6 ms·
Why did the US let a child safety bill for social media die?
- giancarlostoro 2y agoBecause they care more about being contrarians than actually working together, and it shows. This isn't the only bill to have this issue, and it sure wont be the last. This can be true about either side btw.
- MetaWhirledPeas 2y ago(Quotes from an AI summary.) > Key provisions include requiring platforms to implement default safety settings for users under 17, provide parental oversight tools, and limit data collection and targeted ads for teens aged 14-15, who would also need parental consent to use platforms like TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, and X. We may have dodged a bullet here. The big platforms would have (mostly) no problem implementing compliance, but smaller sites? Forget it. This would therefore be one more step toward squeezing small sites offline. No. Not to mention there is no way to guarantee results from this. > provide parental oversight tools Good, but see my statement above. Implement this? Yes. MANDATE this? NO. > limit data collection and targeted ads for teens aged 14-15 Explain to me how you prove that someone is 14-15? This is a bunch of nonsense fluff and I'm glad it didn't pass.
- TimorousBestie 2y ago[dead]
- stonogo 2y agoYour AI hallucinated. It probably confused the KOSA in question (Kids Online Safety Act) with a local children's soccer league called "KOSA 14/15" (https://www.redrosearena.com/team/102420 https://www.redrosearena.com/team/102420). You're arguing against something nobody proposed.
- MetaWhirledPeas 2y agoThank you for the correction. That is both amusing and annoying.
- Spivak 2y agoHonestly, good riddance. We shouldn't revive it. It was a bill that granted overboard powers to governments who were and still are actively salivating over the idea of weaponizing it to suppress speech they don't like. There's no more, "oh it's fine they won't really use it for that" discussion to be had because the current administration is just saying it out loud and publicly now. Social media sites sympathetic to the administration have already implemented the bits the opposition was worried about. The bill would make it so you can't just go somewhere else.
- bee_rider 2y ago> It would have mandated that platforms like Instagram and TikTok address online dangers affecting children through design changes and allowing young users to opt out of algorithmic recommendations. > A central – and controversial – component of the bill was its “duty of care” clause, which declared that companies have “a duty to act in the best interests of minors using their platforms” and would be open to interpretation by regulators. […] > Sensitive but important topics such as gun violence and racial justice could be viewed as potentially harmful and subsequently be filtered out by the companies themselves. These censorship concerns were particularly pronounced for the LGBTQ+ community, which, opponents of Kosa said, could be disproportionately affected by conservative regulators, reducing access to vital resources. Sounds like it was an internet censorship bill. But lawmakers accidentally included some anti-algorithmic profiling stuff which would annoy their bosses, corporate lobbyists. I guess we’ll see a new version that only tramples the rights of normal people eventually.
- kindeyooweee 2y ago[dead]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y ago> allowing young users to opt out of algorithmic recommendations. How is giving users more choice "censorship"? More like encroaching on big tech profits by empowering users.
- nickthegreek 2y agoFirst you need to identify young users. Which means you need to identify all users.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoHow is identifying users censorship?
- nickthegreek 2y ago
- dragonwriter 2y agoKOSA was not a child safety bill, it was a political (and particularly LGBTQ) harassment and suppression bill lightly masquerading (lightly, because right-wing supporters could not stop gloating about ita utility for that purpose) as a child safety bill that too many on the Democratic side in the Senate willingly went along with because they lack the courage to argue against the thinnest layer of pretextual justification (which is a broader problem than just that bill.)
- jeremyjh 2y agoThis explains everything except why it didn’t pass the house. If what you said is true I would have expected it to be first bill Trump signed.
- nickthegreek 2y agoIt also stepped on BigTech with some language around algorithms. Which is actually why it failed.
- scarface_74 2y agoIt’s parent’s responsibility to look after their kids - not the government’s job. Every consumer computing platform has parental controls.
- lnsru 2y agoParents have no chances against multi billion corporations turning kids into zombies. I see hordes of these on the way to school in the morning and trying find way home afterwards.
- jeremyjh 2y agoYes and we should legalize lead paint again while we are at it. It’s a parents responsibility to prevent their child from eating paint chips everywhere they go.
- nh23423fefe 2y agoYou couldn't exhibit a better analogy, so you used this bad one instead.
- jeremyjh 2y agoAnd you couldn’t list one reason it’s bad, so you didn’t give any.
- JustExAWS 2y agoBecause there is no knob you can turn and get rid of lead paint. You can use parental controls and block kids access to sites and apps you find objectionable
- dragonwriter 2y ago> You can use parental controls and block kids access to sites and apps you find objectionable You can use parental controls and block kirds access to sites you found objectionable in the past, just as you can keep your kids out of buildings you jave previously inspected for lead paint. OTOH, I suspect people raising this objection (note that I am not, even if I think I have an understanding of how they might apply the analogy) would prefer to have some guarantee that people aren't doing the equivalent of repainting with lead paint after the parents have inspected, and would often even prefer not have to do the equivalent of inspecting every virtual building their children might enter for the digital equivalent of lead paint.
- crooked-v 2y agoThe opposition to the bill is simple: KOSA was written from the start as a broad-spectrum censorship bill obivously designed to (among other things) suppress LGBT existence with the excuse of "won't someone think of the children". For example, the censorship of any discussion of "illegal narcotics" - don't forget, all those state-licensed marijuana businesses out there are still illegal under federal law...
- duxup 2y agoI find most child safety legislation borderline hysterical. Fear of "algorithms" and such always turn into absurdist type laws. Long ago, my state we had a law (quickly suspended and later struck down) that made it a felony to sell a minor a "violet" video game. I don't think making some poor store clerk a felon is solving anything...
- potato3732842 2y ago>I don't think making some poor store clerk a felon is solving anything... It's solving the government's lack of power of arbitrary enforcement over a bunch of store owners.
- duxup 2y agoI will admit that the lowly store clerk deep state will need to be dealt with one day.
- rickandmortyy 2y agodamn why they hating on colors? is your state grove street gang affiliated? jesus says ballards deserve love too
- duxup 2y agoI’m so bad at spelling.
- Hizonner 2y agoBecause it was dumb?
- mrandish 2y agoI find that headline to be unintentionally hilarious because anyone paying attention to online child safety legislation already knows the vast majority of it is either terribly written and destined to trigger unintentional consequences or a naked power grab by law enforcement using 'child safety' as a pre-text to get more and/or easier access to user data.
- wakawaka28 2y agoI think the side effects are the intention. A significant part of our government wants to ignore the pesky 4th Amendment.
- dkuntz2 2y agomisleading headline, kosa had nothing to do about child safety and everything to do with government censorship, anybody framing it as "child safety" is a rube falling for the oldest conservative christian play in the book.
- btown 2y agoPeople are downvoting comments about the impact of this bill on LGBTQ+ people, but “protecting minor children from the transgender [sic] in this culture” was literally the stated motivation by the senator who co-introduced KOSA: https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-politics-and-policy/senator-appears-suggest-bipartisan-bill-will-censor-transgender-conten-rcna103479 https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-politics-and-policy/sena... If courts can look at the statements of bills' sponsors when interpreting laws, it's not unreasonable for us to do the same when thinking critically about a bill's likely implementation.
- wakawaka28 2y agoBecause it's a dystopian nightmare waiting to happen. The real question is, why the hell did it do so well in the Senate? Also, why is The Guardian apparently shilling for that and not mentioning privacy first and foremost? We know the UK has already passed something just as oppressive.