3 ms·
Urine and poop have been known as great fertilizers for longer than recorded history. However be careful about trying this for yourself. These are both toxic
by bluGill 2y ago
Urine and poop have been known as great fertilizers for longer than recorded history. However be careful about trying this for yourself. These are both toxic wastes and if not handled correctly can kill you. Urine isn't too bad in amounts you are likely to deal with in a garden. Poop provides are lot more benefit than Urine in the garden - but tiny amounts not handled correct can kill.
I do not know all the factors in play. If you are considering this instead of commercial fertilizer for your garden then you need to do real research (not youtube research - read real academic papers)
- Workaccount2 2y agoI'm curious how poop is so deadly.
- bluGill 2y agoBacteria, parasites and other nasty things live in it. I'm being vague because if you need a more detailed answer you really need to break open academic papers and spend years reading them, not try to figure things our from a discussion forum. (I only need the discussion forum version so I don't know more than the above)
- Spooky23 2y agoYou know how there’s periodically a recall of green onions or lettuce due to e.coli contamination? That is because farms in the desert irrigate the plants with water contaminated with cow or pig feces.
- canucker2016 2y ago[warning - skip reading this comment if you don't want to be reminded how raw produce may get to your tabletop] see https://www.sfgate.com/business/article/New-focus-on-field-sanitation-E-coli-2551035.php https://www.sfgate.com/business/article/New-focus-on-field-s... If there are humans picking the crops, and if their hygiene is lax, then there might be some contamination via a human vector.
- bluGill 2y ago"I know a guy" who went to tour a lettuce farm at harvest. He had to wear special booties, gloves, and a hair net. The farmers proudly showed how the lettuce was picked and immediately (no wash step!) wrapped in plastic so that no contamination could happen. Then he looked up and say birds flying overhead and as bird do pooping in mid flight. Wash your lettuce.
- em-bee 2y agoi don't think you can store lettuce after washing. it would get soggy. you can rinse it. like rain. but that's about it. so this is not surprising.
- _bigbear_ 2y agoHuman urine - yes good source of nitrates, although it will kill plants if undiluted (too much of a good thing...) . Human poop NO! it should NEVER be used as fertilizer. Typical human diet makes it pretty worthless as fertilizer, and pathogens make it a really dumb thing to do. Poop from grazing animals isn't the same stuff as human poop, which is where i think people get mixed up.
- wswope 2y agoThis is highly misinformed. There are strict processing requirements, but it is safe and legally permitted in many specific contexts. This page lists some of the processing techniques and statutory requirements: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composting_toilet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composting_toilet See also: Dillo dirt
- deepsquirrelnet 2y agoBat guano is a common fertilizer that should be used with caution. Remember covid? Bad stuff lurks in the feces of cave dwelling mammals… You hope it has been safely composted, but has it?