4 ms·
My Wife's Enemies Are Now My Enemies, Too (2019)
- bell-cot 2y ago> Swearing to hate my wife’s [numerous, and often for trivial reasons] enemies has made me a better, more rounded person. Not only does it give me a benchmark for measuring my loyalty to her, but it’s made me more resolute in my own beliefs. Because all the spiting and snubbing of her foes has shown me how much colder I could be to the people I already didn’t like. Nice that he believes(?) it worked out well for him. But I've know people who married enemy-collecting spouses - and that usually wasn't so happy. Plus, if the marriage hits a rocky patch, be ready for a really ugly divorce.
- recursivedoubts 2y agoThat's a good thing, I suppose, because I am told you are supposed to love your enemies. I have found that advice paradoxical, confounding & frustrating, in turns, but ultimately very effective.
- whatshisface 2y agoI don't think it's that confounding, your enemies are just mad, and your abusers think of you more like a resource than an opponent.
- Dalewyn 2y ago>When the person you love decides that someone in the world brings him or her only frustration and pain, that person is your enemy, even if that person has always been cool to you in the past, or you’ve never actually met the person, or your partner has never actually met the person. The more you love someone, the more ardently you should feel not just obligated but driven to want to destroy the people your loved one wishes ill. If you're going to betray a friend just like that, you're a mentally ill asshole rather than a loving family man.
- ubermonkey 2y agoThat's... a wild take. Your spouse is your partner. This is your primary relationship. If someone you know is treating them poorly, and you choose to retain that friendship because, you know "gee, they've always been cool to me," then you're being grievously disloyal to the person who should matter more than anyone else in your life.
- whatshisface 2y agoYou're overlooking the subtle different between someone doing wrong to your wife, and someone being your wife's enemy. Relationships where you're expected to cut off all your previous friendships are some of the most prototypically abusive ones.
- Dalewyn 2y ago>If someone you know is treating them poorly That's the thing though, re-read what the author said very carefully: "that person is your enemy, even if that person has always been cool to you in the past, ... or your partner has never actually met the person." If your spouse decides for any or no reason to hate your friend that they never even met, you're just an asshole if you then decide to mirror that sentiment just because.
- c22 2y agoWow, this guy's wife sounds like a real catch.
- dole 2y agoI know the type, my top 10 friend suggestions on any given social platform are people I'm supposed to hate and usually in-laws.
- pricees 2y agoI remember when I re-met, online, a kid from my high school that I had picked on and bullied. Years later, we were grown up, matured, but I nevertheless felt bad for the way I treated him. Why did I treat him this way? Well, I can't answer that exactly. However, I do know that my first impressions of him were force-fed to me by my peers. I never even got to know the kid I bullied. I just did it to feel part of the crowd, among other reasons that I work through with therapy. Now, I take the different approach. My wife can have enemies. My friends can have enemies. But I stay out of gossip (which gossipers hate) and off social media. I can listen to my wife vent, I don't have the luxury of hating people or cutting people out of my life for trivial reasons. I thought this article was meant to be a sarcastic take on the emotional toxicity pervading most of society today. It reads like the diary of a codependent sociopath, which makes for entertaining television, but a miserable life.
- quesera 2y agoThank you for growing up. Not everyone does.
- midtake 2y agoEven my wife's friends are often my enemies too. Maybe it's just me, but it seems that being the man in a relationship has taken a nosedive in value in recent times.
- dr-detroit 2y ago[dead]
- ubermonkey 2y agoWhat does "being the man in a relationship" mean to you?
- skulk 2y agoIt means telling your wife she can't hang out with her friends.
- uncletaco 2y agoIf many of your wife’s friends hate you then it’s almost certainly just you.
- drawkward 2y agoIf this is satire, it's not very good. If this is not satire, it's not very good.
- marcosdumay 2y agoIf it's not satire, it's really, really bad.
- CommieBobDole 2y agoThe writer is a comedian, so I'm going to assume 'satire' or at least 'tongue-in-cheek'. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josh_Gondelman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josh_Gondelman
- drawkward 2y agoThen I suppose it should be funny?
- CommieBobDole 2y agoFunny is subjective. I don't find it particularly funny or good, but I guess the editor who published it did, which implies someone else might too.
- imajoke 2y agoIs this published in your column?
- drawkward 2y agoI am sure you will find that the vast majority of criticism is not published in a publication owned by the critic.
- sebastianconcpt 2y ago[flagged]
- morkalork 2y agoOr just don't have enemies? You can dislike someone as a person but framing them in your mind as an enemy is childish and gives them power over you. Or as the kids say these days "you're letting them live rent free in your head".
- michaelt 2y agoI don't have enemies. But also nobody's grabbing my ass in the workplace, making catty comments about my Jeff-Bezos-like appearance, or treating me like a secretary. If my partner reported being disrespected like that, though, you can guarantee I'd be on her side.
- apetresc 2y agoI don't understand how everyone here can be missing the sarcasm literally dripping off of every word in this article.
- uncletaco 2y ago> The more you love someone, the more ardently you should feel not just obligated but driven to want to destroy the people your loved one wishes ill. Bars.
- drawkward 2y agoPoe's law. (It's also not very well written.)
- Ylpertnodi 2y ago...wait for the EU comments.
- tonyedgecombe 2y agoFor whatever reason sarcasm doesn't seem to work with a predominantly American audience. Brits would get this straight away.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoBecause some of us know this to be a real thing, taken straight, word-for-word. If that was meant to be a comedy piece, the author accidentally wrote a factual article.
- dkarl 2y agoI think people are missing that this is humor. Its approach to the truth is not direct. It lays out a humorously extreme position and challenges us to articulate where, presumably somewhere in between the Vulcan rationalism it's so easy to project on the internet and the abject surrender the piece portrays, the truth really lies. It challenges us to figure out, to what extent can we deny these things about ourselves? Surely the entirety is an exaggeration, so which parts are untrue, and to what extent? If you don't approach it in that spirit, you waste your time reading it. And no, you don't have to be a genius about marriage to write something like this, but you would have to be a genius at marriage to read it and not feel in any way implicated.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 2y agoIf that's what it was trying to do, it failed, because the "humorously extreme position" is actually a real experience people have - or at least have with their partners, or see other couples that seem to have it.
- jancsika 2y agoYes, and you wrote it more succinctly than I did in a sibling comment. :) The specific problem as I understand it: marrying/dating a narcissist will spiral into utter toxicity 100% of the time. In that case the protagonist's difficulty separating reality from their own subject experience isn't something abstract to reflect upon. It's instead something akin to an evil demon charming them to butter them up for abuse which is made permanent through eternal gaslighting.
- ryandrake 2y agoI couldn't tell if it was humor, sarcasm, tongue-in-cheek, or just weird fiction. Talking casually about one's "enemies?" It's definitely not normal to have enemies. I certainly don't have any. Warlords have enemies. Extreme politicians have enemies. Am I just lucky? Or just super non-confrontational? I couldn't relate to a single word of this.
- ConspiracyFact 2y ago>Until about five years ago, I got along with basically everyone. Sometimes, I knew, people didn’t care for me, but my impeccable get-along instincts and crushing fear of confrontation prevented things from coming to a head very often. And if I didn’t like someone, I’d try to never let them know, because even if the sight of them made my stomach curdle, I still wanted them to like me. I usually don't mind a bit of self-deprecation but this makes it hard to want to read the rest of the article.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoCan confirm the phenomenon. For better or worse, I seem to never have developed the ability to hate people. I understand the concept of an enemy in the abstract, I can even emphasize with someone when they're talking about their enemies (but only if we're talking life or death, or comparable degree of trauma, and then only if I don't start thinking too much about it) - but I can't really classify anyone in my life as one. I might not like someone, feel threatened by them, but I can't bring myself to hate them - instead, I'll invent 20 different rationalizations for their behavior and hypothetical mutually-beneficial compromises. I'm not bragging here - at this point in life, I'm not even convinced this is healthy[0], and it sure makes me struggle with being assertive as an adult. Now, connect that with what the article says. I too, along with my lovely wife, inherited a set of enemies-in-law, and developed deep feelings of desire and obligation to hate the people she hates. Except at the same time, I can't. Josh Gondelman in the TFA wrote: > My wife’s enemies are now mine, and the rationale behind why doesn’t really matter. Reasons great and small both count, not equally but heavily. Unfortunately, for me, the reasons still matter. It took me a while to stop instinctively jumping to defend the enemies-in-law whenever she mentioned them, even those I never met. It took me even longer to accept that this is one of those "your partner needs you to listen, not to solve the problem" case - here, she isn't looking for conflict resolution, but rather to vent frustration. And while I still ain't gonna badmouth anyone for anything, I do accept the silent compromise of "if I can't say something mean about them, I won't say anything at all". It still feels like emulating hatred, though. I'm not sure if I'm in a good place, or denying myself some healthy part of humanity, but I can't imagine the mindset the author has: > Swearing to hate my wife’s enemies has made me a better, more rounded person. Not only does it give me a benchmark for measuring my loyalty to her, but it’s made me more resolute in my own beliefs. Because all the spiting and snubbing of her foes has shown me how much colder I could be to the people I already didn’t like. I mean, like why? Why people want to have enemies? -- [0] - I'm pretty sure it's the result of me developing my moral compass as a kid from two "role models" simultaneously: fundamentalist Christianity and Star Trek: TNG. I bet it's about as healthy as it sounds. But then, I mostly like what I got out from it, and it could've been worse.
- gedy 2y ago> this is one of those "your partner needs you to listen, not to solve the problem" case - here, she isn't looking for conflict resolution, but rather to vent frustration. I hate to sound callous, but I don't like to normalize that the problem is "you just want to fix things" - it's a huge mental burden on the listener and not respectful to people who get a lot of stress hearing these things. "Fixing something" is how they deal with stress. Everybody has to vent sometimes/infrequently and we should listen, but I've also been around a lot of people who want to "vent", but then march repeatedly right back into the same patterns and situations that cause the problems, and don't want to hear that they can often avoid this. I don't want people to feel better temporarily and end up prolonging their bad situation.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]