5 ms·
I don't think it's really about science. I mean if anything the science agrees with them. Sex is extremely bimodal (intersex is on the order of 1 in 1000): htt
by IshKebab 2y ago
I don't think it's really about science. I mean if anything the science agrees with them. Sex is extremely bimodal (intersex is on the order of 1 in 1000):
https://isna.org/faq/frequency/ https://isna.org/faq/frequency/
Also the use of gender as "it's like, how you feel, man" is very recent. When I was growing up (80s, 90s) it was just a synonym of "sex". If you look in old dictionaries that's what it says.
I looked it up and apparently the more recent definition came from feminists in the 70s (I guess it didn't catch on until later).
I think this is a massive over-correction (banning words is dumb) but they're not completely wrong.
I think the sane path lies in the middle: people shouldn't be forced to avoid "pregnant women" or "pregnant people". That includes being forced by social ostracism, which is the far left's method of choice.
- defrost 2y agoTaking it back to RealScience™ is fine. Elemental distribution in the universe is also extremely bimodal .. moreso even than the exceptions to the reproductive male or reproductive female buckets. Everything in the universe is either Hydrogen or Helium .. save for a tiny tiny cluster of exceptions known (to astronomers) as "metals" and as "every other damn element including carbon and oxygen" to the aquatic apes. Science is quite happy to endlessly study things with a frequency of ppm (parts per million) and less.
- IshKebab 2y ago> Everything in the universe is either Hydrogen or Helium Not sure what point you're trying to make here but we don't live in a star.
- defrost 2y agoWe do all live in the same universe. Give it some time, it may come to you eventually. Or not.
- IshKebab 2y agoWell I guessed that you were trying to make a point about how our language is highly biased towards heavy elements even though they are a tiny proportion of the universe, and that means it also makes sense to bias our language towards intersex people even though they are a tiny proportion of the population. But it can't be that because that is an obviously stupid point. So what was your point?
- defrost 2y agoRemind me of your point, if you would: > I think this is a massive over-correction (banning words is dumb) but they're not completely wrong. Is it that "they're not completely wrong" to ban terms referring to events significantly more common than the occurrence of gold in the earths crust? To quote another: > it can't be that because that is an obviously stupid point. So what was your point? ---- For general interest: * frequency of "true" (undecidable) intersex (1 in 5,500 births): https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00224490209552139 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0022449020955213... * Mean global crustal ppm of gold: 0.004 (four thousandth of one in a million) : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_elements_in_Earth%27s_crust#List_of_abundance_by_element https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_elements_in_Earth... * Report on Gold deposits in a high yeild region: Gold Deposits of the Pilbara Craton https://www.ga.gov.au/pdf/RR0065.pdf https://www.ga.gov.au/pdf/RR0065.pdf (74 page AGSO report, 'rich' veins have 0.4 ppm gold)
- ephimetheus 2y agoThis is a fantastic analogy!
- RealityVoid 2y ago> (intersex is on the order of 1 in 1000) Whoa, honestly, that is much more common than I expected in my mind.
- defrost 2y agoStrict intersex, as in can't decide via genetic tests and physical examination is rarer. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex for why it's not straightforward and why the edges are pretty fuzzy. The main take away would be that some people are born that are neither male nor female, others are born where assignment isn't clearcut or easy, and such births are more common than the frequency of gold in the earth's crust.
- brigandish 2y agoEveryone is born male or female, some just ambiguously so. Intersex is a colloquial misnomer, the correct and more accurate term is “disorder of sex development”.
- IshKebab 2y agoI don't think that's true. Or at best it's a tautological argument. Some people have crazy genes like XXY. There's no clear gender that they are "supposed" to be. It's very rare though.
- brigandish 2y agoI refer you to my comment[0] (flagged for some inexplicable reason), chromosomes are not the method of sex determination in humans (or most animals), and are not even the necessary condition in the process of fulfilling the sexual reproduction strategy in some others. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42907868 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42907868
- IshKebab 2y ago
- viraptor 2y ago> Also the use of gender as "it's like, how you feel, man" is very recent. That's because we got to some level of acceptance in some regions where we got to agree on some English term. It's not like the non-binary people appeared only very recently. We just got to honestly talk about it now. But there's many known figures from the past who pretty much lived that way, including the Universal Friend. Outside of the usual western countries, it existed for ages, like the non-binary "mahu" in Hawaiian culture.
- derbOac 2y ago0.001 > 0, especially multiplied by the population of the US, continent, or world.
- Levitz 2y agoIf that's your standard you'll quickly find you can't say much about anything. For example, you can't say humans have 5 fingers on each hand, polydactyly (had to google that one) has a higher prevalence than 0.001
- nixosbestos 2y agoAnd yet politicians don't spend their time demonizing people with an extra fingers spreading lies, fear, and hatred. Revoking protections to expose them to harassment. "The cruelty is the point" and all. The context of the discussion matters. My friends are scared, I don't really think your desire to be able to easily generalize the human race is something I can care too much about.
- Levitz 2y ago>And yet politicians don't spend their time demonizing people with an extra fingers spreading lies, fear, and hatred. People with extra fingers don't demand society bends backwards for them, branding anyone who presents any opposition whatsoever as bigots. They don't have a history of, funny enough, "spreading lies, fear and hatred" like trans advocacy does either. Trans people deserve sympathy and care and I have little expectation the current US administration treats them as they should, but the amount of willful ignorance required to look at this as something that "just happened" rather than the result of abuses of power by advocates is such that anyone partaking in it is better off ignored.
- nixosbestos 2y ago> don't demand society bends backwards for them clown comment from the start. utterly delusional bullshit. go on, what demands are trans people making of "society" other than "leave us the hell alone". >. They don't have a history of, funny enough, "spreading lies, fear and hatred" like trans advocacy does either. just outright making shit up, cool.
- 0xbadcafebee 2y ago> Also the use of gender as "it's like, how you feel, man" is very recent. When I was growing up (80s, 90s) it was just a synonym of "sex". If you look in old dictionaries that's what it says. The changes in society are recent, the ideas are extremely old. In our society, being gay used to be illegal, black people were property, and women had no rights. Then somebody would suggest that be changed, and the majority of people would freak out, for exactly the same reason: "that's not how it was when I was growing up!". Yet multiple genders [not sexes] have existed for millennia, we didn't have the concept of two sexes [not genders] until the Enlightenment, and these words have changed their meanings and been used in different ways throughout time. Society changes. Our understanding of the world changes. Sometimes we regress, like right now, like we did in the Victorian era, like we did after the fall of Rome, etc. But we need to push back, so that regression doesn't harm people, the way it has harmed people so many times in the past.