4 ms·
I think quotes like this should be attributed to the character (the secret police commissaire?) not the author?
by rightbyte 2y ago
I think quotes like this should be attributed to the character (the secret police commissaire?) not the author?
- matwood 2y agoIncluding 1984 in the cite makes it clear IMO. I referenced 1984 in comment this morning related to websites disappearing. We’ve (always|never) been at was with Eurasia…
- rightbyte 2y agoYe I get that but my main point is that it is not Orwell the real person that is quoted, but a fictional character that is a high level official in a dystopic police agency. If you haven't read the book it might be as Orwell the author is complicit. But sry might be a nitpick and obvious from context.
- matwood 2y agoI’m old and have read 1984 many times. But to your point, it doesn’t mean everyone has. Your note provides useful clarification. Cheers!
- gopher_space 2y agoIt’d be a point against in a formal debate, but in casual conversation it’s safe to assume your audience passed junior high and is familiar with the work.
- Terr_ 2y agoAlternately, if there were two layers of quoting (here, adding a >) then the outer layer would more-clearly refer to the book, rather than the lines of the character.