5 ms·
Those Exos drives have been popular with homelab types because they are usually $50-$100 cheaper than prosumer drives that claim to save maybe 0.5 W and 2-3 db
by PaulHoule 2y ago
Those Exos drives have been popular with homelab types because they are usually $50-$100 cheaper than prosumer drives that claim to save maybe 0.5 W and 2-3 db of noise on the datasheet. (The latter could be effaced by a bad bearing anywhere in your build, I haven't seen either claim tested by a review site)
It's funny but in this case the enterprise product is the cheap mainstream product and the 10-20 SKUs aimed at prosumers are the exotic expensive products. It is senseless to me that vendors like WD make special SKUs for security camera use or for 2-3 bay NAS, 4-7 bay NAS, etc when all it means is Best Buy won't stock any of them, development costs are spread out over fewer units, more versions of firmware and hardware to have bugs, etc.
- londons_explore 2y ago> make special SKUs If your company is set up for it, special SKU's can be really cheap. Some can be software-only changes that even get applied after the product gets into the hands of the users. eg. during the setup process, the hardware phones home, and some server side component matches it up to the original sale at the retailer and figures out which features to enable. There might even be more SKU combinations than products have ever be produced. Not saying hard drive manufacturers do it, but it is both possible and done in some industries.
- PaulHoule 2y agoI was impressed in the 1980s when I heard about how 390 mainframes had a modem in them so IBM could phone in orders to unlock extra capacity if the customer needed it for a short time. Today I think that's a sign to sell the stock of the company involved. It costs money to build hardware that is locked out, either the customer pays for it or the stockholders of the vendor pay for it, if the customer doesn't get to use it it just wasted. A vendor that even considers value subtraction is on thin ice and can only get away with it because there are barriers to exit. (This is particularly true of "fused off" features in Intel chips.)
- londons_explore 2y agoWhen you look deep enough, nearly all 'tech' products costs are IP. For IP, it costs nothing to include a feature locked out. Even real hardware is usually like this. An expensive camera is probably only expensive because it had more R&D go into it and all of its components. The actual sand to make the silicon chips didn't cost any extra. Unfortunately, the way todays capitalist society works, it's pretty hard to say "I'd like to buy 1 million of your camera sensors please, and I'd like to have 200k of them be high performance and 800k be kinda noisy, but I'll let you know which are the high performance ones after I sell them". A really vertically integrated company like Apple could do it though - and they do, selling super high performance chips in cheap iPads, but software locked to not run a decent desktop OS - for that you have to buy a macbook with the same chip for triple the money.
- PaulHoule 2y agoThe sensors are physically very different in the latest Sony α7, α7R (high resolution) and α7S (high sensitivity) cameras.
- Merrill 2y agoIn an early minicomputer, the $500 power fail interrupt feature was field installed by clipping a jumper. There were mainframe line printers that implemented a different lines per minute feature depending on which gear set was installed.
- dingaling 2y agoOn-demand scaling is still a feature of zSeries mainframes, now called Elastic Capacity on Demand . To non-corporates it might look like wasted resources or gouging the users, but from the enterprise perspective it's a marvellous feature. It's basically on-premises cloud-scaling.
- egorfine 2y ago> the hardware phones home ah, nothing like Windows-only hardware that is being purchased for Linux usage.
- compootr 2y ago> the hardware phones home, and some server side component matches it up to the original sale at the retailer laughs in linux my drives have physical extra pins that make it disable itself with a normal SATA connector that's left unplugged in its plastic case
- Dylan16807 2y agoIf a normal SATA power connector disables your drives, that just means your power supply is old. It wasn't the best idea to reuse the deprecated 3.3v pins for controlling drive power, but it's easy enough to deal with.
- tjoff 2y agoOr the only difference of those specialized SKUs is a single parameter in the firmware making a different tradeoff for, lets say, random seek vs. sustained sequential reads/writes. A different cache strategy. Or whatever. Being able to charge $100 more for that is very worthwhile.
- PaulHoule 2y agoI think the "larger NAS" drives have better shock absorption, which is a hardware thing. No matter what, it's a reason why you can't get any large capacity drive at Best Buy. They'd have room for one SKU but can't afford to stock an Amazonian variety of unusual types. I feel the whole industry has gone in a bad direction. My workstation has a modern case that doesn't really have a lot of room in it for HDDs, so I added an external HDD for my sports photographs. I sure as hell don't get the bit about "serious external HDDs have their own power supply" because it is one more thing that can fail (get unplugged) and cause data loss. I'd get warmer and fuzzier feelings if the drive was powered off USB.
- gruez 2y ago>No matter what, it's a reason why you can't get any large capacity drive at Best Buy. Is 24TB big enough for you? https://www.bestbuy.com/site/wd-easystore-24tb-external-usb-3-0-hard-drive-black/6585399.p?skuId=6585399 https://www.bestbuy.com/site/wd-easystore-24tb-external-usb-...
- vel0city 2y ago> WD make special SKUs for security camera use The workload for a security camera or a DVR is going to be pretty different from a lot of NAS devices or desktop/server use. Shingled Magnetic Recording (SMR) is fine for things like a security camera, where you're just going to be writing long files and probably just overwrite eventually. SMR is really bad if you need lots of random sparse file modifications. I do agree they're probably overboard on SKUs but having an obvious SMR SKU versus non-SMR is pretty important in my book. The fact they mixed in SMR into some regular drives and muddied the waters on which tech is going into which SKU really turned me off WD; I don't think I'll ever buy another one of their hard drives again.
- lmpdev 2y agoYes PSA to anyone reading: do not use Purple drives for anything non-DVR/NVR related
- duskwuff 2y agoIs there something that makes them unsuitable for other workloads?
- smegsicle 2y agowrite amplification. random writes can take, what twice as long? wear leveling could mitigate, but the choices are somewhat limited: NILFS seems to make assumptions based on SSDs, blowing up during its cleaning operation btrfs or bcachefs could help, but who knows whats going on with those
- buran77 2y agoWD mixed both CMR and SMR for the WD Purple, an a few other models too. The CMR wouldn't see any write amplification. But the SMR will suffer from all of the usual SMR limitations. Most importantly that it's only really useful with sequential writes, on top of the write amplification. Actually the Purple only has one distinguishing characteristic. An ATA command to skip bad sectors instead of trying to read/write repeatedly. This is great for an NVR but it's not mandatory to use.
- LeFantome 2y agoSurveillance represents a pretty big market though and the OEMs are not getting them from Best Buy. Most storage workloads read more than they write. Surveillance is the opposite. You are always writing. Much ( maybe almost all ) of what you write is never used and is simply overwritten again.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoSimilar workload for high energy physics, think CMS or ATLAS detectors at the LHC.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> claim to save maybe 0.5 W and 2-3 db of noise on the datasheet The huge issue here is that hard drive datasheets have gotten very inaccurate. They're not wrong, per se, but they tend to make very weak promises that ruin the ability to compare. Like if every car said "more than 10 miles per gallon".
- PaulHoule 2y agoI am skeptical about any claims about noise. I built two computers circa 2001 and read guides on Tom's Hardware and similar sites about how to build a quiet PC and to my schizotypal brain [1] the machines still screamed like banshees and I had to replace HDDs, fans, power supplies and such multiple times until I found parts that really were quiet. My take is there is a high variance in the noise of 'identical' parts, it just takes a bad bearing to produce an annoying squeak 15db or more above spec. I'm also skeptical about claims about power. Performance loss is real, power savings might not be. I had a $3000 desktop which I couldn't stand to use when I set the minimum CPU low because the machine would go to a lower power state between keystrokes or when I was only moving the mouse around, so it would seem to take forever for characters to appear when I'd type. Granted, my schizotypal nervous system is bad at latency compensation, even when my condition is remission, but I've found trying to save power makes a $3000 desktop feel worse to use than a $300 Chromebook. [1] particularly inflamed at that time