3 ms·
Governments who want power will hoard the knowledge, which is power. Other governments will share. This is perpetual tension: we collectively receive utility wh
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
Governments who want power will hoard the knowledge, which is power. Other governments will share. This is perpetual tension: we collectively receive utility when good policy is active (rapid dissemination of vuln info), but we need third parties to seek these exploits out when government cannot be relied on. Very similar to the concept of journalism being the Fourth Estate imho.
(vuln mgmt in finance is a component of my day gig)
- tptacek 2y agoThis is a little bit like talking about why they hoard the guns. The reason governments have caches of exploit chains is not hard to understand.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoYou're the expert, and certainly not wrong, I wrote my comment because I have had to explain this to folks in a professional capacity and thought it might be helpful.
- tptacek 2y agoIt's just a rhetoric thing. We're talking about the USG "hoarding" stuff, but, in a sense, the government has a conceptual monopoly on this kind of coercive capability. Anybody can find vulnerabilities and write exploits, but using them in anger and without mutual consent is an authority exclusively granted to law enforcement and intelligence agencies. This is just an extension of the "monopoly on violence". The longstanding objection to this is that secretly holding a gun doesn't intrinsically make everyone less safe, and there's a sense in which not disclosing a vulnerability does. That argument made more sense back in and before 2010; it doesn't make much sense now.
- DoctorOetker 2y agoIt is substantially different from hoarding guns: not hoarding exploits takes away those exploits from adversaries. If an important factor is the ratio of exploits A and B have, then publishing their hidden but common exploits the ratio does not remain the same. The ratio is interesting because potential exploitation rate is proportional zero days (once used, the "zero" day is revealed and remediated after a certain time span).
- thomastjeffery 2y agoYou can't hoard knowledge, just like you can't take it away.
- Xen9 2y agoOnly predictive capabilities & AI trained on data can be more valuable than having perfect profile of the person who turns out to be an enemy of your nation in whatever sense. Taking a person down once you know everyone they have ever talked, been interested about, or thought, is trivial. This can only be acheived by mass surveillance & hoarding. Arguably US as a nation state has the very best LLMs in the world, which is why I personally think they have been running weak AGI for few years, e.g. for autonomous malware analysis, reverse-engineering, and tailored malware generation & testing capability. Because they can actually store the personal data long term, without habing to delete it, this may be of gigantic strategic advantage due web being highly "polluted" after 2020-2021. I would from this guess US has bet on AI research since end of WWII, and especially within last 30 years, noting the rather highly remarkable possibility that Surveillance Capitalism is actually part of the nation's security effforts. The warehouses of data they have built are warehouses of gold, or rather, gold mixed in sand since of course lots of it is also garbage.
- Eisenstein 2y agoHas the US done anything that huge and kept it secret? The Manhattan project is the only one I can think of, and that involved sequestering the entirety of the nations top physicists, chemists, and metallurgists in the desert and employed 130,000 people. This was before the internet and during a time when Americans were unified in a war effort in a way that hasn't existed before or since.
- boringg 2y agoHuh? You absolutely can hoard knowledge and you can most certainly purge knowledge as well.