4 ms·
The Path to American Authoritarianism
- anovikov 2y agoI think the existence of states and the need for 2/3 of the states to agree to change Constitution, with no chance for 2/3 of them to ever become red, is a good protection against authoritarianism, so people shouldn't worry. Also, blue states are free to ignore Presidential decrees and laws accepted by Congress if their Supreme Courts see them as unconstitutional, and it will become very inconvenient to rule the country if many of the states start ignoring Washington, which they have full right to do.
- pjmlp 2y agoMaybe, then again, https://www.militarystrategymagazine.com/article/civil-war-comes-to-the-west/ https://www.militarystrategymagazine.com/article/civil-war-c... At the rate things are going after two months, who knows if in four years democratic elections are still a thing.
- spiderfarmer 2y agoIt also helps that the blue states have bargaining power. The typical red state gets back 19 cents more for each dollar sent to Washington than its blue-state friends. In other words, they subsidize the red states.
- injidup 2y agoBlue states should start putting tariffs on red states, threatening to annex them, steal their resources and disenfranchise their voters.
- nathanaldensr 2y agoThat's illegal. The Import-Export Clause of the US Constitution forbids it.
- jrs235 2y agoDoesn't mean they can't say it. They can create chaos and distraction too.
- autoexec 2y ago> is a good protection against authoritarianism, The increasing authoritarianism disagrees with you, and states can only ignore federal law to the extent that the federal government allows it. There has been an increase in defiance recently, but nothing stops the feds from storming in and enforcing their laws beyond it not being seen as worth doing.
- anovikov 2y agoBecause states have their own armies - the National Guard - it can be only done by military, not police, or even FBI/SWAT/whatever. That is, real military with tanks and fighter jets. A civil war. I seriously doubt military loyalty to Trump can be THAT high.
- autoexec 2y agoThe National Guard is only authorized in the first place by the US constitution, and every member of the National Guard swears an oath to support and uphold the US constitution against all enemies (foreign and domestic), and also to obey the president of the US. The idea that the national guard will rise up against their own commander in chief is a fantasy. We've already seen how it plays out when states raise an army against the federal government and it doesn't work out very well for them. Even if (and it's a big if) the military didn't agree with Trump specifically, they'll still largely believe in the country and the constitution. If the federal government does something terrible and unconstitutional enough that it becomes necessary for states to attack the federal government they will have abandoned anything resembling 'state's rights' and moved into lawless/oath-breaking civil war.
- dyauspitr 2y agoOnly if there are repercussions to ignoring the constitution. There are plenty of illegal initiatives currently happening with no one really physically stopping them from happening.
- cess11 2y agoDidn't protect against the Patriot/Freedom Acts, The CLOUD Act. Didn't protect against presidents actually ruling by decree. Didn't keep the US from illegally invading and occupying other countries, or put an end to its colonies and colonial practices.
- maxerickson 2y agoAt heart, law is a collective fantasy. If the fantasy breaks down, it doesn't matter what the paper says.
- dkjaudyeqooe 2y agoTrump has SCOTUS in his pocket, who will enforce the constitution? Between the two, it's become an irrelevant document.
- scoperesolution 2y ago[flagged]
- roenxi 2y ago> Even in countries such as the United States that have relatively small, laissez-faire governments... What US is this article talking about??? The US government makes up about half the US economy by GDP [0]. It is the largest government in the history of history. Arguably maybe 2nd to China in recent years. I quite like this article - it has two obvious implications. (1) Reduce the size and scope of government and (2) Maybe the US Democrats should experiment with nominating better candidates and policies. I'm not sure the situation is dire enough to justify either of those things, the Republicans have been in similar straits in the past and just kept on keeping on. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending_in_the_Uni...
- fatuna 2y agoSome quick googling tells me the US gov spends between 35 and 40% of the US GDP. Also, the article says 'relatively'. Compared to other nations, especially other developed nations, the US government can definitely be called 'relatively small'.
- scarab92 2y agoThe government share of GDP is a silly thing to care about. The important questions are: 1. What services do voters want (enough to pay for) 2. How can we meet that need at the lowest cost The first has a broad range of valid answers, the second is something that everyone ignored until DOGE
- ben_w 2y ago> The first has a broad range of valid answers, the second is something that everyone ignored until DOGE They cared plenty before, and there's no real indication to me of a difference with DOGE. Both pre- and post-DOGE, it's all about weird anecdotes like "this wrench cost $20,000! This toilet seat cost $600!"[0], which, even at their current rate of work, would only amount to a rounding error compared to the $2 trillion they talk about cutting. Which is probably for the best, because the $2 trillion goal — about the combined total of the entire US social security system plus all military pensions — is so large that "success" will cause a huge recession. [0] https://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/378125-myth-truth-behind-20-000-wrench.html https://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/378125...
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 2y agoHow this is going to unfold? I think the first step is to seize the media, using buyouts (Twitter) and law suits (Gawker), and at a later stage using made up felony charges against owners (everyone is guilty of something). From there on, the road is clear. People are gullible, majority will believe anything media tells them.
- bananapub 2y agothis has already happened, we're already in the post-coup world, most people just haven't caught up yet. much of the media is already de-facto captured - look at the headlines on a major news website today and compare it to what has actually happened. they don't need to be bought or sued into the ground like happened in other countries - the US media has just bowed down without force.
- sadeshmukh 2y agoThe media isn't captured - I see countless articles like this criticizing Trump, even mainstream US media.
- jimswhims 2y ago[flagged]
- tim333 2y agoThe article seems to be jumping ahead of the current reality rather. I mean Trump may get worse but so far >CBS News poll — Trump has positive approval amid "energetic" opening weeks; seen as doing what he promised (CBS polliing article https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-approval-opinion-poll-2025-2-9/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-approval-opinion-poll-202...) I think the fix may be more for the Democrats to change closer to what the origins of their name mean - people power - and align more with what the average people want rather than the leftmost 10%.
- dkjaudyeqooe 2y agoEvery president (almost) gets a honeymoon period, you have to wait a few months before you get a reading on popularity.
- tim333 2y agoTrue, but we'll probably have a bit of a mess and then he leaves in elections in four years in the normal manner.
- kccoder 2y agoHe didn't leave last time "in the normal manner," why would he do so this time? He's been hinting at a third term. I hope you're right and we have a normal election with a peaceful transfer of power in four years, but I'll believe it when I see it.
- slowmovintarget 2y agoRight. All this breathless speculation over authoritarianism is bullcrap when what's actually going on is rooting out deeply entrenched bureaucracy, cleaning up corruption and waste, and securing the borders. The fact that the Trump administration is complying with judicial orders (many of which are unconstitutional on their face) that will be overturned on appeal is evidence that these are not authoritarian moves. President Trump was voted in to do what he's doing. The fact that the Democrats are screaming bloody murder about him doing things they don't like doesn't suddenly transform the actions into authoritarianism. > Authoritarianism is a political system characterized by the rejection of political plurality, the use of strong central power to preserve the political status quo, and reductions in democracy, separation of powers, civil liberties, and the rule of law. -- Wikipedia Strong-arm tactics to preserve the power of the state and entrench one-party control were what was happening under the previous two Democrat administrations. What's happening now is a dismantling of those control structures in government. The funneling of billions of dollars out through NGOs and back in to DNC coffers and news organizations is stopping and the people on the gravy train are flipping out. Good.