5 ms·
Yes, the US gets to try to force a Ukrainian surrender, we're all complaining that's a grossly immoral use of power. I don't think the Ukrainians are going to g
by pjc50 2y ago
Yes, the US gets to try to force a Ukrainian surrender, we're all complaining that's a grossly immoral use of power. I don't think the Ukrainians are going to go along with it yet.
- remarkEon 2y agoThe Ukrainian terms are "all of the land back plus Crimea". Do you understand that this does not happen without the following: massive American mobilization, 2/75 or the whole of the Ranger Battalions jumping, all US Armor units deploying to Eastern Europe, all of 4th, 5th, 6th, and honestly 7th fleet re-deploying to the Med for support operations. A massive amount of U.S. casualties. Is this doable? No doubt. I am out of the Army, but a lot of my boys are still in, and they would love to do a peer fight instead of whatever it was we did in Afghanistan. But I will be the adult here and point out that this is stupid.
- timcobb 2y agoThis isn’t true.
- ArnoVW 2y agoI know that it feels like the military situation is like that. In reality Russia is much weaker than people think. Three years of war will do that to a country. All that is needed is sanctions and enough resources for Ukraine to defend itself. And the military intelligence as a force multiplier. Thats exactly what we have been providing. And it was working. Russian inflation is a 20%+. They are running out of soviet era equipment. They are running out of easily conscriptable men. All of this is documented using open sources. All that was needed was time. Time for Russia to implode. But democracy is a fickle thing, and Putin was counting on this. America will have to live with this period of infamy for a long time. And the world will suffer the consequences.
- dataflow 2y ago> All that is needed is sanctions and enough resources for Ukraine to defend itself. Whatever makes you think Russia won't drop a nuke? Edit: Since people seem confused - I mean on Ukraine. Not on the US.
- efnx 2y agoOn Ukraine? Or the US? Either way - I’m pretty sure they want Ukraine and then there’s mutually assured destruction.
- Daviey 2y agoBecause China won't let them.
- gambiting 2y agoBecause they don't want to start a nuclear war. It's really as straightforward as that. If we assume they are willing to go for a nuclear exchange then it's a different kind of conversation, but no military expert considers this a likely scenario. But even Russians indicate that their mid range ballistic missiles don't need nuclear wareheads to cause untold destruction - it was Putin who said that even without nukes their new missiles can level a city. He seems pretty confident in that, despite western intelligence indicating that the missiles are most likely a bluff as they are barely operational.
- dataflow 2y ago> Because they don't want to start a nuclear war. How would dropping a nuke on Ukraine start a nuclear war? Nobody is going to drop a nuke back on them.
- gambiting 2y ago"Nobody is going to drop a nuke back on them." That's not what military experts are saying. If the nuclear fallout reached NATO countries NATO policy would require a "proportional" response, which again, military experts suggest would be a small scale nuclear strike on a Russian facility of proportional impact. The big question then is what would happen next - either both sides cool down and see where this is going, or Russia starts attacking targets within NATO at which point we're at full WW3 level. The "nobody is going to drop a nuke back" is either extremely optimistic or extremely naive.
- remarkEon 2y agoSince the war began I've been hearing both that Russia is weak and about to collapse, and also that if the United States doesn't directly intervene the Russians will drive tanks into Berlin by Christmas. If they are as weak as you say they are, and I'm inclined to agree, then Europe can handle this, yes?
- ArnoVW 2y agoI never said they were pushovers. Just that they were weaker than people thought. It is clear that Europe would have more difficulty going it alone, since it does not dispose of the intelligence assets that the US has. Spy satellites, SIGINT planes, logistics, etc. Having to go it alone would clearly also impact the morale and thus the political will. But if Putin would decide to invade for example Poland, there is no doubt how he would fare. But from an industrial and economics point of view there is no comparing. Contrary to what mr Trump has been saying, Europe has paid for more than half of the expenses so far. The overall defense budget of Europe was 217B$ in 2019 and has been steadily increasing to 258B$ in 2021 [1]. For 2024 it is at 326B$ [2] Compare that with Russia that had a 184B$ budget this year [3]. And that is whilst being on a war footing. Also. Let's not forget that the US, together with the EU (and Russia) offered security guarantees to Ukraine, in return for them giving their nukes to Russia (since that was making everyone anxious). Our support for them is not some sort of "gift" out of the goodness of our hearts. It is a solemn promise that we made, in return for our peace of mind. Surely the US is not the sort of country that does not honor it's commitments, but backs down when the going gets tough? [1] : https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/EUU/european-union/military-spending-defense-budget https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/EUU/eur... [2] : https://eda.europa.eu/news-and-events/news/2024/12/04/eu-defence-spending-hits-new-records-in-2023-2024 https://eda.europa.eu/news-and-events/news/2024/12/04/eu-def... [3] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_with_highest_military_expenditures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_with_highest...
- remarkEon 2y agoYou mean a memo, with no enforcement mechanism and no treaty stipulations. There were no guarantees involved. Everyone understood this at the time but for whatever reason that particular piece of paper comes up time and again and it gets equated with actual binding treaties. It was not. I understand what you’re saying but appeals about “solemn promise[s]” comes across as emotional blackmail and, for Americans at least, doesn’t have the same rhetorical weight anymore.
- ponkipo 2y agoMan this "Russia is running out of XXX" tale is becoming quite old and not being taken seriously nowadays - year by year goes with the same narrative and it's only getting objectively worse for Ukraine...
- Juliate 2y agoYou did not take note that the Russian military is collapsing: they need north corean soldiers to come to keep up. They need Iranian drones to keep up. Russia has NO defensive capacity left on either other borders, neither internally. Putin, as well as Trump play it like they have a strong hand because they know they don’t really have it and they are scared others would notice it.
- ponkipo 2y agoWhy you need to imagine things? deepstate map shows really well which army is "collapsing" now
- yason 2y agoWhat Ukraine needs and wants is a mechanism of a security guarantee that actually works (whether it's foreign troops stabilizing the eastern areas forever or get back enough nukes to keep Russia away). This is a life-or-death question to Ukraine because without plausible and enforceable security there will not be a Ukraine. Ukraine can certainly give up their now rump states of Donetsk/Lugansk plus Crimea if they were getting something like that in exchange. But until there is even a remote possibility for such security all they have is their terms of getting all their land back. If Ukraine now agreed to "peace" where they give up the land to stop the war then they would have to deal even further in order to gain enough security to prevent the next war from ever happening.
- remarkEon 2y ago>This is a life-or-death question to Ukraine Then why has Ukraine not lowered the conscription age?
- ben_w 2y agoNot enough guns etc. to make use of all the people.
- remarkEon 2y agoSo they decided to give the guns they do have to the 45 year olds?
- ben_w 2y ago1. Conscription starts at 25, not 45. (Even 25 is a lowering, it used to be 27). 2. So what? 30-45 is where their population peaks; massive dip right in the 18-30 range: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Ukraine#/media/File:Ukraine2024.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Ukraine#/media...
- remarkEon 2y ago
- 4ndrewl 2y agoOr Putin could just withdraw his (and the North Korean) troops? He's so trustworthy peacekeepers won't be needed, right?
- DoctorOetker 2y agowe all remember how trustworthy his words were right before the full scale invasion: UK intelligence services warned in public about Russian tanks, supplies etc amassing near the Ukrainian border, warning about what looks like preparations for invasion. What did the Russians claim? "Nyet invasion, just some push-ups next to border!"
- Chance-Device 2y agoAnd what about the longer term? No one wants to commit to this fight, how much worse is it next time? What lesson does Putin learn when he can take Ukraine? Because even if he only takes part of it on paper, he’ll end up with the whole lot. That’s what the mineral “deal” with the US really is - it’s a bribe: “when we’re in control, you’ll still get the minerals”. How stable will the world be when Russia wins, Putin is able to rebuild, and then they want somewhere else? You tell me, which fight is more winnable? This one or the next one?
- andrepd 2y agoYou're completely overstating this. So far in 3 years of war the US has, for something like <10% of their military budget, destroyed a huge chunk of Russian military capabilities, without having to set a single US boot on the ground or losing a single US citizen. On purely selfish terms, that's an undeniably great investment. But it's not only that. The US has an immense amount of soft power that it squanders if it completely mistreats, and even blackmails, its own allies — which it is doing right now — to appease hostile powers like Russia. So with that being said: It's ridiculous to jump to "we're gonna have to deploy x y and z batallions" when the US administration is not even doing the BARE MINIMUM, many tiers below that: they are publicly praising Putin and berating Zelensky. So it's pointless to talk as if this was about direct military intervention when in fact even soft diplomacy is going to the way of appeasement.
- remarkEon 2y agoPart of the issue with tech people discussing this is that they assume there is a tech solution to "human meat sacks are needed in order to control a geography". There isn't, at least not yet or anytime soon.
- DeathArrow 2y ago>massive American mobilization, 2/75 or the whole of the Ranger Battalions jumping, all US Armor units deploying to Eastern Europe, all of 4th, 5th, 6th, and honestly 7th fleet re-deploying to the Med for support operations. A massive amount of U.S. casualties. Then China will step in and WW3 will begin.
- remarkEon 2y agoGlad we’re all on the same page, then.
- corimaith 2y agoI don't agree how you would need so many forces or have many casualties given Russia is struggling right now even with Ukranians. A no fly-zone alone would greatly diminish Russian capabilites, of which the West could easily do given the dire state of the Russian Air Force and their AAD. After that it's just a point it's a just mopping up any artillery duels and then letting the Ukranians advance in.
- mytailorisrich 2y agoIt is not immoral, it is amoral. There is no moral in geopolitics and international relations. The US are not doing anything new. It's just that Trump's style is very "in your face" and that the public have been fed so much BS about "good", "moral", "democracy", etc in international relations that they actually believe it.
- psychoslave 2y agoI don't buy the fully amorale narrative ever. It's just as irrelevant as saying that state of individual cells is something you should ignore when establishing diagnostics of a herd. There's a difference between low pondering and null influence within equations. And if the complexity of the phenomenon exceeds what we can forecast relevantly with equations, then pretending that we know which factor will have significant role all along the development of the situation and which are meaningless is not acting with much sagacity.
- mytailorisrich 2y agoIt's not a narrative. It's really a statement of fact and very relevant. That's how it works: countries act to further their interests whatever the "moral" might be. The US, like other countries, have sacrificed tens of thousands of people or more, even entire countries, in pursuit of interests amd broader objectives, for instance. What is irrelevant is indeed moral.