13 ms·
Richard Feynman's blackboard at the time of his death (1988)
- EncomLab 2y agoAnyone know why it seems that Feynman is coming under attack lately - most prominently by You Tuber Angela Collier whose "the sham legacy of Richard Feynman" now has nearly 1M views? I don't understand it at all.
- artifact_44 2y agoBecause she thoroughly de-articulates the fabricated mystique around Feynman, and openly discusses the toxic effect his legacy has had on science. (Including the fact that a lot of his legacy was fabricated by people that either admired him, or wished to capitalize on that legacy.) Her video on Feynman is long and detailed, and very sobering. I highly recommend it. It absolutely/expertly challenged everything I thought I knew about him. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwKpj2ISQAc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwKpj2ISQAc
- afterburner 2y agoIf you watch it all the way to the end (or skip towards the end if you like), she does mention this legacy is a result of exaggerated stories not even written down by him, but related second hand by people around him with their own attitudes (and financial inventives). He was probably not an angel, even a bit of a cocky dick maybe sometimes in the way of the times, and perhaps a bit vain, but stories related second hand when he was probably joking around don't necessarily represent the true history of his life. She has good things to say about him in the end, from the evidence of his actual behaviour, like doing education outreach and loving his wife.
- tovej 2y agoWell, for one, he strangled his wife when he got upset: https://slate.com/technology/2019/01/richard-feynman-physical-abuse-science-wife-fbi.html https://slate.com/technology/2019/01/richard-feynman-physica...
- dinkumthinkum 2y agoI don't want to get into it but she is a nice person and is quite smart but she is a far leftist and interprets many things through a Marxist and anti-capitalist world-view with a very millennial kind of approach. So, I would tend take a lot of things she says with a grain of salt.
- nurettin 2y agoI'm 2 minutes in, she's doing her hardest to dis F and failing miserably.
- nmz 2y agoI suppose its the evolution of destroying everything that the previous generation likes in an effort to prove wrongdoing and their own modern superiority. It's why OK Boomer is an insult. But what do I know.
- paulpauper 2y agoToo bad he did not live that exceptionally long despite such an exceptional mind and accomplishments. Life is weird in that way.
- cb321 2y agoTo amplify your point, life is indeed weird that way. Feynmann's 69 while, as you say, is not exceptionally long was at least average for men in American in the 1980s. As a far too minimal smattering: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_von_Neumann https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_von_Neumann only made it to age 53. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernhard_Riemann https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernhard_Riemann only to 39. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89variste_Galois https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89variste_Galois barely escaped his teens.
- NotAnOtter 2y agoFeynman should not be celebrated.
- dinkumthinkum 2y agoI'll celebrate him. Stop me! :)
- frakt0x90 2y agoWhy? If I recall he was a womanizer but we can admonish his personal choices while celebrating his incredible scientific and pedagogical achievements.
- NotAnOtter 2y agoHe was a top-tier scientists but kinda disgraceful in every other aspect of his life. Womanizer is a polite way of saying it, I would choose harsher words. He was also just generally a jerk to the people around him. Think Edison, more than Tesla.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- willy_k 2y agoAnd he’s celebrated for his contributions as a scientist and educator, not to ethics or social issues. People don’t disavow Ghandi out of hand because he was anti-vax.
- y1n0 2y agoKnew him well, did you?
- NotAnOtter 2y agoFunnily enough you can learn lots of things when you read books.
- dhosek 2y ago“Know how to solve every problem that has been solved.” That seems a reasonable goal.
- readthenotes1 2y agoBy who standard? It seems like an unsolvable problem to know every problem that is actually been solved correctly...
- cbracketdash 2y agoI think he's being sarcastic
- bitshiftfaced 2y agoIt doesn't strike me as likely that Feynman would have written this with sarcasm behind it. Maybe someone knows the details better. Personally, I think it looks more like the sort of goal that you aim for even it's not literally possible. "Shoot for the moon. Even if you miss, you'll land among the stars."
- yunwal 2y agodhosek was being sarcastic, not Feynman
- danielmarkbruce 2y agoNeither of them were. The quote is saying "practice solving problems on solved problems as much as you can" and dhosek is saying "good idea".
- turnsout 2y agoI read it with a different (epistemic) emphasis… I don't need to know the solution if I know how to solve it. I've never produced a chip before, but I know how the problem has been solved by others. And therefore if I break it down, I could solve it myself. It's also possible that he meant every problem in your domain. That would be slightly more reasonable, and something I could agree with.
- Molitor5901 2y agoSurely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman! is one of my favorite books. We lost him much too soon.
- bookofjoe 2y agoI was a UCLA anesthesiology attending in the 1980s when Feynman came to our OR for an abdominal procedure after having been diagnosed with kidney cancer. I watched as he was wheeled down the hall toward OR 9, our largest, reserved for major complicated operations. As he was wheeled into the room, he clasped his two hands above his head like a prizefighter.
- simonswords82 2y agoSeriously? That is so cool that you were there. Sad that we lost him fairly young. Such a legend, I love his work.
- sympil 2y agoI found this to be illuminating: https://youtu.be/TwKpj2ISQAc?si=O0qabLdBkmWq3jVX https://youtu.be/TwKpj2ISQAc?si=O0qabLdBkmWq3jVX
- gitremote 2y ago"the sham legacy of Richard Feynman" is about Feynman being famous because of this book rather than because of his physics. The YouTuber, an obsessed physicist who had spent months reading all Feynman books, provides a critical analysis and explains the cultural impact of "Surely You're Joking, Mr.Feynman!" https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=TwKpj2ISQAc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=TwKpj2ISQAc
- __s 2y agoOverall seems good, but I find it interesting she says it teaches to always be the smartest person in the room when the book often reflected Feynman as being somewhat simple, going on about reliance on mental tricks in comparison to his colleagues who he felt were much more talented. Or instances where he found himself out of his depth & got lucky (pointing at some random thing on a diagram to figure out what it is without asking, happens to get people he's with to rubber duck debug an actual problem). Which may support her observation of Feynman bros who might find this relatable This all comes back to the observation I've made working with competent people, which is that we're all stuck trying to solve problems with the computational power of a slab of meat (she later goes on to address this modesty as being underhanded) (continued watching, two hours in now, this is great work)
- sigmoid10 2y agoRichard Feynman having the quantum Hall effect on his "to learn" list is amazing. I mean, it makes sense, because less than three years before he died the Nobel Prize in physics was awarded for its discovery. But it shows that even one of the greatest physicists of his generation had not fully grasped something that is now part of every undergraduate physics degree's standard curriculum and is arguably much less complicated than, say, Feynman's contributions to Quantum Electrodynamics.
- mkagenius 2y agoBeing part of a course doesn't mean the students get enough time to delve as deep or have as deep an understanding of the phenomenon though.
- ddtaylor 2y agoI agree. Someone might be able to understand and reproduce some basic components of the system in the same way I use mathematics effectively, but to say I have an understanding of the fundamentals at any level like Wolfram does.
- asdff 2y agoYeah, imagine if the undergrads had to write out the underlying proof. When I took physics classes the professors would do things for our exams like assume gravity is 10 ms to give people an easier time with the numbers, and of course the spherical frictionless cow.
- WalterBright 2y agoI especially liked the pointless masses.
- spoonfeeder006 2y agoMaybe has more to do with volume of information rather than it being especially difficult for him? Could be that was his week's todo list
- 2y ago
- nullbyte808 2y ago"What I cannot create, I do not understand." "Know how to solve every problem that has been solved.”
- bitshiftfaced 2y agoDoes anyone know if this was his personal blackboard? For example, would've his students seen this blackboard?
- ChuckMcM 2y agoHis motto "What I cannot create, I do not understand" has been one of the driving forces in my own quest to understand more about the world around me. A good friend had picked up a corollary which was "What I cannot teach, I do not understand" which I think was quite similar. Definitely one of my heroes.
- jelder 2y agoThere's another corollary that always struck me as true: “To see is to forget the name of the thing one sees.” -- Paul Valéry Posted on HN recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40700530 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40700530
- frugalmail 2y ago>"What I cannot teach, I do not understand" This is really more in line to some of the things Feynman communicated in many of his interviews. I feel like it more accurately reflects the way Feynman approached things. He was such a loss. RIP
- ChuckMcM 2y agoHave you ever asked yourself why this version (with 'create' in it) was on his black board?
- frugalmail 2y agoI'm interested in hearing your thoughts.
- gregschlom 2y ago> "What I cannot teach, I do not understand" And the corollary to that, from 17th century French writer Nicolas Boileau: "Ce que l'on conçoit bien s'énonce clairement, et les mots pour le dire arrivent aisément." - What we understand well, we express clearly, and words to describe it flow easily.
- 2y ago
- hinkley 2y agoI finally put my whiteboard back up that’s been down since before Covid. It still had scribblings of a novel merge sort with lower space overhead that turned out to be an artifact of non-representative sample inputs. As Bletchley Park taught us, humans are terrible at randomness. No piece of software replicates the experience of having a board to write things on (or magnet things to, if yours is ferromagnetic like mine). The ones that come closest, that money is better spent on something else.
- peterburkimsher 2y agoGreat! Would you be able to describe the sorting algorithm as a comment here, to open-source it? Also, if you’d like a free magnet for your whiteboard, I’ll happily send you one from BeWelcome.org;)
- hinkley 2y agoTypically you merge a block A and block B into a new block C that has the same length as A + B. I thought I saw a way to use a few extra pointers and some swap operations to turn A and B into C by chipping away at their left ends, and still being a stable sort. The examples I came up with worked and confirmation bias took over. But in real data there were combinations of runs that broke the algorithm.
- scorbinnicholas 2y ago[flagged]
- thealch3m1st 2y agoThey should sell this as a print
- JKCalhoun 2y agoThere's something rather sad, maybe poignant about it. It stands there as a testimonial to our brevity on this planet, to all that we will not see, do, understand. So it goes, I guess.
- bcatanzaro 2y agoI almost want to read it as satire. Especially juxtaposed against his death. Because the ideas of "What I cannot create, I do not understand." and "Know how to solve every problem that has been solved" seem profoundly unwise and endlessly futile.
- gowld 2y agoIf you are calling Richard Feynman "profoundly unwise" and "endlessly futile", you might need to do a bit more reflection on the grounding for your opinion.
- jszymborski 2y agoSurely it can be true that a profoundly wise and consistently effective person holds a belief or utters a phrase that is profoundly unwise and endlessly futile.
- ScotterC 2y agoAbsolutely true. And paradoxically, they may fully understand that the phrase is profoundly unwise and endlessly futile and yet know the benefit of holding the belief anyway.
- cutemonster 2y agoIsn't there an implicit "... that you stumbled upon, and found interesting". And to him (and others like him), that might have been possible. While for other more ordinary people, it'd be profoundly unwise and endlessly futile, to hope to do that
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kypro 2y agoI'm sure a lot of people here have already seen this, but for those who haven't I highly recommend you watch this video of Feynman explaining light, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FjHJ7FmV0M4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FjHJ7FmV0M4 He had an amazing ability to make physics fun and entertaining. I could listen to him talk all day.
- Mindey 2y agoDon't you see? He encoded the driving force of his motivation.
- wnissen 2y agoQuite interesting to see [Hans] Bethe Ansatz on there. I wasn't familiar with it, apparently it started as an Ansatz and Bethe corrected it into a theory. But this all happened more than ten years before Feynman was doing physics.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- upghost 2y agoDoes anyone know what the comment is in the top right of the blackboard? "why cant x sort" or something?
- bsza 2y agoI read it as “Why const x sect.” (why constant cross section?), but it’s hard to make out.
- adultSwim 2y agoFeynman used his genius to build annihilation. His contemporary from New York, Jonas Salk was a hero. Richard Feynman should be a warning.
- begueradj 2y ago> Know how to solve every problem that has been solved. I wonder how developers nowadays can related to that since -some of them- relate on AI to watch it doing their craft.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Shorel 2y agoThey don't, and they can't. They don't even know that they can't. The mathematics mindset and the programming mindset could not be more different. Writing a mathematical proof is similar to writing everything from scratch each time. However, and this is a serious affirmation: learning to write mathematical proofs will make anyone a much better developer, because of the changes in the mental processes involved in the creation and expression of ideas.
- MisterSandman 2y agoWhat? Every mathematical proof is built on top of other proofs, especially when you look at research that is happening today. Mathematics and Computer Science mindsets are closer than most other pairs of academic streams. There’s a reason why so many universities have their CS departments under their Math Departments.
- xanderlewis 2y agoThese days it’s more like math departments under CS departments (which are seen as highly important, as a CS degree is more fashionable than a maths one and mathematics is seen as an abstruse academic pursuit in the worst sense and a financial sink rather than a source). It’s true that (almost) every proof is built on top of others, but this is not the way mathematicians learn their craft — you do have to start at the bottom. The average programmer, on the other hand, has never been anywhere near the hardware or, these days, the software near the bottom.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- shimonabi 2y agoHe was a con artist with a Nobel Prize. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwKpj2ISQAc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwKpj2ISQAc
- dinkumthinkum 2y agoAs I wrote in a comment about the same person, be careful, she is a far-leftist that regularly pushes a "particular" agenda in her entertaining videos about physics and life as a phd student.
- nmz 2y agoNope https://freakonomics.com/the-curious-brilliant-vanishing-mr-feynman/ https://freakonomics.com/the-curious-brilliant-vanishing-mr-...
- Xelynega 2y agoIt's interesting having this video be my introduction to Feynman, then seeing how people talk about his personality. She brings up points that don't seem easy to dispute, yet all of the comments here seem to be praise for the man outside of just his achievements.
- ballooney 2y agoThis website is 99% the sort of not especially socialised young men who for various psychological insecurities are prone to the sort of hero-worship that she refers to in the video.
- bsza 2y agoEvery person is a con artist if you’re cynical enough.
- DiogenesKynikos 2y agoA "con artist" does not invent the action formulation of quantum field theory.
- dangtheory 2y agoWhat about the rest of the blackboard? couldn't make some of it out (right side).
- nav 2y ago"What I cannot create, I do not understand" , loved it and cropped it up as a little picture reminder for anyone that is interested. https://x.com/nav_chatterji/status/1893224035737030823 https://x.com/nav_chatterji/status/1893224035737030823
- kensai 2y agoThere is more! https://digital.archives.caltech.edu/collections/Images/1.10-3/ https://digital.archives.caltech.edu/collections/Images/1.10...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]