4 ms·
> The law firm says the surgeon made false claims. (Which claims? Were they false?) The letter seems clear to me, and unfortunately for the doctor they have re
by Aurornis 2y ago
> The law firm says the surgeon made false claims. (Which claims? Were they false?)
The letter seems clear to me, and unfortunately for the doctor they have receipts (phone call recordings and the paperwork)
The biggest problem for the doctor is that they have a record of the doctor conceding that the wrong paperwork was submitted by her office (hence the call) and that the UHC rep asked for her to call back when convenient (not in the middle of surgery).
I think the UHC doctor got carried away, assumed all mistakes were on UHC’s end rather than her own admin staff, and then went to TikTok to tell a viral story with an exaggerated (at best) version of events.
> Alas, I guess "big company vs plucky surgeon in social media spat" is a simple script that requires no work, we don't need to be curious about who the hero(ine) and the villain are.
This mentality that we must pick a side, where one side is good and the other side is bad, is a huge problem with social media ragebait.
We can admit that the surgeon was wrong to make a viral TikTok with information that was somewhere between very misleading and an outright lie. Admitting this doesn’t make UHC the good guy or the hero.
You don’t have to pick a side. You shouldn’t automatically assume viral TikToks are true because they are targeted at companies you dislike.
- xp84 2y agoAs far as I'm concerned, I still appreciate the propaganda value of a story even if it's full of half-truths like this one, because it's time for a reckoning for these companies. There's a tiny, like 1% chance, that someday we'll have the opportunity to institute single payer and kill these businesses full of sickening, greedy ghouls overnight, and anything that helps convince people of their sins so that they won't doubt that it's worth doing, I'm okay with. They've earned it with their many, many, 100% factual bad deeds. And they've never been above lying. I admit that taking this attitude toward falsehoods isn't 100% ethical, judged by itself, but if it helps to end a system that has killed many thousands and will continue to do until it is abolished, this is a rare case where I'm ok with the ends justifying the means.
- gruez 2y ago>As far as I'm concerned, I still appreciate the propaganda value of a story even if it's full of half-truths like this one, because it's time for a reckoning for these companies. Just like "2 weeks to flatten the curve" and "masks don't work"? There's no way that "the ends justifies the means, a little lie to advance our cause" would backfire, right?
- xp84 2y agoIndeed, I didn't like the dishonesty there. There's probably many situations where you're absolutely right. It's just that my hatred for this industry is too strong to grant them any quarter even when they're technically in the right. Because the fact is true that even though they probably didn't demand to speak to the surgeon immediately, there's a reason the staff deemed it worth pulling her from surgery, and it's because if she didn't get to talk to the caller right now when they were on the phone, it could be any number of days before the matter could be resolved, and the hospital may not be willing to proceed if the insurance company is going to deny the claim, since that could saddle the patient with an unexpected $10,000 bill. In this way, our shitty system, designed on purpose by companies like UHC, forced most of this to happen.
- gruez 2y ago>Indeed, I didn't like the dishonesty there. There's probably many situations where you're absolutely right. It's just that my hatred for this industry is too strong to grant them any quarter even when they're technically in the right. You know what's arguably worse than insurance companies? Racists. So when there's a mysterious flu coming out of China and racists are latching onto it as a way to hate on Chinese people (eg. "China flu"), we better downplay it[1] so we don't give them any rhetorical ammo. [1] https://www.cnn.com/asia/live-news/coronavirus-outbreak-01-27-20-intl-hnk#h_02f66cdf54b4b06f9daf7de5ab3091e3 https://www.cnn.com/asia/live-news/coronavirus-outbreak-01-2... >there's a reason the staff deemed it worth pulling her from surgery [...] Sounds like you're giving infinite charity to the doctor/staff and not allowing for any possibility that any sort of mistake on their end. Is this based off of any facts, or your "hatred for this industry is too strong to grant them any quarter even when they're technically in the right"?
- franktankbank 2y agoI like how this case hinges on whether the call center employee said "at your convenience". It seems like its double edged to even admit such a thing.
- gruez 2y agoWhy? They presumably have recordings so it's unlikely to going to devolve to a "he said she said" situation, and I'm not sure how else you would rephrase "at your convenience" so the doctor wouldn't scrub out. Does every interaction need a 1 paragraph disclaimer to guard against a social media shitstorm?
- franktankbank 2y agoThe fact that a Doctor has to be worried about this shit at all is damning. The fact that a patient doesn't even pick their insurance (mostly tied to employer HR) is damning. The fact that a group can own the whole vertical is damning. The whole mechanism is a knot and anything less than untying it is going to have scary consequences I think.
- TheCoelacanth 2y agoIt also matters whether they are actually reachable at your convenience. A lot of business are virtually impossible to actually talk to unless you answer their call. They say to call back at your convenience, but you will only get their voicemail or an infinite waiting queue.
- nineplay 2y agoThe call center employee said 'at your convivence' knowing full well that they'd never be available at a convenient time.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoIt was 2024, it should not hinge on that at all. We have asynchronous communications, a timestamped email should be all the proof required. If UNH requires others to communicate with them via complicated phone trees that waste callers' time, then that means UNH is automatically at fault.
- legitster 2y agoIf anything, the doctor is admitting to a potential crime! Medical providers aren't supposed to deny procedures based on insurance coverage. Even if UHC called during surgery to say the claim was denied, it's the doctor's choice to do the surgery of not.
- mlyle 2y ago> Medical providers aren't supposed to deny procedures based on insurance coverage. This is false. There's EMTALA, which requires that emergency services will be provided until a patient can be transferred. But doctors absolutely refuse to provide services based on ability to pay all the time.
- legitster 2y agoGood point. But as the original story made the rounds on social media, it got exaggerated to make it sound like this was a life-threatening surgery. Knowing that it was a routine call and it was a plastic surgery procedure definitely deflates the scandal of the whole thing.
- ceejayoz 2y agoRemoving a brain tumor is "life-threatening surgery", but it won't be subject to EMTALA requirements.
- nradov 2y agoWell that would depend on the facts of a particular case. If a patient presents at the ER with a brain tumor which is causing severe symptoms such as unstable vital signs then under EMTALA the hospital might be legally required to remove the tumor regardless of the patient's ability to pay.
- ceejayoz 2y agoNo; the tumor itself would be non-emergent. The symptoms it causes - pain, for example - would be treated, then the patient would be discharged with a suggestion of a follow up with oncology.
- ranger_danger 2y agoThank you for such a well articulated response, I agree with you. I am not a surgeon but I have experience standing right next to them during surgeries. In my opinion, they already know that there is never a need to take a phone call from an insurance company during a case. Other reasons for a call may exist, sure, that part is not out of the ordinary... but insurance approval would have already happened before the case had ever started. Plus the overnight stay is not part of the billing for the surgery itself anyways.
- nineplay 2y ago> the UHC rep asked for her to call back when convenient (not in the middle of surgery) I'll echo the above poster - when an insurance rep calls us we drop everything on the floor and rush to answer it because otherwise they will continue to deny our claim and not get back for weeks. Then they reject our claim because it's now outside their 3 month window.
- legitster 2y agoIn this case though, the claim should have been denied because it was filed incorrectly. Is there also a reason the surgeon themselves needs to get on the phone with insurance? Isn't that what the rest of the staff is for?
- nineplay 2y ago> the claim should have been denied because it was filed incorrectly Spoken like someone who has never spent hours online with an insurance company. They have told me that they can't see uploaded forms due to a 'glitch'. They have told me fields were missing when I am looking at the same forms and telling them where the field is and what it contains. They have been carefully instructed to tell lie after lie after lie hoping that the consumer finally gives up.
- y33t 2y agoI've seen the same damned thing. Even when the state has previously gotten involved on behalf of a patient, I've seen insurance try to deny a surgery less than an hour before it was scheduled. Patient's husband called up the state and they said to not worry about it, they'd handle it. But even still, insurance companies do not stop trying it. The penalties they get are a joke to them. Executives need to face criminal penalties and be locked up in federal prison. Fuck it put em in Gitmo, those people are terrorizing us all.
- nineplay 2y agoThe goal is to wear you out and it's the context missing from the discussion. An external observer could look at any of my contested insurance claims and say 'They asked for more information, you gave it to them, the claim was approved, so what is the problem?" What's missing is all the days I had to get up, check on my claim, and call them because the claim was still denied and they sure weren't going to call me. What's missing is the hours I spent on the phone with them taking them step-by-step through the same issue each time.
- IG_Semmelweiss 2y agoI think the false claims were on the Tiktok, but the crux that i detect is the issue "UHC called doctor out of OR" is likely true even if UHC didn't intend it that way. >>The letter seems clear to me Where is the letter? >> doctor conceding that the wrong paperwork was submitted by her office (hence the call) That is a strong assumption to make. The tack you are taking is that one of the 2 parties noticed a wrong PA was requested (and approved) and tried to do something about it, preop. That's the assumption. IF the PA was fine, and that's 100% shenanigans by UHC. Less likely, but still very possible.
- karuselli 2y agoStarts at 0:07 into the doctor’s video here (I don’t think she posted the document outside of this format): https://x.com/epottermd/status/1888397730784883096?s=46 https://x.com/epottermd/status/1888397730784883096?s=46