8 ms·
The author estimates that electricity prices would be reduced by up to 33% (from $0.45 blended rate to $0.30), but PG&E’s profit margins are only 11%. That’s a
by Aurornis 2y ago
The author estimates that electricity prices would be reduced by up to 33% (from $0.45 blended rate to $0.30), but PG&E’s profit margins are only 11%. That’s a good hint that this hypothetical is missing some important details
The article hedges against someone pointing this out by admitting that Walnut Creek is an unusually optimistic location and that PG&E is also recognizing large expenses related to ongoing infrastructure buildouts, but no solutions are offered for these caveats.
The hidden problem with projects like this is that once you roll these utilities into the city’s budget it’s too tempting to start dipping into taxpayer funds for needed improvements rather than raising electricity rates. When problems arise, politicians try to kick it down the road so it becomes their successor’s problem, or they try to offload the expense onto a growing debt load because that delays the problem to the next generation. It becomes easier to keep the highly visible rate down, but taxes might go up to cover the infrastructure costs instead.
So I’m skeptical. If there was an analysis that showed a drop in rates that was not 3X higher than the profit margins of the private utility I’d be more open to the idea, but as presented this feels like back of the envelope math that generates savings by ignoring all the details that didn’t make their way onto the envelope.
- colechristensen 2y ago>The author estimates that electricity prices would be reduced by up to 33% (from $0.45 blended rate to $0.30), but PG&E’s profit margins are only 11%. That’s a good hint that this hypothetical is missing some important details PG&E customers are paying very large amounts for the consequences of bad infrastructure causing wildfires and other legal costs which are being paid for with higher rates. Example: https://www.ewg.org/news-insights/news-release/2022/12/pge-asks-california-regulators-recover-136b-ratepayers-cost https://www.ewg.org/news-insights/news-release/2022/12/pge-a...
- Aurornis 2y agoRight, but that’s my point: You can’t assume these costs disappear if the government takes over. They just get blended into the tax bill.
- necubi 2y agoHe’s talking about local governments in places that have little or no fire risk. Should people living in dense cities be paying to underground power lines to rural communities hundreds of miles away?
- colechristensen 2y agoPG&E is a private company, much of the responsibility for their wildfire costs are the result of mismanagement of the risks. Their costs get shouldered by their customers and their stock price. (they really should issue shares to pay their bills to dilute their stock price and cause their existing investors to lose money). In any case it's not going to get very willingly picked up by the government. PG&E's liabilities aren't going to be put into taxes. It's not the state government taking over PG&E, it's individual municipalities leaving the PG&E network and forming their own utility to buy wholesale electricity (or make some of their own) and distribute it to their citizens... resulting in a large reduction in cost in no small part because they no longer have to pay for PG&E's liabilities.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jncfhnb 2y agoNo, their argument is sound. It’s just missing the point of utilities. They’re saying that the cost of providing electricity to the cities, where everything is densely located and there are fewer trees and fewer overhead lines needing under grounding is lower so they should charge less to city consumers. They imply that the bulk of the cost is delivering power to the richer consumers further out because there’s a lot of line miles that need under grounding. That’s probably accurate. But utilities are restricted from pricing like that because you don’t want utilities triaging customers that are less profitable. The article here makes the argument that the far away and expensive customers are rich, therefore fuck ‘em. I’m not familiar with California but I doubt this is true across the board. There are surely notably rich communities far from the city but surely there are also poorer areas further from the city that are relatively cheaper because the commute is worse.
- jeffbee 2y agoMaybe, but it's also clear that rural electrification was a huge error. People should live in clusters of at least a handful of structures where it's practical and affordable to provision electric lines (and telecommunications), or they should be off the grid altogether. What we built in the 20th century was the worst possible thing: mile after mile of transmission and distribution equipment serving dispersed houses in forests. This should never have been built and we should not perpetuate it with subsidies: https://www.google.com/maps/@38.4638277,-120.656418,3a,75y,303.07h,100.82t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sfib7zJBdnKVsH3yzgIV0Jw!2e0!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.googleapis.com%2Fv1%2Fthumbnail%3Fcb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile%26w%3D900%26h%3D600%26pitch%3D-10.821915535625621%26panoid%3Dfib7zJBdnKVsH3yzgIV0Jw%26yaw%3D303.0698026053538!7i13312!8i6656?entry=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI1MDIwNS4xIKXMDSoASAFQAw%3D%3D https://www.google.com/maps/@38.4638277,-120.656418,3a,75y,3...
- hypothesis 2y agoEh, but we should not leave people without basics of civilization. Yes, it’s a subsidy, but benefits outweigh hoarding of wealth.
- 2y ago
- bitmasher9 2y agoI don’t think profit margin is the correct way to calculate their expenses. For one, it includes expenses outside of the municipality. For another, corporations are often okay overspending on executive compensation and other lavish business expenses for tax purposes.
- EduardoBautista 2y agoGovernments are often okay overspending on government contracts.
- greesil 2y agoWhat about
- Aurornis 2y ago> For one, it includes expenses outside of the municipality. Exactly. The cherry picked example in the article was chosen to ignore areas with higher expenses. > For another, corporations are often okay overspending on executive compensation PG&E had $25 billion revenue last year. How much do you think they spent on lavish executive compensation? Even if you could eliminate $100 million in compensation (doubtful) that’s still less than 0.1% of revenues. People overestimate the impact of executive compensation in large companies by orders of magnitude. > and other lavish business expenses for tax purposes. Again, you’re not going to find dramatic savings anywhere in the budget by cutting lavish business expenses at this scale. It’s noise. There’s also a persistent myth that companies can spend their way into saving money via tax write-offs, but for some reason my accountant tells me that’s not how taxes work.
- gamblor956 2y ago162(m) limits a company's deduction for executives (and other highly compensated employees) compensation to $1m per exec/employee. Or in other words, companies aren't overspending on exec compensation for tax purposes. They're doing so because the board is not exercising proper financial control over the company.
- apercu 2y ago
- shiftpgdn 2y agoWhat is PG&Es generation cost vs administrative and legal overhead? The 11% margin isn't a good basis number. How is other states like Texas or Colorado are delivering at 10-12c/kwh ? I do agree with your sentiment that city bureaucrats may be tempted to raid the energy business to pay for pet projects and other things. This can be protected against by segmenting the energy business into its own protected organization.
- Aurornis 2y ago> What is PG&Es generation cost vs administrative and legal overhead? The 11% margin isn't a good basis number. Administrative and legal costs don’t disappear when the city runs it, so why does it matter? When the city runs a utility, nearly all of the costs associated with running a utility still exist. If your mental model of a city-owned utility is that they’re going to generate power and sell it at cost with no administrative overhead, you’re really just assuming that administrative overhead will be covered by taxpayers. Electricity rates down, tax rates up. > How is other states like Texas or Colorado are delivering at 10-12c/kwh ? Texas produces the most crude oil, natural gas, and also wind generated electricity. A quarter of the entire country’s wind energy generation happens in Texas. Comparing electricity prices across regions is meaningless. Everything is too different.
- roenxi 2y agoThe basic argument on Texas seems to be: "Texas avoided 75% of the costs in California by doing everything differently. California can't learn anything from them because they do things differently". That seems like a weak argument. California would have to do things quite differently to get a 75% cost reduction. It is stereotyping, but it sounds like the sort of state that has a strong regulatory regime that would be quite controlling about what people can actually do. I note the irony that when Texas had a power outage everyone wanted much more regulation to force changes to grid maintenance, but when California spends 4x as much and PG&E skips on grid maintenance everyone throws their hands up because they can't call for more regulation and are out of ideas. The regulation doesn't seem to have dodged the maintenance problems but I'd bet it drives the cost up.
- renewiltord 2y agoOne of the things we find with cost-plus contracting is that the team providing the service somehow has a great deal of costs. Ironically, abandoning this approach leads to hiring higher margin businesses which nonetheless cost less. A confusing phenomenon when one doesn't account for the fact that people optimize to get more money ceteris paribus.
- AnotherGoodName 2y agoLess than 20c per kWh for my local city power - https://www.cityofpaloalto.org/files/assets/public/v/5/utilities/rates-schedules-for-utilities/residential-utility-rates/e-1-effective-2024-07-01.pdf https://www.cityofpaloalto.org/files/assets/public/v/5/utili... About half the price of PG&E. This is in an otherwise PG&E area. People should be demanding their city handle power. It leads to half the price.
- Aurornis 2y ago> People should be demanding their city handle power. It leads to half the price. My power is significantly cheaper than yours but it comes from a private company. Picking random cities doesn’t tell us anything at all about costs or efficiency. Different areas have different costs and expenses. You have to compare apples to apples.
- AnotherGoodName 2y agoThis is a PG&E area as stated charging ~40c per kWh as stated by the post above?
- musicale 2y agoIt's interesting that 1) there are PG&E areas in Palo Alto (such as the Stanford University campus) and 2) PG&E manages the transmission grid for the whole SF Bay Area. Stanford endured lengthy PG&E power outages while the municipal utility continued to operate. However, the university probably has negotiated rates that are lower than what regular PG&E customers pay in Palo Alto.
- vlovich123 2y agoWhat city in the Bay Area is that out of curiosity?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dv_dt 2y agoProfit margins don't reflect how efficiently they manage costs. It could as easily be the case the PG&E mismanages resources and costs more to deliver the same power.
- darth_avocado 2y agoProfit margins are low because they need to pay $20M in opex for the CEO’s bonus.
- asats 2y agoIf I'm not mistaken that's 0.08% of their revenue.
- ceejayoz 2y agoHe won’t be the only person getting a bonus. Or a fancy office conference table. Or offsite team building exercises in Hawaii.
- gruez 2y ago>Or a fancy office conference table Even smaller order of magnitude than executive comp >offsite team building exercises in Hawaii. Source this actually happens to an extent that would materially affect the balance sheet?
- ceejayoz 2y agoThey add up. Private plane: https://www.sfgate.com/business/article/executives-at-pg-e-hoping-to-fly-in-style-2535959.php https://www.sfgate.com/business/article/executives-at-pg-e-h... You hire your buddy’s company as a consultant or contractor, too. At a sweet rate.
- gruez 2y ago>to an extent that would materially affect the balance sheet?
- jf 2y agoThe highest price that the city owned electric utility in Alameda, CA charges on the standard rate schedule is $0.29453 / kWh https://www.alamedamp.com/DocumentCenter/View/1268/FY25-Rate-Summary-Final https://www.alamedamp.com/DocumentCenter/View/1268/FY25-Rate... Edit: Oh, this utility runs at a profit and has for decades. The profits have been going into undergrounding transmission lines
- abathur 2y agoNot trying to neg how you phrased it, but I wonder if the whole damn system would be a smidge better if we had strong well-worn widely-used terms to discriminate between profit-taken and surplus-reinvested (and maybe to further discriminate between unrelated r&d, related r&d, and direct performance/capacity/resiliency/etc. investments)
- vlovich123 2y agoCan you distinguish effective investment from ineffective? For example, paying competitively to attract and retain talent can be seen as an investment as well. And before you restrict it to just physical infrastructure investment, a non-trivial part of the cost of that infrastructure is in salaries and also how you manage everything at scale and I would think you’d want to incentivize more efficiency there too. This is why the tax code gets so insanely complicated.
- abathur 2y agoI'm a little unsure how to take you here, because I avoided dragging the efficacy of an investment into frame on purpose. Maybe you just mean to tack on the idea that we could benefit from having better language to separate shrewd and incompetent investments, in which case I'm ~fine with some language to retcon the difference between merely lighting investments on fire and using them to drive an engine back on to those investments once we know the difference. But if you mean to suggest that it's pointless for us to bother discriminating between profit-taken and investment-(effective|ineffective) just because we don't know whether the cat is dead or alive yet, then I suspect I disagree to the death. (Edit: In case I'm being obtuse, I at least think I agree that "investing" surplus in hiring and retaining great employees is a surplus-invested, and not a profit-taken.)
- nwiswell 2y agoAs of 1/1/2025 the residential average rate paid for the municipal utility of Santa Clara, CA is $0.175/kWh vs a residential average of $0.425/kWh for PG&E https://www.siliconvalleypower.com/residents/rates-and-fees https://www.siliconvalleypower.com/residents/rates-and-fees PG&E has an 11% margin on those rates because they keep burning the state down and having to pay for it. Municipal utilities don't have to worry about that. The only thing that could be seriously considered a downside is that Santa Clara, CA is now absolutely jam-packed with data centers that have low employment per sqft.
- theptip 2y ago> prices would be reduced by up to 33% (from $0.45 blended rate to $0.30), but PG&E’s profit margins are only 11%. This is addressed right at the beginning of the article. The argument is not that PG&E is skimming off huge profits, rather that it is structurally inefficient: > Distribution: How much to get the power from your local substation to your house over local power lines. In PG&E's rate chart, they charge 20 cents per kilowatt hour for this. That just does not match up with how much it actually costs them to transmit power over local lines and keep the lines maintained. > Everything else: Operations, maintenance, profit. This is where PG&E is actually seeing large expenses, because their coverage area is massive, it costs a lot of money to deliver power to rural customers, and they are also undertaking a massive project to underground utility lines in fire-prone areas. The backstory here is that PG&E underfunded maintenance for decades while paying out substantial dividends to shareholders, and now that fires are killing lots of people, they have to go back and properly maintain their network. Now, you can make the case that CA as a whole might not be better off if cities leave PG&E and the state has to subsidize rural power delivery even further, but I think the article is correct on the question that it tackles.
- kevinburke 2y agoI'm the author here. The cost savings come from not having people who live in cities pay for undergrounding lines and maintaining power lines in rural areas. Maintaining the city networks is much cheaper. This is why Santa Clara, Palo Alto and Alameda's power companies can deliver power for half of what PG&E can. You can just copy their cost structure.
- nocoiner 2y agoCool. Now you’ve just undone 70 years of rural electrification in the United States. Optimizing for factors other than universal service is completely valid, but I’m guessing each of those municipal power systems pre-dated rural electrification and thereby get to somewhat free ride on the system more than anyone would reasonably allow Walnut Creek to do in the year 2025.
- 2y ago
- kevinburke 2y agoHighly recommend reading the state LAO report which goes into the cost structure behind the large utilities. https://lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/4950 https://lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/4950 As well as Palo Alto's utility financial statement which is linked in the post.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThe idea is there are parts of California where life is heavily subsidised. Paying PG&E as a low fire risk community is a net transfer out. (How the Bay Area hasn’t done its own grid à la Santa Clara is wild.)
- ryao 2y agoThe author addressed that discrepancy: PG&E's current rate structure has urban rate payers subsidize rural rate payers and people who live in wildfire zones in e.g. the Orinda Hills, who need substantial investment in order to receive power without sparking wildfires. This is bad policy - instead of subsidizing fire zones, it should be cheap to live in safe places and more expensive to live in dangerous places. Lower cost of electricity would reverse these trends.
- gnopgnip 2y agoUntil recently I lived in Alameda with AMP for municipal power. Consumers pay about half what PG&E charges. AMP has a net profit and provides some revenue for the city each year. You can see the most recent financial statement here. https://www.alamedamp.com/DocumentCenter/View/1187/AMP-ACFR-FY23-Final https://www.alamedamp.com/DocumentCenter/View/1187/AMP-ACFR-... Sacramento with SMUD is another success story. But there are some differences with economies of scale
- amluto 2y ago> The author estimates that electricity prices would be reduced by up to 33% (from $0.45 blended rate to $0.30), but PG&E’s profit margins are only 11%. One detail is that PG&E is a heavily and (IMO) incompetently regulated utility, and their profit margins are more or less set by regulation. So they inflate costs to drive up profits, and one should not assume that the only room for savings is removing their profit margin.
- fransje26 2y ago> So I’m skeptical. If there was an analysis that showed a drop in rates that was not 3X higher than the profit margins of the private utility I’d be more open to the idea, but as presented this feels like back of the envelope math that generates savings by ignoring all the details that didn’t make their way onto the envelope. That's possibly because of a strong underestimation of the actual indirect inefficiencies that come with shareholder profit-oriented companies. Every investment is seen not as a way to maximise profit in the long run, but as a direct decrease in shareholder profit, and should therefore be avoided at all cost (ha!) or postponed for as long as possible. Strong counterexamples, admittedly not from energy companies, can be found in the remunicipalisation of the water supplies in Berlin and in some districts of Paris. Both came with drastic decrease of user costs, better water quality and a decrease of outages.
- simonebrunozzi 2y agoi guarantee you that PG&E is nothing like an efficient company.