider alternative (ie. Google, Microsoft, etc) would likely be the target of similar government instructions. In fact, I bet they already are - they just can't talk about it. And of course, it's already possible to disable iCloud backups and use a smaller provider or host your own alternatives. I already do, through Nextcloud, etc. It's not as fully integrated of course, but you bet that if it was, then the largest alternatives would be targeted all the same.
- petedoyle 2y agoIf Apple were to add new APIs, it might be possible to use personal cloud storage (NAS, Decentralized Web Nodes, etc.) with the same UX as iCloud with E2EE.
- zimpenfish 2y ago> it might be possible to use personal cloud storage [...] with E2EE Which would quickly become illegal if UKGOV is set on getting access to people's iOS backups / cloud storage / etc. Hell, it's already a legal requirement to hand over your keys if UKGOV demands them[0]. [0] "Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 part III (RIPA 3) gives the UK power to authorities to compel the disclosure of encryption keys or decryption of encrypted data by way of a Section 49 Notice." https://wiki.openrightsgroup.org/wiki/Regulation_of_Investigatory_Powers_Act_2000/Part_III https://wiki.openrightsgroup.org/wiki/Regulation_of_Investig...
- doublerabbit 2y agoI would be less pissed with this if the UK actually kept the data to the UK.
- timewizard 2y agoYou'd be fine with _domestic surveillance_ as long as it's kept within country? The average jurisprudence of a UK citizen is mind blowing to me.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- throwaway290 2y agoI'm not british. I would be fine under their government. Not too thrilled but fine
- LocalH 2y agoParent said "less pissed", not "fine"
- timewizard 2y agoI don't negotiate with terrorists.
- alwayslikethis 2y agoScale matters. Police don't have the time to go through everyone's computers. It is much easier to scan everyone's conversations, notes, or photos. Cloud storage invites this kind of mass surveillance by being high-value targets with little capacity to resist.
- Aloisius 2y agoBit more complicated than that. iCloud isn't passive storage. A fair bit of the logic exists on the server.
- stuaxo 2y agoAh, so in the UK or China this could go through a proxy that steals all the keys. Half the computer crimes in the UK involve illegal access to the PNC (police national computer), how exactly do we think this would go. For all the checks you put on people who can access this stuff the temptation is too big - just look at the intelligence analysts using systems to stalk Exs etc. For any system like this to exist you must ask yourself if you would be happy with the worst person you know having a job where they have access to it.
- alwayslikethis 2y agoYou can always have an company without legal presence in the UK to do the operations, beyond the reach of the UK government. If you are allowed to run your own software on your devices, you can always encrypt before sending. Apple and to a lesser extent Google got themselves in this position of being able to spy by building their walled gardens.
- alecmuffett 2y agoOP here. I am sympathetic, really I am, but the challenge then is a diversity of solutions tends to lack really good high quality security systems integration, meaning that data leaks differently. It's hard to have a high integrity solution which is an open standard and implemented equally well by all players.
- bigyabai 2y agoI would rather that Apple invests in solving hard problems. Spending that money on legal representation only kicks the can down the road.
- alecmuffett 2y agoOne of the hardest problems you can face is getting a community of disparate developers to do the right thing at scale; sometimes the easiest solution for that is a monolithic integrated blob.
- bigyabai 2y agoI agree, that's why I applaud smart regulation. Apple is a disparate business too, you have no way to bring them to the table for doing "the right thing" unless there's some threat of repercussions. It's really easy for Apple to back themselves into a vulnerable corner with the "ecosystem" mentality drawn out to it's logical extremes. I'd argue it's our democratic duty to stop businesses from endangering their customers like that, but that really depends on how you feel about consumer protections.
- easytiger 2y agoThe EU and the EUC are not your friend when it comes to privacy https://home-affairs.ec.europa.eu/networks/high-level-group-hlg-access-data-effective-law-enforcement_en https://home-affairs.ec.europa.eu/networks/high-level-group-...
- bigyabai 2y agoNor is the jurisdiction Apple is headquartered in: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/12/apple-admits-to-secretly-giving-governments-push-notification-data/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/12/apple-admits-to-... It feels like a moot point, to me.
- easytiger 2y agoHow is an exploration of broad spectrum legislative attacks on all forms of encryption regardless of hosting and corporate ownership and data communication moot?
- bigyabai 2y agoThe UK has to formally ask for a backdoor, the United States has the leverage to coerce Apple into implimenting one while demanding that it remain a secret. We don't know if the US has implemented equivalent iCloud backdoors yet, it might be under wraps like the push notification bug. Maybe that doesn't concern you though, and that's fine. Apple is always looking for customers that don't care that much about their devices.
- easytiger 2y agoI genuinely have no idea what you are talking about. Is there a particular reason you don't want to discuss the EU working group which is what I posted in response to your comment. I didn't even dive in to how your original comment doesn't make sense to me. How do you think the DSA would help or change anything regarding either.
- 2y ago
- freehorse 2y ago> There would be no world where Apple could even threaten to disable it. They did not "threaten to disable it" and apple's stance on E2EE is not the issue here, UK's stance is. UK essentially made icloud E2EE by demanding apple to make a global backdoor into it, and essentially thus forced them to disable it. It is not disabled anywhere else in the world. Essentially the UK (and other states) want somehow to have their pie and eat it too, but that's just not possible.
- doublerabbit 2y agoIf UK is already doing this, then what's them from banning all new iPhones? Some countries do.
- mikestew 2y agothen what's them from banning all new iPhones? The torches and pitchforks that are soon to follow? You might get away with that in oppressive “some countries”, but I just can’t imagine it ending well in someplace like the UK.
- andrewflnr 2y agoI'd hope so, but you never know what you can get people to tolerate "for the children". This is, after all, the same UK population that voted these halfwits into power.
- nicoburns 2y agoThe children themselves would be in the streets protesting if you banned iPhones in the UK.
- andrewflnr 2y agoNaturally we have to protect them from themselves. /s
- 2y ago
- ziddoap 2y ago>UK users would not be beholden to Apple for E2EE if their clients had legitimate alternatives to the first-party iCloud service. Any sufficiently popular alternative would be subject to the same issue: you can't backdoor encryption without making it insecure. >There would be no world where Apple could even threaten to disable it. Your framing of this seems to blame Apple, and I don't understand why.
- alwayslikethis 2y agoYou can have a service beyond the reach of UK law enforcement. Somehow piracy on the clearnet never really stopped with it being illegal in most countries.
- tree_enjoyer 2y agoIf you're a company with offices, personnel, and assets in the UK, well your "service" may be beyond the reach, but the rest isn't.
- ziddoap 2y agoYou're suggesting that Apple, a giant publicly traded company with known people that can be summoned to court and assets located in places that can be seized, should ignore lawful orders from a country they are operating in? Can I ask you how you think that would play out? >Somehow piracy on the clearnet never really stopped with it being illegal in most countries. I'm sure you can spot the difference between a small group of people running a piracy site and a multinational company selling physical devices in physical stores.
- alwayslikethis 2y agoI'm not talking about Apple here. This is what you said: > Any sufficiently popular alternative would be subject to the same issue: you can't backdoor encryption without making it insecure. I'm just saying this is not true because you can have a company without any legal presence, thus susceptibility to law enforcement, in the UK. The legal issue will be shifted onto the user, but it's hard to go after millions of users compared to one big company. The parallel with piracy is that they also tend to be operated from beyond the jurisdiction of countries enforcing the copyright.
- jeroenhd 2y agoThe UK demands a backdoor in the backups, so having an alternative backup app isn't the solution here. All the alternatives would just get forced into also adding backdoors, or everyone working for the companies that provide alternatives find themselves unable to ever enter the UK again. That said, I do wish there were more backup solutions for mobile platforms. Android has an API for this, but it's only available to software signed with manufacturer keys. LineageOS and various other custom ROMs use this to allow Seedvault backups, but as a stock Android user I can only pick between Google backups and no backups. On the other hand, these backups do contain material you don't necessarily want random apps to have access to. Seeing how powerful stalkerware/"parental control" already is on Android, I recognise that there are dangers that the general population might not realise. Adding additional warnings and messages about backups (even when the backups are made using manufacturer software) would probably strike a balance, though.
- t00 2y agoBoth Apple and Android (stock) are candidates for anti-monopoly regulations regarding the limited, vendor locked backup API. Enforcing choice of the backup solution would solve the problem of rogue countries like the UK meddling with privacy and security. Like the browser choice, backup provider choice can end up being enforced, likely by the EU as they have a good history of breaking up vendor lock-ins. Possibly an information/lobby campaign can be started and endorsed by some major online storage providers?
- jeroenhd 2y agoI agree, though with Android an argument can be had that Samsung and other manufacturers can offer alternatives if they want to (they have their own stores and their own platform keys). I don't think there's a large lobby for the backup app industry but a lawsuit against Apple/Google/Samsung should be easily won here.
- XorNot 2y agoNo android backup software I've seen is remotely good enough though: as in "indeop my phone in a shredder, and replace it with another identical model but thanks to the backup it relaunches exactly as it was" Like a bunch of stuff will backup data, yet it's just about impossible to autonomously and confidently ensure I can restore my home screen and other app configuration data.
- stetrain 2y agoThe UK is the one saying that they have the right to request backdoor access to any E2EE services. This could extend to any app available in the UK market, or in preventing the phone makers from allowing software to run that is not approved by the UK. A truly open software ecosystem would make this harder to enforce, but it wouldn't stop them from trying.
- zaphirplane 2y agoI don’t know if you are expressing a thoughtful commment or do not understand the issue Another iCloud provider will also need to comply with the UK stance. Can you clarify what you are going within that context