10 ms·
> A Redding Police Department officer in 2021 was charged with six misdemeanors after being accused of accessing CLETS to set up a traffic stop for his fiancée'
by simonw 2y ago
> A Redding Police Department officer in 2021 was charged with six misdemeanors after being accused of accessing CLETS to set up a traffic stop for his fiancée's ex-husband, resulting in the man's car being towed and impounded, the local outlet A News Cafe reported. Court records show the officer was fired, but he was ultimately acquitted by a jury in the criminal case. He now works for a different police department 30 miles away.
When people say "I don't see why privacy matters, I have nothing to hide" this is the exact kind of edge-case I always think about.
The problem with a lot of these massive surveillance systems is that a lot of people end up with access to them, and some of those people may not be trustworthy.
In this case, your ex-wife gets engaged to a cop and now they're abusing their access to databases to cause you harm.
(That note that "he now works for a different police department 30 miles away" is such a toxic aspect of American policing: cops who get fired for stuff like this inevitably end up in the exact same job somewhere else.)
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoThe biggest problem with police is it's the sort of job where the more a given person wants that job, the less they should probably have it. For their sake and others.
- pc86 2y agoAnother huge problem is that law allows union bargaining agreements to dictate what happens to disciplinary records, that officers are allowed to resign when there are investigations happening that effectively kills them, etc. Once an investigation starts you shouldn't be allowed to resign, or at the very least the investigation should still continue and you should still be able to be punished after. Any union contract requiring the deletion/obfuscation of any disciplinary records for any reason other than clerical error or pardon should be illegal.
- aidenn0 2y ago> Another huge problem is that law allows union bargaining agreements to dictate what happens to disciplinary records, that officers are allowed to resign when there are investigations happening that effectively kills them, etc. Once an investigation starts you shouldn't be allowed to resign, or at the very least the investigation should still continue and you should still be able to be punished after. I don't think requires any union pressure; the department is happy to be both rid of a problem officer and not have to put it in the public record just how bad the problem officer was. I have a friend who is a cop in Indiana (a "right to work" state), and after talking with him, I've realized that the department, as an organization, can largely be modeled as an entity that takes action to minimize its liability (individual officers are mostly shielded from civil liability, but the department is much less so). Apropos to this subject: - They want to minimize the number of apparent past bad actors that will be revealed during discover because a lot of past bad actors could be presented as a pattern of poor hiring and/or training. Allowing officers to resign to kill an investigation is golden). - When something bad happens and it makes it into a courtroom with sufficient evidence that it happened, they want every officer in the department to testify that the action in question is definitely not common practice and completely contrary to training. Such testimony would be greatly undermined by a subpoena that revealed several investigations finding officers to have engaged in such behavior in the past. Again anything that stops the investigation before it can find anything material could potentially save the department millions of dollars in future liability.
- chaps 2y ago"the department is happy to be both rid of a problem officer and not have to put it in the public record just how bad the problem officer was." ...have you not seen the extents that LE agencies and the FOP will go to make sure these folk aren't fired? There's a reason LE have FOP cards in their wallets that include a statement to be read verbatim into a transcript for disciplinary meetings. - When something bad happens and it makes it into a courtroom with sufficient evidence that it happened, they want every officer in the department to testify that the action in question is definitely not common practice and completely contrary to training. Such testimony would be greatly undermined by a subpoena that revealed several investigations finding officers to have engaged in such behavior in the past. Again anything that stops the investigation before it can find anything material could potentially save the department millions of dollars in future liability. You have a very rose-stained perception into these things. I highly recommend you do some court watching to really understand how these systems work. These sorts of retrospective analyses of misconduct truly don't exist as deeply or as strong as you think they are. I recommend reading: https://chicagoreader.com/news/police-misconduct-brady/ https://chicagoreader.com/news/police-misconduct-brady/ (disclaimer: I'm one of the authors)
- defrost 2y agoAs a US outsider (Australia) I see the Tulsi Gabbard hearing has stirred a barely tangential can of worms re: disclosure and keeping secrets. It's national security related, Was Snowden a traitor or a whistleblower and pokes the bear on whistleblowers and duty to disclose poor and outright illegal behaviour. Not sure if that's your beat or interest as a reporer .. but it goes to a core issue wt public institutions. related: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/01/30/us/politics/tulsi-gabbard-confirmation-hearing-intelligence.html https://www.nytimes.com/2025/01/30/us/politics/tulsi-gabbard...
- chaps 2y agoTransparency is indeed a large focus of mine, but it's mostly focused on local transparency and not federal.
- jl6 2y agoWhy? Most police spend their time keeping the peace and catching bad guys. That seems an intrinsically rewarding activity. No need to posit any character flaw to explain why someone would want to do that. Maybe you are thinking “power over other people” is the issue, but I think most cops see that as a necessary tool rather than the chief reward.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- codr7 2y agoCould have fooled me! I'm more worried about the Police than any other class of criminals.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI think that is a pretty privileged position. You might feel different if there were homicides and armed burglaries in your neighborhood
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y agoPersonally, I’m not so sure. That’s not to say I welcome the burglars and murderers but it would be comedy to say, “At least it can’t get any worse,” and then the police show up.
- fn-mote 2y ago> I think most cops see that as a necessary tool rather than the chief reward. The problem with this view is that there are a lot of high profile cases that are examples of people abusing their power. I am happy to believe that “most cops” see it that way. I am less familiar with those police officers supporting reforms that would either expose or suppress the bad behavior of the minority.
- darioush 2y agoThis is not the problem. The problem is a higher portion of people who just want to power trip apply to these positions, even if they are not the majority of the police force. Basically, it is the dream job for a bully. It seems there should be severe penalties for "power tripping" (aka misuse of authority and databases for special purposes); slap of the wrist fine, suspended paychecks and internal investigations will not deter this group of people. I don't see how these crimes are considered less than drug dealing. Specifically the punishment should include mandatory jail time and permanent ban from jobs where they have any form of authority over others including management, teaching, and all government positions.
- sambull 2y agonot just the same job, likely a cash transfer bonus. get caught doing bad shit, and get a new boat for next season.
- nxobject 2y agoOf course, this applies mass data collection by private entities too [1], and entities seeking to cross-reference commercially-available data sources together – even governments (thanks, Palantir!). There are plenty of ways to harass people without misusing your privileges as law enforcement. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/13/uber-employees-spying-ex-partners-politicians-beyonce https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/13/uber-empl...
- TriangleEdge 2y agoEx Palantir here: Palantir provides tools for data analysis and operations. The tools don't collect data. It's like saying: Thanks PostgreSQL for allowing this specific data misuse case. When I was at Palantir, the tools came with a robust ACL solution. I'm not advocating for the company, but the statement in the comment is shallow. I was a̶b̶u̶s̶e̶d̶ assaulted while employed there, which is why I left, but my comment stands.
- gosub100 2y agoYou weren't abused. You were just talked to in a way that caused an elevated emotional response. That said, I do find your argument interesting as it parallels the "guns don't kill people" argument. An I am a gun rights advocate yet am against Palantir's product usage on US citizens. Good food for thought.
- weakfish 2y ago“You weren’t murdered, you were just interacted with in a way that caused cardiac arrest”
- Hikikomori 2y agoTypical cop press brief
- AnthonyMouse 2y ago> That said, I do find your argument interesting as it parallels the "guns don't kill people" argument. The general form of both arguments is that you have a tool that can be used for good or bad things, so should you ban the tool (guns) or just the bad uses of the tool (murders)? If you had perfect enforcement then it would obviously be the latter, because you'd arrest the murderers without harassing people who buy guns for hunting or self defense etc. But law enforcement isn't perfect, so there is going to be some spillover where some murderers wouldn't have been caught. Then you have to get into debatable questions like, if it was illegal for them to buy a gun, would they have just bought a gun illegally, or used some other kind of weapon? If there are a lot of murders happening, how many of them could be prevented by using more resources to catch them or e.g. legalizing drugs to reduce gang activity, without banning guns? The pro-gun argument is that the positives outweigh the negatives and/or we're better off doing the other things to prevent murders instead. You can ask similar questions about Palantir and mass surveillance, but that doesn't mean you have to come to the same conclusion, because it has different positives and negatives and ability to be mitigated if you do it. In particular, preventing abuses by governments is much harder because you'd be relying on the government to prosecute itself, which is notoriously ineffective, especially with programs that are insulated from public accountability through secrecy. Meanwhile the negatives are much more dangerous because of the speed, scale and severity at which an already-existent mass surveillance system can be converted into a tool of mass oppression when there is a change in administrations. And the positives are muted because the legitimate goals of mass surveillance can also be achieved -- often at lower expense, given how much it costs to sift through a firehose of >99% false positives and innocent behavior -- using traditional targeted investigative methods.
- schainks 2y agoReminds me of this: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/13/uber-employees-spying-ex-partners-politicians-beyonce https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/13/uber-empl...
- bttrpll 2y agoAlso reminds me of Amazon being sued for giving employees access to Ring data: https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/01/08/ring-has-terminated-employees-abusing-access-peoples-video-data-company-tells-lawmakers/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/01/08/ring-ha...
- nonameiguess 2y agoI don't disagree on the principle you're advocating for here, but this example isn't about massive surveillance systems. CLETS seems to aggregate various databases police already had access to, probably some of which include data that ideally we wouldn't collect at all, but vehicle registration has to be stored somewhere and cops always have and always will have access to that.
- rcpt 2y agoYeah. In my opinion we should replace most of these cops with traffic cameras which don't do this kind of crap
- sweeter 2y agoThe other factor is that police have near blanket immunity to violate any of our rights, whether that be privacy, using the power of the state to harass individuals, and even killing or maiming people. Then the worst consequence they face is a light slap on the wrist, paid vacation and then a transfer to another Police department. Police only serve one purpose, and that is... well if you know, you know. They have a mass surveillance state in their hands, blanket immunity, and no oversight or checks and balances. People should at the very least recognize this fact. On top of that I get super frustrated when people want to do austerity measures like cutting funding to libraries, cancer research, public health etc... but refuse to even acknowledge that the police takes up the majority of a states public funding by orders of magnitude, and often receive "surplus" military weaponry. If anyone actually cared about govt spending, it would be extremely clear that military and police funding would come first and foremost. The reality is that these two things are heavily intertwined, and the ways in which they are corrupt are the same... but one should ask themselves why does the US police force need to be more powerful than nearly every countries military? Who is it that they are fighting and who are they fighting for?
- mschuster91 2y ago> but one should ask themselves why does the US police force need to be more powerful than nearly every countries military? Who is it that they are fighting and who are they fighting for? Well, either you pay for healthcare (especially mental health care) and social security programs such as affordable housing... or you'll pay police to deal with the fallout. Unfortunately, unlike in Europe, "government handouts" for the poor aren't something to score political points with, but authoritarian police is...
- derektank 2y agoThe US does not spend extravagantly on police services. Expenditures on police were $240B in 2024 [1], or a little over 3/4s of a percent of GDP. This is actually a little less than the EU average of 0.9% [2]. The US spends a lot in absolute terms because it's a big country and a rich country where you have to pay people working in service jobs a lot. [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/G160091A027NBEA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/G160091A027NBEA [2] https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Government_expenditure_on_public_order_and_safety https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...
- siltcakes 2y agoI was at a party with an early FB employee once and he was bragging about how they would spy on people to see who's profiles they were looking at. He thought it was hilarious, I never used FB again. I think his exact quote was "Hot girls are like celebrities, we watch people refresh their profiles all day long LOL".
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y ago>this is the exact kind of edge-case I always think about. I think you're overly generous in calling this an "edge case". I do not think it uncommon at all, what we hear about are those who are too stupid to remain uncaught.
- datavirtue 2y agoNo human is trustworthy. Verify.
- plagiarist 2y agoThe other problem is this fellow was acquitted when he should have been jailed for stalking.
- weddpros 2y agoLet's remember, it's not just about privacy, it's privacy against government overreach. Those in power, whether government officials or public servants, often abuse it. The public might want to defend their privacy vs. corporations, and/because the media will spin privacy to target companies, while government and public servants escape accountability for their actions.
- cratermoon 2y agoSince when have corporations been accountable for their actions?
- burningChrome 2y agoI remember a pretty big class action lawsuit against Phillip Morris and "Big Tobacco"? The BP Oil Spill class action? The Anderson Family class action against GM? The VW emissions scandal? Enron Securities fraud case? WorldCom accounting fraud case? Fen-Phen diet drug settlement? Bank of America Countrywide Mortgage fraud case?
- cratermoon 2y agoAnd what were the typical penalties imposed for these incidents?
- weddpros 2y agoAsked Perplexity to summarize and answer to you: Tobacco litigation ($23.6B) BP oil spill ($20.8B) VW emissions scandal ($38B) Enron/WorldCom financial fraud ($9.55B combined) Pharmaceutical/auto/mortgage cases ($16.15B combined)
- cratermoon 2y agoGet back to me when you can provide real sources, not some hallucinatin' jumped-up stochastic parrot.
- electrondood 2y ago> I don't see why privacy matters, I have nothing to hide Anyone who says this should then be just fine with putting a webcam in their shower.
- zelphirkalt 2y agoOr permanent character in a truman show, without any compensation for it.
- happyopossum 2y ago> such a toxic aspect of American policing Does not jibe with > he was ultimately acquitted If he was acquitted then he has to be treated as innocent, lest our justice system becomes an avenue for the exact type of crime you’re decrying.
- cratermoon 2y agoYou might be under the mistaken impression that the US criminal justice system has anything do with justice. After all, it's right there in the name: justice. It's an old, worn out trope, but it's still true: there are in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect. Guess which group cops belong to?
- rcpt 2y agoFeel like he could have done this pretty easily with 1950s tech
- janalsncm 2y agoTo me the core problem is that the criminal justice system doesn’t work. A man broke the law, was caught, and received no punishment. If the argument is “we can’t give powers to police because they can be misused” this is an argument for disarming them entirely. To me that is just giving up. Instead, we need to fix systems to hold them accountable.
- chii 2y agoYep, that's exactly it. The police needs to be held to a higher standard than ordinary citizens in terms of law compliance.
- throwaway290 2y ago> accessing CLETS to set up a traffic stop for his fiancée's ex-husband > When people say "I don't see why privacy matters, I have nothing to hide" this is the exact kind of edge-case I always think about. These cases are far and between. I suggest to think instead of something like pre-WWII Germany. Once you get everyone's say religion on file it's only a matter of accessing it if you want to prosecute any group at scale. Fun thing there will be no criminal cases at all because it will be fully legal
- EvanAnderson 2y agoThe example I like to bring up, albeit not in California, is the Brigham Young University police searching local law enforcement databases for sexual assaults on BYU students and reporting the victims for "Honor Code" violations. There's a ton of reporting about this, but as a good overview: https://www.kuer.org/race-religion-social-justice/2021-12-17/after-legal-battle-new-documents-give-clearer-picture-of-officers-relationship-with-the-byu-honor-code-office https://www.kuer.org/race-religion-social-justice/2021-12-17...
- busterarm 2y agoI recently beat a speeding ticket because by the time it got to court, my officer was fired from his department. He was fired because he was beating his wife, who worked in the court and took a restraining order out against him. He did in fact end up working for the department the next town over.
- quitit 2y ago>I don't see why privacy matters, I have nothing to hide. You are exactly right, "Nothing to hide" is also an invalid argument - because a valid suspicion of criminality will be authorised for subpoena by a judge. Without such oversight we immediately and repeatedly see abuse of these systems: here's just a tiny list of cases where the "good guys" abused their access to systems to stalk ex-lovers and people they found attractive. This underlines why the "good guys" argument is both invalid, but deliberately misleading. We don't plan systems and security around good guys, we plan them around bad guys. USA: N.J. cop used police databases to stalk ex-girlfriend, investigators say https://www.nj.com/monmouth/2023/01/nj-cop-used-police-databases-to-stalk-ex-girlfriend-investigators-say.html https://www.nj.com/monmouth/2023/01/nj-cop-used-police-datab... Officer Fired for Allegedly Using Police Database to Stalk, Harass Women https://www.newsweek.com/officer-fired-allegedly-using-police-database-stalk-harass-women-1615920 https://www.newsweek.com/officer-fired-allegedly-using-polic... Australia: Former policeman accused of using force database to stalk ex-wife and girlfriend https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/former-policeman-accused-of-using-force-database-to-stalk-ex-wife-and-girlfriend-20230303-p5cp8g.html https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/former-policeman... Former federal police officer faces new charges over stalking of ex-girlfriend https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/6138318/former-federal-police-officer-faces-new-charges-over-stalking-of-ex-girlfriend/ https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/6138318/former-federa... (Note the two above articles are not the same person) UK: Met police officer 'used CCTV cameras to stalk his ex-girlfriend after telling her to take up sex work to pay her bills' https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11868575/Met-police-officer-used-CCTV-stalk-ex-girlfriend-telling-sex-work-pay-bills.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11868575/Met-police... Creepy cop saw attractive woman on the road and 'looked up her license plate number so he could stalk her on Facebook' https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2178556/Officer-Jeffrey-Tyther-used-license-plate-database-stalk-woman-Facebook.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2178556/Officer-Jef...
- chii 2y agoAnytime someone uses the 'nothing to hide' argument, i ask them why they close the toilet door when they do a number two.
- chii 2y ago> a toxic aspect of American policing anywhere you have a brotherhood that is more loyal to members than the public they're meant to serve is not going to produce good results imho.
- trod1234 2y ago> When people say "I don't see why privacy matters, I have nothing to hide"... These people fail to follow and resolve the indirect links that threaten their future. Privacy is their future. Without privacy, you have no future, because you are vulnerable to attack by unknown third-parties. Information is the first thing required for a successful attack on your persons, or family. You can even torture people today and the bar is so incredibly high to prove vexatious acts that there's not much one can do except in some very egregious situations where they step over the line.