4 ms·
No surprise. The car salesman has gone mad. In addition, people are finding out that an EV is not a high-tech product (except for maybe the battery), and can b
by amelius 2y ago
No surprise. The car salesman has gone mad.
In addition, people are finding out that an EV is not a high-tech product (except for maybe the battery), and can be made just as well and cheaper in low-wage countries.
- aurareturn 2y agoI think Elon saw the writing on the way a long time ago. So he's in the process of trying to pivot Tesla to a self-driving taxi, humanoid, energy company. In addition, he's trying to buy as much time as possible by lobbying for huge Chinese tariffs in the US.
- churchill 2y agoNope. There's no way to disguise or explain away his recent actions: Elon's actions are clearly those of a person who has grudges against certain segments of society and wants to use political power to fix them. If he just wanted tariffs on China he could have just imitated Miriam Adelson: give the Trump campaign $200M & state your demands without mincing words. Or, split the amount between both parties and ride whichever horse that comes out on top.
- rgmerk 2y agoChinese cars are already effectively barred from the USA.
- walrus01 2y agoAnd Canada, which has, as I recall, a one hundred percent tariff on something like a BYD or any other car made in China, even if they did submit them for federal road safety compliance testing.
- ideasarecool 2y agoThat's not it. He did that stuff to frame it as a tech company not as a car company. WeWork did the same thing. If you are seen as a tech company. Not just another normal company then you can justify the ludicrous evaluations you are getting. While dismissing questions about why your company is worth more than any of your competitor with saner financial statements.
- tinco 2y agoMaybe I'm naive but I don't think you need to construct an argument of ill intent/deceit to explain Tesla's actions and marketing. Nothing Tesla has done is in conflict with the strategy laid out at the beginning which was to first sell expensive cars, and then selling increasingly cheaper cars. FSD is not in the strategy to frame it as a tech company, but to make use of software margins. If you can sell a car that cost 30k to manufacture for 40k instead of 35k because it has software on it, that greatly improves your margins because the software doesn't have manufacturing cost beyond the initial R&D. There's a lot about Elon to dislike, but his business ideas are sound. At the same time I fully believe his behavior is going to run Tesla into the ground which will be a real shame. He really took the incredible amount of goodwill they got for being the first to make a car that could be both cheaper and better for the environment in the face of both established car companies and the oil industry, and he just flushed all that goodwill down the shitter. Tesla's saving grace would be to produce cars at a competitive price point, I think money always trumps politics, and with tariffs on Chinese imports that might be achieved, but they'd still be losing the European market and any extra margin they might have gotten from their previously good reputation.
- ModernMech 2y ago>Maybe I'm naive but I don't think you need to construct an argument of ill intent/deceit to explain Tesla's actions and marketing. Yes -- given who Musk is, it's naive to construct an argument of what Tesla is doing that doesn't include malicious intent. > There's a lot about Elon to dislike, but his business ideas are sound. If his ideas were sound, the valuations wouldn't be sky high. His ideas are anything but sound, so the valuations are sky high because he has such a small chance of pulling them off.
- DanielHB 2y agoThat strategy is just for raising money, as far as I know Tesla doesn't raise money from investors anymore. Although you do have to keep stockholders happy and framing as a tech company helps with that. No it seems he really wants to pivot tesla away from cars to services like Apple. Sell the hardware but have the massive profits on services. Remains to be seen if the strategy will work out, it is a very risky bet.
- jesterson 2y agoDoes “salesman” figure actually affect your choice of car? Shouldn’t it be objective characteristics like TCO, reliability, etc
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoCars are one of the most brand and image driven purchases that people make, certainly when weighted by cost. There's very little cold logical thought involved in most new car purchases.
- gtirloni 2y agoThis should clarify a few things: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human
- Tesslaaas 2y agoYes. I have not bought that kitchen by that weird sales guy who ignored my wives kitchen 3d model (ah we don't need that, we will start from scratch) I will not buy a Tesla either.
- short_sells_poo 2y agoYes, yes it does. Why is it inconceivable that people don't want to give money to Musk? It's called voting with your wallet. I may like the car, but I deeply disagree with the business owner's views and deranged behavior over the last couple of years. The easiest thing I can do is to give my money to someone else instead. Ultimately it doesn't matter whether Musk truly believes some of the lunacy he says, his actions speak for him. I disagree with his actions and don't want to support him. He could make the best car in the world for all I care.
- jesterson 2y agowhat do you think of Volkswagen then?
- short_sells_poo 2y ago
- pjc50 2y ago> EV is not a high-tech product EV doesn't have to be a high-tech product, although you need some fairly high tech stuff in the charger and BMS; the problem with modern cars is (1) protectionist questionable tech mandates like backup cameras and tyre pressure sensors and "phone home in event of crash" which inflate the BOM and (2) the need to add "features" to inflate the margin, like complicated dashboard computers and subscription heated seats. This is why average Chinese drivers are picking up huge numbers of moderately priced EVs that the West is preventing from being sold.
- gambiting 2y agoI honestly and unironically think that our EV(a Volkswagen e-UP) is what most buyers actually want, but what manufacturers aren't making. It's simple, everything inside is using normal analogue dials including the one for battery level, it gets ~150-180 miles of range out of its 36kWh battery(even Tesla doesn't do those kinds of efficiency numbers), it doesn't have satnav just a factory holder for your phone.......that's all you need. You get in, turn(!!!) the key and go. It works day in and day out. No software updates, no phantom braking, no beeping at you because it read a sign wrong....it's what an EV(and I'd argue - any car) should be. Obviously package it in a larger body for people who need the space(eGolf exists and uses exact same EV drivetrain), but yeah stop cramming EVs with every gadget under the sun, most people don't want it and they certainly don't want to be paying for it.