4 ms·
The legislative branch can recall both the president and the judges, but it won't do that because it is happy with what they are doing. Even a Democrat landsli
by immibis 2y ago
The legislative branch can recall both the president and the judges, but it won't do that because it is happy with what they are doing.
Even a Democrat landslide in two years wouldn't change it, because almost all Democratic politicians are unwilling to cause a fuss (or they are secretly happy with what the other branches are doing).
But the people are getting what they voted for, so is it really ethical to intervene in that?
- afavour 2y ago> But the people are getting what they voted for I think that’s extremely debatable. Last I checked “unauthorized access to confidential taxpayer information” was not an election topic. This is true on all sides of course, folks who voted for Obama didn’t vote for drone strikes against US citizens either. Winning a presidential election does not mean four years of dictatorship and silencing of criticism.
- Spooky23 2y agoWe (supposedly) elected a king. He’s exempt from all rule of law save spineless congressmen. Whether most of the people doing so were smart enough to understand it is a good question, but the fact is we put a Perón-like figure into office, and only age will likely make him leave.
- germinalphrase 2y agoFWIW, people thought that when Obama ran around saying “these extrajudicial drone strikes are illegal” they assumed that he would end them rather than do what he actually did - make them legal. Power Wars by Charlie Savage covers this rhetorical zig zag.
- CamperBob2 2y agoI think that’s extremely debatable. Last I checked “unauthorized access to confidential taxpayer information” was not an election topic Gee, I'm shocked, shocked, that a guy who stole large numbers of classified documents on his way out the door and stuffed them in unused bathrooms in his house(s) would fail to safeguard confidential taxpayer information. You're right, it wasn't an election topic. Nobody who had any power cared to make it one, nobody who cared had the power... and nobody else was paying attention.
- krapp 2y agoI don't think it's extremely debatable. Obama didn't run on drone strikes, but everything Trump is doing has been a part of the Trumpist or Republican fringe platform for years. The Republicans have wanted to defund and destroy government ever since Grover Norquist said he wanted government to be small enough to drown in a bathtub. Purging academia of DEI and "woke," aggressive anti-immigration policies, tariffs, rule through executive order, none of it is new, all of it is established, boilerplate Trump-era Republican doctrine. Trump ran on "draining the swamp." This is what "draining the swamp" means. The only real exception to the norm seems to be Trump's sudden hard-on for invading Greenland and Canada.But even then you can look back at his infamous comments on not wanting immigration from "shithole countries" like Haiti versus places like Norway, or his comments on Mexico sending rapists over the border, and see how he might want to forcibly annex a few million white people to balance out the scales of white replacement or whatever racist paranoid shit goes on in his head. I don't know. But let's please stop pretending no one who voted for Trump knew who he was or what he was about, or that what's happening now is not in effect what many Trump supporters wanted.
- maxerickson 2y agoWhat happened to all that soaring rhetoric about the tyranny of the majority?
- _petronius 2y ago> But the people are getting what they voted for, so is it really ethical to intervene in that? No electoral mandate (and the argument for a clear mandate for all of this is thin or nonexistent) makes unconstitutional/illegal action suddenly legal or constitutional. Whether anyone with the relevant power chooses to punish these violations, is a different matter. The choice since January 2020 has been to repeatedly do nothing in the face of illegal action, but winning elections doesn't make criminal action magically non-criminal.
- avmich 2y ago> No electoral mandate (and the argument for a clear mandate for all of this is thin or nonexistent) makes unconstitutional/illegal action suddenly legal or constitutional. Playing devil's advocate - but the people asked for this, right? Isn't it time to amend the constitution then? The will of people is the ultimate judge, isn't it?
- jakelazaroff 2y agoWhy are they operating illegally, then? If "the will of the people" is unified enough to change the Constitution, why not… do that?
- ryandrake 2y agoWhy go through all the trouble of amending the Constitution when you can just do whatever you want because nobody's going to stop you? Suppose Trump declared himself king tomorrow. Who with any power is going to push back? It doesn't matter if it's against the law if nobody cares about the law.
- jakelazaroff 2y agoI was responding to this: > Playing devil's advocate - but the people asked for this, right? Isn't it time to amend the constitution then? > The will of people is the ultimate judge, isn't it?
- 2y ago
- tyre 2y ago> they are secretly happy with what the other branches are doing Knowing people in democratic politics, this isn’t true. The root of the problem is that they don’t understand or prioritize power. They have overwhelming support for every major issue: abortion, gun control, corporate taxes, HNI taxes, healthcare, social security, climate, gay rights. All of them. And yet they lose. Minority on the Supreme Court, house, senate, presidency. Think about Obama’s first presidency. Sixty senators. What happens if they: 1. Make DC a state. That’s two senators. I don’t think they could get Puerto Rico. 2. Make Election Day a federal holiday. That spikes turnout, which benefits democrats (see: advantage in every major issue.) That’s the type of thinking that gives and maintains power. But they don’t think that way until it’s panic time and already over.
- avmich 2y agoHaving power for the purpose of having power isn't too meaningful. In democracies parties (already questionable concept) should ideally not worry about power, but worry about reaching useful goals.
- nine_k 2y agoIt's hard to reach a useful goal without power to do so. Also, think game-theoretically (or practically). If you don't dedicate at least some effort to gain and retain power, you will be displaced by those who do. The first priority of a pilot is to stay in the air, the second is flying in the right direction.
- avmich 2y agoRight, and it's all rather obvious. The problem is better seen when, if you focus on staying in power, you have to spend all your resources on this goal, and you can't reach any other goal. Republican party in USA currently does rather little - they do dismantle government, but the more they do that, the harder it is to them to stay in power, so their resources are self-limiting.
- smallerfish 2y ago
- modriano 2y ago> But the people are getting what they voted for, so is it really ethical to intervene in that? Did people vote for this? I thought people were voting on the price of eggs. Trump dishonestly disavowed the Heritage Foundation's Project 2025 ghostbuster containment system of horrible policies when people started becoming aware of the horrors that were in there. Sure, Trump is releasing those demons on us now, but a lot of voters claimed to believe Trump's dishonest disavowals. Trump wouldn't have won if he had been honest about what he would do. Voters didn't choose *this*.
- hn_acc1 2y agoIf you believed Trumps disavowal, you're seriously gullible. We all knew that was fake.