5 ms·
> We don't understand human cognition despite literally thousands of years of thought and study, but some nerds with a thousand GPUs are going to make a machine
by ben_w 2y ago
> We don't understand human cognition despite literally thousands of years of thought and study, but some nerds with a thousand GPUs are going to make a machine think? Ridiculous.
DNA doesn't understand intelligence.
"The question of whether a computer can think is no more interesting than the question of whether a submarine can swim." - Edsger Dijkstra.
And what we have now, with LLMs, met the standard I had for AGI just five years ago.
Only thing that changed for me since then is noticing that not only does everyone have a different definition of what AGI even is, also none of the three initials are even boolean-valued: "how intelligent" can be a number, or even a vector that varies by domain as linguistic intelligence doesn't have to match spatial intelligence; "how general" could be what percentage of human cognitive tasks the AI can do; "how artificial" is answered entirely differently by those who care differently about learning from first principles vs. programmed algorithms vs. learning from reading the internet.
> People were misled by graphs that they were told pointed to a singularity right around the corner, despite obvious errors in the extant systems.
Tautology.
If there weren't obvious errors in the extant systems… there wouldn't be anything left to do.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoAgreed. Dogs & 4 year olds & LLM's all have general intelligence. Defining "AGI" to mean "superhuman intelligence" seems ridiculous to me. The Turing test was the standard benchmark for so long, but now that an LLM can pass the Turing test we've moved the goal posts.
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoThe Turing test was never a standard benchmark. It was common in pop science coverage, but no AI researcher (including Turing himself!) ever proposed it as a useful test of intelligence. It was an illustration by Turing that we can meaningfully talk about a machine thinking in the first place. We've known for over half a century since ELIZA that the ability to carry on a plausible natural language conversation is much more narrow than it intuitively seems.
- tripletao 2y ago> now that an LLM can pass the Turing test What study are you referring to here? The ones I've seen don't particularly resemble anything Turing described. The preprint from UCSD got heavy coverage in the popular press but its headline claim is an elementary statistical mistake, modifying the test so it's no longer a binary comparison but still treating 50% as a meaningful pass threshold. It hasn't yet passed peer review nine months later, and I'm cautiously optimistic that it never will. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40386571 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40386571
- singularity2001 2y agoI agree in my view the modern language models already processes general intelligence: they are better at some tasks and worse than others compared to human, but in principle they can tackle any problem (if given agency like tool access) this is probably a religious question so people will not be convinced of intelligent machines even if they have an EQ and IQ of 200 because they don't work the same way human cells do I suppose.