10 ms·
"Do you not like money?"
- dcminter 2y agoTo be facile, this post ignores the existence of numismatists!
- xxs 2y agoIn that case it'd be 'coin', though
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- blueflow 2y agoAnyone remembers the faceless from "spirited away"? Its a daemon that lures people with an offer of gold, and when they get closer to take some, they get eaten. The protagonist breaks that daemon by refusing the offer with "I don't need it".
- snapcaster 2y agoSimilar to hellraiser if you pick lament
- sillywabbit 2y agoThe daemon wasn't truly evil. Being in the bath house that the witch was running to extract money from the spirits is what brought out that side. The aunt from Grave of the Fireflies who convinces the kid to sell his parents' stuff for food money and then complains he did nothing to deserve the food she made was a piece of work though.
- Timon3 2y agoThanks for bringing this point up. When I watched the movie as a child I didn't understand the nuance behind No-Face, but this video was a very enjoyable dive into the character & background: https://youtu.be/EavUeCBDTPo https://youtu.be/EavUeCBDTPo
- hiatus 2y agoWhen my brother was getting married, the priest looked over the audience and singled me out, asking, "Do you love your watch?" I said no—it's a good watch but I don't _love_ it. He moved on to ask others about some objects in their possession and asked if they loved them. Each answered yes. He told the group that love should be reserved for people and living things, and that we do love a disservice when we profess our love for inanimate things.
- luqtas 2y agointeresting that we have Christians coming to America to rape and slave people and bring gold to fancy churches in Europe... Vatican is a also a quite fancy and rich place in 2025 what if you love your pro-social company or your gadget that allows you to do a more effective activism that helps people? what if loving your gadget makes you not treat them as an ephemeral thing, thus making you stay with them longer and contributing to the enviroment with less e-waste?
- snapcaster 2y agoI don't mean to single your comment out, but i feel like this is a line of argument i see frequently that I don't think has merit. Like, sure "love your pro-social company or your gadget that allows you to do a more effective activism that helps people" is maybe theoretically possible but come on. in 99.99999999% of cases people loving a company or a gadget is bad and it's not particularly nuanced or complicated. Why must people (or just engineers?) fixate on some weird imaginary possibility edge case instead of just accepting the statement as "true". Is it pedantry, cope or something else i'm missing?
- dartos 2y agoI think the root issue is that the word “love” in English has far too many meanings. When you “love” a company, it’s not the same as “loving” your wife. And “loving” your wife is different, still, than “loving” your brother or best friend.
- 2y ago
- yakcyll 2y agoI have a feeling we, collectively, glance over the question, and over the author's stance on the subject, and almost dismissively say 'yeah, sure', without the amount of thought that they deserve.
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoWell, I like it just fine, but I like life on my own terms even better.
- kasey_junk 2y agoMoney is a fascinating technology. To me, the most fascinating. And like any technology it’s not evil, it’s just a tool that can be used for things, good or evil. The problem is this modern (very American) idea that having money in someway is a sign of human value. But saying money is evil is as problematic as saying having money is good. It makes it hard to use the technology to solve hard problems, that it’s good at solving, when the technology itself is attributed with those moral judgements.
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoThis is a good take. Moral judgments on technology tend to lead to inability to use it properly for maximum benefit of society (see: vaccines, guns)
- mrbluecoat 2y agoEvery time I have to research and purchase a new U.S. health insurance plan, I'm reminded there's a spectrum with private equity on one end and me on the other. I'll sacrifice a life of luxury if it means I don't have to bow to the golden calf.
- glitchc 2y agoYou could always move to Canada or Finland, but I bet you won't.
- mrbluecoat 2y agoToo cold ;)
- protonbob 2y agoCanada and Finland don't just let people move there. They have immigration laws like everyone else.
- rbanffy 2y agoYou need to find a job there first. Canada has a points system - my wife an I were going to Canada, she for a doctorate, I as the significant other working remotely for Canonical. The only reason we didn't went there was a nice job offer from Ireland. Also less freezing than Toronto.
- gigantaure 2y agoa long while ago i was considering a centrally monitored physical security system for my home. that was long before you could easily host your own security cameras with convenient mobile alerts. The salesman comes to my home. wife and kids are around. He sits at my dinner table and begins with asking me "is your family important to you?" to which i replied "please leave now". needless to say i didn't buy anything from him. I have no time with shady sales tactics and manipulation. i can totally relate to this article.
- photonthug 2y agoThis is so completely reasonable, and yet so unexpected that the "please leave now" actually reads like a joke punchline. In the last few years ads have become remarkably dystopian and unapologetic about it.. I mean it was always "No one will love you if you don't buy our thing!" but they didn't quite come out and say it before. The "less likes, more love" campaign comes to mind as ironically appropriate. I'm not in a position where I deal with actual human salespeople that often, but we're all products of the culture we're embedded in. So I assume that's gotten more masks-off crazy and feral too.. just very openly trying to find your anxieties and squeeze.
- rbanffy 2y ago> I have no time with shady sales tactics and manipulation. i can totally relate to this article. Sometimes I recommend people to go to high pressure sales meetings, such as the ones where they try to sell time-shares (is that still a thing?). They'll pick you up at the hotel on a limo, and offer you free tickets to some shows if you go. It is insanely annoying, but it's a great exercise on your ability to say no under psychological pressure. They will try to attack you at your most core values and the moment you realize it is an attempt to manipulate you, you develop some immunity to it - the said ability to say "leave now". On the time-share, the poor third (!) salesperson who tried to convince me surrendered to the math - US$100K for a week, for a ~300K apartment was about US$ 5 million, which was the going price for apartments in the very fancy building next to it. At that point they relented, gave us the tickets (they were sold out at the venue) and drove us back to our hotel.
- 2y ago
- BabylonSysErr 2y agoI have a strong antipathy for money. So far this has worked in keeping it mostly far away from me.
- Mali- 2y agoI imagine a peasant of old moving from bartering to coins would 'like' money - would that be allowed by this author or be too gauche?
- snapcaster 2y agoNot super related to your comment but that's not how it happened. This idea of barter -> coin money as natural progression is a fairy tale economists tell people but doesn't really have any bearing on real historical events
- bluGill 2y agoBarter is so bad for complex transactions that it couldn't go that way. Every transaction that needs to based on more than trust that you will get your gift back later needs some universal coinage. A trader can only take grain in your village, then in the city only pay in grain, but anything more complex needs money.
- snapcaster 2y agoYes this is what economists say, the truth of development is a lot more complicated. Suffice to say you're massively underestimating how complex debt/non-coinage based economies can be
- bglusman 2y agoThis is actually apocryphal, I think from Adam Smith & before him Aristotle, pull quote from 1985 anthropology professor “No example of a barter economy, pure and simple, has ever been described, let alone the emergence from it of money" https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/02/barter-society-myth/471051/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/02/barter-...
- magicstefanos 2y agoYeah sounds like bartering exists only in the world of thought experiments. Gift economies were the norm
- JohnFen 2y agoThe author expresses my attitude toward money almost perfectly. I'll even go a step further: I hate money. It's a thing I have to deal with, but I hate every bit of it. I hate that I'm forced to devote so much of my life and mind to it. I hate that it rules every aspect of my life. I hate that its used as a weapon by those who want to subjugate me or harm me (for more money, even). I hate that it tends to ruin everything. It's a huge downer all around and reduces my ability to enjoy life. But, such is life. I'm forced to deal with it, so I do. But I yearn for a better way.
- azemetre 2y agoSuch is not life friend. Society is whatever we want to be. The rules are made up and we, the people, can decide what society should value. It doesn't have to be this way, it can change. Maybe not in our lifetimes but we plant the seeds so future generations can live better lives.
- JohnFen 2y agoBig picture, you're absolutely right and I do what I can to plant those seeds. However, while that could help future generations and so is worth doing, it doesn't actually help me in the here and now. There's nothing I can do that will positively change things on this count within my lifetime.
- netrap 2y agoPerhaps there is just something small you can do that is passed down or acknowledged by others who will pass it on. A behavior, an action, or some other change.
- tim333 2y agoThere is probably a big change coming with AI. At the moment we need to pay people to work so stuff gets done but if AI can do it instead that goes away.
- 2y ago
- weatherlite 2y ago"The love of money as a possession – as distinguished from the love of money as a means to the enjoyments and realities of life – will be recognised for what it is, a somewhat disgusting morbidity, one of those semi-criminal, semi-pathological propensities which one hands over with a shudder to the specialists in mental disease. All kinds of social customs and economic practices, affecting the distribution of wealth and of economic rewards and penalties, which we now maintain at all costs, however distasteful and unjust they may be in themselves, because they are tremendously useful in promoting the accumulation of capital, we shall then be free, at last, to discard." John Maynard Keynes 1930 Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren
- stego-tech 2y agoCan totally relate to this article. I don’t like or love money. Or capital. Or wealth. I enjoy the things money can acquire, sure. I enjoy my photography hobby, which isn’t cheap by any stretch. I enjoy my home theater, with games on a big OLED screen and my surround sound speakers filling my ears with crisp, clear audio. I enjoy building a gaming PC ($$$), I enjoy taking trips ($$$$), I enjoy eating out with friends ($$). But money? No, I do not like it. In fact, I dislike it because it, as a concept, is so easily exploited. I understand that it’s the best system we have to store the value of labor within, but I’m also smart enough to realize that isn’t how it’s presently used. Those with the most money have not saved the most time, or created the most output, or labored harder and longer than those with less, and that irritates me. I am forced to engage in a society where money’s definition as a value of labor is highly duplicitous at best, and it’s nauseating. And thus I circle back to the root question again: Do I like money? No. I do not. I tolerate money. I have a finite tolerance for money, where should I have any surplus amount above that threshold I would donate it to others, for my life - and the lives of my dozen or so family and friends - would be stable, in equilibrium with society and the environment until our inevitable deaths. But no, I do not like money. I do not like having to spend time managing gambling - sorry, investment accounts - to ensure I can maybe retire or buy a home. I do not like having to learn rulesets to different games - sorry, payment cards - to ensure I’m not squandering my finite resources on fees or penalties. I do not like having to juggle multiple accounts across multiple institutions with different governance structures, rules, taxes, fees, and schedules. I do not like any of this because I know their core function is to more easily funnel my finite money to those with infinite sums. But I tolerate money, because there is no alternative.
- card_zero 2y agoI'm fond of wealth, but that's different.
- stego-tech 2y agoDo you like wealth, or the security and stability that wealth brings? Because I love the latter, but dislike the former. I hate seeing large numbers sitting in an account doing nothing but growing larger, and telling myself this is the “smart” thing to do to create security for myself and my loved ones. I should be able to acquire and maintain the latter without sitting on a growing pile of tickets masquerading as “wealth”.
- 1970-01-01 2y agoYou do like money. Try not having any. https://upgrader.gapminder.org/q/32/ https://upgrader.gapminder.org/q/32/
- KPGv2 2y agoThis is like saying "You love mosquitoes. Try not having any." Not having any would be catastrophic to humanity because whole ecosystems would collapse and we'd have mass starvation. But it doesn't change the fact that mosquitoes are personally, deeply offensive to my day-to-day experience living in a place where they exist. (That being said, I have a lot of money and love it. But I'd give a ton of it away if it meant there were whole classes of problems I never had to think about again, like paying for my children's university, or making sure I can afford health care. I'd certainly give that amount away if it meant nobody needed to.)
- 1970-01-01 2y agoThe analogy doesn't make sense. You can't get food, shelter, medicine, transportation, education or anything with a mosquito.
- Izkata 2y agoMosquitoes are near the bottom of the food chain, eaten by a bunch of other animals. There would be some amount of risk to our food supply if all mosquitos just vanished one day.
- claykkari 2y ago> Money is selfish. I used to believe so too but after reading this I'm no longer so sure: https://meltingasphalt.com/wealth-the-toxic-byproduct/ https://meltingasphalt.com/wealth-the-toxic-byproduct/
- philipov 2y agoEven if someone does like money, the line of argument Ruben examines is trying to convince you that the ONLY thing you should like is money. One can 'like' money, and still recognize that other things are more important than money. I like cake, but I don't want limitless cake to the exclusion of every other concern. . You know who else liked money? King Midas.
- rausr 2y agoMoney is more often than not an impediment to doing or achieving things (especially these days when the ultra rich are trying to hoover it all up themselves to enable power). Imagine if money did not exist, and things were decided on actual merit? "Poor" people with good ideas might - dare I say it - do things that improved the world for everyone! ;) There'd be many ways of achieving this, so I'll not bait people with C or S words.
- nathan_compton 2y agoMoney is an good thing but leaves much to be desired. If we consider money's primary beneficial quality to be that it enables commerce and commerce rewards people who provide value then it is great. Money is pro-social, from this point of view. The big problem is that money provides little recourse for the rest of us in the case that a person provides a lot of value, accumulates a lot of money, and then turns around and acts like a jerk. Having money allows one to destroy value indiscriminately, to a large degree. I can't think of a better system, really, however, besides a robust system allowing democratic regulation of commerce.
- theiebrjfb 2y agoTry to ask "should we give 50 trillion USD to fight global warming?" Then most people LOVE money!
- throw0101d 2y agoThere was a good book I read (by either Cullen Roche or Morgan Housel) that observed the collecting money is not the important part, but rather using money is. Money is the ticket to the performance/show, and you generally don't get excited by the fact you have the ticket, but by the opportunity to go to the event.
- bluGill 2y agoI get peace of mind by having enough money to live the rest of my life.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- egypturnash 2y agoLately I've been thinking about how one of the main things that keeps a particular kind of money valuable is that it's what the landlord requires you to pay your rent in; the dollar has dropped almost to 1/10 of what it was worth when I was born in the seventies, and a much larger percentage of the supply of dollars is in the hands of rich idiots whose only goal in life seems to be to get even more despite the fact that they and their great-great-great-grandchildren will never need to work a single day in their life, with no regard for how much misery they cause as a side effect (and they cause a whole lot of that). And then I go to the local farmer's market and while now pretty much everyone takes cards via an app on their phone that tithes a few percent of every transaction to a credit card company, ultimately making one of those rich idiots wealthier, there was a period where the best way to pay besides cash was to visit a little tent that would take a credit card transaction and give you a handful of wooden coins with various denominations screen-printed upon them; shoppers can't cash them out but vendors can; if you pay with food stamps then you get extra tokens in different colors that can only be used for certain classes of items; it's very pleasing to reach into my pocket and pull out a couple $5 tokens to pay for something, and get a few $1 tokens back, no fussing with the infinitestimal value of pennies, rounding everything off to $1 is really just fine even though I'm kinda broke. And I keep on thinking about just... taking a bunch of those tokens, and seeing who around town I can persuade to accept these instead of US$. But the thing is that US$ is also valuable for exchanges outside of my community, if I go to a coffee shop they're not going to be able to use these to pay the Brazillian farmers who grow those beans, I'm not going to want to accept payment for a private art commission in farmer's market tokens. And I know that if people start solving this problem with exchange policies for farmer's market tokens, then there will be problems with counterfeiting, and eventually the government will want to step in and enforce its monopoly on being the one who controls the medium of exchange. And then I look at the amount of grinding poverty around me, and the immense inefficiencies of the attempts to fix that (sure, let's get all these homeless people out of downtown before the Superbowl and stick them in a warehouse that's rented out from a private owner for more money than it'd cost to pay all these folks's rent for a couple years) and I wonder if the whole idea of capitalism is just completely fucked from the bottom up. So no. I don't really like money either.
- card_zero 2y ago
- wrs 2y agoMoney isn’t “necessary” or even “real” in a physical sense. Absolutely everything that happened today (*) could have happened exactly the same way if money didn’t exist. The only thing money does is affect what people decide to do. It’s the distributed control plane for society. And as yet, nobody has invented a better control plane that scales. (*) Ignoring things that happened with money directly, of course, like the financial “industry”.
- bluGill 2y agoMost things could not happen without money. I have no use for the million dollar gadget I make. After 5-10 years on my job I would earn just one - but I need to eat every day not wait until I have earned one machine which then I have to find the person who needs it and trade for whatever they make with it (which they would have to give me all at once even though the gadget should work for years), and then trade those things around until finally I find someone who can give me some food... Money is a necessary tool to make modern life possible. Other ways of life are possible, but not my current one.
- rbanffy 2y ago> but I need to eat every day not wait until What if you just went to the grocery store and got what you need, without paying money in return? What if everybody continued doing what they do, except that no payment took place? People would deliver groceries from the farm to the market, would write software for ensuring the right deliveries get where they are needed, and so on. Bank clerks would probably not have much to do, but, if they wanted, they could still go to the bank and play cards with their colleagues. Wouldn't that be a better world? > Money is a necessary tool to make modern life possible. It's so because we seem to have, as a society, it is.
- bluGill 2y ago> Wouldn't that be a better world? Only if your world is small enough that you can trust nobody is cheating. If everybody is doing their share to ensure there is always food in the store it works great. If only a few people are cheating it still works well enough. (I'm going to include the disabled in the cheating category for this discussion, because this is complex enough without trying to fit everything into the mold). As your world gets larger eventually more and more people start to realize that they can get by without working until there is no food in the store for anyone. Note that getting food includes not just the easy stuff, but the gross stuff. If you can trust the store has what you need, you need some way to incentivize someone to get rid of the trash anyway. Money provides a good abstraction for some jobs being worth more - nearly anyone can haul trash to the dump, but because of the "gross factor" it pays more than other jobs that nearly anyone can do. Very few people can pass medical or engineering school - it is known as a hard study for good reason, so we incentivize people to go that route with more pay, if you can get everything you need, does your society have the right incentives to ensure it gets better? History is full of societies that work similar to what you say. They all have their own ways of dealing with the above problems. One thing they all have in common is most people only contact a limited number of people and so they can crack down on cheaters because they learn who they are and so reputation matters. (the few travelers paid for their food via stories or barter, and often were looked down on anyway. Or often travelers were military and just took by force) Again, money makes modern society possible and everyone who proposes otherwise normally just handwaves away real problems with their proposal. A few are willing to accept that downside, but when I look at those downsides I conclude I'm not and I think most will agree once they understand them.
- clcaev 2y agoMoney is control. Without cash reserves, you have less opportunity to control your work and personal/family risk. However, capital need not be binary: exclusively personal or otherwise. Sometimes capital can be community based: allocated via cooperative governance or democratic means via municipality.
- cynicalpeace 2y agoMoney is really an IOU from society to you. Money did not originate as a mediator in a barter system, but rather as a unit of account to keep track of who owes whom, at least that's the predominant theory amongst monetary theorists nowadays. [1] If I take you out for a beer, "This one's on me", but there's an implication that you "owe me one", and you buy me a beer next time. Do this amongst many people and many scenarios, and eventually you need to keep track of who owes whom by tallying it on some bone or giving a shiny rock in return to a neighbor that gave you some eggs. And/or, a king raises an army, invades your village and orders you to pay tax by sending your grain to the temple. The king needs this surplus because maybe the Euphrates won't flood as much this year, and he will lose power if his soldiers and priests starve. So, you bring your grain to the temple, the priest tallies your contribution on a clay tablet, and gives you receipts. Soldiers later stop by your house and you give them some receipts to prove you paid your debt. At least this one conception of how things went. Looking at money as an IOU really causes you to look at it differently. The amount of money you have is really a measure of how much trust and value you have put into your society. If I repair someone's roof for $1,000, I spend hours of my day doing it, and I'll never get that time back. I get money, which I trust will let me buy food tomorrow. It's a measure of the debt society owes to me for the value I have provided. Hopefully society doesn't deem that measure worthless by then. Interestingly, this is basically why the dollar is the world's reserve currency. People trust it a lot. It's also one theory as to what led to the deindustrialization of the USA. When the dollar became the gold standard in 1971, everyone wanted dollars, and so we exported our dollars, which we can just print, and imported cheap manufactured goods. Who benefits? The people that make dollars, Washington and Wall St. Who loses? People who manufactured goods in the USA. This shrunk our manufacturing base and caused the enormous wealth inequality in America today. Anyways, if money really is a measure of how much trust and value I've put into a society, then it's interesting why we pursue it so much, beyond the fact that (usually) it gets us food and shelter. Perhaps it's just because a side effect of having put in so much trust and value into a society is that society will give you status symbols in return, so you can attract a mate. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_money#Prehistory:_predecessors_of_money_and_its_emergence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_money#Prehistory:_p...
- card_zero 2y ago
- A7C3D5 2y agoDuring HS/college I resolved to pursue a career doing something at least somewhat interesting / somewhat practical / potentially fulfilling on some imagined philosophical level without regard to maximizing earning potential. I was so wrong lol; find philosophical satisfaction when you don't have to work on anything you don't want to do. Seems really obvious now haha... ah well.
- r00fus 2y agoBible would totally support not liking money: "the love of money is the root of all evil". Money is a tool, it's not something that's natural to "love".
- yadaeno 2y agoAgreed. If you take it to the extreme, money is a tool that reduces your life-energy to a numerical value which is anti-human.