6 ms·
> my understanding was that this was disproven To the extent anything in this discussion can be absolute, it's the wrongness of your statement. Nothing about s
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> my understanding was that this was disproven
To the extent anything in this discussion can be absolute, it's the wrongness of your statement. Nothing about singularities has been empirically proven (or disproven).
- oneshtein 2y agoWe can empirically prove that gravitation cancels out in the gravitational center of an object, if we will dig into Moon.
- mr_mitm 2y agoWhat does this have to do with singularities? No one expects any kind of singularity anywhere around or in the moon.
- oneshtein 2y agoSingularity is not possible at 0G, isn't?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Singularity is not possible at 0G, isn't? One divided by zero is a singularity. Singularity, mathematically speaking, means your math breaks. Calculus gets around this problem with limits. But there is absolutely nothing about physics that prohibits singularities, even gravitational singularities, in a zero G space because by definition a gravitational singularity per se has an undefined G.
- oneshtein 2y agoSingularity means that at least some barions will be at the same place in the same time, which against nature of fermions. Moreover, it hard to imagine that Higgs bosons will act at same place and time with same effectiveness. So, I cannot believe in a singularity unless it will be physically demonstrated.
- mr_mitm 2y agoSounds like you mean fermions. Bosons absolutely can occupy the same quantum states, look up the Bose-Einstein condensate. Also, no one serious claims that singularities exist when taking quantum mechanics into account. It's completely unknown territory.
- oneshtein 2y agoI wrote «barions», but yes, you are right, I meant «fermions». Fixed.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThey’re mixing up barycentres [1] and baryons [2]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barycenter_(astronomy) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barycenter_(astronomy) [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baryon https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baryon
- oneshtein 2y agoAnyway, I propose to dig tunnel to the center of the Moon with plasma cutters and make a lab there. IMHO, the result will be worthy. As non-native speaker, it's hard for me to argue with native speakers (especially when I sick, tired, in army, and at war), and I refuse to use AI to translate, because I suspect that such messages will be automatically rejected by future archivists.
- nathan_compton 2y agoWhy not dig a tunnel to the center of a smaller body like an asteroid? I think you're talking about the fact that the gravitational force inside of a symmetric shell of matter is zero. But the potential is not, as can be (and has been, I believe) demonstrated quite easily by just putting a clock in a hole and measuring the time dilation relative to the surface. Sorry you are at war. Good luck.
- 2y ago
- api 2y agoIf matter falling into a singularity never reaches it because time slows down infinitely as you approach, wouldn’t this be a physical representation of a mathematical limit from calculus? The actual literal 1d singularity never forms but it is approached infinitely close.
- cyberax 2y agoMatter falling into a singularity reaches it in a fairly short time, according to the falling observer's clock. It's just that the _light_ that this observer emits takes infinitely long to reach observers outside of the singularity.
- credit_guy 2y agoYou don’t seem to be new around here, so this quote from this forum’s guidelines is more for the benefit of others > When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoYou’re right. My apologies to OP and y’all. Can’t edit, but the snark was uncalled for.
- slwvx 2y agoI don't see any name calling. Could you eplicitly state what the problem is?
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThe comment stands factually with just the second sentence.
- wavewrangler 2y agoBut that is not name-calling. In your words, that is snark. Are all snarky comments also name calling now, and vice-versa? One could argue that the comment stands factually with just the first sentence, too. It’s strong, yes, but very different from name calling. I think it’s a valuable tool in learning in that it [snark] reminds us to choose our words very carefully, and we all need reminders of that sometimes. Also…
- strogonoff 2y agoThere are plenty of various oblique ways of expressing similar sentiment that can hurt an educated person much more than name-calling (which, conversely, can be more amusing than anything). Digs like “the wrongness of your statement” are definitely far on relevant spectrum. Therefore, I believe the rules against name-calling are not literal. As you noticed, attempting to restrict discussion more strictly would make it bland, but on the other hand when it comes to literal name-calling in a civilized discussion it’s way past all limits. Tangentially, I was surprised to learn recently that merely the use of specific “you” in an argument is already considered unnecessary and perceived as somewhat confrontational. Haven’t confirmed it from multiple sources (not sure how to search for), but in hindsight it makes sense: the mood changes, and the argument can quickly devolve thereafter. I suspect it might be something from psychotherapy practice.