3 ms·
> non-existent “cancel culture” Wow I've never heard anyone deny the very existence of cancel culture before. Or is this some kind of semantic distinction-with
by IshKebab 2y ago
> non-existent “cancel culture”
Wow I've never heard anyone deny the very existence of cancel culture before. Or is this some kind of semantic distinction-without-a-difference?
- dragonwriter 2y ago“Cancel culture” as a distinct novel thing doesn't exist; ostracism of people that diverge from a group’s values has existed forever, “cancel culture” is just a name applied to it by those indulging in certain beliefs that had previously been unquestionably dominant after they had become sufficiently controversial that those opposed to them were a significant-enough group that the ostracism that that previously dominant group had previously applied to its opponents sometimes had substantial impact in the other direction.
- tbrownaw 2y ago> “Cancel culture” as a distinct novel thing doesn't exist Remember that something being a culture is about pervasiveness and normalization. It's not a mob harassing your employer because you posted photos with the wrong brand of political attire; it's it being culturally acceptable for a mob to harass your employer because you posted photos with the wrong brand of political attire. Sure people protesting things is old, like you say. As are groups deciding to not associate with certain people. But that is not in fact the same a nominally-impartial authorities encouraging protests for the purpose of having an excuse to impose a hecklers' veto on things they don't like. And it is not the same as targeted harassment of anyone outside the ostracising group who doesn't bow to their demands.
- dragonwriter 2y ago> Remember that something being a culture is about pervasiveness and normalization. It's not a mob harassing your employer because you posted photos with the wrong brand of political attire; it's it being culturally acceptable for a mob to harass your employer because you posted photos with the wrong brand of political attire. And, and that's been true forever; in fact what is attributed to cancel culture is mild compared to what has been socially acceptable within living memory for displays of political wrongthink, what changed is that that comparatively mild social consequence became acceptable against the side which had previously only been the giver but not receiver of socially acceptable consequence for noncompliance with their norms.
- tshaddox 2y agoIt exists in the same sense that "pie attack culture" exists. Some people certainly have been pied in the face, so how could you deny that "pie attack culture" exists?
- tbrownaw 2y ago> Some people certainly have been pied in the face, so how could you deny that "pie attack culture" exists? By not being obtuse enough to conflate "this has happened at least once" with "this appears to be widely considered culturally acceptable".
- IshKebab 2y ago"Culture" means that it has become common and normalised. If there was a big uptick in pie attacks then sure, but there hasn't.
- pjc50 2y agoThe word got used to mean everything from "complaining about a bystander using a rude word on twitter" to "finally prosecuting somebody after enough credible rape allegations went public".