5 ms·
Gravitational Effects of Small Primordial Black Hole Passing Through Human Body
- dudeinjapan 2y ago[dead]
- odyssey7 2y agoNo empirical data observations? Jk, this is an interesting scenario to think about.
- 1970-01-01 2y agoBlack holes killing cancer cells when?
- stronglikedan 2y agoMaybe causing?
- oldMobileOnWifi 2y agoAs long as they aren't controlled by a Therac-25, I'm all for it.
- changoplatanero 2y ago10^17g is about 20,000 times heavier than the great pyramid of giza. Funny to imagine something as massive as a pyramid pass through your body and not noticing it.
- kypro 2y agoI'm trying to get some intuition for this. Is the difference that a massive objective hitting you would typically do damage via the electromagnetic force? But if you consider the gravitation force of the pyramids obviously that's extremely weak compared to the other forces on our body, so we shouldn't expect it to do damage in the same way?
- mystified5016 2y agoRemember that gravity falls off in strength with the square of distance. The gravitational field around such a black hole would be immensely strong and absolutely miniscule. The event horizon would be the size of a few atoms. Locally, the black hole would swallow any atoms it comes into contact with and would probably scatter nearby molecules, but that's it. It'd pass straight through you.
- bookofjoe 2y agoLike a neutrino
- isoprophlex 2y agoOnly not weighing millions and millions of kilograms
- adastra22 2y agoNo a neutrino would literally leave no trace. The black hole would harm the cells in its path.
- Tuna-Fish 2y agoA small enough black hole would be very unlikely to hit even one atom in one cell while going through you.
- 2y ago
- clbrmbr 2y agoWait, do we know there to be PMBs passing through us like neutrinos? Is this a new kind of cosmic ray?
- devmor 2y agoAn anecdote from one of my former physics professors was that there are theories that PMBs are being constantly generated and annihilated near-instantaneously all over the universe and that odds are astronomically low but one could form inside your body and be so far away from the nearest subatomic particle that it would starve out immediately. Of course, the very concept of a black hole is still technically only the "best theory" to explain observed gravitational and radio anomalies, so it's always helpful to remember as a layman how distant from us this stuff truly is.
- H8crilA 2y agoBesides being funny this paper also has some points - for example we know that no human has yet died due to a PBH passing through their body, but they very likely would had one passed through them. So that's sort of evidence against their existence. Although the estimated number (estimated towards the end of the paper) of such events per year would be utterly small anyways.
- voakbasda 2y agoHanlon’s Razor suggests no reasonable pathologist would ever label a death as caused by a PBH. It could have happened, but the effects probably looked similar enough to something more common for such deaths to be mislabeled.
- mturmon 2y ago> Besides being funny ... I enjoyed this part too -- the author (Robert Scherrer) also offers the following link to an even drier paper: https://my.vanderbilt.edu/robertscherrer/miscellaneous/ https://my.vanderbilt.edu/robertscherrer/miscellaneous/
- jerf 2y agoNo. There is a range of PMBs masses not currently excluded by observation that may explain dark matter, but if dark matter consists of PMBs in that range we're talking on the order of single digits in the solar system per century, not PMBs streaming through you like crazy.
- leereeves 2y ago> with a cutoff mass for serious injury or death of approximately MPBH > 1.4×10^17g Am I misreading or does that say that a PBH with the mass of a million aircraft carriers[1] could pass through a human without killing them? 1: the largest aircraft carriers displace about 100,000 metric tons or 10^11 grams
- PaulHoule 2y agoGravity is a really weak force. Electromagnetic forces generated in your muscles can overcome the gravity of the whole planet, like 6 × 10²⁷ grams.
- gottorf 2y agoIt's true you can jump, but you do need to achieve 25,000 mph to truly "overcome" Earth's gravity ;-)
- soulofmischief 2y agoIf you could continually generate thrust of the same magnitude as a jump though, you'd still break free.
- PaulHoule 2y agoAnd you can do that with the electromagnetic forces in the fuel in your tanks with a mass ratio of 15 or so. Not that hard.
- holyhowitzer 2y agoWhat's the actual point of this? So PBHs are hypothetical micro black holes that even if they do exist it's so unlikely to harm humans.
- dotancohen 2y agoUntil this study was done, we did not know if these objects could have affected humans. Imagine if they _had_ discovered the ability of PBHs to e.g. puncture a lung, blood vessel, or brain synapse. Maybe we would better understand e.g. crib death, or Alzheimer's disease. Wouldn't any parent line their baby's crib with the mass equivalent of a million aircraft carriers in lead, to protect them?
- icapybara 2y agoAre we that out of ideas for crib death and Alzheimer's that black holes would be considered a root cause?
- throwway120385 2y agoI think that lead would be a bad material to use, considering a baby's propensity to put everything within reach into their mouths starting at a couple of months of age when they can start reaching. When they start teething they will inevitably start chewing on the soft metal.
- masfuerte 2y agoBabies particularly enjoy chewing on lead (and lead paint) because it tastes sweet.
- doctor_phil 2y agoWe have a hard time understanding what dark matter is. There are theories that some of the dark matter could be tiny black holes left over from the big bang, called primordial black holes (PHBs). How can we detect PHBs if they exist? If they existed in large numbers, would we notice them? The paper says that you would notice a PHB if it went through you, since you would likely die. We are not noticing people dying by mysterious gunshot-like wounds without guns in any large amounts, so there can not be that many PHBs around. The paper is (weak) evidence against a large amount of PHBs. The paper is also slightly funny.
- pavel_lishin 2y agoFor a science fiction take on this - and sorry for spoilers - check out Isaac Asimov's "The Hole Man", written in 1974. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hole_Man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hole_Man
- bookofjoe 2y agoIn 1974, science fiction author Larry Niven wrote a murder mystery with an interesting premise: could you kill a man with a tiny black hole? Reference: Niven, Larry. “The Hole Man.” Analog Science Fiction/Science Fact (1974): 93-104. It won the 1975 Hugo Award for Best Short Story. Borrow it here: https://archive.org/details/holeinspace00nive https://archive.org/details/holeinspace00nive https://imgur.com/a/Lu16TDT https://imgur.com/a/Lu16TDT
- HelloUsername 2y agoAlso related: Anatoli Bugorski, a Russian retired particle physicist, known for surviving a radiation accident in 1978, when a high-energy proton beam from a particle accelerator passed through his head (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42213629 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42213629)
- JadeNB 2y agoAlso, using this as a plot point though in no way engaging with the science, there's the recent "Omni Loop" (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt28150132 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt28150132).
- bookofjoe 2y agoThank you so much for this! Never heard of it till I read your comment. Gonna watch it tonight. Bonus: Mary-Louise Parker, one of my favorite actors, stars.
- JadeNB 2y agoAs sibling commenter bookofjoe (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43102892 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43102892) and your link point out, it's Larry Niven, not Isaac Asimov.
- rich_sasha 2y agoWould such "tiny" black holes be stable? I'm thinking Hawking radiation, or indeed the opposite, growing without bounds. If they are, are they considered as possible "particles" for dark matter? I guess that's what MACHOs are? And won't interact electromagnetically, only really by gravity.
- dsr_ 2y agoBoth of these questions are considered in the article.
- Tuna-Fish 2y agoHawking radiation gives you a lower bound for the size of a primordial black hole that still exists, at 10^15 g. Primordial black holes largely cannot grow, because they would be traveling very fast, likelihood of interaction with ordinary matter is very small, and there is no mechanism that would slow them down. So if there are some in our galaxy, they would just be zipping about at intergalactic speeds until the heat death of the universe, or until they hit the event horizon of a larger black hole and get absorbed. The present-day universe is just too sparse for them to form or accrete material.
- weitendorf 2y agoNot necessarily. That is only the case for black holes with no charge and angular momentum. Given high enough charge and angular momentum for a given mass, black holes become "extremal" and their hawking radiation/temperature approaches zero. It's argued these are unstable or maybe can't even exist for various reasons, but it's a pretty active area of physics AFAICT https://www.quantamagazine.org/mathematicians-prove-hawking-wrong-about-extremal-black-holes-20240821/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/mathematicians-prove-hawking-... That said, if these were primordial I'd expect their charges to not all be 0, so they'd interact with normal matter.
- weitendorf 2y agoSmall black holes can be stable if they have a charge or high angular momentum. These are called extremal [0] black holes - the charge and/or angular momentum counteract the hawking radiation. Some physicists have argued that electrons (stable, very tiny) could technically be described as super-extremal black holes [1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremal_black_hole https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremal_black_hole [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_electron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_electron
- behnamoh 2y agoNew fear unlocked :) seriously though, is it true that a black hole can be as dense as it wants and still be smaller than an atom? at that point (pun intended), how do we even measure its size, given that it bends the space around it?
- Ajedi32 2y agoThe "size" of a black hold is directly proportional to its mass. Specifically: Mass * 2 * The Gravitational Constant / The Speed of Light Squared: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarzschild_radius https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarzschild_radius Note that the speed of light squared is a really big number, so black holes are quite small relative to their mass.
- lemonberry 2y agoFor as long as I can remember I've had these random hyper-local sharp pains on my body. By the time I register them they're gone. I've always wondered if they were some particle passing through me. I don't know enough about anatomy to know how big something has to be to hit a nerve and have it register it.
- jajko 2y agoNot possible in way you describe. Either book an appointment with neurologist or learn to live with it.
- lemonberry 2y agoWhat an odd comment.
- spuz 2y agoAre they localised in the same area or in totally random areas?
- lemonberry 2y agoRandom areas
- mlhpdx 2y agoOkay, so detecting damage to people from PMBs would be difficult. People are fairly difficult to work with as a specimen anyway, so wouldn’t a more meaningful study be “what easily detectable evidence would be imparted by one?” Holes in silicon wafers?
- nolroz 2y agoOh man, so many questions! Would a PBH passing close enough to Earth to hit a human end up being drawn to the Earth's core or the Sun? Or would the mass/inertia of a rogue PBH be enough to keep it from falling into a local gravity wall and gobbling up the solar system?
- ck2 2y agoStephen Hawking theorized it is even possible there is one hiding in our sun. Below a certain size it would not be detectable by any current method. And of course there is a PBS Space Time for that (edit wrong video) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q6kJaMf3Lgo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q6kJaMf3Lgo (more awesome here https://www.youtube.com/@pbsspacetime/videos https://www.youtube.com/@pbsspacetime/videos )
- rachofsunshine 2y agoAny object that approaches the Solar System from interstellar space is necessarily moving at least (solar) escape velocity. It's "falling down" into the Solar System's gravity by a distance equal to how far it has to "climb up" to get away in a system with little appreciable friction. The paper assumes 100 km/s, which is more than double the solar escape velocity at Earth's orbit. The mass doesn't make a difference in the absence of friction and assuming it is much less than the primary body; escape velocity depends only on the mass of the primary. There would be some "friction" (since the hole would be eating up small amounts of mass on its journey and that mass would be moving at less than solar escape velocity), but without doing any calculations I'm almost certain it's nowhere close to enough to slow it down.
- antognini 2y ago"Unfortunately, it is easy to see that the effect of PBH collisions with the human population will always be negligible." I'm not so sure that is unfortunate.
- curtisszmania 2y ago[flagged]
- tere0 2y agoI don't know, that sounds quite LLM-generated to me.
- tempodox 2y agoBut where is the reproducible experiment?
- ted_dunning 2y agoYou and I are doing it right now. Prediction: no effect due to rarity and no effect anyway Observation: no effect Theory not falsified.