3 ms·
Ontario to Slap Export Tax on Electricity to U.S.
- BunsanSpace 2y agoGood. I hope provinces extend this to all critical exports, including potash, nickle, uranium and oil. The US deserves to suffer for this trade war. You guys elected this dictator from Temu, you should bleed as much as he's going to make Canada bleed.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 2y agoPotash, Uranium & Oil are from Saskatchewan & Alberta. Those provinces won't put on an export tax because that would be "unfair" to those two deeply conservative provinces. There are a lot of MAGA supporters in those two provinces.
- chollida1 2y agoTariffs are put on at the federal level, not the provincial level, but your misunderstanding is very common. The US themselves are tariffing potash at 25% from Canada coming into the US. In Canada > Section 91(2) of the Constitution Act, 1867 gives Parliament exclusive jurisdiction over “the regulation of trade and commerce.”
- bryanlarsen 2y agoThe province of Ontario is in the headline of this article.
- chollida1 2y agoAh, I see our disconnect. You are talking about export taxes and I am talking about the federal government.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoYou still might be right. Ontario might be able to adjust electricity export prices because it's a highly regulated provincially regulated market. Alberta might not be able to unilaterally add an "export tax" to oil the same way. OTOH, if Alberta asked for one, the federal government would comply.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoAnd that looks like it applies here as well. Today's announcement was a joint announcement between the provincial and federal government.
- wasabi991011 2y agoHowever Trudeau has repeatedly emphasized working closely with the Premiers to ensure that tariffs aren't discriminatory against some provinces and favouring others. It seems to imply that despite his legal power, the federal government would not impose those tariffs as it would come at the cost of Canadian unity.
- carbine 2y agoNot anymore. Conservatives in Western Canada are just as anti-Trump as Liberals now.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- fredophile 2y agoWhen the talk about tariffs started I wondered why no one was doing something like this. With exporting there's a risk that people will find ways around it but infrastructure for power, oil, gas, etc takes years to build so it's not like the US has a viable short term alternative for some of these.
- chollida1 2y agoThe problem with this is that its almost all blue states that are in the North East, so its Trump's "enemies" that will feel the bulk of this in the form of higher energy prices. Oddly its Mexican tariffs that will have a bigger deterrent to Trump as his base is the red southern region of the US that take more Mexican imports. Looks like inflation is back on the table for the US, and this time they've done it to themselves via higher prices from tariffs. One other thing to watch is that this is currently weakening the Canadian dollar and Mexican peso, which means the USD is getting stronger which is the opposite of what Trump wants ultimately. So far the markets in all countries just hate this news. China has taken the following actions as well this morning - China to Levy Tariffs on Some US Products Including Chicken - China to Impose up to 15% Tariff on Some US Goods - China to Levy Tariffs on Some US Products Including Soybean - China Adds 10 US Firms to Unreliable Entity List Smart as this targets the US farmers, so Trump is almost certainly going to do what he did last time and just print money and hand it out like candy to the US farmers. The worst case outcome and one that analysts at all major sell site institutions are now considering to be a possibility is worldwide stagflation. Normally the economy of one or two powerhouses is humming along while others are going through cyclical downturns which helps smooth things over. The United States seems very determined to crash the entire worlds economy at the same time, which will mean all major economies will be printing and spending cash all at the same time in an effort to prop up their economies. The US has just started their printing press, and Beijing has been doing so for a year to try and fix their already hurting economy. The world is in for a lot of pain in the next 2 years.
- graypegg 2y agoWhile this does affect home electricity prices, doesn't this also affect costs in manufacturing? If trump's administration wants to promote american industrial manufacturing, the rust belt would be the place to do it, and this only makes it harder than it currently is.
- tayo42 2y agoI think the power only targets New York, Michigan and Minnesota and upstate NY is all republican voters which borders Canada. Id think that's the area that actually effected? Blue/Red state is misleading, you need to look at smaller areas to see how people voted. Its urban vs rural for the most part.
- graypegg 2y agoHas Québec made any similar arrangements? HydroQuébec feeds into a lot of the New England region power grid as far as I know.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 1970-01-01 2y agoEVs in those states just became 25% more expensive to recharge. But that will be tomorrow's story.
- jeffbee 2y agoUsually retail prices are regulated so it will be the utilities eating the difference, won't it?
- 1970-01-01 2y agoYes, but that buffer cannot and will not last.
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoNew England has been trying to build an 1.2MW ~150mi interconnect from Canada through Maine down to Massachusetts for many years now, and was hoping to wrap the project up this year. https://www.bangordailynews.com/2025/01/03/business/business-energy/central-maine-power-corridor-construction-completion-plan-2025/ https://www.bangordailynews.com/2025/01/03/business/business... Its been very controversial, especially because most of the land gows through Maine, cutting a line across it. Without doing much to improve Maine's grid. Mainer's passed a ballot initiative to halt the project, but courts ruled that Mainer's didn't have any right to halt the project. So, the Central Maine Power (the power company) Corridor - officially called the New England Clean Energy Connect (NECEC) - was back on. With various rounds of tax increases for various states & federal grants. Total cost has gone from $1B to over $1.5b. Conceptually seems like a good idea! It's so unfortunate that it's such a visible cut through & across the land. And now, with this madness, who knows what the future holds.
- jeffbee 2y agoDid you mean GW?
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoI did! Thank you! I translated 1200 MW in my head to 1.2 GW but forgot to M->G by the time it came to post. 1.2MW is ~1600 HP, or two modern EV's at peak power. Let's hope that's not what all the fuss is for! :)