7 ms·
California homeowners to fund half of high-risk insurer's $1B 'bailout'
- lttlrck 2y agoThe state had, IIRC, a $100 billion surplus 2 years ago. They knew the insurers were leaving and why. Yet didn't fund FAIR correctly at the time? Or what's the excuse? Of course now there is a massive deficit. Maybe they'll pay us back on the next surplus...
- nickff 2y agoFrom what I understand (and I’d appreciate any corrections) FAIR was supposed to pay for itself, not be a subsidized insurer. It seems like FAIR was underpricing the risk, and the private insurers were right to pull out.
- readthenotes1 2y agoIt didn't work out well... "FAIR Plan has about $300 billion in total exposure, meaning how much they actually insure, and about $200 million in the bank," - March 2024 https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/california-fair-plan-insurer-of-last-resort-warns-major-disaster-could-wipe-out-funds/ https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/california-fair-pl...
- Sakos 2y agoWhy would the state pay to fund FAIR? It's just a pool of insurers required to provide fire insurance and it's paid for by insurance customers. Even if the state had $100 billion surplus, why would it be justifiable to use it on FAIR as opposed to the countless other ways the money could be used to help Californian residents? It would effectively be like taxing Californians to pay for homeowner fire insurance. Is that fair?
- plasticchris 2y agoThey never actually had that surplus, it was projected revenue. The projections were wrong - they extrapolated, then planned spending around that. Source: https://calmatters.org/commentary/2023/10/california-budget-whiplash-pitfalls-forecasting/ https://calmatters.org/commentary/2023/10/california-budget-...
- linotype 2y agoIf they put the money into a fund, you would have complained that the government was overtaxing the citizens.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThe problem is the same thing that leads to many California problems - it’s the leaders voters keep choosing. One party states tend to be wasteful and ineffective. More details on the insurance debacle, which basically is classic over regulation: https://youtu.be/ojzUtQlug3I https://youtu.be/ojzUtQlug3I
- jerlam 2y agoCalifornia has budget rules that cap its ability to save money from surpluses and require it to issue refunds: https://www.capradio.org/articles/2024/01/22/how-california-budget-rules-can-prevent-saving-for-a-rainy-day-and-why-newsom-wants-to-change-that/ https://www.capradio.org/articles/2024/01/22/how-california-...
- dehrmann 2y agoI must be missing something, but FAIR is an insurer of last resort backstopped by the insurance companies who refused to sell risky policies in the first place?
- plasticchris 2y agoThe weren’t allowed to - not even the fair plan was charging sound actuarial rates. Cali put price controls on insurance, making this debacle inevitable.
- chaboud 2y agoThat’s really the core problem here. As is often the case with rent control models, the natural outcome of an incentive structure came to pass in spite of the best intentions of legislators/regulators.
- SllX 2y agoYep. Government-imposed price controls and caps should actually be illegal. Like actually unconstitutional, with the requisite constitutional amendments in California (and the other States) and the US Constitution being passed. No matter what anybody’s intentions are, they always end up creating market distortions that eventually lead to more societal issues than the ones they’re suppose to alleviate and it’s just bad economics that shouldn’t even be a tool in politicians’ (or voters, but ballot box lawmaking should be illegal too) toolboxes so they’re forced to address the upstream concerns that cause prices on land, housing, rents, services and goods to climb to the point of being unaffordable to most of the population.
- dehrmann 2y agoI keep waiting for people in less risky parts of California ask why they're paying more for insurance and power so that people can live in risky, fire-prone hills and mountains, but it doesn't seem to be happening.
- riku_iki 2y agopeople are asking, but can't do anything without major power shift in state government.
- AustinDev 2y agoJungle primaries make this nearly impossible.
- KerrAvon 2y agoThose asking might want to have a chat with Florida residents, who have a completely ideologically opposite state government and have the same situation, but with flood insurance. Some risk has to be socialized or no one can live anywhere safely.
- riku_iki 2y agoIt's not about ideological side, but about group of people having power monopoly and abusing it without consequences. Specifically, current CA governor having close relationship with state wide electricity provider and allowing to hike rates to whatever level they want.
- seesaw 2y agoAs an example, my power is generated by one company and distributed by PG&E. I pay $57 for power generation and $140 or so for distribution. PG&E reported close to [1] $2.5B profits for last year. My bills have been going up for $50/month to over $400/month in the last four years. [1]. https://www.santacruzsentinel.com/2025/02/15/pge-profit-electric-gas-utility-fire-economy-bay-area-oakland-san-jose/ https://www.santacruzsentinel.com/2025/02/15/pge-profit-elec...
- primitiveData 2y ago[dead]
- adrianco 2y agoIts hard to understand why so many California houses are built of wood. After a fire all that’s left is a few chimneys. However I happen to live in California in a house made of concrete bricks and we don’t get a higher valuation per square foot or a discount for our fire insurance. There should be more incentives to build fireproof houses.
- woldemariam 2y agoEarthquakes?