3 ms·
> but the nursing board goes to bat for nurses allowing independent practice while doctors have chosen in some states to sabotage PAs The way Nurse Practitione
by Aurornis 2y ago
> but the nursing board goes to bat for nurses allowing independent practice while doctors have chosen in some states to sabotage PAs
The way Nurse Practitioners are allowed to practice independently now is a contentious topic in the field because they’re now operating essentially as doctors, but with much less education and hands-on training.
The original idea was that NPs could handle a subset of simple and routine issues and leave the more complex issues for fully trained doctors. The current situation has NPs and doctors performing the same functions but with very different training, while patients are mostly unaware that there’s a difference.
It’s a common complaint on forums like /r/medicine because doctors are seeing a rapidly growing number of patients who have gotten bad advice or prescriptions from overconfident NPs, especially in states where NPs can prescribe controlled substances. Going the NP route is also the preferred direction for people who want to practice alternative medicine but have a prescription pad, leading a lot of patients unknowingly into the hands of NPs who actually shun large parts of traditional medicine.
Common problems around here are NPs who prescribe antibiotics on demand, some times dangerously powerful ones for extended periods of time. NPs writing long-term benzo prescriptions as first line treatment for anxiety (very bad practice) has created a mess of dependent patients who didn’t know what they were getting into, who end up back at fully trained providers who need to taper them off for sometimes as long as a year.
So it’s not as simple as medical licensing boards being mean. There are some very real problems with the current double standard of training between NPs and doctors.
- sarchertech 2y agoNP education is basically the Wild West. Much of it is practical training under a doctor, but unlike residency there is very little oversight and standardization.
- orwin 2y agoIn my country, you can be reimbursed on substance prescribed by a nurse (or any medical practitioner, including physical therapist) if its effect is proved, but only doctors can prescribe regulated substances, and this kind of prescription are typically monitored (and stats are made on those prescriptions. Why, i don't know yet, we set up the big data infrastructure like 5 years ago, so probably nothing yet). And there is another tier of regulated substance that you can only be prescribed at a hospital (rarely-used antibiotics, you must stay under surveillance while you take them to avoid creating resistance), and another tier that can only be prescribed by a specialist (methadone, lithium, probably a ton of others), but i would hope this is the same in the US.
- Aurornis 2y ago> but only doctors can prescribe regulated substances In the US this is determined at the state level, so it’s different depending on where you live. In many states, NPs can prescribe controlled substances now. This has become a problem in some areas with certain NPs prescribing Adderall, Xanax, or Ketamine at alarmingly high rates. We do have monitoring mechanisms and people can be flagged if their prescriptions are becoming a problem, but the system is slow to respond. The cases are publicly searchable and I spent some time reading my local cases last year. The reports were often unbelievable, with some NPs becoming locally known for prescribing certain drugs at high doses. You can even find tips about which NPs to go to on certain Reddits.
- dpkirchner 2y ago> It’s a common complaint on forums like /r/medicine because doctors are seeing a rapidly growing number of patients who have gotten bad advice or prescriptions from overconfident NPs, especially in states where NPs can prescribe controlled substances. I wonder how much of this is simply because people are more able to afford (or even merely schedule!) medical care because NPs are available. There are certainly a lot of doctors that overprescribe and give bad advice after all.