6 ms·
At M.I.T., Large Lectures Are Going the Way of the Blackboard
- mamama 18y ago"the professor covered multiple blackboards with mathematical formulas and explained the principles of Newtonian mechanics and electromagnetism." Walter Lewin did a lot more than just that.
- tokenadult 18y agoWalter Lewin did a lot more than just that. Please tell us more. I've never had the privilege of seeing Walter Lewin in action.
- harpastum 18y agoProfessor Lewin has several classes available online through both MIT OpenCourseWare (OCW) and the iTunes store. OCW Link: http://ocw.mit.edu/OcwWeb/Physics/8-01Physics-IFall1999/VideoLectures/ http://ocw.mit.edu/OcwWeb/Physics/8-01Physics-IFall1999/Vide...
- aston 18y agoAs entertaining as his lectures were, it was still pretty easy to leave with barely any more knowledge than you had going in. Especially as the topics got more complex. I had him for my Waves class, and kids found it to be incredibly hard (and to require lots of on-your-own learning) even while Lewin was jumping around the room and making cool things happen with light and sound.
- harpastum 18y ago"As each semester progressed, attendance in [the professor's] introductory physics courses fell to 50 percent, as it did, he said, for nearly all of his colleagues...'I had poor attendance, and was failing 10 to 15 percent'" So, 50 percent of the students aren't coming to class, and they're only failing 10-15 percent? It sounds like the tests are too easy. If the tests were more demanding, more students would come to class--which might (paradoxically) lower the fail rate. "Unlike in the lectures, attendance counts toward the final grade...[the professor] gauged the level of understanding in the room by throwing out a series of multiple-choice questions. The students “voted” with their wireless “personal response clickers”" I'm currently a sophomore in Computer Engineering, and I have had several 150+ student lectures that used these clickers to take attendance. It's a simple way to make sure students come to class. This is a major benefit that has nothing to do with smaller class sizes.
- mhartl 18y agoIt sounds like the tests are too easy. You might be right that much or most of the higher pass rate is due to higher attendance, but it's also possible that students were learning plenty from section, the book, and working on problem sets. When I taught the analogous course (Physics 1) at Caltech, many of the students skipped lecture entirely. The failure rate was typically under 5%, and I guarantee it wasn't because the tests were easy. One student I remember took it all the way: he skipped everything, including homework (which counted for 20% of the grade), but he got perfect scores on all four quizzes and on the final exam. According to the numbers he had an A- because of the 0 on homework, but everyone in the grading room agreed that was absurd, and so we gave him a flat A instead.
- rw 18y ago1. - 0.2 = 0.8 is typically a B-. Is there a different grading scale there?
- jimbokun 18y agocurve?
- mhartl 18y agoBasically all classes at Caltech are curved. It actually makes a lot of sense, because it means you can make the tests really hard and leave plenty of room at the top, which among other things helps reduce the variance due to careless errors. (If you make a couple minor minus sign mistakes, but nail a hard problem most people miss, you still come out ahead.) In Physics 1, typically 90%+ was A+, ~82-89% was A.
- sachinag 18y agoI pulled this trick in my entry-level calculus class in college. They were so generous with extra credit that my marks should have meant that I got an A. But I didn't do any of the homework and the TA decided to punish me with an A-. I suppose I should have fought, but I'm epically lazy. Lesson: if you're going to do something like this, don't assume that the people on the other end will hold up their end of the implied bargain. Either fight or do some token tribute.
- RK 18y agoAs a slight thread hijack, which do you prefer, blackboards or whiteboards? The physicists and mathematicians I know seem to universally prefer blackboards, while everyone else seems to like whiteboards. I like whiteboards for any semi-permanent or "data-rich" writing (i.e. multi-color), but probably prefer blackboards for intense computation.
- cturner 18y agoWhile RK is asking - has anyone had contact with those glass boards that Joel wrote about recently?
- mseebach 18y agoYep, they're nice. One thing though, when there's direct light, what's written on the surface casts a shadow on the painted back-side. It looks a bit odd. Also, the same effect results in a fuzzy picture when the glass board is used as a projector screen. I'd love to experiment with back-lighting the glass board. If would eliminate the shadow-problem, and look pretty neat, I think.
- ponnap 18y agoWe've had them in my previous company. How different are they from the regular whiteboards? They probably look a lot cleaner than the white ones after years of usage. If the ink in the marker dries out, it is harder to read than it is to, from a whiteboard. Can't think of others for now.
- eru 18y agoI like blackboards --- but then I am a mathematician. I even brought blackboard foil to glue to the walls at home.
- hs 18y agoi like blackboard for the simple reason that chalk never lies
- noro 18y agoblackboards are much better: * easier to erase * easier to clean board and erasers * chalk is cleaner, cheaper, more expressive, less wasteful (no plastic), and there are generally more colors available * chalk stays at full "marking capacity" until it runs out. Dry-erase markers make you write at less than full contrast for a long while until you toss them. * chalk dust is no problem if you have windows you can open a little * sounds better when you use it. :) * nicer light-on-dark contrast (IMO) But whiteboard gets chosen by non-experts b/c it supposedly makes less dust for electronics/projectors. Unfortunate.
- bz 18y agoThe general sentiment about the TEAL classes (the ones with the clickers) is that they are really gimmicky. Supposedly, it gives the professor some feedback on what concepts are unclear and pushes the students to be attentive. The problem seems to be that it's just unnecessary structure for something that's typically dynamic. It at least partially devolved into an attendance system - students used to just press in for missing friends, until recently when they had each student buy their own clicker.
- quantumhobbit 18y agoI remain convinced that the only reason they require those clickers is to charge $70-$100 to each student for them.
- JabavuAdams 18y agoYou're joking! $70-100?
- gravitycop 18y agoAnd, in a virtual age, what is the point of a physical school? Answer: there is no point.
- Kototama 18y agoSynergy. Relationship. Feedback. Allowing smart people to meet each other today so that they will build the startups of tomorrow.
- gravitycop 18y agoAll possible online. No? For example, a lot of HN visitors interact here primarily to meet founding partners.
- Kototama 18y agoPossible but not as good as when you interact directly with people (in my view). Direct feedback with teachers is far better than a lot of email exchanges, or than videoconference. Spending a lot of time with other students on the same projects, in the same room and everyday at the university give you the opportunity to know their personality, and how they work. A lot better than doing a project in common with Internet. You also have more opportunities to meet people from other horizons (i.e. non geeks).
- gravitycop 18y agoDirect feedback with teachers is far better than [...] videoconference. Wouldn't that depend upon the quality of the "videoconference"? http://www.google.com/search?q=telepresence+%22eye+contact%22 http://www.google.com/search?q=telepresence+%22eye+contact%2... - in the same room Kind of like ... HP's Halo? http://www.hp.com/halo/introducing.html http://www.hp.com/halo/introducing.html Halo gives the sense of being in the same room together.
- gamache 18y agoNerd sex.
- stcredzero 18y agoThe large lecture hall is an example of something which was necessary due to past technology constraints but which persists even though it's no longer optimal. I've taught such classes of 75 to 80 students. Even at that modest size, there is considerable overhead just from managing that many people. What we really need are uses of technology that maximize interaction between students and professors and amongst fellow students. The most productive time in terms of my teaching were the lab sessions of only 25 students each. That and office hours, which were attended by a shockingly small number of students. I suspect that study groups are also highly productive. Technology should be used to enable more interaction akin to study groups and office hours.