3 ms·
Even though "... anyone can RSVP, regardless of whether they have an Apple Account or Apple device" I think this being an Apple branded service is going to make
by PaulHoule 2y ago
Even though "... anyone can RSVP, regardless of whether they have an Apple Account or Apple device" I think this being an Apple branded service is going to make this appear exclusionary and will mean some people won't participate even if they could.
I see the same risk involved with Apple TV's branding; Apple TV works great on Xbox, on NVIDIA Shield and on PC. I'm sure though there are a lot of people who just decide that shows like Foundation and subscriptions like MLS Season's Pass just aren't for them. I don't know if it is a 5% or a 20% drop but it has to be real.
- EyMaddis 2y agoAs a non-exclusive, non-big tech and dead simple alternative, I’ve built Partey.io [1] myself. [1] https://partey.io https://partey.io
- 13_9_7_7_5_18 2y ago[dead]
- Brystephor 2y agoSoftware engineer here with an android phone. I've never bothered to look into Apple TV because I assumed it'd only be available on Apple devices. Similarly, I saw this post and thought there may be a reason for me to get an iPhone now as I assumed this would be available on apple devices only.
- echelon 2y ago> "there may be a reason for me to get an iPhone now as I assumed this would be available on apple devices only." That's the objective. Green text and all. To force everyone to adopt one platform because of network effects and social stigma. These platform plays by the god tier trillion dollar companies are insidious and should be given scrutiny by the DOJ / FTC. A breakup of these platforms would make none of this matter. You could pick and choose services across devices. We might even see some competition for Android and iPhone if the DOJ would step in and break this up. Big tech is too big. A breakup would oxygenate the entire tech sector. It would probably even make the MAGMA stock go up because the sum of parts are being given away for free just to get eyeballs. Billions of dollars are being given away for free to scrape in network effect advantages. It's at a level where competition from new players is virtually impossible. They can tax anything that moves. Every transaction, every relationship, every quanta of information.
- jbl0ndie 2y agoIt's pretty good on Chromecast, though some of the media player design patterns don't quite translate to non-apple.
- dboreham 2y agoI'm only aware it doesn't need an Apple device because spouse does have an iPhone and was able to set it up on our Roku that way. I still assume that someone in the household does need an iPhone in order to get a subscription, although now I think about it probably that's not true.
- sbuk 2y agoYou can subscribe to Apple TV+ directly through Amazon Prime.
- carlosjobim 2y agoThere's a dedicated physical button for it on the Roku remote. Kind of hard to miss.
- dkjaudyeqooe 2y ago> I think this being an Apple branded service is going to make this appear exclusionary and will mean some people won't participate even if they could. Don't you think that's kind of the point? Do you think having green and blue messaging bubbles was unintentional?
- karaterobot 2y agoYes it was intentional, but this is a different case. If a meaningful percentage of people don't think they can attend an event because they don't own an iPhone, that's a big problem for adoption of this product. Whether that will happen or not, I have no idea, but I think that's what the person you responded to was saying.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nonchalantsui 2y agoThe Apple TV one is particularly bad due to them naming the service, the box, and the app the same thing. One of them has a + tacked on, who knows which. As long as they don’t start naming other things Invite, they might avoid that issue. Although maybe they’ll name their HomePod with a screen that and we’re back to square one.
- aurareturn 2y agoOne of the rare marketing misses for Apple is naming the app, box, and service (with + added on) the same.
- PaulHoule 2y agoI was shocked at how bad the onboarding experience for Mac is in 2025. I replaced a dying but well seasoned Alienware laptop with a M4 mini, my wife was furious about 'ads everywhere' I mean, Microsoft is notorious for the unwanted solicitations that come with Windows but the nagging pop-ups that are barely altered from 1984 modal dialogs [1], dock crammed with unwanted applications, terrible Safari experience without ad blocker, need Apple account to install ad blocker (at least you can log into Windows with a Microsoft account.) So far as I can tell I didn't even get the 3 months of Apple TV that comes with an iPad. [1] OG mac, not Orwell. At least Microsoft nags look like HTML.
- Melatonic 2y agoSeriously - not sure what they were thinking - but this confuses the hell out of everyone (especially if they have the Apple TV+ app installed on their smart TV directly and an Apple TV physical box hooked to the same TV)
- nonchalantsui 2y agoLet's just hope they don't start producing TVs (the screens) alongside all of this!
- 2y ago
- echelon 2y ago> there are a lot of people who just decide that shows like Foundation and subscriptions like MLS Season's Pass just aren't for them. This needs anti-trust breakup. Tech companies shouldn't be media giants. They're turning a once-healthy media industry into an attention economy platform play, giving it away below cost, and wringing a robust sector of the economy of its value. It's disgusting that Apple and Amazon are doing this. Amazon owns James Bond. And they're a grocery store and primary care doctor, for god's sake. That's not good. This is worse than Standard Oil and Ma Bell because they own our entire lives: eyeballs, financial transactions, business matters, commerce, and personal relationships.
- wrfrmers 2y ago"Conglom-O: We Own You." ...Just to highlight the absurdity of the situation. Literally cartoonish corruption.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- makeitdouble 2y agoIt will feel that way at a distance because it basically is. To start, it's not a service but an app. Sure there is a web interface, but the focus on the app already sets the stage (which also puts macos only users in an interesting position). Then non-Apple users probably can only respond when the sales pitch is "to contribute to Shared Albums, and engage with Apple Music playlists" If I'm not an Apple user there will only be downsides to using this service compared to any other one.